Gotham: Every Major Villain Ranked From Worst To Best
"We could all go insane with just one bad day."
Gotham ran for five seasons, during which it entertained audiences with a whole host of villains ranging from the iconic to the slightly strange.
The series - a Batman prequel - charted the rise of Detective James Gordon and Bruce Wayne in a version of Gotham set long before the latter became the Dark Knight.
However, Gotham also provided us with origin stories for many of Batman's most famous adversaries - maybe even a few you've never heard of - and they completely stole the show. There was plenty of comic book material for Gotham's writers to draw from, and the showrunners even took the liberty of adding their own villains into the mix as well.
It wouldn't be Gotham without an appearance from iconic characters like The Joker, Ra's Al Ghul or Penguin, and they're all there. Beyond that, Gotham sought to make history by including live-action debuts of characters like Barbara Kean and Hugo Strange.
So, how do they compare? From crime lords to clowns; From assassins to anarchists - Gotham had it all. They do say a hero is nothing without a villain so let's start from the bottom. Things can only get better...
17. Sal Maroni (Season 1)
Sal Maroni, portrayed by David Zayas, was an antagonist of Gotham's premiere season. The show hadn't quite found its pace or footing yet - very much operating like a police procedural before it shifted to a more warmly received season-long structure in season two.
As head of the Maroni crime family, Sal Maroni was at war with Carmine Falcone and it was the constant battle between the two that proved to be a problem for the GCPD and Jim Gordon. That being said, it was at the hand of Fish Mooney that Maroni met his death. He called the wrong woman 'Babe' - it's hardly going out in a blaze of glory, hence this low ranking.
Maroni wasn't an awful villain but he was slightly underwhelming. The angry mob boss archetype has been seen in countless incarnations and Gotham's Maroni failed to add anything new. There are plenty of great villains in the Batverse that the Gotham writers could've drawn from - which they certainly did - but Maroni just wasn't one of them. Simply put, he lacked individuality.
16. Nyssa Al Ghul (Season 5)
Nyssa Al Ghul is a well-known character in the Batverse and one that was introduced to Gotham pretty late in the game. Portrayed by Jaime Murray, Nyssa was one of the primary antagonists of Gotham's final season - descending upon the city to exact revenge on Jim and Barbara for the death of her father, Ra's Al Ghul.
Nyssa was full of intent but she failed to succeed in her plans which needless to say, earns her a low ranking place on this list. As the daughter of the head of the infamous League of Shadows, you couldn't be blamed for expecting more from Nyssa. She certainly was shown to be ruthless - condemning ordinary citizens to death during the time in which Gotham became No Man's Land - but her later villainous attempts proved a little lacklustre.
There was a lot to fit into Gotham's final season: Bruce truly taking on the role of Batman, the rise of The Joker, the introduction of Bane. It's probably why Nyssa was a slightly underwhelming villain.
15. Carmine Falcone (Season 1)
Fellow mob boss Carmine Falcone, played by John Doman, outranks Maroni by a couple of places. Like Maroni, Falcone was also an antagonist of Gotham's premiere season but later retired from his life of crime once the mob war was finished. However, that wasn't quite the end for Falcone.
Falcone returned to Gotham to exact revenge upon Jim Gordon for killing his virus-infected son. Jim survived Gotham's five season run and so evidently, Falcone failed. In fact, he didn't even go through with the hit and called it off. In another act of moral goodness, Falcone later made the mistake of trying to control his headstrong daughter, Sofia.
Sofia shot him for getting in the way of what she wanted (clearly some Falcone's have more conviction than others).
Falcone didn't always feel like a villain and that's one of his biggest faults. Villains don't have to be evil through and through - some of the best are complex and exist in the grey areas - but Falcone was almost too good. He retired from crime, acted against his violent impulses and tried to do what was morally best for his family. This made him an interesting character, but not necessarily an interesting villain.
14. Ra's Al Ghul (Seasons 3-5)
Ra's Al Ghul (played by Alexander Siddig) is another well-known name in the Batverse - often considered to be Bruce Wayne's arch-nemesis. As a prequel, it was clear that in Gotham, Al Ghul would take on a slightly different role. Unfortunately, what we didn't know is that it would be a little underwhelming.
Gotham's Al Ghul played a pivotal role in encouraging Bruce to become the Batman but otherwise, his villainous attempts felt short-lived. Alongside Jeremiah Valeska, Al Ghul succeeded in killing Gotham's Mayor and destroying the bridges that provided access to the city, but this is where his plans ended.
With Barbara Keane and Bruce Wayne killing Al Ghul, it was Valeska who seized the opportunity to take advantage of Gotham's newly formed island state. Ra's thus felt like little more than a lackey - a means to an end.
Gotham's Head of the Demon was underused. He's the head of the League of Shadows - yet we never really saw what he was capable of.
13. Firefly/Bridgit Pike (Seasons 2-4)
Bridgit Pike, played by Michelle Veintimilla & Camilla Perez, was Gotham's incarnation of the villain, Firefly.
Pike was originally reluctant to become a villain. She assisted her brothers with a series of arson attacks and robberies. It wasn't until Pike accidently wounded Officer Luke Garrett and went on the run with Selina Kyle, that she started to fall into her inevitable villainous role.
Pike's downfall was that she never really had a plan or a motive. Throughout its five season run, Gotham's writers just never quite worked out what to do with the character. From being manipulated by Hugo Strange to working for Penguin, Pike never stood on her own two feet.
The only constant in the character's storyline was her love-hate relationship with Mr Freeze, which saw the two characters constantly changing from allies to enemies. The storyline was somewhat entertaining, but it was little more than a time-filling sub-plot.
12. Mr Freeze/Victor Fries (Seasons 2-4)
Much like Firefly, Victor Fries/Mr Freeze (played by Nathan Darrow) was a supporting villain in Gotham. In other words, he was underused. First appearing in season two, Fries tragically became a villain after attempting to commit suicide using one of his cyro-cartridges.
As an origin story, it was very compelling and Darrow played it well. You could feel how desperate Fries was to save his wife and his complete and utter despair at failing to do so.
However, it is when Fries becomes Mr Freeze that things became a little more lacklustre. It's exactly the same storyline as Firefly: Mr Freeze was recruited by Hugo Strange before then going on to work for Penguin. Just like Firefly, Fries lacked his own storyline.
Mr Freeze scores points for his aesthetic - he looked every part the Gotham villain. On top of that, Darrow successfully grounded the character in what was an over-the-top show. Unfortunately, Fries' lack of motivation and storyline hinders any greater ranking on this list.
11. Poison Ivy/Ivy Pepper (Seasons 1-5)
Ivy Pepper went through some substantial changes throughout Gotham's five season run. Played by Clare Foley, Maggie Geha and Peyton List, the character transformed from a young child into a dynamic villain. Ivy's mystical 'age-up' only aided the development of the character.
Ivy was certainly an entertaining and charismatic villain which made up for the fact that she lacked the threat needed to be a 'big-bad.' Foley's young Ivy did a good job of introducing us to the little outcast girl with an affinity for darkness ,but it was Geha and List's older Ivy that captured our full attention.
Ivy had what many other villains thus far ranked in this list lack - motivation. She'd always been disregarded and hurt by people who considered her to be a nobody. Every child at some point wishes they were an adult and for Ivy, that happened overnight. Her quick-age up provided her with a new-found power but she still retained all the angst of her youth. It was this relationship between the two that made Ivy such a compelling villain.
10. The Mad Hatter/Jervis Tetch (Seasons 3-5)
Jervis Tetch was Gotham's incarnation of DC villain, The Mad Hatter. Although played excellently by Benedict Samuel, Tetch was a little basic in regards to his motivations - he's an anarchist. That being said, it's people like Tetch that made Gotham both the show and city we know and love.
Tetch had a satisfying arc that allowed us to see the growth of the character. In Gotham's third season, Tetch was your average villain - stealing money from Gotham's wealthiest - but as with most villains, his hunger for power grew.
Gotham's 'Mad City' storyline allowed Tetch to proceed to the next level as he created the infamous 'Tetch Virus' following the death of his sister, Alice. Even Arkham Asylum wasn't enough to stop him. His incarceration only fuelled his desire for anarchy.
As established, Samuel did a great job of playing Tetch. He was eccentric and let's be honest, borderline insane, but Samuel always matched Tetch's energy with that of the scene. He certainly held his own alongside Penguin and Valeska in the 'Legion of Horribles,' which is a big undertaking.
9. Victor Zsasz (Seasons 1-5)
If Victor Zsasz could be praised for one thing, it's consistency. He was Gotham's go-to hitman and remained so throughout the show's five season run. With Zsasz you knew what to expect - if you pay, he shoots.
As a consequence of that, Zsasz lacked character development but this largely went unnoticed. Zsasz lurked on the side-lines. It was never Gotham's intentions to make him the centre of attention. In a show that charted the evolution of so many villains, Zsasz's consistency was refreshing. He did what he knew best and he was good at it.
Gotham's Zsasz was played by Anthony Carrigan and superbly so. His performance is a big contributing factor to Zsasz's ranking on this list.
Zsasz wasn't threatening in the way you might expect a hit-man to be threatening. He's not physically imposing in terms of bulk. He's not aggressively loud or gruff. Carrigan's Zsasz was aloof and quiet. Eerie and calculating. It is exactly this that made Zsasz such a compelling villain.
8. Fish Mooney (Seasons 1-3)
Jada Pinkett-Smith was one of the big-name draws of Gotham's premiere season. Gotham charted the rise of many famous DC Batverse characters but Pinkett-Smith's Fish Mooney was a brand new creation for the show.
From crime lord to mind-controller, Mooney held on to a pretty strong reign but all good things must come to an end. Pinkett-Smith did a great job with the role and was a valuable part of the cast. That being said, it seems that Pinkett-Smith's ever-changing commitment to the show jeopardised the character's potential.
One of Mooney's greatest strengths was her ability to command power despite having no enhanced abilities herself. This all changed after Hugo Strange resurrected Mooney, providing her with the power to control the minds of others.
It was an entertaining storyline and brought Mooney back into the fold but the arc ending up being her downfall. It took away the simplicity of the character that made us respect her in the first place.
7. Hugo Strange (Seasons 2-5)
Gotham marked the first time Hugo Strange was portrayed as a live-action character. This is a pretty big deal and thankfully, Gotham did a great job. Portrayed by B D Wong, Strange made his first appearance as a part of the 'Wrath of the Villains' arc in season two - although he stuck around for the majority of Gotham's five season run.
Strange's greatest strength was most definitely his curious and diabolical mind. His experiments created or enhanced a number of villains including Fish Mooney, Mr Freeze, Firefly, Azrael and Clayface - to name a few.
Not only was Strange a compelling villain in his own right, he's such an important catalyst in the villainous rise of others. This made him one of Gotham's most valuable assets.
Wong was perfect in the role and had a poker-face like no other. Strange played both sides of the field throughout his time on Gotham and you were never quite sure which side he was on at any given time. That makes him one of Gotham's greatest villains.
6. Barbara Kean (Seasons 1-5)
Barbara Kean is somewhat of an odd one out on this list. Portrayed by Erin Richards, it was never the intention for Kean to become a villain. In the comics, Kean is simply James Gordon's wife but Gotham's writers were so impressed with Richards' acting that they decided to give the character a villainous streak which, continued to grow and grow.
Barbara had great character development and her storyline never felt stagnant. Few would've guessed that she was destined to become Gotham's newest crime boss - especially after falling victim to The Ogre in season one.
The scenes between Kean and Gordon were some of the show's best. Gordon was a resilient man - he had to be in a city like Gotham - but something about Kean weakened and unnerved him. That was the great thing about Barbara. She was constantly changing her alliances but that's what allowed her to stick around for so long.
Barbara Kean also formed 'The Sirens' alongside Selina Kyle and Tabitha Galavan, and we'll never say no to a bit of girl power.
5. The Riddler/Edward Nygma (Seasons 1-5)
The Riddler - played excellently by Cory Michael Smith - was a major antagonist in Gotham and one that was always intended to be so from the start. It felt like there were two main arcs in Nygma's storyline: before and after he assumed the identity of The Riddler.
The former was perhaps the strongest of the two. Still working for the Gotham City Police Department as their forensics investigator, pre-Riddler Nygma walked a slippery slope. All the makings of his villainous alter-ego were there - his clever mind, his affinity for riddles, and his possessive relationship with Kristen Kringle - but Nygma was still trying to keep hold of his morality.
After acknowledging his identity as The Riddler, Nygma certainly looked the part and Michael Smith provided the character with an intellectual intensity that perfectly suited his quick-thinking mind.
At times, it felt that Gotham wasn't certain about what to do with Nygma 2.0 as he lacked an endgame. Sadly, that's just a part of Gotham's format. The show thrills us with the origin stories of Batman and his greatest adversaries without ever giving or showing us their eventual showdowns.
4. Theo Galavan (Season 2)
Unlike most of the high-ranking villains on this list, Theo Galavan didn't stick around for very long - only serving as villain for the second season. That being said, he worked his way up into becoming Gotham's Mayor thus assuming the most powerful position in the city.
It's no secret that Gotham's cast was its greatest asset. They did a phenomenal job of bringing these characters to life and James Frain's portrayal of Theo Galavan is no different. He was both charming and charismatic - which aren't the words you first think to use when describing a villain but for Galavan it worked so well.
Galavan played an important role in the rise of some fellow antagonists including Barbara Kean and Jerome Valeska. Kean and Valeska went on to become some of Gotham's most powerful villains. Evidently, Galavan must've had a very strong hold in order to control them as a part of his team.
3. Jeremiah Valeska (Seasons 4-5)
Gotham wouldn't be a prequel to Batman without an appearance from the iconic Joker - or two. Jeremiah Valeska was the latter of the two. Played by the phenomenal Cameron Monaghan, Jeremiah's storyline culminated in a scene we are all familiar with - the showdown between 'Joker' and Bruce Wayne at Ace Chemicals.
Monaghan had already won Gotham fans over with his portrayal of Jerome Valeska and so, it's no surprise that his performance as his brother Jeremiah also went down a treat.
At first, Jeremiah appeared to be the complete opposite of Jerome - calm, collected, intelligent, sane, and most importantly, moral. Essentially, it was over only six episodes in Gotham's fourth season that Jeremiah quickly transitioned from this into Gotham's most feared villain.
So much of the success of the character was down to Monaghan and he deserves all of the attention he got from the role. Gotham's writers also earn huge props. Jeremiah was only ever referred to as The Joker in Gotham's promotional footage but there's no doubt that Monaghan's performance will long be heralded as one of the best.
2. Penguin/Oswald Cobblepot (Seasons 1-5)
Jim Gordon may have been Gotham's protagonist but Oswald Cobblepot certainly commanded a very large amount of screen-time - and the show was all the better for it. Needless to say, Robin Lord Taylor was made to play the role and it was thrilling to watch him rise from Fish Mooney's lackey to the most powerful villain in Gotham, Penguin.
Penguin is unlike any other villain featured on this list because he does little to hide his emotional vulnerability. Even when he is at his most powerful, there is always something grounding him such as his love for his mother or his friendship with Nygma.
Lord Taylor's Penguin was outlandish and exuberant but never ashamed of his feelings. You only need hear him say, "He killed my Mother, Jim." His voice break is enough to tell you that this is a character with a deep sense of humanity despite the atrocities he commits.
Penguin also managed to survive Gotham's entire run which requires ingenuity so this has to earn him some extra points.
1. Jerome Valeska (Seasons 1-4)
This list has been a long journey from Sal Maroni to here but finally, we rank Jerome Valeska as Gotham's best villain. This is actor, Cameron Monaghan's second appearance on this list as he also played Jeremiah Valeska who ranked in third place.
Jerome is often referred to as a prototype Joker. There's no need to restate how talented Cameron Monaghan is but we will anyway because he's THAT good. If you're a long-time fan of Gotham, you'll remember a stand-out scene from the Season One episode, 'The Blind Fortune Teller.'
It was the first time we started to get the idea that there was more to Jerome than meets the eye. Every actor brings something new to the iconic Joker laugh and Monaghan's is certainly memorable. His downturned chin and upturned eyes make for a sight that is difficult to forget for all the right reasons.
Jerome had some pretty iconic lines too. He tells his brother, "We could all go insane with just one bad day." This sums Gotham up and seems a fitting way to end this list.
The Ultimate Gotham Quiz