10 Ridiculous Wrestling Booking Decisions Nobody Can Explain

Bullet holes in the Swiss.

Cesaro Mania XXX
WWE.com

Explaining certain inexplicable booking decisions is ironically easy, with the most cynical of mindsets: Vince McMahon is absolutely mental, or least incredibly erratic, and is as set in his ways as your racist grandfather. He is a racist grandfather.

This bizarre mentality explains why, for example, McMahon refused to push the insanely popular Daniel Bryan ahead of WrestleMania XXX - and why, upon finally relenting to the pressure, he outright informed Bryan that Roman Reigns was The Guy going forward. Bryan = short, pale, scraggly. Reigns = tall, sculpted, handsome. You needed only a visual cue irrespective of how deafening the sentiment was. McMahon was deaf to it, and not without some justification, or at least explanation: the man has monopolised pro wrestling so thoroughly that certain Network television stations in North America are toying with the idea of purchasing the company's TV rights.

This, in turn, explains decisions more depressing than mystifying. John Cena dominated the Nexus because he sold metric f*cktonnes of merch; Randy Orton won the 2017 Royal Rumble because he was established and popular among the casual audience; Finn Bálor doesn't get to break the wheel because he is but a spoke in it.

These decisions...these are legitimately inexplicable...

10. Cooling Wrestling's Hottest Commodity

Bret Hart
WWE.com

It's easy to explain the vast majority, if not all, of WCW's various disasters. You can explain them with a meme: LOLWCW. But such a ridiculous wrestling organisation warrants an entry on this list, and perhaps the absolute most inexplicable booking decision concerns the debut of one Bret Hart.

The most controversial wrestler on the planet, and arguably still the best, Hart had departed the WWF in the most acrimonious, shocking, sensational, industry-shaking manner in the history of modern professional wrestling. Eric Bischoff's stock in trade was controversy. He'd courted Hart's signature for months and months, and must surely have done so for a reason, usually manifesting in the form of a "plan". This was a perfect storm for a moment iconic, momentous, or, at the very least, of major intrigue.

Instead, WCW installed him as the special guest referee in a comedy match between Eric Bischoff and Larry Zbysko, the stupefying subplot of which teased Bret Hart's defection to the nWo. If there was ever a pro wrestler with absolutely no reason whatsoever to join a stable of anti-WCW WWF sympathisers, it was Bret bloody Hart.

Brainless; mundane; wasteful - this was a telling symptom of the terminal disease infiltrating the organisation.


9. Rob Van Dumb

Rob Van Dam TNA Debut
Impact Wrestling

It's easy to explain the vast majority, if not all, of TNA's various disasters. You can explain them with a meme: LOLTNA. But such a ridiculous wrestling organisation warrants an entry on this list, and perhaps the absolute most inexplicable booking decision concerns the debut of one Rob Van Dam.

Van Dam represented a good get for TNA - nowhere near a needle-mover, he nonetheless was popular enough for his many fans to keep up with. Those fans, if they had bothered to tune in, must have tuned immediately back out: their guy, once the coolest in all of wrestling, entered a showreel performance displaying cowardice, weakness and, ultimately, instant irrelevance. Van Dam never amounted to much in TNA. Few did - but this was something unspeakably stupid.

Debuting as a babyface - we think - Van Dam attacked a heel Sting from behind, because Vince Russo is all about classic wrestling psychology. Then, after the most opportunistic pin imaginable, a millisecond after which Sting kicked out, Sting beat the sh*t out of Van Dam with a baseball bat, which drew little sympathy. Van Dam deserved it.

And then - and then - Hulk Hogan made the save, stealing Van Dam's stretcher spot. And then - and then - it was all retconned, revealing Hogan as the heel, and Sting as the face all along.


8. Oiling The Brass Ring

Cesaro Mania XXX II
WWE.com

Cesaro infamously drew the ire of Vince McMahon on the Network edition of Steve Austin's podcast.

"He's no connecting yet, but we hope he will. He doesn't quite have the charisma, he doesn't quite have the verbal skills as well, and maybe because he's Swiss, I don't know, with that European style. He lacks "it"."

Cesaro had connected with the audience, by going on an absolute tear in the months leading up to WrestleMania XXX, at which he was rewarded in the shape of the André The Giant Memorial Battle Royal trophy. The fans in the New Orleans Superdome went apesh*t, because this was a star-making moment awarded to a guy they had anointed as a star. It seemed, in parallel with the belated Daniel Bryan coronation, that the company had finally strained to repair broken fan relations.

WWE swiftly severed this bond by allying Cesaro with heel mouthpiece Paul Heyman on the same night he callously bragged about shattering the Undertaker's Streak - the greatest institution in the entire company. Cesaro's turn never once felt like a betrayal - more a really bizarre and mistimed retcon of an on-fire babyface character.

The one silver lining never materialised, either: Beast Vs. Superman didn't happen because Heyman and Cesaro amicably went their separate ways a scant three months later.


7. 3..2...For F*ck's Sake

Rey Mysterio Royal Rumble 2006
WWE

Vince McMahon isn't stupid. He's egotistical, he's stubborn, and he's out of touch, but he isn't stupid - hence why Roman Reigns entered at #30 in last year's Royal Rumble match. Deftly deflecting attention away from the umpteenth Randy Orton push, McMahon put him over as the Lesser Of Two Evils. That catchphrase was never going to hawk any t-shirts, but then, it didn't inspire a #CancelWWENetwork hashtag, either.

Three years earlier, he must have been acutely aware that whomever occupied the same slot was in for a roasting by virtue of not being the insanely grassroots popular Daniel Bryan - which surely demanded a heel appearance. Even Vladimir Kozlov would have generated something approaching heat, in this context. Instead of potentially making one heel, McMahon elected to bury two babyfaces - one of whom he's still trying to replace to this day. Rey Mysterio entered the ring to a chorus of boos.

Did McMahon simply throw Mysterio to the wolves because he knew he was unable to cope with the brutal WWE grind, and had requested what Vince felt was too much in the way of compensation?

On the subject of Bryan, his mooted upcoming heel turn is allegedly driven by a desire to ruin him elsewhere - so the events of 2014 probably aren't that inexplicable.


6. Bret Hart Vs. Vince McMahon, WrestleMania XXVI

bret hart vince mcmahon
WWE.com

A match years in the making - but a match that probably shouldn't have happened - Bret Hart was legally prohibited from and physically unable to take any bumps, necessitating some form of smoke and mirrors.

Still, given the starkest heel and babyface dynamic in the history of the industry, that WWE contrived to engineer sympathy on Vince's behalf must condemn this as the worst layout in the history of the industry. Bret simply battered Vince with a tire iron in the harrowing absolution of a 13-year nightmare. What a sh*tty weapon to introduce, too: with no audible thwack nor visual wow factor, the match instead resembled a real-life pensioner beatdown broadcast by the least reputable news agency known to man.

All anybody wanted to see was Vince receive some sort of reckoning. We did - but the whole thing circled back on itself to evoke feelings of unthinkable horror. Vince, as we are painfully aware, is a bloody lunatic. In order to remind fans of the tension and fashion a "moment" of it, he should have instructed Bret to blacken his eye in the pre-match, in a belated apologetic gesture - before covering the bruise with make up.

Then, after taking a worked punch and frantically removing the foundation in plain sight, Hart applies the Sharpshooter, taking us home with a visual promising catharsis, not pure nightmare fuel.


5. Brock Lesnar Vs. John Cena, Extreme Rules 2012

Brock Lesnar John Cena
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar returned to WWE in 2012 equipped with an aura no wrestling promotor on earth, ever, could engineer. Not Vince McMahon in his 1980s pomp. Not Giant Baba in his 1990s heyday. Not Paul Heyman, a man with a ridiculous ability to make Shinola from sh*t, in that same decade. Not Gedo right now.

Lesnar commanded that aura by dominating an unfamiliar, legit combat sport to the tune of record-breaking PPV revenue. He p*ssed credibility, and, in a superbly stripped-back pre-match promo, accused Cena of p*ssing his pants in fear at the prospect of facing him. Turning the airwaves blue was not the only otherwise prohibited means Lesnar was permitted to get himself over; in a wild angle, Lesnar bloodied Cena the hard way to drive PPV buys. On the night of the PPV itself, Lesnar was just as dominant, bloodying and brutalising Cena in a disturbing, ultra-stiff spectacle of a match...

...from which Cena emerged victorious, for reasons absolutely moronic both on the face of it - and because Cena's character arc throughout 2012 necessitated a crisis of confidence in order to justify his WrestleMania 29 "chance for redemption". Instead, he defeated Brock B*stard Lesnar and had a grand old time bullying John Laurinaitis. In the meantime, Lesnar plumbed the depths in a dire series with Triple H nobody, audibly, was interested in.

Lesnar had to break the Undertaker's WrestleMania Streak in order for WWE to maximise their massive investment.


4. Cooling Wrestling's Hottest Commodity, Part II

CM Punk The Miz
WWE.com

Every now and then, a pitch demands the inclusion of well-covered ground, the insights into which barely qualify as such. It's just as well, then, that you could dig up the earth to find the logic behind the mishandling of CM Punk circa 2011 and still fail to locate the corpse of the Straight Edge Superstar himself. The character, and his momentum, was buried that far below the surface.

It was an anthology of pure sh*te. You could write books on the subject, so for the sake of a bearable word count - and to avoid digging up the same old same old - let's just focus on one deeply strange artefact as a distillation of how drastically wrong WWE got it.

By October, we had somehow reached a point at which The Miz - a complete WWE thoroughbred, apologist, company man, etc. etc. - was somehow positioned as a renegade union leader. This was a role to which only Punk was viably suited, but by then, he had stopped raging against the machine. He was a scab subsumed by it, prattling about with Triple H - with whom he'd just feuded - as part of his sycophantic skeleton staff.

A victim of the most convoluted burial ever seen in wrestling, Punk was either insidiously targeted or definitively botched. Folk are still working it all out - but since the television was so putrid and un-re-watchable, we may never receive an answer.


3. The Murder Of Zack Ryder

Zack Ryder Kane
WWE.com

Poor Zack Ryder.

The guy is evidently a major fan of WWE; his adult bedroom resembles a childhood paradise writ large, and he "enjoys" a sort of Stockholm Syndrome relationship with company. He epitomises what Dolph Ziggler has referred to as the "Gratitude Era". Ryder isn't just happy to be there; he is absolutely thrilled.

This was probably his undoing, let's face it. For whatever reason - pure vindictiveness, sadly, is the likely root cause, especially armed with the knowledge of how WWE reacted to AJ Lee's celebratory tattoo - WWE enjoyed draining Zack Ryder of his momentum via exsanguination. He got over with the hardcore portion of the fanbase, even those who deemed Z! Long Island True Story a bit naff, purely because his enthusiasm was so infectious, his drive so admirable. A token United States Title win, at TLC 2011, felt like a real accomplishment to the fans - but, given what followed, it was probably a cruel rib; a tantalising taste of achievement spooned out purely to take it away.

There's a weird "missed opportunity" narrative surrounding Ryder, which isn't true. Had WWE pushed him to the main event level, there's every chance his exposed in-ring game would have eroded the feel-good factor - but, Christ almighty, what a devastating cautionary tale this was, for talent and fans alike.

Don't dream, don't get over if we don't want you to get over - because if you do, the Big Red Machine will come after you. And he'll push you off a stage while you're in a f*cking wheelchair, for f*ck's sake.


2. Ostracising Macho Man Randy Savage

Randy Savage Vince McMahon
WWE.com

As the WWF hurtled perilously close to extinction in the face of the steroid and sex scandals of the early 1990s - and attractions like Hulk Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior departed the company in acrimonious circumstances - Vince McMahon felt a youth movement was the best way forward, as a means of disassociating the public from the ghosts of the gassed-up Golden Era.

This doesn't explain the relegation of Macho Man Randy Savage to commentary duties, since he still looked in superb condition, having slimmed down considerably. Savage desperately wanted back in the ring. As he proved in the great Indian summer of 1997, he could still go in said ring. McMahon refused to relent, outside of a programme with Crush, of all people. No: Savage was a dinosaur, and McMahon was the meteorite - even though he really could have done with a man of Savage's star power in a turbulent period of fading popularity. Savage wasn't even booked as gatekeeper, really; just a commentator.

What's incredible about this sequence of events is that, bang in the midst of formally declaring this nascent philosophy via the 'New Generation' branding, McMahon booked Roddy Piper Vs. Jerry Lawler as the main event of King Of The Ring 1994 - which Savage called.

It was possibly the most insane aspect of a career built on 'Macho Madness',


1. The World's Strangest Match Result

Mark Henry Ryback
WWE.com

Even if WWE had failed to line up a challenger to John Cena and his newly-won WWE Heavyweight Title, the decision to put Mark Henry over Ryback at WrestleMania 29 was a strange one; the man's late-career renaissance peaked in 2011, his physical condition, never great in the first place, was in inexorable decline, and Ryback had firmly connected with the fanbase. He needed a win to either maintain that connection, or strengthen him ahead of his imminent heel turn.

There's no way WWE hadn't lined up a challenger, obviously, 24 hours after the biggest event of the year; a heel Ryback was selected as Cena's next antagonist because there were few, if any, viable options available - yet another indictment of the part-timer era. What's strange about the whole thing, more so than the result itself, is the way in which the post-match angle was framed; armed with the knowledge that Ryback was set to turn, the Big Guy's big Shell Shocked spot looked more petty than it did heroic or nasty, failing to really resonate one way or the other.

Ryback doesn't half talk some absolute b*llocks on his podcast - but this genuinely did kill his headliner prospects.


Watch Next


In this post: 
cesaro
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!