Supernatural: 10 Biggest Unanswered Questions
Saving people, hunting things, and a whole lot of answered questions.
After 15 years on air, Supernatural finally came to an end in 2020. Over the course of the show's 15-year run, the story of the Winchesters' battle against the Supernatural slowly became more complicated and complex as the beings the boys would find themselves fighting against became increasingly powerful.
Though the show did do a good job in answering and fully closing the book on many storylines, there were some that were left unfinished. As the series continued throughout the years, the behind the scenes of Supernatural went through multiple showrunners, directors and creative teams, making it hard to remember to answer every plot point in the show.
However, many fans are burning to know what the answers could be to these unresolved stories. Some storylines have been forgotten on purpose due to the backlash the series got, while a lucky few were brought back into later seasons to give fans the closure they needed but some were just plain forgotten.
For a small screen offering that ran as long as it did, we can forgive the showrunners for forgetting some of these plot point. That said, it’s these ten unanswered questions many fans are dying to know the answers to.
10. Who Is Sam's Wife?
One of the biggest unanswered questions after watching the Supernatural finale is who is Sam's blurred out wife? We see Sam shown with his son Dean at various points of his life over the years, but the audience only gets a slight glimpse of Sam's wife standing on the porch while Sam and their son play baseball. Many fans believe that his wife may be Sam's love interest Eileen after it's been assumed Jack revived her once he absorbed all of God's powers; however, this was never confirmed.
Fans of the show were rightly disappointed that they never got to see who Sam ended up with. Only getting a blurry, long-distance shot of her standing on the porch felt like a punch in the gut to many life-long fans of the series. After witnessing Dean die (for the very last time) in front of him, fans were excited to see who Sam would finally settle down with and have a so-called "apple pie life".
Jared Padalecki was asked about this storyline and if his wife is anyone specific. Padalecki answered no, that the character was meant to be open to fan interpretation, and he even stated that in the script the blurred character was not revealed to be anyone other than a character simply named WOMAN.
9. What Happens To Sam's Son?
Another question regarding Sam's family after hunting, is what happens to Sam's son after Sam died. The Supernatural finale showed Sam living a long and happy life after giving up hunting but doesn't go too deep into the details.
Photos in Sam's house and an anti-demon possession tattoo on his son suggest to fans that Sam did open up to his family about his previous hunting life. However, many are left wondering if Sam ever taught his son how to hunt monsters and if he will carry on the family business. It is noticeable to fans that Sam was a better father to his son than John Winchester was to both Sam and Dean. Sam is shown to be present at every point of his son Dean Jr's life, teaching him mundane things including throwing a baseball with him in the backyard; something the Winchester brothers wished they had with their father.
Many fans can imagine Sam telling his son stories of him and Dean saving the world multiple times and how Dean was the greatest hunter the world has ever seen. However, with Jared Padalecki stating, “I feel like a lot of what Sam did after Dean died was almost in honour of what Dean would have wanted," fans believe if Sam did continue the family business it would've gone against his wishes since Dean wanted Sam out of the hunter life.
8. When Did The FBI Stop Looking For Sam And Dean?
In the earlier seasons of the show, we saw Sam and Dean get caught up on the wrong side of the law when shapeshifters took their identities and committed numerous crimes. From this, the boys were on the run from the FBI all while trying to stop many world-ending disasters. This storyline followed the boys to Season 7 when Leviathans posed as Sam and Dean and went on a crime spree around the country.
Since then, this problem was only mentioned three times in the show. Once when Sam and Dean were imprisoned for the attempted assassination of the President, another when Sam doesn't want to help Donna find her missing niece - reminding Dean about the FBI list and how they think they're dead - and finally in the show 300th episode, Lebanon, we are shown Dean is on the FBI's wanted list.
Despite the FBI thinking Sam and Dean are dead, the brothers never did anything to try and hide their appearance or blend in with a crowd when they were around the police force. With Sam and Dean being such high-class criminals you'd think someone would notice who they are and tip off the FBI that they saw the crime duo.
7. What Happened To The Leviathans?
The Leviathans were the main antagonists of Season 7. Leviathans served as the first of God’s creations, predating demons, angels, humans and even the soul. The Leviathans became too powerful for God’s liking and he made Purgatory to lock them away for eternity. When Castiel opened the door to Purgatory, absorbing the souls and letting the Leviathans free, they didn’t waste any time conquering America, wanting to make themselves the dominant species on Earth.
Throughout that seventh season the Leviathans manufactured a corn syrup that had been mixed into food supplies, giving them control over the human population. Even though Dean kills their leader (causing him and Castiel to be transported to Purgatory) there are many Leviathans which are left over, confused as to what to do now that their leader is dead.
According to Crowley, with their leader dead, Leviathans are no stronger than ordinary monsters and are easier to kill, but what happened to the remaining Leviathans? There have been many storylines that have crossover to many seasons, but the Leviathan storyline disappeared altogether. Even after the Leviathan leader was killed there are many still across America, no doubt still killing people for consumption. It’s a wonder that Sam and Dean never ran into any post-Season 7.
6. What Happened To The Boy Who Was Suppose To Be The Antichrist?
Although Season 5 is wildly regarded as one of the best Supernatural seasons, there are many plot holes left open. The story shifted widely to become mainly focused on the upcoming apocalypse, the Four Horsemen and Sam's choice to whether he would say 'yes' to Lucifer or not. A big storyline that was never resolved from this season is the introduction of Jesse Turner, the Antichrist.
Portrayed as an innocent child, Jesse is a powerful combination of a half-human and half-demon offspring. According to Castiel, Jesse was destined to become the Antichrist and help Lucifer in his war against Heaven. Jesse had the power to exorcise demons with just a few words and could potentially be a powerful weapon in the wrong hands. As Castiel argues with Sam and Dean that Jesse needs to be killed before he causes the destruction of the world, the Winchester brothers wanted to give Jesse a choice, believing if they tell the truth about who he was and his part in the war between Heaven and Hell he can choose not to join.
Jesse ultimately chooses to disappear somewhere where he can't be found. However, that's the last time we see or hear about this character. Jack was later introduced into the show, and he was also deemed the Antichrist - seemingly taking over the role from Jesse.
5. Why Didn't Sam And Dean Continue To Say 'Christo'?
When demons were first introduced to the show, they were considered to be enemies who were much higher than the Winchesters' pay grade. In the later seasons of Supernatural, demons became almost useless, with Sam and Dean killing them off one by one with ease - only struggling with the odd overly powered demon here and there.
Before the Winchester brothers became buddies with Crowley, their one proper interaction with a demon was the main antagonist (at the time) Azazel, a Prince of Hell. As the show was still new, they had viewers believe demons were extremely powerful beings often only appearing in pivotal episodes in the series. In season 1, Sam and Dean revealed a method of spotting a demon is to speak the word 'Christo', which would then force the demon to reveal his black eyes.
The brothers used this tactic throughout the first season's Phantom Traveller episode and stopped the demon from crashing a commercial plane. However, they never use this method again. If the brothers and other hunters continued to use this method when hunting demons, it would've made their lives a lot easier and their hunts a lot shorter. This seems to be something the writers forgot about or simply thought it wouldn't work when the Winchesters surrounded themselves with demons.
4. What Happened To The Other Horsemen?
The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse arrived in Season 5 in the wake of Lucifer’s arrival. A group of enormously powerful entities that embodied the four prime concepts that drives the Apocalypse, each Horseman uses a special ring to channel their core ability - without which, their physical forms are lost, excluding Death.
When Lucifer rises from his cage in Hell, he takes command of the Horsemen and directs them to start his genocide against humanity. When Sam and Dean figure out the rings the Horsemen wore were also the keys to opening Lucifer's cage, they stole them all by force, apart from Death who willingly gave his over to Dean.
Although Death became a reoccurring character of the series - returning multiple times and even being replaced with the reaper Billie - Famine, Pestilence and War never returned after their respected episodes.
Once the four rings were used to open the portal to Lucifer’s cage, we never heard what happened to the other three Horsemen. Wouldn’t they try to track down the Winchester brothers to try and retrieve their rings that were taken from them? Since these beings were (at the time) above the boys' paygrade, a final showdown between the Winchesters and the remaining Horsemen would have made for a great watch and ended the Horsemen storyline nicely.
3. What Happened To Amy Pond’s Son After He Saw Dean Kill His Mother?
In Season 7’s The Girl Next Door we learn that when Sam was a kid, he made a friend with a harmless kitsune named Amy Pond. Amy would later have a child, Jacob, who she needed to kill in order for him to survive. Despite Sam’s pleas to Dean to not kill Amy and let her live, Dean goes behind his back and kills Pond as her son watches on.
Dean threatens Jacob by telling him to be good, and that if he ever started killing people, he would hunt him down and kill him too. Jacob vowed that the only person he will kill will be Dean out of revenge for his mother. Again, this seemed to be another storyline that the writers completely forgot about.
It would have been great to see Jacob come back in later seasons looking for revenge and causing Dean to face the consequences of killing an actual good monster who was only trying to do good. Ultimately, Jacob returning would’ve caused a rift between the brothers, as Sam would’ve felt betrayed with Dean killing his friend after promising him he wouldn’t.
2. What Happened To Castiel?
In Season 15's Despair, we see Castiel confess his love to Dean Winchester, surprising many hardcore Destiel fans by making the popular ship canon and sacrificing himself by letting the entity in the Empty take him away. Many fans were disappointed to find out that the fan-favourite angel didn’t make an appearance in the show’s finale after being such a prominent character for the past ten years.
Fans only got one line in the finale mentioning Castiel’s fate, that Jack, once he gained God’s power, took Castiel out of the empty and brought him back to help rebuild Heaven. With Castiel never shown to reunite with the Winchesters again, one of the biggest unanswered questions fans have after watching the finale is how Dean may react after seeing him again.
Castiel somewhat became the Winchesters' guardian over the years. So, it is safe for fans to assume that, while in Heaven, Castiel still did watch over Sam while he was alive, and is also watching over his son to make sure nothing bad happens to him. Although the finale disappointed fans for various reasons, Castiel not making an appearance made many fans feel unheard, as the show wouldn't have gone on for as long as it did without the loveable angel.
1. How Were Sam And Dean Okay With Killing Innocent Vessels?
We all know Dean’s iconic quote of “saving people, hunting things, the family business”, but it seems that the Winchester brothers themselves forgot about the "saving people" part at times.
Hunting was all about saving and preventing innocents from being harmed by supernatural beings. During the earlier seasons, Sam and Dean always made sure the people they were saving were to be unharmed by the end of the episode, and those who unfortunately died would weigh on their souls greatly, with the brothers feeling they have failed since not everyone was saved.
When Ruby’s demon knife was introduced into the show, the boys started stabbing demons and their hosts without caring if the innocent host would die or not. Of course, when there are multiple demons surrounding and attacking the brothers, it’s near impossible for them to exorcise them all. However, with rouge demons, the brothers could have tried to save the host instead of killing the innocent victim.
Sam and Dean killing innocent people does sort of takes away the purpose of hunting if they are also killing innocents as well as the supernatural.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know Supernatural?