Gotham: 15 Craziest Moments

There was never a dull moment to be had in this infamous city.

Gotham Jerome Laugh
Fox

Jim Gordon may have been Gotham's protagonist and the city's white knight, but there's no doubting that the show's villains truly stole the show. They ran the city - from the mob bosses, to those who worked their way into City Hall, to the anarchists who just simply ruled the streets - Gotham belonged to its villains.

Unsurprisingly, the Batman prequel also had its fair share of crazy scenes and moments. This list is full of murder, confrontation, more murder, surprise confessions, and even cannibalism - so crazy was the show as it neared its finale.

Arkham Asylum was a frequent location and it never seemed to be short of inmates. In fact, most of the characters featured on this list spent a stint there, so it only further demonstrates Gotham's breeding of crazy.

The Gotham City Police Department certainly had their work cut out during the show's five season run - so much so, that they're completely absent in almost all of these scenes. Of course, Gordon is the exception - but even he struggled to put a stop to these moments of insanity...

15. Nygma Kills Kristen Kringle (Season 2, Episode 6 - 'By Fire')

Gotham Nygma Kringle
Fox

Things didn't go to plan for Ed Nygma (Cory Michael Smith) when he made a much-awaited confession to Kristen Kringle (Chelsea Spack) back in Season 2. The situation soon escalated after Kristen panicked upon finding out that Nygma had killed her abusive boyfriend, Tom Dougherty - even faking his disappearance.

Before this point, Nygma had displayed some of his Riddler-like qualities but he hadn't truly turned full supervillain just yet. That was all about to change. When Kristen wasn't grateful for what Ed had done, he killed her too - right then, right there.

Clearly this murder was a lot more difficult for Nygma to commit - after all, Nygma loved Kringle. He truly believed he'd done her a favour, but once she was gone, so was the last positive moral influence on his life.

Nygma was a popular character in Gotham throughout its five season run, but there is no doubting that the most thrilling element of his arc was his devolution into becoming the Riddler. Nowhere was that clearer than here.


14. Bruce & Selina Meet Again (Season 5, Episode 12 - 'The Beginning')

Gotham Season 5 Batman
Fox

When Bruce Wayne (David Mazouz) and Selina Kyle (Lili Simmons) reunited in this flash-forward, we got a glimpse into the adult relationship between this iconic pair.

What was crazy about this scene was the pay-off after building the relationship between these two characters during their formative years. Bruce and Selina were introduced to us as children but by this scene, they had both assumed their iconic identities of Batman and Catwoman - and it was so satisfying to watch.

Major praise to Lili Simmons who did a great job playing the adult Selina Kyle. Many fans were upset to find out actress Camren Bicondova wouldn't be reprising her role in the final episode - due to it being a flash-forward - but she honoured Bicondova's Selina perfectly. Props to the casting department too - Simmons and Bicondova could seriously be related.

This scene summed up what Gotham was all about. It successfully charted the origin stories of all of our favourite Batverse characters and ended on an iconic moments like this.


13. Theo Galavan Kills Penguin's Mother (Season 2, Episode 7 - 'Mommy's Little Monster')

Gotham Galavan Penguin
Fox

The manner in which Gertrud Kapelput (Carol Kane) was murdered wasn't particularly crazy for Gotham. She was stabbed in the back - both literally and figuratively - as Galavan (James Frain) pretended to let her go. The crazy element of this scene was Penguin's (Robin Lord Taylor) reaction and the quick succession of emotions we saw him go through.

Robin Lord Taylor was excellent at portraying Penguin's temper and eccentricity, but this scene provided him with the opportunity to flex his skills a little more. Betrayal turned to anger, to relief, to despair, and finally, to grief.

Penguin may have been one of Gotham's most powerful villains but that didn't stop him from being a mommy's boy. Seeing his sentimental side was more out of the ordinary than all of the anger and violence he'd exerted up until this moment.


12. Bruce Vs. Fake Alfred (Season 4, Episode 21 - 'One Bad Day')

Gotham Alfred
Fox

Bruce Wayne and Alfred Pennyworth (Sean Pertwee) were an iconic duo. Throughout Gotham, they had a few disagreements but nothing came close to matching this fight.

Due to Scarecrow's 'fear gas,' Bruce got involved in a violent fight with a fake Alfred. It wasn't particularly enjoyable to see the pair go head to head, knowing their true respect for each other, but it did provide a fresh dynamic.

Pertwee is a great actor but he often had to hold back physically as Alfred is a very reserved man. Here, that wasn't the case as Scarecrow's 'fear gas' rid the character of any moral goodness. This made for an interesting struggle. Bruce had to defend himself, but he also didn't want to injure Alfred.

Bruce had definitely come a long way since season one and it was exciting to see him hold his own in such an intense fight - both physically and emotionally. This scene's intensity was made possible thanks to the great relationship Pertwee and Mazouz had built between their characters over the years.


11. The Ventriloquist/Scarface Death Scene (Season 5, Episode 8 - 'Nothing's Shocking')

Gotham Scarface
Fox

Considering Penguin and Riddler were such high profile villains in Gotham, you couldn't be blamed for wondering how they found themselves under threat from a puppet - but that's exactly what happened in this scene.

The Ventriloquist (Andrew Sellon) believed he was under the control of his puppet, Scarface who was taunting him to kill Penguin and Riddler - just another normal day in Gotham. It was as crazy as it sounds but that's why the scene made this list.

As odd as a killer puppet may sound, Scarface did look pretty terrifying - especially peering through those blinds. You definitely wouldn't want to get on the wrong side of him as Penguin and Riddler unfortunately did. Thankfully, Penguin saved the day by shooting Scarface in the head thus freeing The Ventriloquist from his influence - because of course, that makes perfect sense.

One of the best elements of this scene was the great chemistry between Penguin and Riddler. Their friendship had been well established by this point in the show but it was always a treat when the two characters found themselves drawn back together.


10. Mad Hatter, Scarecrow & Jerome Escape Arkham (Season 4, Episode 16 - 'One Of My Three Soups')

Gotham Jerome Mad Hatter
Fox

It was always great to see multiple villains team up together and that was the case in this scene as Jervis Tetch (Benedict Samuel), Jonathan Crane (David W. Thompson), and Jerome Valeska (Cameron Monaghan) teamed up to escape from Arkham Asylum.

Arkham was such an iconic location - favoured in Gotham for its pure chaos. This scene encapsulated that. Each villain had their role to play. Tetch was tasked with breaking out Crane, Crane was tasked with breaking out Jerome, and Jerome seemed to then assume the role of leader - no surprise there.

Soon after, every Arkham escapee rushed towards the gates. It was a great episode opener - promising chaos would ensue in the scenes and episodes to come.

There was definitely a power-struggle going on in this scene - even if Jerome was the only character in contention. Tetch and Crane weren't too happy about this and it culminated in a great line. Jerome tells them, "There's plenty of time to stab each other in the back later." It's nice to know villains understand their own predictability.


9. Ace Chemicals (Season 5, Episode 7 - 'Ace Chemicals')

Joker Gotham
Fox

In contrast to a lot of scenes in Gotham, the one in discussion here didn't have too many secrets hiding up its sleeve. The showdown between Bruce Wayne and Jeremiah Valeska (Monaghan) was lifted straight from the comic-books and was a key moment in their developing rivalry.

Gotham put their own twist on the scene. Jeremiah already had his signature acid-wash skin. Instead, the chemicals burn and rot away at him providing Jeremiah with a look unlike any other Joker. Thematically, it seemed fitting that Jeremiah's appearance started to show physical decay right as Bruce was starting to overpower him in their ongoing rivalry.

When Gotham began in 2014, Bruce Wayne was introduced to us as a child. To see the same character command such a physical presence in this scene - in the final season - was a great pay-off. Gotham truly did Bruce Wayne justice in showing his journey into becoming Batman.

Monaghan was great as always. Both him and Mazouz really did work well together. They may have been a lot younger than a lot of previous Batman/Joker pairings we've seen, but they weren't phased by this and undoubtedly made the roles their own.


8. Penguin & Butch Kill Azrael (Season 2, Episode 20 - 'Unleashed')

Gotham Galavan Death
Fox

Everything about this scene was ridiculously over-the-top but that is what made it so good. Jim Gordon (Ben McKenzie) is prevented from taking Azrael into custody when Penguin and Butch Gilzean (Drew Powell) turn up out of nowhere. Armed with a rocket-launcher, they see Azrael off for good. Yes, you heard that right - a rocket-launcher.

There were so many clichés in this scene. From Penguin's tongue-in-cheek, "Always bring the right tools for the job," to Azrael's comical, "Oh God," to that shot of Penguin and Butch walking through the flames when the job is done… but cliché is in Gotham's identity.

It was scenes like this that felt like they were lifted straight off a comic-book page. Gotham could get away with things very few other shows could pull off - it was when it took advantage of this, that the show really shined.

Many characters returned from the 'dead' in Gotham: Fish Mooney, Penguin - even Azrael was Theo Galavan's second shot at life. Therefore, it took a good dose of crazy to truly see a character off for good. This scene provided that.


7. Jerome & The Cheerleaders (Season 2, Episode 2 - 'Knock, Knock')

Gotham Maniax
Fox

This marks Jerome Valeska's second appearance on this list and it certainly won't be his last. Jerome was the epitome of crazy - he was an anarchist.

Along with the other members of The Maniax, Jerome hijacked a bus full of cheerleaders - taunting them at gun point before eventually attempting to set both them and the bus on fire. It was all just another normal day in the life of Jerome Valeska. Unfortunately for him, Jim Gordon arrived just in time to save the day on this occasion.

Jerome contemplated mass-murder like it was a game and that is what made this scene one of the craziest in Gotham's run. Jerome wasn't concerned with the dozens of lives he was about to end. In fact, he enjoyed relishing in the chaos. Sure, the other Maniax were there to help him, but make no mistake, Jerome was the one in charge here.

It wasn't just the actors that shone in this scene. The stunts and music were both excellent making this a stand-out scene as well as a crazy one.


6. Jerome Takes Bruce To The 'Carnival' (Season 3, Episode 14 - 'The Gentle Art Of Making Enemies')

Gotham Jerome Bruce
Fox

This is a prime example of when Gotham just let loose and went to town on the absurdity and craziness levels. In this episode, Jerome's followers took over the city and in particular, the carnival. Proud of how this widespread insanity was infecting Gotham, Jerome took Bruce to see it all for himself.

You couldn't help but feel sorry for the everyday people of Gotham who just wanted to live their lives in peace - although if they wanted that, they were living in the wrong place. In a series of torturous carnival games, they were shot at with darts, pelleted with baseballs, held at gunpoint, and smashed with a hammer. If that wasn't enough, a poor man is dropped into a tank full of man-eating piranhas as the big finale.

That's all before Jerome stabbed a man and wiped his blood all over Bruce's face, giving him his own Joker smile.


5. Barbara Kills Her Parents (Season 1, Episode 21 - 'The Anvil Or The Hammer')

Gotham Barbara Kills Parents
Fox

The Ogre (Milo Ventimiglia) didn't make it past the end of season one. His time on Gotham may have been relatively short, but he had a big impact on the trajectory of Barbara Kean (Erin Richards).

When Jim Gordon discovered Barbara's parents lying dead on the sofa in this episode, no one could've expected that Barbara herself was the killer. Richards played the scene with ambiguity and it worked perfectly. As Barbara edged into the room, her doe-eyed bewilderment could've been mistaken for grief - little did we know that Barbara clearly didn't want saving.

Gotham was a TV show that demonstrated that loyalty meant nothing - that you never really knew someone, no matter how much you thought you did. Barbara's actions in this scene demonstrated this and it really signified that no characters were safe from the city's corrupting forces.

The Ogre's manipulation of Barbara led her to become the tenacious character we would see in later seasons. So, whilst The Ogre may not be the most memorable Gotham villain, we can thank him for at least doing that.


4. Fish Mooney Removes Her Eye (Season 1, Episode 17 - 'Red Hood')

Gotham Dollmaker
Fox

It's hard to forget this particularly gruesome scene. When The Dollmaker (Colm Feore) presented Fish Mooney (Jada Pinkett-Smith) with a tricky ultimatum, Fish took matters into her own hands - gauging out her own eye.

The scene was as disgusting as it sounds - Fish used nothing but a spoon. If that wasn't enough to turn your stomach, the sound of her eyeball popping as she stamped on it should've done the trick. It was equal measures of laughable and stomach-churning - crazy to say the least.

Like so many other great scenes in Gotham, it was the absurdity of the scene that made it so memorable. In our current TV landscape, it's so difficult to surprise audiences - but Gotham never failed to do just that.

Fish Mooney was a character loved by many, but this scene just confirmed what a badass character she was.


3. Professor Pyg's Dinner (Season 4, Episode 9 - 'Let Them Eat Pie')

Gotham Professor Pyg
Fox

It doesn't get much crazier than cannibalism, right? Wrong. Add cannibalism to a musical number and then you're getting there.

In this episode, Professor Pyg served each of his guests a human pie whilst entertaining them with a rendition of the 'Meat Pie Tango' - his own interpretation of Chicago's famous 'Cell Block Tango.'

Both Penguin and Sofia Falcone (Crystal Reed) were in attendance and it was definitely a dinner to remember. The craziness didn't stop there. To top it all off, Sofia was stabbed through the hand whilst the other party guests were forced to eat their human pie or else end up in one themselves.

This scene was both horrifying and hilarious. It was another classic Gotham moment and was completely absurd from head to toe. With so many villains plaguing Gotham's streets, you must have to be pretty eccentric to stand out, and Professor Pyg definitely was that.


2. Jerome's Interrogation (Season 1, Episode 16 - 'The Blind Fortune Teller')

Joker Gotham Jerome
Fox

It won't come as a surprise to anyone that Jerome's interrogation is featured on this list, as it is often hailed as one of the best scenes in the entirety of Gotham's five season run.

Jerome was called in for questioning by Jim Gordon regarding the mysterious death of his mother. Shortly into the conversation and within a matter of seconds, gone was the grieving son. Tears of despair transformed into a maniacal laugh and there, the first prototype Joker was born.

Gotham's writers likely didn't know just how big of a presence Jerome - and later Jeremiah - would grow to have in the show, but Monaghan's performance was electric and so it's no surprise he kept coming back.

It must be a daunting task to take on the iconic Joker laugh, but Monaghan seemed to do so with great confidence. His performance as Jerome is like no other Joker that has come before - you can easily see why the scene went viral.

This scene is truly a highlight of the show - and only the start of Jerome's journey.


1. Jeremiah Reveals His True Nature (Season 4, Episode 20 - 'The Old Corpse')

Gotham Jeremiah Valeska Season 4
Fox

Everything about this scene was phenomenal. This episode contained so many surprises and plot twists - all of which were revealed with such perfect timing. The tension was palpable.

It was a needed relief for Gotham fans to see the recently deceased Jerome Valeska still causing chaos from beyond the dead… or so they thought. Little did we know that this was all the work of his seemingly 'good' brother, Jeremiah .

In the scene between Jeremiah and Bruce Wayne, you can tell something is off - this isn't the meek Jeremiah we've been introduced to. The moment 'Jerome' is in fact revealed to be Jeremiah is such a revelation - it was executed perfectly, and the two personalities were truly distinct. Jerome was a true anarchist, but Jeremiah was calm and calculated - he actually believed he was sane.

The true stand-out shot in this scene was when Jeremiah wiped the blood off his face only to reveal the iconic Joker pale skin hiding under his fake complexion. Gotham didn't get better than this - this was crazy in the best way.


You'll Never Get 100% On This Gotham Quiz

Gotham Pilot Gordon
FOX

1. Whose Death Does Gordon Fake In The Very First Episode?

In this post: 
Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Experienced journalist bringing you ALL the content on everything gaming, film & tv. Popular opinion: We need Jon Bernthal back as The Punisher in the MCU. Unpopular opinion: Abby > Ellie in The Last of Us.