The Simpsons: 10 Most Heartfelt Episodes
With over 700 episodes, which Simpsons stories tug at our heartstrings?
Since its debut on 17 December 1989, The Simpsons has become the longest-running American animated sitcom, with its satirical depiction of American culture gaining much acclaim.
On the surface, one of the show’s main attractions to audiences across the world is its parody style humour. However, The Simpsons is first and foremost about family and it is the relatable dynamics between the family of five which has stayed with us for so long.
Although it has somewhat declined in popularity in recent years, the show still manages to entice viewers with regular showings of early episodes from the so-called ‘golden age’.
Many of these episodes feature a pitch perfect blend of comedy and heart, exploring real meaningful experiences of the human condition.
Not every episode could make it on to this list, but here we have compiled together the very best Simpsons episodes that will touch your heart and reinforce the great power this show could be when it was at its peak success.
10. Lisa’s Substitute – Season 2, Episode 19
When Lisa’s teacher Miss Hoover takes medical leave,
substitute teacher Mr. Bergstrom takes over the class and inspires Lisa with
his creative teaching methods, causing her to form a strong admiration for a
positive adult role model.
Duston Hoffman guest stars as Mr. Bergstrom and brings a wonderful playfulness and grounded believability to the role, with even a cheeky reference to his big break in The Graduate snuck in.
This episode is great for not only exploring Lisa’s character, but also her complex relationship with her father, Homer. Lisa feels she lacks a strong male role model in her unintellectual father and it is sad to see how Homer begins to realise this throughout the episode.
The best scene takes place on a train station platform, where
the departing Mr. Bergstrom reassures Lisa that whenever she feels alone, all
she needs to know is in the contents of a note: “You are Lisa Simpson”. Homer and
Lisa also finally share an endearing heart to heart after Lisa takes her grief
out on him.
9. Moaning Lisa – Season 1, Episode 6
Another poignant episode focusing on the second youngest
Simpson, this story was also the very first to focus on Lisa.
The episode must be commended for its tender exploration of depression and existentialism, especially in a child.
It has a striking opening with Lisa staring into her own reflection in the bathroom mirror, saddened and lost and when she is at school, she is criticised for improvising in her music lesson and is “too sad” to play dodgeball.
Lisa finds a way to express herself through music after meeting Bleeding Gums Murphy, with a hauntingly beautiful scene of Lisa walking through a moonlit Springfield to find the jazz singer and composing a song expressing her depression.
Marge also experiences a strong character arc in this story, as she tries to encourage Lisa to smile and hide her true feelings, taking on the lesson her own mother told her. Thankfully, she soon realises the huge mistake she is making and expresses her support in Lisa feeling whatever she needs to.
A very emotional and relatable episode for many.
8. Bart Sells His Soul – Season 7, Episode 4
After Bart sells his soul to Milhouse, several strange events
causes him to realise what he has lost and he desperately tries to regain it by
any means necessary.
This episode can be downright heart-breaking, with Bart’s torment causing him to have nightmares about reaching heaven and not having any soul to accompany him, unlike his classmates. He becomes even more disheartened when he discovers Milhouse has sold his soul to Comic Book Guy.
The sheer desperation causes Bart to sleep outside Android’s Dungeon until the owner arrives and the peak of his distress comes when he prays to God for the return of his soul. Nancy Cartwright is incredible in this scene, capturing the pure anguish and hopelessness in Bart as he breaks down in tears.
The episode also highlights the strong sibling bond between
Bart and Lisa when it is revealed his sister bought his soul back to return it
to him, resulting in a touching scene between the pair. Those two definitely
share plenty of sweet moments.
7. I Married Marge – Season 3, Episode 12
The second flashback episode in the show, I Married Marge
tells the story of Homer and Marge’s marriage and the events leading up to Bart’s
birth, whom they accidentally conceived after a passionate night inside a golf
course castle.
This story is essential viewing for cementing Homer and Marge as the beating heart of the show. Marge stays completely committed to Homer, even after they get married in a seedy wedding chapel and Homer’s job does not provide them with enough funds for a new baby.
As with every impressive episode of the show, there is a terrific blend of comedy and authentic drama at play, with Homer actually choosing to leave Marge to find another job so he can send her and the baby money.
Even though we know how bad Homer’s new job at the Springfield Nuclear Power Plant will be, we cannot help but feel just as optimistic when he manages to make it to Bart’s birth and we see the beginnings of the family we all know and love.
Full of pitch perfect sentiment and well timed comedy - a must
see!
6. And Maggie Makes Three – Season 6, Episode 13
Homer recounts the story of Maggie’s birth when the kids ask
why there are no photos of her in the family album.
In this heart-warming story, Homer has to give up his dream job working at a bowling alley to return to the Nuclear Power Plant to be able to provide for another child. It is ironic to see past Homer complain about having another mouth to feed, only to be instantly smitten with his baby daughter when Maggie is born.
Mr. Burns manages to rub salt in the wounds, however, when he crudely leaves a plaque on Homer’s desk reading: “Don’t forget: you’re here forever”.
Then, we finally find out where Maggie’s baby pictures are in
one of the most touching scenes in the show’s history. Homer says the photos
are where he needs them most – on the plaque, which he has altered to read: “Do
it for her”. Cue hundreds of melting hearts!
5. I Love Lisa – Season 4, Episode 15
Lisa gives Ralph Wiggum a Valentine’s Day card when she sees
that he has not received any, causing him to pursue her for affection.
The subtle power of this episode is difficult to put into words, but it orchestrates another seamless blend of humour and tragedy. A great example here is when Bart runs a videotape of when Lisa publicly berates Ralph in front of an audience for Krusty the Clown’s Anniversary show, with Bart stating: “you can actually pin-point the second when his heart rips in half”.
Childhood crushes and heartbreaks are certainly a difficult subject to get right and every aspect of this episode is handled with delicate care, tenderly approaching the subject with sheer honesty and gravitas.
Ralph channels his heartbreak into his performance as George
Washington in the school’s President’s Day pageant and we are treated to a
beautiful ending with Lisa and Martin becoming friends through the exchange of
another pun featured card.
4. Mother Simpson – Season 7, Episode 8
After faking his own death to avoid going into work, Homer is
reunited with his mother Mona, who he thought had died two decades prior.
The family are quick to bond with Mona, who we learn was involved with a group of hippies back in 1969 and was forced to go into hiding after taking part in an ill fated germ warfare protest.
Guest star Glenn Close is wonderful as Homer’s mother, sweet and passionate for her causes. It is like a cherry on top of an already perfect cake to see that Homer actually inherited his famous catchphrase “D’oh!” from his mother.
This episode features another one of the most emotional endings in the show’s history, where Homer is forced to say goodbye to his mother again when she is discovered. After she leaves with another group of hippies, Homer sits on his car hood watching the stars long after she drives away and the credits roll. A poignant, captivating way to close out the episode.
3. One Fish, Two Fish, Blowfish, Blue Fish – Season 2, Episode 11
After Homer consumes a poisonous fugu fish at a sushi restaurant,
he is informed he has less than 24 hours to lives and with this knowledge,
attempts to try everything on his bucket list before he dies.
This episode is deeply affecting with the grim reality of Homer’s apparent fate never leaving the spotlight and the time he takes to spend time with his family before the end is very moving.
The full impact of the situation is felt when Homer quietly bids each member of his family goodbye while they sleep and succumbs to his death by sitting in the living room and listening to Larry King read the Bible on tape. The sombre, dark tone is quite haunting during this sequence.
Although the episode features a hilarious ending, the emotional core of the story is what lingers in the mind long after the credits run.
2. Bart Gets an “F” – Season 2, Episode 1
Under the threat of repeating the fourth grade after continuous
test failures, Bart vows to do better and study hard for his next test, only
for various obstacles making things more and more difficult.
An insightful, poignant story which is bound to resonate with many viewers for its exploration of the demanding nature of the school system and the causes this can have on the mental health of a young mind.
Bart tries everything to pass the test, enlisting the help of child genius Martin and even praying to God for a miracle, but he still fails and it is incredibly emotional when he breaks down in tears upon seeing the dreaded ‘F’.
Although the episode ends optimistically, this story is
grounded and honest and full of thought-provoking drama.
1. Lisa’s First Word – Season 4, Episode 10
As the Simpson family attempt to coax baby Maggie into saying
her first word, Marge reminisces and tells the story of Lisa’s first word.
The quintessential heart melter of the show, we are treated to a superb flashback story where Marge discovers she is pregnant again and the family need to find a new home for their growing size. It is also interesting to see that when Lisa was born, Bart actually loathed her out of jealousy.
However, everything is flipped on its head when Bart decides to run away, only to be stopped dead in his tracks when Lisa speaks her first word: “Bart”.
If we thought this episode couldn’t get any sweeter, we cut back to present day with Homer putting Maggie to bed and when she is alone, she utters a single word: “Daddy”.
Nothing could be cuter and more wholesome than this episode.