10 Unbelievable WrestleMania Matches That Almost Happened
Almost on the 'Grandest Stage of Them All'.
WrestleMania season is a wrestling fanatic's Christmas period. However, meeting their mammoth expectations is no easy feat and the booking can change substantially over the course of a WWE year.
While a number of the shelved matches have since become ingrained in wrestling folklore (such as Hogan vs. Flair and Bret/Shawn 2), there are countless other pencilled-in bouts that became victims of the almighty eraser.
As such, the list of considered matches is a wide-ranging catalogue of curious oddities and missed opportunities. In some cases, it's a relief these matches were scrapped, while in others, it's an agonising glimpse of what could have been.
From jaw-dropping championship showdowns to drool-worthy dream bouts, Vince McMahon's WrestleMania notepad has seen plenty of interesting doodles over the years. In the ever changing world of WWE, most of these notes wound up in the trash. Nevertheless, journeying through the alternate universe of WrestleMania is always an interesting ride.
With a myriad of rumoured matches, we've picked out a handful of the most unusual. If we've left off your favourite, feel free to add it to the comment section below.
10. Terry Funk Vs. Mick Foley - WrestleMania XIV
Terry Funk and Mick Foley ad a bloody rivalry that was itself unrivalled. From flaming chairs and branding irons in ECW to the barbed wire ropes and exploding C4 deathmatches of Japan, the crazed grapplers knew no limit to their sadism when they met in the ring.
So when Funk resurfaced in the WWF in early 1998, Foley naturally wanted to present this sick symphony on 'The Grandest Stage of Them All'. Sadly, with the presence of Mike Tyson attracting widespread media attention, McMahon didn't want to present his product as a bloodthirsty, violent cockfight and put the bout on hold.
Nevertheless, Mick Foley and Terry Funk did get their WrestleMania moment. However, it was fighting with each other instead of against; the wildmen defeated The New Age Outlaws for the Tag Team Titles. Coincidentally, the impetus for that feud with The Outlaws came at the close of a Foley vs. Funk bout on Raw.
After dropping the belts post-'Mania, Foley and Funk would eventually have their one-on-one war on Raw on 4 May in a predictably brutal encounter . Despite their advancing ages, the hardcore twosome would rekindle their bloody feud once again eight years later at One Night Stand 2006, with a predictably similar level of physicality.
9. Randy Savage Vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania XII
When Randy Savage was confined to the broadcast table in early 1993, the legendary 'Macho Man' was largely put out to pasture in the WWF. Despite competing pretty regularly in-ring on the house show loop, Savage only wrestled on WWF TV a handful of times after 1992.
It was clear that McMahon saw Savage as being in the twilight of his career and wanted the elder statesmen to step aside in favour of a younger crop of stars. Sensing this shift in direction, 'Macho Man' made one final plea, with a spectacular idea that would send him into retirement for good.
According to his brother, Lanny Poffo, the former WWF Champion laid out an intricate exit strategy that saw him enter a two year feud with Shawn Michaels. The finale would see 'The Macho Man' lose a retirement match at WrestleMania XII and see him resigned to commentary for the rest of his career.
Michaels and Savage had crossed paths only a handful of times before, most notably on the European Tour of '92 during Savage's last run as WWF Champion. However, the two had never engaged in a legitimate programme on TV.
Savage saw HBK as the man to help him finally surpass the standard set by him and Steamboat at WrestleMania III. Sadly, Vince disagreed, prompting Savage to leave for WCW, never to return.
8. Bret Hart/John Cena Vs. Vince McMahon/Batista - WrestleMania XXVI
In the weeks leading up to WrestleMania XXVI, it was reported by the Pro Wrestling Torch that multiple sources in the WWE had noted an unusual booking shift for 'The Show of Shows'.
In late February, the plans for WrestleMania were for John Cena to team up with WWE legend, Bret 'The Hitman' Hart, to take on the team of Batista and Vince McMahon. What's even more incredible is the fact that it was even proposed that the WWE Championship be on the line with Bret walking out victorious.
The build up to 'Mania itself seemed to corroborate this angle, as both Cena and Batista had been heavily involved in the development of the Bret/Vince feud. Cena was even the one who had relayed Bret's WrestleMania challenge to Vince, while Batista had gotten physical with Bret a couple of times leading into 'The Show of Shows'.
In hindsight, this would have allowed Bret a spectacular return to the centre stage of WrestleMania with the safety net of Cena and Batista around him to pick up the slack. Bret even proved at SummerSlam, five months later, that he could contribute pretty well in a tag team setting.
Unfortunately, WWE ultimately went a different direction and had the pairings of Vince/Bret and Batista/Cena square off in solo competition as the tag scenario was dropped.
7. The Rock Vs. JBL - WrestleMania 21
In 2005, WWE was beginning to transition towards a new crop of stars, with the ascension of both Batista and John Cena. However, in a year where WrestleMania went "Hollywood", one notable star was absent for that very same reason.
Having appeared a handful of times throughout 2004, The Rock last competed in a WWE ring at WrestleMania XX, teaming with Mick Foley against Evolution. Prior to that, it was Backlash '03 against Goldberg. Point being, when The Rock laced up the boots, it's a big deal. Which makes the proposed WrestleMania 21 pairing for 'The Great One' all the more odd.
After The Rock's original idea of wrestling Sting was dismissed when WWE failed to acquire the WCW icon, the attention soon turned to reigning WWE Champion, JBL. The Rock would challenge the big Texan for the title, win the gold and drop it back to him shortly after, with 'The People's Champ' disappearing back into movies until the next WrestleMania.
Incredibly, The Rock's WWE contract was left to quietly expire without so much as a phone call at the close of 2004. As such, The Rock wasn't contractually obliged to do anything and that fact proved costly. Ultimately, WWE's biggest export to Hollywood was conspicuously absent when WrestleMania hit Tinseltown and he wouldn't appear in a WWE ring again until 2011.
6. Sting Vs. Kurt Angle - WrestleMania X8
After WCW fell apart, Sting appearing at WrestleMania was a consistent topic within the wrestling rumour mill. Talks of a dream match against The Undertaker seemed to recur almost annually and came agonisingly close to happening on a number of occasions, most notably at WrestleMania XXVII.
However, many may not be aware that Sting actually came very close to signing with WWE years earlier. According to former WWE writer, Dave Lagana, Sting was considered a lock in 2002 and the writing team were even instructed to work him into booking plans for WrestleMania X8. Those plans allegedly saw WCW's franchise player square off with WWE's Olympic gold medalist.
Sadly, WWE failed to secure 'The Stinger' and Angle was placed into a throwaway mid-card bout with Kane. Meanwhile, Sting would remain in semi-retired until he joined the World Wrestling All-Stars in late 2002.
While WWE ultimately failed to pull off the wrestling dream match, Angle and Sting eventually squared off a number of times in TNA. The duo even main evented TNA's flagship event, Bound For Glory, in 2007, battling over the TNA World Heavyweight Championship in arguably one of the best matches of Sting's career.
Nevertheless, the pairing of Angle and Sting in WWE would have been magic and 'The Grandest Stage of Them All' would have been the perfect platform.
5. Brock Lesnar Vs. Chris Benoit - WrestleMania XIX
Anyone familiar with Kurt Angle's career knows that he won an Olympic gold medal with a broken [freakin'] neck. Those same neck issues reared their ugly head once more at No Way Out 2003.
Suffering from a litany of spine-related issues, Angle's participation in the WrestleMania main event against Brock Lesnar was in severe doubt. So much so that a back-up plan was created that allowed the show to go ahead without the 'Olympic Hero'.
On 6 March, Lesnar won the right to challenge Angle for the WWE Title early by destroying Paul Heyman in a Steel Cage. According to Angle, the plans then called for him to quickly drop the title to Lesnar the following week on SmackDown, before leaving for surgery. Meanwhile, Chris Benoit would become number one contender, having narrowly lost out to Angle at the Royal Rumble, and challenge Lesnar for the championship at WrestleMania XIX.
However, just days before he was scheduled to lose the WWE Title on SmackDown, Angle had a run in with a neighbour's child who suffered from Down syndrome. The child told Angle how excited he was to see him compete at 'Mania and that encounter was enough to change history.
The surgery was postponed, Angle/Brock was back on for 'Mania, and the WWE Title defence on SmackDown was brilliantly worked into the storyline.
4. Mike Tyson Vs. Triple H - WrestleMania X-Seven
With the huge WrestleMania rematch between 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin and The Rock scheduled to headline WrestleMania X-Seven, Triple H was left in no-man's land heading into the event without an opponent of his own.
A number of scenarios were bandied around in the build up to the big show, including Triple H coaxing Shawn Michaels out of retirement for a DX implosion. While that would eventually take place at SummerSlam 2002, HBK wasn't quite ready in 2001 and the idea was shelved.
Instead, the attention turned to sports stars, including Ray Lewis of the Baltimore Ravens and even an MMA import from Pride FC. Neither idea went much further and Vince instead looked to pair 'The Game' with boxing's biggest badass, 'Iron' Mike Tyson. Playing off their previous association in D-Generation X, this booking would have made far more sense and the global name-recognition of Tyson was infinitely more marketable.
While the specifics of the match are sketchy, the bout would have seen Triple H square off with 'The Baddest Man on the Planet' in a six round boxing match. Luckily for 'The Game', the money involved was astronomical; the Tyson bout was nixed and Triple H's face was spared.
Instead, 'The Cerebral Assassin' faced The Undertaker in hugely entertaining bout that spilled throughout the stadium.
3. Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin - WrestleMania XIV
There are many "What if...?" scenarios in wrestling but very few are as intriguing as the possibility of life without the Montreal Screwjob. Had Vince McMahon not opted out of his 20 year deal with Bret Hart, the lay of the land would have been drastically different going into 1998 - including WrestleMania.
WrestleMania XIV was always set to be the coronation of 'Stone Cold' as the WWF's king of the hill; however, chances are his opponent could well have been drastically different. While the specifics have varied over the years as to what could and would have happened, one of the more believable and logical scenarios that has come to light is the prospect of Steve Austin facing Bret Hart for the WWF Championship.
'The Hitman' and 'The Rattlesnake' would have been at odds for almost 18 months by the time WrestleMania XIV rolled around. Had Bret been staying put, it's also likely that he would have defeated HBK at Survivor Series '97 as redemption for his loss at WrestleMania XII.
With 'Stone Cold' representing the revolution of the Attitude Era and the 'The Excellence of Execution' flying the flag for tradition, the ready-made conflict would have presented the perfect scenario for Austin's coronation at WrestleMania.
Nevertheless, Bret's push out the door changed everything. Mike Tyson came aboard and the rest is history.
2. Daniel Bryan Vs. Undertaker - WrestleMania XXX
When The Undertaker was considering opposition in early 2014, it's a little known fact that the Brock Lesnar bout that took place at WrestleMania XXX wasn't always the top choice. In fact, 'Taker himself had apparently lobbied to work with Daniel Bryan at that year's 'Grandaddy of Them All'.
While a Brock match had been in the works for some time, dating back to their bizarre confrontation in the aftermath of UFC 121, question marks loomed in the run up to 'Mania in New Orleans as to whether or not the ageing 'Deadman' could withstand a beating at the hands of 'The Beast'. Sadly, those fears proved well-founded and The Undertaker would inevitably leave 'Mania that year in an ambulance.
Nevertheless, Plan B saw 'The Phenom' squaring off with Daniel Bryan in a continuation of 'Taker's run against proven in-ring workers since 2008. At the top of his game at the time, Bryan would have been the perfect opponent to provide 'The Demon of Death Valley' with the match he deserved at WrestleMania's 30th outing.
Ultimately, CM Punk's departure changed the course of wrestling history. Lesnar squared off with 'Taker as planned and shocked the world when he broke 'The Streak'. Meanwhile, Daniel Bryan went on to win the big one and took his rightful place in WrestleMania history.
1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Eddie Guerrero - WrestleMania 22
There are a number of dream matches we will likely never ever see. From Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle to Steve Austin vs. Hulk Hogan, the list of WrestleMania main events that never came to be is eternally heartbreaking.
Fantasy booking aside, one dream match that was very much in consideration was Eddie Guerrero and Shawn Michaels. Lightly pencilled in for WrestleMania 22, 'Latino Heat' vs 'The Heartbreak Kid' would have been an amazing story to tell and a true pleasure to watch unfold.
Former WWE writer Court Bauer noted on the MLW Radio Network that plans were indeed put in place just days before Guerrero passed away in November 2005. Former WWE Exec, Bruce Prichard, has since gone on to confirm this statement.
Given the stellar work rate of both men and their similar ascensions to the top of the wrestling industry, this would have been a wrestling purest's dream match and the similarities in style would have meshed tremendously.
Even their battles outside the ring with their own personal demons mirrored each other and both men found redemption as born-again Christians. Sadly, Guerrero's death just days after the idea began to snowball left the match confined to fantasy warfare. In one of wrestling biggest missed opportunities, the two men never crossed paths in the squared circle.