The OA: 9 Crazy Fan Theories That Might Actually Be True
Is any of this real? Is it all a lie? These theories will keep you busy until Season 2 arrives.
Sneaking onto Netflix just before Christmas last year, The OA quickly became one of the most-talked about TV shows of 2016.
The series was equal parts bedazzling and baffling, inspiring and infuriating. The story of Prairie, a blind girl who returned home after being missing for seven years, and mysteriously had her sight back, unspooled into something very, er, different over the course of eight episodes.
The storyline showed us her in the present day, connecting with a new group, to whom she told the story-within-the-story of her capture. Near-death experiences, the afterlife, alternate dimensions, and interpretative dance all played key roles.
With a second season recently confirmed, there are a lot of questions the show has to answer. Until such a time comes, though, it means viewers have to really on speculation about what it all means.
Few TV shows of the last year have generated theories the way The OA has, from Christ allegories to everything being one big fat lie, and these are the ones to keep us occupied until Season 2 proves them all right or wrong (or just ignores them completely).
9. What 'The OA' Really Means
One of the show's big reveals - and a point when many will have checked-out - was when Prairie comments that 'The OA', the name of not only the show but what she insists on being called, stands for Original Angel.
However, given that she initally explains it as being a version of 'away', it's not necessarily to be taken seriously, or at least it may not be the only explanation.
One suggestion is that it refers to the Alpha and Omega from Revelation. The OA would be a reversal of that, meaning the end comes before the beginning, which fits with the themes of having to die in order to begin your next journey in the world and the exploration of afterlife and alt-dimensions (not to mention the various Biblical references littered throughout).
Another theory is that it means DOA, which is what The-O-A would sound like depending on pronunciation, and could be a clue to the fact that Prairie really is dead all along.
8. Riz Ahmed's Character Put The Books In Prairie's Room
The most high-profile actor in The OA's first season was Riz Ahmed (The Night Of, Rogue One), so it was surprising to see him relegated to a relatively minor supporting role as The OA's therapist.
Although he works for the FBI, he comes across as being sympathetic to her and on her side in listening to the story, evidenced by being the only one to call her The OA. But what if there's more to him than meets the eye?
He appears in Prairie's house in the season finale, while the family are at a hotel, conveniently timed with the discovery of the books she was supposedly hiding. It's all a bit off, and the prevalent theory is that he planted the books there in order to discredit her story.
Why? Because he works for the FBI, who are aware of these 'angels' and are tracing alternate dimensions (they may even have worked with Hap), but don't want the story getting out.
This theory does hold a lot of water, because there's not really any other reason for Elias to be in Prairie's house. Similarly, her having the books herself doesn't make sense, because (as broken down here) Prairie is unlikely to be able to read English to such an advanced level.
7. The Story Is A Coping Mechanism, Or A Delusion
One of the big things to come from the end of The OA is that, well, it was all a lie. Or at least that some of it was.
While there are some consistencies, such as her being Russian and adopted, the rest of the story is so fantastical in nature that many believe it isn't true, with the books found at the end simply being the final nail in the coffin.
The question, then, is why would Prairie/Nina/The OA make up such a story?
The unifying thread is that Prairie has mental health problems, something we did see signs of in the show, and the story is either a delusion of hers or she's made it up as a coping mechanism, because she did go through some sort of torture in her time away.
In terms of the former, we see her wake up in a white room that could be a psychiatric ward. We also know her parents were warned about her mental health when she was young, and we see Homer being chased through some sort of medical facility, with mention of a Dr Roberts.
For the latter, we know that she was away for seven years, and something drastic obviously happened to her. In the restaurant, the girl who approaches her mentions being kept in captivity and raped, which might actually be the true story, and she made up her friends and the subsequent story as a way to cope.
It could feel like a bit of a cop-out for it to all take place in her head, but given what happened in the first season it's not implausible either, and could lead to a deeper examination of mental health.
6. Or It's Actually True
On the other hand, perhaps Prairie really is telling the truth. After all, this is the way it's (mostly) presented during the show, and as viewers we're sucked into the story and led to believe what we're seeing actually happened.
The biggest of these is that she was definitely blind, did go missing for seven years (and was definitely in a New York subway station playing a violin at one stage), and then returned with her sight back. Even if other parts of her story are untrue, that's a fact - which could lend itself to the coping mechanism theory, but may also mean the rest of the story is true.
There's also the fact that she was adopted and, even if some of the Russian-set story is untrue, has ties to the country. Then there's the strong possibility she couldn't read English and the FBI planted the books; that she searches for Homer on YouTube before getting them (regardless of whether they were hers or planted); the whoosh noise; and had a vision/premonition (of some sort) of the school shooting.
None of it provides absolutely irrefutable evidence that her story is true, but added together it does all help point in that direction.
5. Movements = Mudras
The movements, which are ostensibly channeled through the captives to open up rifts between dimensions and bring people back from the dead, but are really just interpretive dance moves, are one of the hardest parts of the show to buy into.
However, one Redditor did note a lot of similarities between the movements and a ritual called mudras. It's not a full explanation as such, but does shed some more light on them and may make them more palatable to skeptics.
Used in both Hinduism and Buddhism, mudras sometimes involve the whole body, but most just rely on the hands and fingers. They're used for spiritual reasons, believed to influence the energies of the body and the cosmos, but have also been used to aid with physical ailments as well.
The show has borrowed a lot religious iconography, and obviously the creators did their research, so it seems a fair bit that mudras were a strong influence behind the movements.
4. Khatun Is...
Khatun is one of the hardest characters to pin down in the entire series, given she's the most mysterious person and the strongest connection to the otherworldly activity that we see happen.
She serves as a spiritual guide to Prairie after she has her NDEs, taking her sight and giving her movements, but who/what exactly is she?
One theory is that she's a nephilim, a half-angel from Christianity, which comes from her exposing one angel wing, and the fact she sits in the middle of numerous floating galaxies. Another intriguing idea is that she is the representation of all the versions of The OA who have died; so when she tells Prairie that she's the "original", it means 'the first one to die'.
The braille on her face, meanwhile, is in German (the character really is a cocktail of cultures and spiritualities if nothing else), with words that have been translated including 'who if', 'because', and 'angel', which most likely just ties in with her being a spirit guide, but could point to her being an angel herself. Her name, meanwhile, is Arabic, meaning 'Lady' or 'Noble woman', which fits with her appearance and status.
There's also a similarity between her name and that of Siberian Shamanism sea goddess Aba-khatun. Shamanism involves reaching altered states of consciousness in order to perceive and interact with a spirit world, which may be what the NDEs are doing for Prairie here.
3. The Present Day Characters Are Alt-Versions Of The Captives
The yarn that Prairie spins takes place mostly in our own , recognisable world, but it does also quite clearly visit an alternate dimension: the place the subjects go when they do.
That means we have two dimensions in play (assuming the story is true), but what if there's a third. There's the afterlife place, the 'real' world where Prairie is now, and then a third world with Hap, Homer and the rest. Prairie is trying to get back to them when she jumps, and then surrounds herself with alternate versions of her fellow captives.
There are numerous similarities that can be drawn between the characters. The most obvious is between French and Homer, with the two serving as Prairie's closest disciple, having the same scar, and then French seeing Homer in his reflection.
It doesn't end there though. Buck, a singer, passes a car crash and sees a red backpack, which is similar to Rachel's (also a singer) NDE. Jesse and Scott are outcast types. Betty and Renata are older women, spending time with younger men.
It's not a totally perfect match-up - there's no real accounting for Steve, for example - but it does work to some degree. The show obviously wanted us thinking about other dimensions, and this may be why. It could be that they're exactly the same, having also crossed over (travelling between dimensions causes memory loss), or just spiritual representations of them.
2. Rachel Was A FBI Plant
The idea that the FBI have been heavily-involved in the tests around the 'angels' is an intriguing one, and certainly the notion of Elias planting the books in Prairie's room holds a fair bit of water.
Even more evidence comes from the braille on a wall at the offices where he works, which it's been spotted reads the word 'Rachel' (or at least R1C85L, but it does fit).
Curiously, Rachel was the only one of the captives to not receive a movement. Why would this be, when all the other captives did? Because she's not an angel, and thus never supposed to receive them. Instead, she's an FBI plant, put there to learn the secrets of what was going on and pass them back to the agency, although she may or may not actually be a NDE survivor.
There's also a suggestion Hap is in on it too. It's probably more compelling if he isn't, and Rachel is a mole even he doesn't know about, but it could work if he needed someone to really gain their trust in a way he couldn't.
1. Praire's In A Coma Or Purgatory
So, what if the story isn't a lie... but it's not the truth either. Nina didn't get adopted, didn't go missing for seven years, but instead 'died' when the bus crashed.
The theory states that Nina now exists in either in a coma, waiting to wake up, or in purgatory, waiting to cross over to the other side. It notes that when she was in the bus, there were four other children with her - making a total of five, two boys and two girls.
It also explains why Hap killed all of his victims by drowning them. Therefore she has to make a choice, to go onwards or back. It's interesting, though doesn't explain why her mind created this particular story, or where she is at the end (though that could be a representation of her waking up and coming back to life).
On that note, another theory is that at the end of the show she is now in purgatory, or at least another dimension. The all white room invokes imagery of heaven, and ties in with the idea of the fifth movement being death. So she's been shot, and now is the time for her to either move on or go back.
It's all enough to keep our heads spinning until The OA finally returns. What are your favourite theories? Let us know down in the comments.