True Detective Season 2: 10 Rumours You Need To Know

Didn't you hear? Public transport is the new Satanic cult!

Like the occult horrors investigated by its characters, True Detective seemed to come out of nowhere. HBO picked the show up on the basis of the first script, which was written by a little-read author whose only previous TV work was a couple of episodes of the much-maligned US version of The Killing. Looks can be deceptive, however, as the writer in question - Nic Pizzolatto - had been building up a cache of influences and great characters, and the end product was helped no end by the cavalcade of cinematic talent who helped bring them to life. Now that it's here, though, it doesn't look like it's gonna go away. Since the first season we've been haunted by True Detective (much like, yes, the occult horrors investigated by its characters); by the performances of Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson, the well-drawn characters they played, the sumptuously spooky visuals, and the engaging murder-mystery at the heart of it all. It seems slightly unfair that we only got eight episodes of it, because we tend to be pretty entitled when it comes to our HBO crime dramas with supernatural undertones. So, in place of having new episodes of True Detective to watch, we've began to obsessively follow each and every single rumour and tease of information about the next batch of episodes. Due to start filming later this month, before premiering in of summer 2015, concrete details have been fairly thin on the ground - but speculation is rife. Everything from the cast to the composer to the setting of the next batch of episodes have been scuttlebutt and hearsay, but here are the ten rumours you really need to know about True Detective's second season.

10. T Bone Burnett Won't Be Back

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4zluA60hjs The first season of True Detective managed to pull off such an intense, foreboding atmosphere because every element of the show worked in unison: the moody performances by everyone (particularly McConaughey and Harrelson), the washed-out cinematic direction of Cary Fukunaga, the desolate Louisiana and - oh yeah - the music. From the Southern Gothic country of The Handsome Family's Far From Any Road that soundtracked the opening credits to the dark, rumbling orchestration of the original score, the show's tone was as effortlessly controlled aurally as visually. And that was all thanks to one T Bone Burnett. A longtime musician and songwriter in his own right - previously a member of Bob Dylan's touring band and multiple award-winner for his movie work on the likes of O Brother Where Art Thou? and Walk The Line - it was Burnett who both composed the score and chose the perfectly suited soundtrack. Most of said soundtrack was suited to the setting, and also to the composer's particular skillset - namely down country, swampy blues and folk. Rumour has it that this integral member of True Detective's first season won't be returning for the second which, on one hand, is a shame (Burnett's a soundtrack master and all) but also makes sense, since the next season will be totally shifting locations, so here's hoping they manage to find someone whose handle on Californian rock is as adept as Burnett's on the spooky country stuff.

9. Expect More Spooky Stuff

Speaking of spooky stuff, the grapevine reports that we can reliably expect more of that in True Detective's second season. A lot more, in fact. Many fans latched onto the occult references in the first batch of episodes, with winks and nods to the cosmic Cthulhuian horror of literary racist HP Lovecraft and one of his own influences, Ambrose Bierce, and his short story An Inhabitant of Carcosa. The murdery-mystery Rust and Marty were digging into the first time around specifically drew on Robert W Chamber's The King in Yellow, a classic piece of supernatural meta-fiction. And all of that was drawn together by Thomas Ligotti's Conspiracy Against The Human Race, a piece of pessimistic philosophy which compares real-life existence to the futility of those in horror fiction. Phew. Right now we're not sure what the reading list for Nic Pizzolatto's second batch of scripts will be, but we do know the spooky stuff will be making some sort of a return. Early reports have the writer talking up €œthe secret occult history of the United States transportation system€ as a principal element, adding €œI need to keep being strange€. Here's hoping the supernatural elements continue to exist more as atmospheric window dressing than overwhelming the proceedings, with an underlying spookiness bolstering the actual human drama. Although the transportation system does sound pretty scary...

8. But This Time In California

Again, it sounds like the second season of True Detective will be taking the elements that made the first one so successfully, but trying to transplant them into different surroundings. Where the original story was very much rooted in the Deep South €“ with the environment, musical and literary traditions all playing into proceedings €“ the follow-up will apparently do the same, albeit in slightly sunnier surroundings. Rumour has it that True Detective season two will take place in California and, straight from Pizzolatto's mouth again, "Not Los Angeles but some of the much lesser-known venues of California, and we're going to try to capture a certain psychosphere ambiance of the place, much like we did in Season 1." We're not sure what a psychosphere is (and neither does our spellchecker), but we're assuming that's just fantasy talk for saying it's a nice location. There's a tradition for Californian crime dramas and noir of a similar tone to True Detective's first go around, so we've got pretty high hopes for the show's second season: Pizzolatto bringing some grim, gritty storytelling in the vein of LA Confidential and Chinatown, but with some supernatural bits and bobs thrown in, along with his singular writing style and some high production values? And none of the usual tinseltown distractions about faded stars and aspiring actors stabbing each other in the backs (both figuratively and literally)? Yeah, go on then.

7. Public Transport > Satanic Cults

One of the few explicitly real "supernatural" parts of True Detective's first season was the terrifying cult which, technically, worshipped Chamber's equally devilish Yellow King rather than the dark lord Satan himself, but they still did plenty of nasty stuff in his name regardless. Like murder, child abuse, and a whole lotta incest from the looks of Errol Childress's house of horror from the finale. Again the show was being very clever by tapping into some real world, local concepts, like the moral panic about (mostly non-existent) Satanic cults in the eighties, and the actual conspiracies to kidnap and torture young children that occurred in the South not long after. So obviously they can't do that again, but thankfully California has its own history of occult depravity. And, erm, it has something to do with the transportation system, as Pizzolatto told us just a moment ago. "The secret occult history of the United States transportation system." What does that mean? We don't know. It's a secret. A leaked plot outline gives us a little more of an insight, suggesting this time the murder victim is knocked off "amid a potentially groundbreaking transportation deal that would forever change freeway gridlock in the state." Thrilling! Oh but he is found with "satanic symbols etched on his chest," so that's something.

6. Every Male Actor Has Auditioned

The quality (and mainstream popularity) of the first season of HBO's prestige crime drama was assured when they'd confirmed the casting. Not only did they bring on board underrated screen actors like Michelle Monaghan and Kevin Dunn but they also scored a home run by securing bonafide Hollywood stars Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey in the starring roles. Not only did those two big names bring in viewers who might otherwise have passed the show over, but they also brought the requisite acting chops to properly play the sort of morally complex and interesting characters like Rust and Marty. It worked so well the first time around, why not try for it again? Well, that's exactly what they're doing. Rumours have been flying for months now, with breathless reports detailing anyone and everyone who's been called up for an audition. And we do mean everyone. So far we've heard talk that the likes of Colin Farrell and Brad Pitt have been brought in to test for True Detective's second season - who, based on their performances in the likes of In Bruges and Se7en (respectively), would be pretty perfect - alongside the slightly less believable names like Taylor Kitsch and Vince Vaughn. Yeah, we're not sure about the latter two in terms of the actual "dramatic acting" thing, and we've still not got confirmation of who exactly will end up starring in the second season, but from this pool it looks like they're gonna be some more big names.

5. And Every Female, More Importantly

One of the few criticisms of True Detective's first season (and quite rightly) was how little time the show had for female characters. For a show principally about the evil that men do to women, there sure wasn't a lot of lady folk around to highlight said theme. Well, not live ones, anyway. There was Marty's long-suffering wife and his accumulated, worryingly young mistresses, Rust's brief attempt at a girlfriend, and that's about it. From the looks of it Pizzolatto heard these criticisms and took them on board when penning his second bunch of scripts, this time ensuring that this time the main characters will be a mix of men or women. Either two men and two women, or mostly women, depending on when you ask him. As such, we've got almost as many rumours about big-name women actors circling the parts as the male ones. Apparently Jessica Chastain, star of Mama and Zero Dark Thirty, was used as the €œprototype€ for the female character, meaning that her name was in the mix from the start. Since then we've heard a load of scuttlebutt about the likes of Cate Blanchett, Michelle Forbes of The Killing and - most recently - Elisabeth Moss, Mad Men's Peggy, being considered for the vaunted female roles. The latter of which we'd be very happy about, since Moss starred in one of favourite post-True Detective comedown shows, this year's Aussie drama Top Of The Lake. Again, we've no idea if any of these people will actually be on board (apparently Moss has now been replaced by Rachel McAdams anyway), and Pizzolatto says that "literally, not a single rumour about casting that has been printed anywhere has any truth to it whatsoever", so take all of this with a hearty pinch of salt.

4. The Character Breakdowns

Those coming to True Detective for the whodunit may have been a little put out. Whilst the overarching mystery of the first series was interesting and ended in a satisfying (if in a non-showy or predictably twisty) way, the real meat of the show was the people involved. It was less of a plot-heavy crime thriller and more of a character-driven drama, exploring the psychology of homicide detectives Marty and Rust, and how dealing with the more depraved elements of humanity affected them. By making them horny and pessimistic, respectively, basically. What we're getting at is that the characters are the most important thing, so it's a good thing we've got some rumours about them as well. Unofficial" breakdowns for the second season's cast - the same ones that named Jessica Chastain as the model for one of the women character - listed the three leads as a fortysomething male detectives/cops with Joaquin Phoenix, Christian Bale and Josh Brolin as prototypes, with a twentysomething male cop and a thirtysomething female detective (the Chastain one) coming up behind. Which is a pretty big change from the two leads of the original, this time apparently opting for more an ensemble piece. What does that mean? Is the whole tone going to feel a little different? Are these characters going to be less well-drawn than first time around? Are there enough parts to go around to all the rumoured actors? We'll soon see.

3. There'll Be Multiple Directors

Cinematic writing, music and performances all helped to make True Detective the best movie we spent eight hours watching on our tellies(well, laptops, let's be honest) this year. Besides the words everyone was saying, who was saying them, and the selection of gloomy country - plus the odd hip-hop - tracks that were playing in the background were all responsible for the prestige, atmospheric feel, but the one person who brought them all together? That'll be Cary Joji Fukunaga, who previously directed the similarly moody and visually stunning big screen outings Sin Nombre, and the 2011 adaptation of Jane Eyre starring Mia Wasikowska and Michael Fassbender. Fukunaga not only delivered some of the most thrilling sequences we've seen anyway for a good long while (including the finale and that one much-vaunted six-minute tracking shot from episode four), but also made gave the show a unified, cinematic look. Next season seems to be focussing on the latter more than the former, luring in a selection of big screen directors to helm a few episodes each. We're a little concerned that this may make the show lose some of its visual spark, or at least seem a bit more messy than the original, but we're reassured a little by some of the directors involved. Some of those directors are pretty bloody exciting, you see, including none other than Exorcist and French Connection mastermind William Friedkin reportedly being in talks to direct some episodes.

2. Or Maybe Just One

Another of the more, ahem, interesting names rumoured to be in consideration for helming some of the second season's episodes is one Justin Lin. As in, the Justin Lin whose filmography includes the distinctly un-True Detective likes of several Fast And Furious films and a handful of episodes of quirky sitcom Community. Which we do love, just in a different way to the grittily realistic and atmospheric look of True Detective. Still, maybe this is another shift pertaining to the change in location €“ moody Louisiana swapped for glitzy, Hollywood California €“ so we're willing to give it a punt. Especially if the conflicting rumours about how many episodes Lin could be directing turn out to be true. Whilst there were early reports that the second season of True Detective would be directed by a bunch of different cinematic powerhouses, the Lin rumours come alongside the suggestion that he might be handling the whole run. Apparently he's in talks to direct €œat least€ the first two episodes, which means he could potentially take on more. We really don't have any concrete info about this next run of the show besides the little titbits that Pizzolatto has deigned worthy of sharing with us, so there's every chance that this season could have a single director again, and that that director could be Justin Lin. The guy who did a bunch of Fast And Furious films. Eek?

1. Matthew McConaughey Might Make A Comeback

Up until very recently, Matthew McConaughey was not a respected actor. In fact he was the exact opposite, the first word in annoyingly smug protagonists in particularly naff rom-coms whose career was going nowhere fast. There were some early sparks of brilliance, sure, but since then he'd been more than happy to tow the line through a load of dire middle-of-the-road fare. Nobody was expecting him to win an Oscar for his powerful portrayal as an AIDs victim in the straight-faced drama Dallas Buyer's Club, let alone that the former star of The Wedding Planner and Ghosts Of Girlfriends Past would end up acting Woody Harrelson off the screen as a suicidal, enigmatic and slightly pretentious Louisiana homicide detective. And yet he did! Nic Pizzolatto's scripts certainly gave Rust Cohle a back bone, cribbing from pessimistic philosophy for his sunny outlook and existential rants, but it was undoubtedly McConaughey who brought him to life. Out of nowhere he went from a one-note joke to a character actor capable of pulling out a fully-realised, three-dimensional guy who you could believe as a living, breathing person. Who had a peculiar similarity to Hollywood actor Matthew McConaughey. The breakout of the show, Rust Cohle has since appeared in countless parodies and won the hearts and minds of every viewer who lays eyes on him. Which made it all the more disappointing to discover he wouldn't be appearing in the second series of True Detective. Or will he...? McConaughey has expressed reticence at abandoning a character he clearly poured so much into whilst bringing to life, stating as much in interviews and effectively reprising his role for a Lincoln car advert. The actor has put it out there that he'd be happy for Cohle to appear, even briefly, in a future series of True Detective, with Woody Harrelson echoing those sentiments. Is there a chance we may catch a glimpse of Rust in the second season, if only for a moment? Well, if time is a flat circle...

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/