Star Trek: 5 Reasons Wesley Crusher Doesn't Deserve The Hate

wesley-crusher2 Poor Wesley Crusher... the character is possibly the most maligned in all of Star Trek. His name elicits immediate derision from every corner of the Trek universe and one is more likely to find a Sarah Palin fan at a Jay Z concert than to find an actual Wesley Crusher fan. Now I have to admit to having my own bias against Crusher and even joining in on the bashing once or twice but I decided to give Wesley a second chance based solely on how cool of a guy his portrayer, Will Wheaton, turned out to be. The guy does a pretty nifty podcast and has no problem making fun of himself as evidenced by his portrayal of a supremely dickish "Will Wheaton" on The Big Bang Theory. So I did a bit of a Crusher-esque review of Star Trek: The Next Generation to try and find ways that Wesley Crusher was not so awful and was able to scrape together a list full of backhanded compliments and thinly veiled snark that proves why Wes was not quite as horrible as everyone thinks.

5. He Is Not The Worst Mary Sue Ever

wesley-crusher Now before the cries of "No! Mary Sue's suck! And Crusher was the worst of them all!" comes shooting out of the peanut gallery, let us all admit that the majority of fiction (especially science fiction) benefits from having that one character that can serve as a stand-in for the audience, which is what Wesley Crusher was billed as even if he was really Gene Roddenberry's surreptitious way of inserting an idealized version of himself into Trek lore. Wesley was supposed to be the audience proxy and through his eyes we would see the new universe that Roddenberry had created. Sure things got seriously out of hand that first season with Wesley constantly saving the day and just strolling onto the bridge all willy-nilly but by Season 2 his Mary Sue-ness was dialed down by a billion and he became just another member of the cast. Wesley Crusher may be a textbook Mary Sue but he is definitely not the worst. Twilight's Bella Swan holds that dubious distinction.

4. He Had The Makings Of An Awesome Mad Scientist

293958 Mrcrusherisbignow Super For all the times that Wesley ended up saving the day with ideas that really should have been realized by one of the ranking science officers on The Enterprise long before a precocious 15-year old, he also put the ship and its crew in jeopardy nearly as often. Being a boy genius, Wesley had a tendency to do experiments that he had no business undertaking and he would usually do them without any adult supervision. This recklessness would ultimately result in whatever experiment Wesley was working on going haywire and almost destroying The Enterprise or killing his mom. If only one of his screw-ups had actually killed Dr. Crusher or blown Data to bits or made Wesley bald (hey, being bald at 15 is a traumatic event in the life of boy geniuses that can lead one to a lifetime of crime and a seething hatred of flying men in blue tights) so that he could grow bitter and vow to use his overdeveloped brain to wreck havoc all over Federation space. That would have been a heck of a better destiny for the kid than that nonsense with The Traveler.

3. He Was Ultimately A Bit Of A Slacker

Wesley Crusher From the first moment we meet Wesley Crusher we're told he's a genius, and not long after being told how smart he is the kid would prove it by saving the day. With a resume that features saving an entire starship and its crew multiple times plus being awarded an Ensign ranking without ever actually attending Starfleet Academy, it would not be out of line to think that Wesley was destined to breeze through the Academy, graduate early and be valedictorian or whatever the top cadet is designated. Boy, would anyone with that notion be wrong. Our boy Wesley didn't even make it into Starfleet Academy initially because of low test scores. Low test scores!!! This kid was manipulating warp fields at 16 but he couldn't pass the same entry test that a bonehead like Nog was able to ace? WTF? Wesley was finally able to get into the Academy but he would ultimately screw up again by covering up an accident that killed a fellow cadet, an action that cost him all of his credits and made him have to start all over again as a first year cadet. Then he just zipped off to another plane of reality with that weird Traveler dude and never graduated. My theory is that The Traveler was Wesley's weed man and the two of them checked out of the rat race to live life as a couple of pot heads. An abundance of marijuana use is the only way to explain Wesley's sudden downturn into mediocrity.

2. His Presence Provided Cover For The Other Sucky Characters On The Show

Wwcrusher With the almost instant hatred of Wesley Crusher by Trek fandom a lot of other characters were given passes especially in those first two seasons... I'm looking at you Dr. Crusher, Counselor Troi and Lt. Worf. Those three characters were gawd awful in the early goings of TNG. Dr. Beverly Crusher was as interesting as a rice cake €“ she was a bland, stiff, dull woman devoid of any spark, be it romantic with Capt. Picard or as a comrade to the rest of the crew. The best thing Dr. Crusher did was leave the show so that the infinitely more interesting Dr. Pulaski could take her place, albeit all too briefly. Worf ended up becoming one of my favorite characters in all of Trek but early on he was a snarling poseur who talked a good game about how tough he was but who ended up getting his ass handed to him on a regular basis. The only thing that Worf could be relied on is being the first person knocked unconscious on the bridge. And Troi, well Troi was just awful from start to finish. I am wracking my brain as I write this trying to find one redeeming quality about her and I am coming up totally blank. If there were no Wesley Crusher serving as a human force shield, then Deanna Troi would have probably been the target of all of the fandom's laser-focused hatred and there would be meme generators littering the entirety of the Internet in her dishonor instead of Wesley's.

1. He Was Only A Regular On TNG For 4 Seasons

Wes Crusher Say you can never bring yourself to come to the conclusion that Wesley Crusher is anything but a pox upon the House of Trek, I can understand and would only point to one fact that makes his perceived suckiness not be so all-encompassing. That would be the fact that Wesley was only a regular on the show for four seasons and only made sporadic appearances for the rest of the show's run. Since TNG was pretty crappy as a whole for about two and a half seasons anyway it would be perfectly acceptable to chalk up those bad times as never happening and then all you would have is one and a half seasons of Wesley Crusher to suffer through. Skipping every episode in Season 1 except for Encounter At Farpoint would also allow you to avoid the majority of the most egregious Wesley Crusher terrible moments. So all it takes is a little skillful editing in one's repeat viewing of TNG and it is almost like Wesley Crusher was never a full-time character on the show.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm like Costco. I'm big, I'm not fancy, and I dare you not to like me.