Every HBO Comedy Ranked From Worst To Best

42. How To Make It In America

How To Make It In America
HBO

The second Mark Wahlberg-produced comedy for HBO is a lot more likeable than the Happening star’s first. Like Entourage, How To Make It In America is a story about some young men with a dream, hoping to rise out of their New York neighbourhood and into the stratosphere.

Unlike Entourage, though, this is a show that can approach its premise and characters with a little humility. Its focus is two entrepreneurs looking to break into the glamorous world of fashion. Bryan Greenberg and Victor Rasuk charm in the lead roles, and there are solid parts for Lake Bell and Luis Guzman.

It’s on the fluffy side, and the business exploits of the main characters aren’t quite as intriguing as the writers would like to have us believe. It also took a significant dip in the second season; it never quite seemed to have the full backing of HBO, and fizzled out quietly.

Still, this was a perfectly decent show in its day. Not one to rush out and watch, but a charming underdog worth rooting for.


41. Avenue 5

Avenue 5 High Laurie
HBO

The jury, thus far, is out on this one. In any sane world Avenue 5 should overcome a slightly shaky debut season to become something great. It’s created by the fantastic Armando Iannucci, and has a cast that includes Rebecca Front and Zach Woods. It’s a daffy space comedy with a lot to like about it, but there’s a strong argument to be made that it’s underperformed thus far.

The strangest thing about Avenue 5 is that it doesn’t seem to put its setting to the best of use. The show is based on an interplanetary cruise ship, a unique locale with the possibility for a load of fresh comedy fun, but most of the comedy takes the form of the quips and one liners that could have appeared on Iannucci’s earlier, earth-bound work.

To that end there are still plenty of laughs, but if we’re grading on a curve, we expected a bit more from the guy behind so much of the best comedy of the past 30 years. It’s only one season in, though, so things could easily turn around.


40. Hung

Hung Thomas Jane
HBO

The mid-to-late ‘00s was a peak time for “struggling parent does X unsavoury act to make money” TV. Following in the wake of Weeds and Breaking Bad, HBO unleashed Hung, the story of a well endowed single dad becoming a gigolo in order to make ends meet.

The premise is a pretty simple one and Hung rarely proves especially interested in taking a deeper look into the world of sex work. The business proves easy for protagonist Ray Drecker (played with charm by Thomas Jane), and it’s more inclined to snicker and chuckle at the industry than attempt anything incisive.

That said, the show had a knack for creating solid characters and relationships, most notably between Drecker and his old flame turned pimp Tanya (Jane Adams, perhaps the most likeable pimp ever presented on TV). The pilot was directed by Alexander Payne (Sideways, Election), and his brand of cynicism combined with empathy pervades the three seasons.

30 episodes was a bit of a stretch for the premise and Hung is running on fumes somewhat by the end of its tenure, but beyond the smirking concept is a show of solid heart.


39. Hello Ladies

Stephen Merchant Hello Ladies.jpg
HBO

While Ricky Gervais has hogged the headlines since splitting from writing partner Stephen Merchant, the lanky Bristolian has easily racked up the finer credits. His 2013 sitcom Hello Ladies is no masterpiece, but Merchant’s ability to balance heart and humour without lurching clumsily between the two elevates this beyond his former colleague’s solo work.

Merchant plays a version of himself, here called Stuart, as he navigates the Los Angeles nightlife in a search for love. He’s never afraid to make himself the butt of the comedy, and unlike Gervais is more than happy to defer to his castmates, giving the likes of Christine Woods and Nate Torrence plenty of funny material.

The premise is hardly original, and admittedly Merchant doesn’t do much new with his unoriginal premise, but the jokes are certainly there and the plots, while never groundbreaking, are made easy to invest in by likeable characters.

Hello Ladies lasted only one season, but could quite easily have sustained more. It’s a comforting hang out sitcom that’s easy to watch and even invest in.


38. Tenacious D

Tenacious D
Red Hour Films

The show that made stars out of Jack Black and Kyle Gass, Tenacious D’s brief tenure on HBO was a real labour of love. Created by the two band members alongside Mr Show’s David Cross and Bob Odenkirk, the guys made just six episodes across a three-year time span, indulging in their every whim in a blend of music and freewheeling comedy.

The total freedom given over to the D can lead to some bagginess as Black and Gass follow whatever whim entertains them at the time, but for the most part it’s a successful series. The episodes are loose and varied. Some are built around little more than a spat between the two guys; others feature gunfire and sasquatch (a cameo by John C Reilly).

The main event is the music - each episode features several songs, usually culminating with Tenacious D performing onstage, often hilariously recapping the events we’ve just seen.

It’s not to everyone’s taste - this is surreal comedy delivered in a brash fashion - but if you’re down with the D and have only sampled their music or the watered down presentation of the feature film, the HBO series is the pure stuff.


37. Dream On

Dream On
HBO

An unsung hero in HBO’s early line up, Dream On was the sitcom that paved the way for much of the network’s continued success going into the ‘90s and beyond. In its formal daring and use of adult content in a manner that wasn’t just for the sake of it, the show devised by Friends creators Marta Kauffman and David Crane is arguably one of HBO’s most important.

That’s not to say it’s one of the network’s best, because as we can ascertain from its placing on this list, it isn’t. It tells the story of Martin Tupper, unlucky in love divorcee, as he attempts to rebuild his life following the split from his wife. In its story beats and characterisation, it’s not majorly original.

Its key gimmick, though, was the interspersal of clips from old TV shows, which both served as a mood board for Tupper’s state of mind, and an illustration of how his (and our) mind had been shaped by untold hours in front of the box.

The postmodern vibe of Dream On would go on to inspire so many shows that obsess over pop culture, and the adult themes actually fed into the plot, rather than previous shows’ nudity and swearing just because they could. It’s been left behind a little by what came later, but is still well worthy of praise.


36. Family Tree

Family Tree
HBO

Christopher Guest, it must be said, is one of the greatest comedic minds of our time. As the co-creator of This Is Spinal Tap, Waiting For Guffman, Best In Show, and plenty more, his improvisational style helped reshape the comedy landscape, particularly on TV. His return to the small screen with 2013’s Family Tree seemed like the king coming to reclaim his throne.

And there’s plenty to like about the loose, character-filled sitcom, especially for those already into Guest’s style. Starring Chris O’Dowd as a man exploring his lineage, it takes Guest’s usual mock doc format and roves around the O’Dowd’s extended family, with Ed Begley jr, Michael McKean, and plenty more comedy greats making appearances.

The problem is that the setting isn’t nearly so engaging as most of Guest’s other works. With so little to go on, the characters are asked to do a lot of heavy lifting, and while there are plenty of gags in there, a decent amount of it unfortunately falls flat.

A charming show you’d love to see succeed, but my episode eight it had definitely run its course.


35. Random Acts Of Flyness

Random Acts Of Flyness
HBO

This award winning comedy is one of the most singular sketch shows in recent memories. Terence Nance created, writes, and stars in Random Acts Of Flyness, and it’s clearly his vision throughout. The show Nance presents is like stepping inside his head and listening to him opine on modern society, crack jokes, tell stories, and sometimes invite his celebrity pals around.

Witness the cameo from Mad Men’s Jon Hamm in episode one, playing an information spokesman for a product which, when applied to the temples, eradicates any white thoughts. Hamm and all the special guests involved are hilarious, let off the leash by Nance and his poetic style.

Nance’s focus isn’t always on the joke, which sets it apart from similar sketch shows for good and ill. As fascinating as his distinct style is, it can feel at times like a little more structure wouldn’t go amiss, and a few sketches do simply fizzle out.

Still, there’s no denying the impressive impact of Nance’s authorship, and his world is a fun if sometimes discombobulating one to spend time in.


34. Togetherness

Togetherness hbo
HBO

If you’re familiar with any of the myriad films written and/or directed by the Duplass brothers, you’ll know roughly what to expect here, and probably whether or not you’re going to enjoy it. The Duplass boys deal in low stakes but closely observed depictions of ordinary life, with a wry comedic style and loose, often improvisational filmmaking.

Mumblecore proves to be a great fit for the small screen, with Togetherness’ 16 episodes giving an ample canvas on which to paint the story of a small family and the folk in their orbit. Mark Duplass and the always excellent Melanie Lynskey are the husband and wife at the show’s core, and they present an impressively intimate and realistic portrayal of marriage with all its ups and downs.

This isn’t a show for those in search of a thrill ride, or big belly laughs, but if you’ve enjoyed modern American indie cinema over the past decade and change, this is likely to be up your street.


33. The High Life

The High Life
HBO

A comedy 10 years ahead of its time, had The High Life been produced 10 years later, it could have been a significant hit, or at the very least a beloved cult artefact. Instead, the one-and-done series by long time Letterman writer Adam Resnick was quickly buried, and is difficult to find today.

The series depicts a pair of idiotic businessmen in 1950s Pittsburgh. Emmett and Earl, two scheming boobs, spend each episode trying to get rich through a new ill thought out ploy, and by the end of the episode it tends to have blown up in their faces in a ludicrous manner.

The series is shot in black and white, emulating sitcoms of the era, but the subject matter is frequently outrageous - the boys wind up involved with the Ku Klux Klan, or are unwittingly accused of being communists. This, alongside production problems and the relentless nastiness of the main characters (which would come into vogue in the ‘00s) made this a hard sell for viewers, and it quickly fizzled out.

It’s hard to know what kind of shelf life this format could have had, but there’s definitely some greatness in these eight weird, uncomfortable episodes.


In this post: 
HBO Veep
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)