Marvel's Daredevil Season 2: 10 Ups And 2 Downs
The moments that were Elektra-fying, and those Punishing to watch.
How did you spend your weekend?
Lol, as if I even need to ask. Daredevil Season 2 dropped into Netflix on Friday, ensuring that anyone who enjoyed the first instalment - i.e. anyone who watched it - was ready to give up their weekend and any pretensions of having a social life in order to binge-watch all 13 episodes as quickly as possible.
Thankfully, despite meaning close to 13 hours of television, it wasn't an arduous task. Far from it, in fact. While the first season focused on Daredevil's origins and his battle with Wilson Fisk, this broadened the scope to introduce Elektra, the Hand, and of course The Punisher.
It was Jon Bernthal's addition that everyone was most hyped for, and suffice to say he didn't disappoint, delivering the definitive version of The Punisher. He was a big reason, though certainly not the only one, that the second outing for The Man Without Fear was just as dramatic, action-packed, and ultimately great viewing as the first - if not even better.
The stakes were raised, the action increased, relationships were made and destroyed, and their were mysteries at every turn. Was it perfect? No, there were a couple of missteps, but on the whole it was a !*$% good season of TV.
Firstly, a look at the many things Season 2 got right.
12. Building Upon Season 1
As mentioned, the first season of Daredevil was a great success, delivering a take on the character that banished any lingering memories of the 2003 film, and was exciting, dramatic, and fun to whizz through in an entire weekend.
If the events of The Avengers led to Daredevil, then the events of that first season lead us to Season 2. Hell's Kitchen is a different place now: the rise of the Devil of Hell's Kitchen gives rise to a new wave of vigilantism, while Fisk being put behind bars opens a power vacuum that is begging to be filled.
It's a logical follow-up, and though there's plenty in this season that stands alone, it's good to see it build upon that great first season and use those foundations as the basis for the various directions it goes in, from Matt and Karen's relationship to the emergence of the Punisher, the return of Fisk, and the mysterious new villains on the scene.
11. The Return Of Wilson Fisk
Ah yes, Wilson Fisk. Season 1 owes as much to its villain as it does its hero, with Vincent D'Onofrio delivering an incredibly nuanced and compelling portrayal of the Hell's Kitchen Kingpin.
Although the first season ended with him behind bars, you'd have been mistaken if you thought his story - and his power - was done. His return is a longtime coming, but when he finally does show up he helps give the season a second wind.
He doesn't dominate the story as he did in the first season, and nor should he. Instead, he's pulling strings from prison, unleashes the Punisher, and has a great face-off with Matt Murdock.
He mentions that he's playing the long-game, and Netflix here are playing the long-game with the character, setting things up nicely for the future while having an immediate impact as well, and D'Onofrio is great to watch no matter how much we get of him.
10. Foggy Stepping Up
Foggy was a fun character in Season 1, a bit more comic relief to the dark and serious tone of the rest of the series. He had some tension with Matt, but it was all resolved by the end.
In Season 2 he gets a lot more to do, and it's definitely for the better of the character and the show. He still has some moments where he's the one providing the humour, but it's less of an on-the-nose parallel this time around as he comes into his own.
He's now the protector of Matt's secret, lying to Karen about Matt's whereabouts, while standing up to his friend and his behaviour more this time around. He does his own digging and puts himself in danger, as witnessed by going to the Dogs of Hell. And most of all, he shows himself to be a fine lawyer, carrying Nelson & Murdock when his partner goes missing, and ultimately striking out on his own.
Where this will lead to in Season 3 (because that's surely just a formality now) is unclear, although it does tie the character into Jessica Jones as well as Daredevil, but for this season he was certainly a much more rounded character, and better as a result.
9. Courtroom Drama
One thing that would've been good to see in Season 1 was some proper courtroom drama, showing Nelson & Murdock in action. There wasn't enough shown of that side of things, and it's something they rectify here as we get to see a proper trial unfold.
It helps that the trial in question is of Frank Castle, a rather unique and compelling case, but just including these scenes anyway are a welcome addition. With Making A Murderer and The People v O.J. Simpson being big hits this year courtroom dramas are very much 'in', and Daredevil puts its own particular spin on this here.
There's some superb grandstanding from both prosecution and defence, the drama of a witness' testimony being thrown out, and then Frank going full-crazy and declaring himself guilty. It adds something different to the show, and another layer to the Nelson & Murdock storyline, and it definitely works here.
8. More For Karen To Do
Karen wasn't a bad character in the first season of Daredevil, but she did start out as a damsel-in-distress and despite helping out at the law firm she didn't progress too far beyond that.
She's given a more established arc here, and not just as a love interest, although that is obviously a part of it. Her relationship with Matt feels natural, and there's an easy chemistry between the pair.
That's not where her character really shines though. Firstly, she comes through as a vital part of Nelson & Murdock, so much so there's talk of her going to law school and the firm becoming Nelson, Murdock & Page. Then she breaks into journalism and, well apparently degrees and other qualifications aren't important, but bringing her personal perspective on The Punisher, and adding more to her mysterious backstory, makes up for it.
She's closely connected to Frank Castle, and gets through to him in a way no one else can, allowing us to see beyond the Punisher and to the much more human core underneath.
7. Charlie Cox's Performance
Charlie Cox had built up a solid CV ahead of Daredevil's first season, but to a wider audience he was still largely unknown. However, he quickly established himself as the character, immediately erasing both doubts and lingering memories of Ben Affleck's portrayal.
He gave a solid performance, if one that was overshadowed by D'Onofrio's Fisk, but he's even better this time around. He's definitely more comfortable in the two roles, both as Murdock and Daredevil, and the story this year gives him much more chance to showcase a range of emotions, and bring more depth to the character, whether it's in the breakdowns of his relationships, or just the little tics and movements he adds to Matt as he's moving around and picking up sounds.
Again, someone else may be stealing the show, but it's Cox's performance that holds all the others together.
6. An Elektra To Remember
While praise for Bernthal's Punisher has been universal and effusive, Elektra may prove to be a little more divisive. There are issues with the way she fits into the story towards the end, and her arrival interrupts the blistering start to Season 2, but in terms of Elektra herself then this is definitely an improvement on what we've seen before. Much like Season 1 of Daredevil made up for the film, Season 2 and Elektra helps make up for the 2005 disaster.
Elodie Yung handles the character with aplomb, the devil on the shoulder of Matt, a sign of his past and what he could be, and something a part of him still is. She provides her own action moments and never feels out of place, while bringing in turns humour and vengeful rage that keep the character interesting.
As mentioned, it's not something without issue, but it's still a big improvement, and a worthy addition to the show despite the later problems.
5. Fight Choreography
One thing everyone agreed on about Season 1 was that the action scenes were fantastic. There was the much-lauded one-shot fight at the end of Episode 2, Cut Man, but that was just the standout amongst many stellar moments.
The question, then, was could they top it in Season 2? The answer is a resounding yes. There's the one that will provide the most obvious talking point, and that's the staircase fight scene in Episode 3, New York's Finest. It was bigger, longer, and crazier, with a chain-wielding Daredevil tearing through his enemies but taking a heavy dose of punishment himself. It's intense, it's brutal, and it's an incredible 10 minutes or so of television, standing as one of the finest fight scenes you're likely to see on the small screen.
It was the standout, but certainly not the only one. A mirror to this can be found with The Punisher's prison block efforts, faced with seemingly insurmountable odds he wins, and does so in devastating manner. Then there are all the fight scenes involving Daredevil, Elektra, and the Hand, because if there was one thing needed to kick the action scenes into an even higher gear, it was ninjas. Maybe they did get a little repetitive by the 4th time it was happening, but it was still fun to watch.
4. Jon Bernthal IS The Punisher
The major addition to the cast for Season 2, the one that had fans salivating with excitement, was Jon Bernthal as The Punisher.
Frank Castle is an extremely popular comic-book character, but one never fully done justice on screen, either because of actor or story. Here, both are in place, and Bernthal steals the entire show.
His presence looms large over everything, and he's an incredibly imposing and intimidating figure. We saw Bernthal become increasingly violent and unstable in The Walking Dead, and he brings something similar to Daredevil. However, while he is a killing machine, he's certainly not insane, well aware of what he's doing, and why.
That brings added depth to the character, as does the tragic backstory of his family being murdered before his eyes, and although he's a murderer you still find yourself rooting for him. Unlike with Fisk last year, there's nothing that changes that point-of-view, no moment he goes too far and becomes unsympathetic; if anything, he becomes more sympathetic as the season moves along.
The Punisher is a ruthless, brutal killing machine. He's an anti-hero bordering on full-blown villainy, and could easily be painted as a monster. Daredevil doesn't shy away from showing that side of him, but it also peels back the layers to reveal the doting father, the grieving husband, the very real, human man with a heart, and Bernthal absolutely nails all of that.
3. Daredevil V The Punisher
The Punisher's battle with Daredevil was one of the biggest selling points of Season 2, an ideological battle between two characters who could in some ways be defined as heroes, but take it to much darker extremes, especially in the case of Frank Castle.
Although they inevitably came together later on, the opening episodes of the season were given over to these two facing off, and it certainly did not disappoint.
The fight scenes between the pair were raw and severe, a weakened Matt (that's what'll happen when you're shot in the head) given a beatdown by the Punisher, and ending up in chains. That rooftop scene, based on an iconic moment from the comics, was fantastic to watch, as Daredevil struggled with saving lives and refusing to kill, and it perfectly highlighted the similarities and differences between the pair.
It all came to a head at the end of The Punisher's mini-arc, when Daredevil actually rescues him, and their conversation in the graveyard was a deeper one than you'd normally find between hero and adversary. They may have ended up on the same side, but those first few episodes, watching them go head-to-head, made for some fantastically intense and exciting viewing.
Now, onto the downs of Season 2...
2. Pacing Issues
Perhaps this was inevitable, given the opening episodes, but there are some pacing issues with Daredevil's second season that don't make binge-watching a completely smooth ride.
The first four episodes, or the 'Punisher arc', go along at a blistering pace. It's exciting, it's tense, there's a lot going on and you're completely swept along with it, setting the stage very nicely for the rest of the season.
The next batch of episodes, the 'Elektra arc', then slow things down somewhat. There are flashbacks, the Daredevil/Punisher stuff is largely done with, but it hasn't yet got to the mystery that will drive the conclusion, meaning that while there's still some strong moments, it does sag a little bit.
It's all brought back together for the concluding episodes, which increases the pace again, but doesn't deliver a wholly satisfying end to things.
Breaking the season up into smaller arcs makes sense, especially with the binge-watch model as it means you're getting something different every few episodes, but the way it goes at breakneck speed and then slows it right down is rather jarring. It perhaps works better if there's a slower episode followed by a faster one, especially if watching all in one go, rather than chunks of slower, more character or story building episodes. It doesn't ruin the season, but it is certainly an issue.
1. Weird Story Turns
As mentioned previously, I thought Elektra was well-portrayed by Elodie Yung, and in terms of the action beats and personality traits the character worked.
However, there were a couple of big moments in the concluding episodes that revolved around her, and they didn't work. One is when they're making their way to the rooftop, ready for a final showdown with the Hand. Knowing they might not survive, Matt gives a heartfelt speech about how he wants to be with her, about the way he makes her feel and how he'll leave his New York life behind to follow wherever she goes.
It felt like a weird moment, and one that hadn't been earned by either character. Matt's city is New York, Elektra even says that, and for him to say he'll leave it and everyone he holds close behind to follow a woman he hasn't loved since college, a woman who is a killer, just doesn't fit. Had they built up to that, with Elektra causing him to question or choose between Matt Murdock and Daredevil it might have worked, but coming in this sudden instance did not.
The other big Elektra moment was the twist, which revealed her to be the Black Sky that the Hand want to unleash. Again, it just felt quite a random and unnecessary moment. Oh, all of a sudden she's the incredible weapon the Hand want to use, and Stick knew this when he raised her, but now he wants to kill her, but actually she's not going to kill him and what?! There was a lack of setup for this moment, and in particular a lack of setup to make us care about the Black Sky in general, that it didn't really work, and ultimately felt pointless - until her eventual resurrection, at least.
What did you think of Daredevil Season 2? Share your own ups and downs in the comments below.
Follow us on Twitter: @WhatCultureTV