Star Trek: 10 WORST Things Gul Dukat Has Ever Done

Was he truly Star Trek's greatest villain, or just an annoying upstart with delusions of grandeur?

Star Trek Gul dukat Smiling
CBS / Shout! Studios

Gul Dukat was with Deep Space Nine from the very beginning, confidently walking into Sisko's office while bemoaning the fact it had, until rather recently, been his own. There was a swagger in the way he moved that suggested a lack of any guilt - bear in mind, we had been introduced to this man as the former prefect of an occupied world. First impressions tend to stick.

As the years rolled by, Dukat oscillated from vague ally to all-out villain, using his cunning charm to hide some truly depraved actions. Once Cardassia joined the Dominion, for the most part, he abandoned all pretence of being a redeemable man. He was just plain bad, no matter how much he tried to hide that behind patriotism.

Then, in the final days of the War, he moved from patriotism to religious zealotry, inspiring Kai Winn to sink into true evil with him. There is a charisma to the man that is undeniable, though he could never be truly counted among the leaders one should try to emulate.

Though his crimes are legion, we are going to attempt to pick ten of the worst.

10. Seeking His Daughter So He Can Execute Her

Star Trek Gul Dukat Breen Uniform Indiscretion
CBS Media Ventures

Indiscretion sees Major Kira teaming up with Gul Dukat - despite high protestation - to find the survivors of the Ravinok. This Cardassian transport vessel was lost during the Occupation, presumably with all hands. One of Kira's friends was a passenger but so, too, was a woman close to Dukat's heart. 

Tora Naprem was, seemingly, one of Dukat's many comfort women that he kept during the Occupation. Though he professed to love her, he had another reason for the search, as became clear when they did in fact find the wreckage of the ship. He and Naprem had a daughter together - Tora Ziyal - who Dukat was now searching for.

For a moment, Kira softened toward him. He amended that rather quickly by informing her that if he found Ziyal, he would have to kill her. The existence of a half-Bajoran daughter of the Occupation would threaten Dukat's standing in society. something he couldn't risk. Despite Kira's outrage, he was determined to destroy all evidence of his infidelities.

Though he did, in the end, let Ziyal live and even bring her back to Cardassia with him, there is no doubt that without Kira forcing him to hesitate, he would have shot his own daughter.


9. Pitting Bajorans Against Each Other

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Kira Meru Wrongs Darker Than Death Or Night
CBS Media Ventures

During the Occupation, the Cardassians encouraged the Bajorans to work with them, promising all sorts of comforts in exchange for loyalty. As one could imagine for any beaten down people, there were those who took this offer and ran with it. Dukat was no exception to this, offering positions of relative power to those Bajorans willing to turn against their own.

There were the Bajorans who worked on the station, safe and comfortable, organising Dukat's harem of comfort women. There were those who spied on others, offering information in exchange for leniency. Then there were yet more who delivered names to Dukat, helping the Cardassians track down Bajoran terrorists in the hopes that this may secure the release of Bajoran prisoners.

Dukat cultivated an environment of fear, of betrayal, and loathing among the Bajoran people. This helped to keep them separated and unable, for years, to form a central group that could rise up against him. As we learned later on, not only did he defend his actions, but he celebrated them.


8. His One Man War Against Sisko

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat Sisko Waltz
CBS Media Ventures

Every villain needs a good hero to battle against. Dukat and Sisko became enemies for the ages, frequently clashing, despite several early attempts at cooperation. Even if we're being kind and accept that, in those first few years, Dukat honestly wanted to work together, there is little doubt that Sisko became his obsession as time went on.

Despite the number of times that Sisko actually saved Dukat's life, the latter blamed the former for many of the ills in his career. Most specifically, he blamed Sisko for the death of Ziyal - ironic, as Dukat had originally planned to kill her anyway, and it was Damar who pulled the trigger. Yet it was Sisko's return to DS9 aboard the Defiant that inspired the Dominion to evacuate, leaving an atmosphere of panic, leading to Ziyal's revelation and death.

This would return to haunt both men. Dukat, forced as he was to endure Starfleet counselling sessions, staved off madness for a short while, then descended fully upon his escape. He then allied himself with Sisko's greatest enemies (more on that to come) striking what he believed to be a deadly blow to one of Starfleet's finest captains. This obsession saw many people die, Sisko's life become increasingly swathed in pain, and led to their infamous meeting in the Bajoran Fire Caves.


7. Beating A Crippled Man With A Pipe

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat Waltz
CBS Media Ventures

In Waltz, Dukat and Sisko finally lay it all out and speak honestly. The scene is set with the destruction of the USS Honshu, then their escape to a nearby barren world. Sisko is badly injured during this escape, leaving him in the unenviable position of being at Dukat's mercy. Frankly, it would be safer to poke a sleeping Dragon in the eye than to allow Dukat to be the one in charge.

As their stay on this planet goes on, Dukat's mental state begins to unravel. He sees apparitions of Damar, Weyoun, and Major Kira - supporting or mocking him, depending on the moment. Though Sisko is initially unaware of this, he can see that time is running out in terms of safety around this man.

Things to come to a head when Sisko finally challenges Dukat on his actions during the occupation. Put on the spot, Dukat cracks, and finally owns up to how much to believes in himself. The Bajorans, in his mind, benefitted from his 'guiding' hand, fully believing that he made things better for them, rather than worse. Sisko attempts to tackle him, before Dukat takes a metal bar from the recently destroyed communications array and viciously beats Sisko with it. 

Attacking a man while he's down is simply par for the course for Dukat, and barely even enters he's top ten worst actions.


6. Executing Innocent People

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat Waltz Rant
CBS Media Ventures

As part of the head-to-head between Sisko and Dukat, the latter starts to recount some of the 'gentle' acts that he perpetrated toward the Bajorans. When he arrived, he cut labour camp quotas 50%, abolished child labour, and gave more concessions, in his estimation. In response, the Bajoran Resistance destroyed an orbital drydock, killing two hundred Cardassians.

In an act of twisted justice, Dukat had two hundred random Bajorans rounded up and executed. This, it is clear, was one of the earliest signs of how he understood justice. There would be no soft hand, nor would there be attempts to foster peace between the Cardassians and the Bajorans.

To further complicate matters, Dukat genuinely believed in Cardassian superiority over the Bajorans. He was enraged by their assertions that they deserved equality, believing their inferiority to be fact. This fuelled his ability to continue to dominate them. Provoked by Sisko, he finally admits that he wanted all of the Bajorans, regardless of any connection to the Resistance, to die. Bajor, he believed, should have been turned into a vast wasteland, thus freeing the Cardassians from having to deal with them any more. 


5. Calling Major Kira On Her Mother's Birthday

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat Kira
CBS Media Ventures

Once his true colours had been revealed, Dukat seemed to revel in his evil status. One such incident saw him contact Major Kira on the day of her mother's birthday. He cruelly revealed that not only had he known Kira Meru, but that they had been intimate. As was often the case with Dukat, this random act of malevolence was mired in the truth.

Meru had been taken from a Bajoran labour camp and deposited on Terok Nor. There, she was personally selected as Dukat's 'comfort woman.' Kira confirms this with the help of the Bajoran Orb of Time. She feels repulsed by what she has learned, and even goes so far as to count her mother expendable in a planned assassination attempt on Dukat's life. However, she changes her mind when she sees that her mother, far from abandoning her family, still cared deeply for them. Her service to Dukat allowed Kira and the rest of her family a slightly improved quality of life.

Dukat, of course, couldn't have known that Kira would discover the full story surrounding Meru's time on Terok Nor. For him, this was torment, pure and simple. Just another day in his warped world.


4. Kidnapping A Rival's Child

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat Bashir And Garak Cardassians
CBS Media Ventures

Cardassia Prime, ever the centre of understanding in the galaxy, has a particularly harsh method for dealing with orphans. To be blunt - they don't deal with them. Orphans have no status whatsoever on the planet, so a child can lose everything before every having a chance to do anything about it.

Knowing this, Dukat orchestrated the kidnap of Rugal, the son of a political rival, Kotan Pa'dar. Pa'dar had voted to end the Cardassian Occupation of Bajor, a decision that Dukat bitterly opposed. When Rugal and his mother were presumed killed in a Bajoran terrorist attack, Dukat actually had the boy taken away and raised by Bajorans, hoping to use the boy to embarrass his father in later years.

Though father and son were eventually reunited, Dukat still achieved a sort of victory. Rugal, raised on Bajor, by Bajoran adoptive parents, and given to the Bajoran belief system, hated all Cardassians - including his father. While Pa'dar's career would survive this encounter, it was clear that his relationship with his son would take years to recover, if at all.


3. Lying About Tekeny Ghemor's Recanting

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat Weyoun Ties Of Blood And Water
CBS Media Ventures

The Cardassian Dissident Movement existed long before the Dominion War, but it came to new strength in opposition to Dukat's conniving and planning. Tekeny Ghemor had been high in the movement when the Obsidian Order were still a great threat, but he was forced to flee Cardassia after the alliance with the Dominion.

Major Kira, with whom he had a close bond, urged him to become the head of the opposition to the Cardassian-Dominion alliance, but he gently refused. He was dying at that stage and was unwilling to sacrifice his final days to the cause. Ever the opportunist, when Dukat became aware of Ghemor's presence on the station, he paid a visit, asking the man to give his public support to the Dominion.

Naturally, Ghemor refused. Naturally, Dukat didn't care. After the man died, Dukat made a public statement, claiming Ghemor recanted his opposition while on his deathbed, fully embraced the Dominion Alliance, and thus quelled the last hopes of the dissidents. It seemed, in the run-up to the Dominion War, that Dukat was closing all avenues of resistance.


2. Joining The Dominion

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat Weyoun Call To Arms
CBS Media Ventures

Perhaps one of the greatest acts of evil committed by Dukat is the secret talks with the Dominion. This was revealed in the hours following the arrival of a large Dominion force in the Alpha Quadrant. Though seemingly geared up to fight, Dukat broke ranks with the Federation ships, joining the Dominion fleet. 

The secret talks in which he engaged were designed to bring Cardassia fully into the Dominion fold. There are, of course, many aspects of this that were devastating for the Alpha Quadrant. While the extent of the war would become apparent in the years that followed, he had effectively doomed his own planet. First, his secret talks ensured that the majority of the Cardassian people had no say in matters.

Then, as the truth came out, Dukat began to see a flaw in his plan: the Cardassians, while certainly a stronger force in the quadrant, had adopted new masters. He had sacrificed their autonomy for the promise of strength. Before the war ended, millions of Cardassians would lie dead on the streets of their own planet - all thanks to the selfish plans of one man.


1. Siding With The Devil

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Dukat What You Leave Behind
CBS Media Ventures

In the world of Deep Space Nine, Dukat literally sides with the Devil. The Pah Wraiths, Bajor's answer to Satan, adopt him as their Emissary, serving as a counter to Sisko. As part of his plans, he adopts groups of Bajorans who truly worship these non-corporeal beings, twisting them into believing the lies that come out of his mouth. 

One of his first, and greatest, evil acts with the Pah Wraiths is the murder of Jadzia Dax, all while trying to cut Sisko off from the Prophets. It is a senseless, brutal act, made no better by his assertion that he hadn't personally meant to harm her.

As Colonel Kira discovers after her abduction, the cult he is raising around himself on Empok Nor are brainwashed into believing anything he says. This, she is horrified to learn, culminates in the suicide of 'true believers', while Dukat himself beams away. He later arrives on Bajor itself, disguised as the Bajoran farmer Anjol Tenan, determined to swing Kai Winn to the side of the Pah Wraiths.

Once again, he is successful, leading to a deadly stand-off in the Fire Caves. He almost succeeds, despite being poisoned by Winn at the last minute. He dies, but is returned to life by his gods, then incinerates the woman. He technically even succeeds in killing Sisko, though of course the true nature of Sisko is up for debate. 

Gul, Legate, then Emissary Dukat is truly one of the most truly evil characters that Star Trek has ever offered up on our screens. 


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"