Red Dwarf: 11 Episodes That Never Made It To Air
With the crimson short one back our screens, we look at the episodes that never were...
If you want to lie shipwrecked and comatose while drinking fresh mango juice, you’re in luck. Because Red Dwarf is finally back for a full series for the first time in four years. And with Series 11 now being broadcast and Series 12 already filmed, Red Dwarf is back to a relatively smooth schedule production-wise for the first time since the 1990s. I'm as surprised as you are to be honest.
Red Dwarf seems to constantly have its feet held to the fire, battling against every conceivable problem you can think of. From a constant lack of budget to the oddly specific issue of just how long an actor can legally perform in a chimpanzee costume, things never run entirely smoothly. And because of that, there are quite a few episodes that failed to get past the early development stages and ended up as dead as A-line flares with pockets in the knees.
But, rather fittingly for Red Dwarf, death wasn’t the end for all of these episodes and some lived on in other ways. Step things up to red alert (and yes, it means changing the bulb) because these are eleven episodes of Red Dwarf that never got off the ground.
11. Bodysnatcher - Series 1 Episode 2
The first of these lost episodes comes right from the very beginning, being from such an early stage that Alfred Molina and Alan Rickman were said to have used the script for their auditions to play Lister and Rimmer. The story itself was largely concerned with Rimmer coping with his death and trying to build a new body from parts of Lister’s. It also put a lot more focus on their interactions than other episodes, whilst the Cat and Holly were mostly background elements.
A major rethink from creators Rob Grant and Doug Naylor after considering the episode unworkable led to the decision to drop the unfinished script in favour of Me2, while a number of jokes and smaller plot points were moved to other Series 1 and 2 scripts. Eventually, the idea of Rimmer trying to build a new body was brought out of mothballs and used for a brief gag in the Series 4 episode DNA.
Almost twenty years later; Grant and Naylor collaborated for the first time in a over a decade to finish the script, and the episode was animated with storyboards for release on DVD along with the remastered versions of Series 1 to 3 as part of The Bodysnatcher Collection. As far as things brought back from the dead go, it’s much more tolerable than Rimmer.
10. Series 2 - The Original Plan
In the earlier stages of production on Series 1, Confidence And Paranoia (Episode 5) was the series finale and would have ended with Lister successfully bringing Kochanski back as a hologram. Closing the series-long story and character arc of Lister being in love with her and trying to find some way to bring her back, while at the same time setting her up as a lead character for Series 2.
But when Bodysnatcher was dropped, the episode order changed and Confidence And Paranoia became Episode 5. The ending was then altered so that Rimmer had hidden his own hologram personality disc in Kochanski’s box, leading into the new series finale Me2 where Rimmer moves in with a copy of himself. We would end up seeing Kochanski again in Series 2 and once more in Series 6 as a hallucination but it would be a full nine years before she joined the crew properly in Series 7, recast with Chloë Annett instead of Clare Grogan.
9. Dad - Series 3 Episode 1
In an uncharacteristically logical move for Rob Grant and Doug Naylor, Series 3 of Red Dwarf would have originally followed on from the Series 2 cliffhanger that saw Lister discover he was pregnant after sleeping with himself in a parallel universe. Which itself was a follow-up to the Series 1 episode Future Echoes that ended with a future Lister giving birth to twins.
But during the screenwriting process, it was decided that a comedy pregnancy didn’t quite gel with the Red Dwarf universe and that the script just wasn’t very funny. Elsewhere, writers of The Red Dwarf Programme Guide Chris Howarth and Steve Lyons have also suggested that the episode was rejected for possibly being sexist. Dad was subsequently replaced by Backwards, an episode now regarded by some fans as one of the very best.
At the start of Backwards, Series 2’s cliffhanger and the considerable changes to the programme (namely Holly’s sex change and the reintroduction of Kryten) were dealt with in typical Grant Naylor style: a Star Wars-esque opening crawl that was fast to the point of being unreadable. But fortunately, some snippets of Dad do survive. Eight minutes of script were animated in the same storyboard style as Bodysnatcher with voice work supplied by Chris Barrie as a bonus feature on The Bodysnatcher Collection.
8. Garbage World - Series 4 Episode 6
The running order of Series 4 was switched around a lot to move the war-themed episode Meltdown (eventually broadcast as the series finale) from the opening slot because of concerns over the ongoing Gulf War conflict. But at one point, Episode 6 was set to be an adaptation of the Garbage World sequence from the second Red Dwarf novel Better Than Life.
In the novel, the ice planet where Starbug crashes in Marooned (Series 3 Episode 2) is revealed to actually be Earth millions of years after the human race voted to evacuate it and use it as humanity’s rubbish dump. Meanwhile; Red Dwarf is being sucked into a black hole and, because of time dilation, the Dwarfers don’t rescue Lister for several decades from his perspective. During that time, he has spent the years living amongst the giant cockroaches that populate the planet and started to restore it.
How much of the Garbage World chapters were adapted is unclear (though the giant cockroaches were included) but the scale of it was enough for director Ed Bye to put the brakes on it for budgetary reasons. The episode was replaced by White Hole, which was adapted from the events of the novel surrounding Lister’s rescue but with the ending changed to be more conclusive, as the book version leads into a sequence based on Polymorph (Series 3 Episode 3).
7. Identity Within - Series 7 Episode 2
The first episode to focus on the Cat, John McKay's Identity Within would have seen the Cat suffer from a condition that would kill him unless he had sex, causing the crew to try and find him a mate at a GELF slave auction. The story would also have touched on the idea of the Cat having become more domesticated, while a later draft included his dorky alter-ego Duane Dibbley in a dream sequence.
A full draft was written by McKay but a significant portion of the Series 7 budget was already spoken for (thanks in part to the various settings of the opening episodes Tikka To Ride and Stoke Me A Clipper), and Identity Within was just too costly. Particularly the need for two key guest stars (provisionally cast with Series 8 actors Yasmin Bannerman and Graham McTavish), a crowded tavern set, and a new eight foot tall subspecies of GELFs.
When it became clear that Identity Within couldn’t be achieved with the available budget, it was dropped and replaced with Duct Soup. An episode that, in a grand old sitcom tradition, was written to be as cheap as possible. But worry ye not, smegheads. A storyboarded version of Identity Within's first draft was released on the Series 7 DVD with Chris Barrie doing the voices. Yes, even Ora the female Cat.
6. Phwooaar - Series 8 Episode 5
When Series 8 was being developed, Series 7 and 8 writer Paul Alexander independently produced a script titled Phwoaarr. A story that would have featured the crew discovering a derelict spaceship where a new perfume was being tested that caused insatiable sexual attraction to whoever smelt it. This would have ended up causing Rimmer and Kochanski to have sex, leading to a lot of jealousy from Lister.
Phwoaarr was rejected on the grounds that its tone and content were inappropriate (at one point involving piles of nude corpses) but Series 5’s Sexual Magnetism Virus was brought back for Series 8’s opening trilogy, and the idea of Rimmer and Kochanski having sex resurfaced as part of Cassandra (Episode 4). An episode that Paul Alexander is credited as a script associate on. Looks like that was one plot point he wasn’t keen on letting go of.
Elsewhere; the piles of nude corpses scene made an appearance more recently in the Series 11 episode Samsara, as part of an attempt by a doomed crew to outwit their ship's karma drive (reprogrammed to reward negative behaviour) by... doing something that looked a bit like playing Twister. It seems that switching the nude corpses to skeletons was enough to okay that particular scene.
5. Time Hacking Episode - Series 8
Another Series 8 idea from Alexander that never made it out of the starting gate was a script involving time hackers downloading time from the future to sell on so that buyers could, for example, live longer than they would have. The Dwarfers would become involved when Lister would wake up to find himself aged seventy, causing the crew to find out just what was going on.
The script also included a device called a Time Gun that could weaponise digitally stored time to do things like turn an acorn into an oak to tree to stop people pursuing the user. And it was this idea that saved the episode in a way since, as the sleeve notes for the Series 8 DVD put it, “this cyberpunky notion was just a little too whacked out, even for Red Dwarf”.
At the time Alexander pitched the Time Hacking idea, Doug Naylor was writing Captain's Office (which would later become the episodes Pete Part 1 & 2) and needed a big climax. Alexander suggested that the Time Gun could be used to turn a sparrow into a dinosaur. The Time Gun became the Time Wand, and the rest is budget-blowing history.
4. Earth - Series 8 Episode 8
Intended as the final episode of the programme altogether, Earth (as the title suggests) would finally see the Dwarfers achieve their goal as Red Dwarf returned to Earth. The slime’s coming home. With a lot of collateral damage along the way.
Not a lot has been discussed about the episode as a whole but Doug Naylor had the final sequence pretty clearly mapped out. Upon its return to Earth; the small rouge one would crash through a number of historic landmarks, destroying most of the planet before coming to a stop. Lister would then emerge from the ship and try to swap insurance details with some of the surviving humans.
As you can probably guess from that description and the recurring reason for some of these episodes being scrapped, Earth just wasn’t possible on a BBC budget. Particularly since Series 8 had already suffered a lot of financial woes that meant Back In The Red (originally Episodes 1 and 2) and Pete (originally Episode 6) had to be stretched to additional episodes, with scenes that had been cut from Cassandra filling some of Pete’s runtime.
In the end, Earth never being made definitely turned out to be for the best since it has allowed for the production of the Back To Earth trilogy, Series 10 and 11, and next year’s Series 12. It’s pretty safe to say that twenty-one new episodes at the cost of losing one is a pretty good deal.
3. The Movie
A Red Dwarf movie seems to be Doug Naylor’s Holy Grail but is constantly just out of his reach. The biggest issue in getting the movie off the ground was always funding, but at least once it was stalled by unrealistic compromises. Naylor met with a producer who suggested a complete recast including Hugh Grant as Lister and Emma Thompson in an unspecified role. Naylor later described himself as having left the meeting rather quickly. Presumably in a pair of jet-powered rocket pants.
There were plans to shoot in Australia in late 2003 at the recommendation of Weta Workshop founder Richard Taylor, and a movie did get to the pre-production stage at least once in the early 2000s. With storyboards being drawn up, test shots of Red Dwarf being filmed, and Robert Llewellyn having his head cast for a new Kryten mask. The script has never been made publically available but a promotional posted created by Winchester Films as part of Naylor's fundraising efforts describes the plot as involving cyborgs called Homo Sapienoids targeting the Dwarfers after wiping out the rest of mankind and dominating the solar system.
The Movie was rescued from purgatory in 2012 when Series 10 ran into production problems (which we’ll get to) and two new scripts were needed at short notice. With a looming deadline, elements of the various drafts of the movie’s script were used for the series finale The Beginning. So with three new series filmed and elements of the movie’s script already used for Series 10, it’s unclear if Naylor still plans to bring Red Dwarf to the big screen.
2. Red Dwarf Unplugged
When plans for Red Dwarf’s revival were still in their early stages, Back to Earth was written as two-parter while the third episode commissioned by Dave would have been a completely stripped down episode titled Red Dwarf Unplugged.
Doug Naylor’s plan for Unplugged would have seen Craig Charles, Chris Barrie, Danny John-Jules, and Robert Llewellyn performing scenes from previous episodes in front of a live studio audience without sets or props. An idea described by Charles as “Just the four of us—and some chairs—trying to improvise, or rather trying to remember, classic scenes”.
During pre-production, it became apparent that the idea just wasn’t working. Instead; Unplugged was scrapped and Back to Earth was expanded to a trilogy, using the two filming days set aside for Unplugged for extra location work. Although this was mainly to fill the contractually required third episode, it also gave Back To Earth more breathing space.
Which was definitely the better option considering that it had been deliberately overwritten in the first place for an extended director’s cut on DVD. Though, ironically, the released director’s cut actually ended up coming in at a slightly shorter runtime than the three individual episodes.
1. Series 10 Episodes 5 & 6
If there had to be two words to describe the production of Series 10, they would probably be: smegging hell. The series struggled under a huge number of production problems, to the extent that only half of Dear Dave (Episode 5) was filmed on-set in front of a studio audience because the other half was still being written. But the biggest loss to Series 10 was the need to drop the original Episodes 5 and 6.
Planned as a two-part finale; these episodes would have focussed on reintroducing Kochanski after an absence of thirteen years, other than a cameo in Part 3 of Back To Earth. But, as the amount of location filming for Series 10 had to be drastically scaled back from a fortnight to a single day, the Kochanski episodes had to go because they featured the most location work.
Ultimately, the single day of location filming was allocated to Lemons (Episode 3), and Episodes 5 and 6 were replaced with the entirely studio-bound Dear Dave and The Beginning. Both of which were written by Doug Naylor in the space of just ten days. But with the rest of Series 11 still to go and Series 12 already filmed, we may not have seen the last of a certain navigation officer just yet.
Which of these unaired episodes do you wish had made it to screen? Share your thoughts in the comments below.