10 Most Important Matches In Modern Wrestling History

The matches without which EVERYTHING looks different: featuring CM Punk, Kenny Omega and more...

Cody Dustin Rhodes
AEW

The following matches aren't necessarily the 10 best matches in the modern era of pro wrestling. One match, in fact, is a complete abomination, something so definitionally bad that it altered the course of history.

All 10 listed did; it is no exaggeration to state that, were these matches not to have happened, the landscape would look drastically different. Frankly, if you are inclined to enjoy AEW - or are even mixed on the product, but are glad that an alternative exists on principle - the state of the industry without these matches does not bear thinking about.

There are a few honourable mentions to quickly wade through first:

AJ Styles Vs. Christopher Daniels Vs. Samoa Joe, from TNA Unbreakable 2005, alongside much of the peak ROH library, ushered in the 'workrate era' - the idea, strange to those raised on WWE, that best-in-class wrestling could exist beyond WWE's vast reach and brainwashing rhetoric. Kenny Omega and Will Ospreay drew considerable inspiration from AJ (the latter even idolised him).

The 'Rainmaker Shock' at NJPW The New Beginning 2012, the boldest booking decision of all-time, launched the career of Kazuchika Okada, who dethroned Hiroshi Tanahashi for the IWGP title (New Japan played a central role in virtually everything, as will be covered). Trish Stratus Vs. Lita, the December 6, 2004 WWE Raw main event, did in fact inspire the generation that followed. For once, WWE aren't bullsh*tting you.

But what are the most transformational matches of the 21st century?

10. CM Punk Vs. Samoa Joe - ROH Joe Vs. Punk II

Punk Joe 2
ROH

The content of the match, sadly, wasn't as influential as the aforementioned three-way at TNA Unbreakable. Stylistically, that match drove much of what followed.

Still, this was the first North American match that Dave Meltzer had awarded *****, back when that was ultra-rare, in seven full years. That meant something. That forced curious fans to pay attention. 

Wrestling would be better off as a form, had more talents studied CM Punk's incredible performance, the seamless, absorbing way in which he chained everything together, the ultra-patient strategy he employed. Punk trusted the fans to get it throughout that seminal full hour. This was key: Punk and Joe respected the intelligence of the audience, where Vinces McMahon and Russo treated them with utter disdain. WWE had its worst year ever in 2004: it's no exaggeration to state that many fans needed Punk Vs. Joe to prove to them that they hadn't aged out of it all.

Also, the modern history of pro wrestling cannot be written without Punk's immeasurable influence over it.

This was his proper breakthrough, with which he evolved from a mega-heel to master craftsman. If this match doesn't put him on the map, he might not go to WWE. He might not destroy, over time, the biases within WWE and eventually alter the recruitment model.

He might not cut the Pipebomb - the call-to-arms so powerful that, from that moment forward, fans refused to accept the state of play in the monopoly. The Pipebomb created a sentiment, a feeling, that ultimately created the conditions for AEW.

Punk made the fans feel like the impossible - true change - simply had to happen.


9. Hiroshi Tanahashi Vs. Minoru Suzuki - NJPW King Of Pro Wrestling 2012

Jon Moxley Hiroshi Tanahashi AEW
AEW

Back before the scale was broken and the inflation that followed, people paid attention when Dave Meltzer awarded this match *****. This rating formalised, to fans in the west, that NJPW had arrived as the best promotion on the globe.

After a barren period in the 2000s, during which only seven matches were awarded the "maximum", Tanahashi Vs. Suzuki was the third match of the 2010s to earn a fiver. For many, this was the entry point to New Japan - and the story of modern pro wrestling cannot be told without the profound influence of the resurgence era. Jon Moxley, the first major direct WWE to AEW "jumper", was of those many.

In a more philosophical way, this match can also be considered a reset point for the very form.

It was as disciplined a match as you'll ever see: there were no near-falls, no easy dramatic shortcuts, and their combined brilliance extracted a mega-pop from a mere dropkick that perfected the idea of the "when" to do a move. And, because Tanahashi had rediscovered the idea of fair and pure competition, he created a platform on which an act like the Bullet Club could make US-style interference, the sort of thing you see every week, a real transgression all over again.

And, of course, the Bullet Club, a zombified husk these days, were instrumental in changing the landscape. The Bullet Club mutated constantly, and, at least until around 2018, extended its tendrils into virtually everything of significance. The group elevated ROH to record business. The Bullet Club Elite created All In, drawing the attention of AEW founder Tony Khan. Even WWE, impressed by AJ Styles, broke its NXT policy and installed him as a key player on the main roster immediately - before which Finn Bálor was not insignificant in building the TakeOver brand as an arena-sized concern.

He wasn't the most significant player in the story, however...


8. Royal Rumble Match - WWE Royal Rumble 2015

The Rock Roman Reigns
WWE.com

According to Wikipedia, the 2015 Royal Rumble match lasted 59 minutes and 31 seconds.

Vince McMahon could have saved everybody a lot of time by simply appearing in the ring, holding up the arm of Roman Reigns, and screaming "F*CK YOU!" down the lens of the hard camera.

For that, for all intents and purposes, is what he did.

You were smacked on the nose not with a set of papers but with mediocre pro wrestling. You wanted certain wrestlers - Dolph Ziggler, Dean Ambrose, Bray Wyatt - to get a push. Yeah, they got a push: pushed out of the ring by Kane and the Big Show. They were actually depicted as bags of trash. They were picked up and thrown out like you would actual shoot bags of trash, from behind your hip. 

It wasn't all bad, though!

You know when you have a bag of trash, but one that's neatly tied up and full but not too full, so you can be confident that it can be thrown hard into a bin without the threat of trash juice exploding all over you?

They were thrown like that: firmly and to-the-point. Not cagily, gingerly.

Ambrose et al. weren't garbage juice, so there's that.

Oh, also, Daniel Bryan, the hottest babyface in the world, whom WWE didn't even need to put in the match because you didn't expect it this time, was dumped out by Wyatt in 10 minutes. Didn't even build to a WrestleMania match.

Roman is the star. Nobody else. Accept it and shut up.

That was the story of the entire match - and people despised the idea of the babyface Roman push.

WWE throughout the 2010s promoted a cornucopia of F*CK YOU matches - matches that told the vocal hardcore fan that WWE was not remotely interested in servicing them. CM Punk Vs. Triple H at Night of Champions, shortly following which the anti-authority renegade was re-cast as a scab, was one of them. The hardcores knew at that moment that nothing would "change". Daniel Bryan Vs. Sheamus at WrestleMania XXVIII backfired on them and how, but that too was a F*CK YOU match. The 2014 Royal Rumble was also a F*CK YOU match. The Jinder Mahal title win: F*CK YOU.

The 2015 Rumble was different, though. Fans weren't raw in their emotion; they just accepted it. The jeering wasn't loud. It was just a sort of drone. #CancelWWENetwork trended worldwide in its wake, and while WWE's viewership was in decline throughout the decade, the excellent Brandon Thurston of Wrestlenomics determined that the match accelerated the pattern.

This match more than any other fractured the relationship between WWE and the "Universe": does AEW exist without it?


7. Bayley Vs. Sasha Banks - NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn

Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Bayley Vs. Sasha Banks was one of the best matches of the 2010s.

It stole the show on NXT's debut in the big time of the Barclays Center, establishing the TakeOver brand as an arena-sized concern. Kevin Owens Vs. Finn Bálor was very good, but Bayley Vs. Sasha, the true main event, was special. This match launched Paul Levesque as a booker and a promoter. He should send Bayley and Sasha fruit baskets for the rest of his life.

As a match in and of itself, it was spectacular - a timeless study in character contrast. Sasha looked like the coolest presence in company history making her entrance, and her nasty streak of violence added a vital sadistic edge to her arrogant cool heel persona.

The juxtaposition of Bayley's work underscored her credentials as the perfect working babyface: she was impossibly wholesome with a value system of pure goodness, but f*ck with her injured hand, and she'd drop you right on the f*cking dome.

If WWE's "Women's Revolution" rhetoric was always hollow, an exercise in optics, Bayley Vs. Sasha substantiated it. It was the first bonafide classic match in WWE's women's division, any era. Cora Jade has spoken of this match being her inspiration to become a wrestler. She's far from alone. Hell, Dr. Britt Baker is about the same age as Bayley and Sasha, she was in training when that Brooklyn match happened, and she cites that match as her inspiration, too.

To this day, many fans have never allowed WWE (nor AEW) to give up on women's wrestling and the parity that should have existed by now.

Does that happen if Bayley and Sasha did ugly heel heat and badass vengeance better than the men in 2015?


6. Kenny Omega Vs. Kazuchika Okada - NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 11

Kenny Omega
AEW

On January 4, 2017, Kenny Omega and Kazuchika Okada generated a sort of noise that hasn't been heard before nor since, even in their superior fourth singles match.

Every individual member of the crowd, about five minutes before the finish, was in a completely different state of wonder. The effect of the match was so potent that you could everybody's deeply-felt personal reaction to it. There was nothing performative about the response, the most earnest atmosphere in years. What you heard was a complete, overdubbed abandonment of inhibition.

46 minutes of extraordinary drama; aerial manoeuvres that were taken in as if some natural beauty had presented itself; work so electrifyingly impossible that you could only tell, for example, that Omega nudged Okada to complete his front flip escape from the One-Winged Angel after the eight or ninth rewind: Omega Vs. Okada was, until Omega Vs. Okada IV, the very best match of all-time.

It was an absolute game-changer, the match that truly set into motion the events that ultimately led to the formation of AEW. AEW does not exist if that match doesn't happen. It was so phenomenal that it altered people's conception of how good wrestling could be again. People after it simply demanded more.

On an altogether more bleak note, through no fault of the performers, this match may well have ruined or at least made exponentially worse the online fandom experience.

Tribalism predates X - you may be shocked to learn that many WWF fans did not like WCW - but it really ramped up and evolved into the definitive way in which all discussion seems to happen now. The sarcastic humour of Being The Elite did not help, obviously, but "six stars in the Tokyo Dome" basically caused people to lose their minds, act defensive, and lash out.

Some haven't stopped crying yet.


5. Kenny Omega Vs. Chris Jericho - NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 12

Chris Jericho
AEW

If Omega Vs. Okada put pro wrestling back in the conversation in a world monopolised by sports entertainment for nearly two decades, Alpha Vs. Omega, even before AEW, was the major label debut.

Jericho wasn't a household name, nor was he a main event tippy-top guy in WWE, but, refreshed in the shocking new context of New Japan Pro Wrestling, he felt like a megastar attraction. He was a legend of course, a Swiss army knife of entertainment, but he was not a great athlete in 2017. Few expected the match to be truly worthy of the sky-high New Japan standard, and felt vindicated in their cynicism when it was gimmicked up as a No Disqualification attraction.

It was phenomenal, utterly distinct. The wild brawling scenes early allowed Jericho, for perhaps the first time, to unleash the full extent of his brash charisma. They reached that high-end NJPW bar by the finish. Omega blasting Jericho in the back with a chair, mid-Lionsault, was an ingenious One-Winged Angel transition.

The match doubled New Japan World subscriptions. It made Jericho cooler and bigger than ever (at the time). It elevated Omega from wrestling's greatest artist to legitimate box office attraction.

The staggering crossover success played a significant role in convincing Tony Khan that it was time to put into action his long-held dream of forming a wrestling promotion. He knew, well before All In, that wrestling was finally big enough to get on television again.


4. Cody Vs. Dustin Rhodes - AEW Double Or Nothing 2019

Cody Dustin Rhodes
AEW

AEW Double Or Nothing had be great. It could not be merely very good.

AEW had - and it was marketing, but you had to believe it for it all to work - promised to change the world. Anything less than a seminal show, one so great that it did nothing less than restore your faith in the medium, would have been unacceptable. The promotional bluster was that intense.

The main event was saved by the shocking, awesome debut of Jon Moxley, but watching it back, Kenny Omega Vs. Chris Jericho II really fell apart by the finish. The Young Bucks Vs. Lucha Bros. was fantastic - the Bucks working through "ring rust" was an inspired choice to articulate the promise of a "sports-oriented" presentation - but it wasn't the true classic that Tony Khan needed to build his credibility and that of AEW.

Cody Rhodes Vs. Dustin Rhodes was that classic: a match so unforgettable in its emotion and drama that it reduced many in the crowd to years.

Dustin leaked so much blood that the drama verged on the harrowing, the unbearable. Cody played situational heel, almost patronising his older brother, which drove the fan support of Dustin to a near-unparalleled extent. Watching a visibly, literally drained Dustin only just getting the shoulder up when caught in the figure-four was as stirring as wrestling gets - and the catharsis of the spot in which Dustin spanked his brother's bare arse was the sort of only-in-wrestling joy that reminded fans of how distinctly great the medium could be.

Cody Vs. Dustin was so different to the genre that helped create AEW that it underscored AEW's "something for everybody" USP - and was so timelessly great that it proved AEW, on night one, had staying power.


3. The Elite Vs. PAC, Rey Fenix & Penta El Zero Miedo - AEW Dynamite January 1, 2020

The Elite
AEW/Lee South

In and of itself, the Elite versus the trio who weren't yet named Death Triangle was an exhilarating if hardly emotionally resonant match.

Insofar as execution and state-of-the-art action, it was thrilling. Kenny Omega was on sensational individual form; in one incredible moment, as Rey Fénix flew into him with a corkscrew plancha, he managed to blast him (safely) in the face with a pinpoint-accurate V-trigger despite the velocity of the rotations he had to account for.

Omega was bound and determined to remind the audience that he was the best wrestler on the planet. He sort of had to; in selling for a Dark Order creeper on the infamous December 18 Dynamite, he had surrendered his star power. This was less than ideal; the Elite as a collective had already planned to lose (and often) in a sort of coming-of-age arc designed to peak at least a year from that moment. It was a bold strategy, one that asked much in the way of patience from the audience, but it was taken several steps too far on a night that inspired a backlash.

Had AEW f*cked it?

Between December 18 and January 1, Tony Khan broke up the booking committee. The Elite had input, but Khan gave himself final cut over the holidays. In a booking masterstroke, the January 1 show was themed on phase one of the Elite's grand comeback.

Are the Elite still Elite?

That was the question posed, and, in a much-needed exercise in reassurance, answered with the feel-good win in crowd-pleasing banger.

Hangman Page provided commentary, and was on priceless form. The Elite were still great, but not whole: Page was left out. That development - the first truly great night for Page and his range - was the cliffhanger.

Khan's first Dynamite as lead booker was awesome, a restorative night, and the goodwill returned at the perfect time: amid such reassuring scenes, AEW was awarded the rights fee from Warner that ensured its medium-term future.


2. Roman Reigns Vs. Edge Vs. Daniel Bryan - WWE WrestleMania 37

Daniel Bryan Roman Reigns Edge
WWE

The main event of WrestleMania night two was a superb match.

It was very intricate in its construction, but, owing to Bryan's genius, every complicated sequence felt like urgent intra-match strategy as opposed to an elaborate set-piece designed to pop the crowd. But then again, what isn't a superb match these days?

This match wasn't important or notable for its quality; increasingly, few are.

It was the night on which Roman Reigns finally, formally made it as a huge megastar. The way in which he manipulated the atmosphere in that stadium was masterful. AEW made gains in 2021, even beating Raw in the demo in the autumn - but this match, the true breakthrough of the Tribal Chief, altered the course of the war. Wars are won and boom periods erupt on the back of stars. Roman Reigns became the official, undisputed biggest star in wrestling on this night.

The repercussions did not end there. Famously, Daniel Bryan felt nothing before and during the match. He knew in that moment that his future resided elsewhere. He jumped to AEW at All Out '21, and this Triple Threat incited the best-ever in-ring run of a man who may very well be the greatest of all-time. Without this match, you may not have watched the American Dragon whip several layers of skin from the face of Ricky Starks.

WWE, as it often did, followed up WrestleMania with a woeful spring in 2021. Roman Reigns had finally made it big, but the promotion was not back.

Yet...


1. The Usos Vs. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn - WWE WrestleMania 39 Night 1

WWE WrestleMania 39 Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

How much has WWE changed in the wake of Vince McMahon's 2022 retirement?

Cynics would argue not much: away from the main event crew that are trusted to cut their own (mostly great) promos, the interviews remain synthetic and are orated in that alien language and cadence. The matches still have that distinct WWE "feel". Authority figures, albeit better ones, still govern a format that hasn't much changed.

The main event of WrestleMania 39 night one however crystallised that which has changed for the better under the creative direction of Paul Levesque.

In the best subplot of a "saga" that has gripped the audience, Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn took down the Usos in a thrilling feel-good tag team WrestleMania main event. Levesque responded to a series of longstanding complaints with this inspired choice.

Your guys got to win, guys who weren't "meant" to win on that stage, and in a tag team match no less - a beloved standard that Vince barely cared about for years. The content of the match, while great in a simplistic way, was not the point.

At one stage in the late 2010s, a WWE resurgence seemed a remote possibility - the true "never" in the never-say-never business. This match best underscored that WWE was all the way back: a towering achievement in its goal of winning back the audience.

One could also argue that, were it not for this irresistible bit of business, fans would have been less forgiving of the controversial decision to have Roman Reigns go over Cody Rhodes 24 hours later.

That wonderful tag did what was once thought impossible: it restored trust in the process.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!