10 Times WWE Accidentally Brought Awful Gimmicks Back From The Dead

"Let the past die. Kill it, if you have to. It's the only way you'll be free"

Tensai Karrion Kross
WWE

Karrion Kross is having a rough time of it these days.

Shorn of his NXT title, separated from his wildly popular valet and suffering the most underwhelming debut in recent history, Karrion Kross' main roster career already resembles the rapidly-decaying flesh of his namesake.

To add insult to mortal injury, Kross debuted a new look on RAW this past Monday that immediately drew comparisons to Sean Connery's NSFW outfit in sci-fi action flop Zardoz, as well as the failed gimmicks of wrestlers past.

It's the latter part of that sentence this article will be focusing on. If the definition of insanity really is doing the same thing again and expecting different results, WWE has proven itself to be as crazy as the idea that CM Punk's AEW debut was a "total miss".

Like that one roommate who insists that expired food will be fine if you blast it in the microwave, WWE has a habit of reheating gimmicks that should have been left to rot in a bin. The unfortunate Mr. Kross is just the latest in a long line of culinary abortions to emerge from WWE's increasingly ramshackle kitchen...

10. Lilly & Rocco

Rocco Legion of Doom SummerSlam 1992
WWE.com

Depending on merch sales, Alexa Bliss' demon doll may not be long for this world. Even if Lilly is fated to depart from our TV screens, her creators can be proud of one thing - she's already lasted longer than the infamous Rocco.

For those who don't know, Rocco was a ventriloquist's doll that the legendary Legion of Doom found themselves lumbered with in 1992. In what was supposedly an attempt to make the Legion more marketable to younger fans, the intimidating duo was forced to drag Rocco with them to the ring as he was a "reminder of their roots".

Apparently, the Legion used to beat the crap out of Rocco when they were children, and this somehow played an important role in their decision to become post-apocalyptic outlaws. (WWE left its fans to fill in the blanks of the story).

Lilly definitely hasn't reached Rocco's level of infamy among wrestling fans, but it's likely both will be enshrined in the WrestleCrap Hall of Fame in the none-too-distant future.


9. Fake Kane & UnderFaker

Kane Fake Kane
WWE.com

WWE spent a good chunk of 1994 on the storyline between the Undertaker and his evil twin. The feud was dreadful, the only highlight being Vince McMahon snarling "Nothing is happening!" on air during the pair's abysmal blow-off match.

12 years later, nothing continued to happen as WWE brought back the imposter gimmick for Kane.

Much like its forebearer, the Kane/Fake Kane feud failed to take off as fans simply didn't care about the man behind the mask. WWE even realised that the angle was a dud and ended it within a month of it starting, as Kane simply beat the s**t out of his mini-me on an episode of RAW and threw him out of the arena.

Fake Kane would later find success outside the WWE as Doc Gallows, teaming with Karl Anderson to become one of the most successful tag teams of this generation. But before that could happen, Gallows formed another tag team with our next entrant...


8. Slam Master J & Too Cool

Slam Master J Wwe
WWE.com

Poor Ray Gordy. Son of wrestling legend Terry Gordy, Ray soon found out that a famous name is no guarantee of success in the wrestling industry.

After working a redneck gimmick for two years alongside Doc Gallows, Ray found himself inexplicably transformed into a Vanilla Ice wannabe call Slam Master J. WWE may have hoped that any lingering audience affection for John Cena's discarded "Doctor of Thuganomics" gimmick would attach itself to Master J, but all it did was remind us of Too Cool.

Too Cool - the team-name of Scotty 2 Hotty and Grandmaster Sexay - were incredibly over in the Attitude Era, but are regarded by modern wrestling fans as a flash in the pan. Teams like The Hardy Boyz, the Dudley Boyz and Edge & Christian are lionized to this day, but Too Cool have largely been swept under the rug.

Too Cool were in the right place at the right time, whereas Slam Master J just looked like a man out of time - an uncle throwing shapes in a nightclub while his nephews look on in horror.

(Yes, John Cena got over with a similar gimmick but Ray Gordy, with all due respect, was not John Cena).


7. Titus O'Neil & The Shockmaster

Titus O'Neil botch
WWE.com

Wrestling fans love an argument, but one thing that unites us all is our love of a good botch. And no botches in history have ever been as widely loved as Titus O'Neill's tripping under the apron at the Greatest Royal Rumble and WCW's Shockmaster falling "flat on his f**king arse", as the late British Bulldog put it.

They were the perfect botches: nobody was injured, everyone watching got a huge belly laugh out of it, and both incidents are fondly remembered to this day.

Less fondly remembered are the gimmicks that followed, as both men were repackaged as clumsy oafs. Shockmaster was treated as an avuncular dork who fell over any loose object on the ground, and Titus found himself unable to enter a ring without risking serious injury. Unsurprisingly, these one-dimensional gimmicks failed to get either wrestler over, and audience interest in both wrestlers rapidly dimmed.

Fortunately for Titus, his sterling humanitarian record has helped soften the blow of the Greatest Royal Rumble, and he is now chiefly regarded as a good egg (who had a great fall).


6. Ms. McCool & Dean Douglas

Michelle McCool
WWE.com

Some gimmicks have a built-in glass ceiling. The likes of IRS (taxman), Thurman "Sparky" Plugg (race-car driver) and Val Venis (pornstar) were never going to be world champions due to the inherent silliness of their gimmicks. To that list, we can add Dean Douglas and Ms. McCool (teachers).

Both wrestlers were hobbled out of the gate by a gimmick that was good for nothing except tired puns, such as McCool calling the team she valeted "Teacher's Pets" and Dean Douglas delivering lines like "I'm giving you a D for dismal". Even The Rock would have struggled to get those zingers over, and neither Dean Douglas or Ms. McCool enjoyed much success in the WWE.

Fortunately for Ms. McCool, WWE changed her gimmick and she enjoyed a successful career in the WWE before retiring due to injury. Dean Douglas, on the other hand, fell afoul of both the audience (who hated his gimmick) and the infamous Kliq (who hated him) and was given his marching orders.


5. Farooq & The Ghost Of Spartacus

Ron Simmons Farooq Asad
WWE

This one is something special, as Vince McMahon brought back a gimmick so terrible it had only existed previously as a bad idea.

The idea of a wrestling gladiator was first thought up of by WCW's Jim Herd, commonly regarded as the worst executive in wrestling history. Herd simply did not understand wrestling or its fans, as seen by his idea of wanting to turn Ric Flair into a gladiator called Spartacus. Herd's reasoning - that Flair needed to"change with the times" - is as baffling now as it was then. Other than the Russell Crowe movie of the same name, gladiators have never been popular and this was years before that came out.

Unfortunately, the same devil that whispered the idea into Herd's ear visited Vince McMahon years later and this time no one was around to stop him. The results weren't pretty - former WCW champion Ron Simmons debuted as the gladiator Farooq, much to the consternation of the fans. Fortunately, Farooq was injured shortly after debuting and was out long enough to come back with a new gimmick.

That's right - the gladiator schtick was so bad that getting seriously injured was actually better for Farooq's career than carrying on with it.


4. Lance Storm & Steve Blackman

Lance Storm
WWE.com

Note to WWE writers: your job is to get wrestlers over, not put them down. Unfortunately, no one told that to whoever was writing for Steve Blackman and Lance Storm.

Steve and Lance were both pigeon-holed as being dishwater dull. Blackman's lack of personality formed the basis of his tag team with Al Snow, as Al would frequently poke fun of his partner being a charisma black hole. Things were even worse for Lance, who had to suffer the indignity of watching Steve Austin himself pretending to sleep on the entrance ramp during one of his matches (Austin had helpfully shouted "Boring!" before doing so, lest WWE's subtle wit be lost on the audience).

Telling your audience to tune out whenever a particular wrestler appears is never a good idea, and it was especially egregious in the case of Lance Storm. Lance was one of the finest technical wrestlers of his generation and he could have turned WWE's midcard scene into a genuine highlight, much like WCW's cruiserweight division had been.

Sadly it was not to be. Still at least WWE learned its lesson and never again mocked its own wrestlers for their lack of charisma, right?

Yeah, about that...


3. Karrion Kross Part I - Marc Mero

Scarlett Karrion Kross
WWE

The last three entries will be doing something different as all three are going to focus on Karrion Kross and how WWE have been setting him up to fail.

First up: Scarlett. The ever-contentious Jim Cornette hit the nail squarely on the head when he said that WWE had only succeeded in making a star out of Kross' valet, rather than Kross himself. Time has proven the controversial critic right, as Kross' NXT swansong against Samoa Joe was soundtracked by chants of "WE WANT SCARLETT!".

NXT only have themselves to blame for this. All of Kross' rivals have made the point that all of his appeal comes from the woman by his side and that if you take her away, you're left with a bog-standard wrestler. Like Lance Storm before him, this kind of backwards scripting has played a huge role in causing audiences to turn on Kross, effectively turning him into Marc Mero 2.0.

Just as Mero became irrelevant in the face of his wife's increasing popularity, Kross has already become a sideshow in the Scarlett circus.


2. Karrion Kross Part II - Tensai

Lord Tensai
WWE

Next up in our terrible trio: Lord Tensai!

The sight of Karrion Kross stomping to the ring in a weird mask evoked fond memories of the artist formerly known as Albert. (Quick recap: Tensai used to work for WWE under the name "Albert" and WWE fans never let him forget it, as every Tensai match was serenaded by the audience chanting his former ring-name).

Fortunately, WWE haven't made the same mistake and pretended the man under Kross' crimson bondage gear is a completely different wrestler. He's still Karrion Kross, he's just taken to cosplaying as Shredder with a BDSM fetish.

Incidentally, if the idea behind Kross' new look really was to boost his merch sales then it's no wonder Vince McMahon holds his audience in contempt. Would you want to be friends with someone if you genuinely thought this was the kind of s**t they were into?


1. Karrion Kross Part III - RETRIBUTION

RETRIBUTION WWE
WWE.com

And for the grand finale, we have RETRIBUTION - the final zombified gimmick munching on the corpse of Kross' credibility.

WWE may have been trying to evoke Kane with Karrion's new entrance, with the red and black outfit and the flames in the background, but Kross looked more like a reject from one of the worst factions in wrestling history - RETRIBUTION.

RETRIBUTION were abysmal - a faction of so-called renegades who gave themselves moronic names and wore masks that looked like the early, drunken drafts of Hannibal Lecter's iconic muzzle. The only member of the group to still get regular TV time is Mustafa Ali, coincidentally the only one who didn't wear one of those godawful masks.

RETRIBUTION have only been dead for less than a year. Hell, Mase and T-Bar (told you the names were stupid) are still wearing the damn masks. Their failure is still fresh in fans' minds, and Kross' career is way too flimsy to survive association with them, however indirect.

To be associated with one bad gimmick may be regarded as a misfortune; to be associated with two looks like carelessness. To be associated with three leaves us wondering exactly whose chips Karrion pissed in on his first night on RAW.


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.