10 Underhyped Wrestling Matches That Blew Everyone Away

Low-key bangers nobody saw coming.

Eva Marie Bayley
WWE

Considering how often hugely hyped matches end up falling short of expectations, it's always a sure relief when a long-anticipated bout actually lives up to the buzz.

But perhaps even better is when a match tears the house down totally out of nowhere, with no prior inkling that it'd make for anything more than acceptable viewing.

These ten matches, from main event World Title bouts to lower-card showdowns, were all presented with a minimal amount of hype, typically either a result of a poor build or a previous outing suggesting fans shouldn't get their hopes up.

But in each case, we were all left pleasantly surprised, with those involved delivering far above what anyone could've hoped for, in turn wrestling some of the greatest and most memorable matches of their respective careers.

While most viewers likely went into these matches with middling expectations at best, that pessimism quickly dissolved away once it became clear that they had more to offer than lazy, predictable booking and the same old routine we've seen week in and week out...

10. Last Man Standing: John Cena Vs. Umaga (Royal Rumble 2007)

Cena Umaga
WWE

Despite being built up as a monster heel in the lead up to this match, Umaga hadn't quite won most fans over yet.

After all, sweeping through the mid-card in a slew of brief squash matches is completely different to main-eventing one of the biggest PPVs of the year, and having him lose to Cena via rollup at New Year's Revolution the month prior massively stifled his momentum.

Expectations were middling-at-best, then, for Umaga's Last Man Standing match against Cena for the WWE Championship, yet the end result was an uncommonly visceral take on the classic match type.

Umaga dismantles Cena for a huge chunk of the match, but rather than have Big Match John mount a typical Superman comeback, he instead overcomes by choking the monster out with a ring rope.

In one of the most memorable commentary calls of the last 15 years, JR shouts, "Even a monster's gotta breathe!", confirming just how unique and creative a finish this was to a generally spectacular and brutal Last Man Standing match.


9. Trish Stratus Vs. Stephanie McMahon-Helmsley (No Way Out 2001)

Stephanie McMahon Helmsley vs. Trish Stratus - No Way Out 2001
WWE.com

On paper, it was easy to sneer at the prospect of Stephanie McMahon stepping into the ring with Trish Stratus because she wasn't happy about Trish dating her dad.

Remember, of course, that Trish was hardly a top-line in-ring commodity at this point in her career, and so this had all the makings of a clumsy dud few would remember fondly.

And while it's certainly not a clinic of technical wrestling, it is ludicrously entertaining as a piece of storytelling.

Sensibly laid out more as a deeply personal brawl than a pure wrestling match, you nevertheless have to give Steph credit for pulling her weight and looking credible against Trish.

There are so many fun moments throughout its mere 8-minute runtime, from Trish getting doused with water to William Regal's hilarious crisis of allegiance, resulting in him aiding both women at various points.

This could so easily have been an absolute mess, but by focusing all its creative energies in the right direction - that is, character work and entertaining extras - it was much better than it really had any right to be.


8. Iron Man Match: The Rock Vs. Triple H (Judgment Day 2000)

The Rock Vs Triple H Judgment Day 2000
WWE.com

The second-ever televised Iron Man match in WWE history had a considerable shadow hanging over it, given that the first one was the masterful bout between Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XII.

Wrestling for a straight hour is a major stamina test for even the most conditioned athletes like Hart and Michaels, but when it was announced that The Rock would defend the WWE Title against Triple H for an hour at Judgment Day 2000, many fans were skeptical.

There just wasn't the general belief that the pair, as talented as they were, could tell a compelling story for 60 minutes without getting gassed.

But the match was booked smartly to be the polar opposite of Hart vs. Michaels, in that it was jam-packed with eleven falls in total, effectively dividing the hour-long match into a series of mini-set pieces, while providing a few moments for the two to catch their breath.

Though largely remembered more for The Undertaker debuting his American Badass gimmick in its final moments - and in turn costing The Rock the title - it largely subverted the expectation that it'd be a sluggish, tiresome slog of an Iron Man match.


7. Bret Hart Vs. The British Bulldog (In Your House 5: Seasons Beatings)

Bulldog Bret Hart
WWE.com

Much like the Iron Man match, In Your House 5's World Title main event between Bret Hart and The British Bulldog had to live up to one of the most iconic and beloved matches of all time - in this case the previous outing between Hart and Bulldog in Wembley Stadium at SummerSlam 1992.

This rematch took place three years later to a muted level of anticipation from fans, in large part due to the fair mediocrity of Bulldog's recent heel turn, done no favours by him losing to Diesel two months prior during his snoozy year-long title run.

But Bret and Bulldog effectively switching positions popularity-wise ensured their In Your House encounter felt fundamentally different, aided further by Hart's decision to bust himself open, a rarity for the Hitman.

Bret of course prevailed this time in a match which soared far above the passable sequel to their SummerSlam match that most were anticipating.


6. Triple H Vs. Taka Michinoku (Raw, April 10, 2000)

WWE Raw Taka Michinoku Triple H
WWE.com

Though nobody in their right mind expected the 187lb Taka Michinoku to steal the WWE Title from Triple H on this episode of Raw is War, the match was booked so convincingly that fans were thoroughly worked into believing that maybe, just maybe, Taka might win after all.

What could've been a joke of a squash match was actually a legitimately competitive fight which squeezed an almost impossible amount of incident into a runtime of barely five minutes.

As much as Trips had a rep for burying everyone in sight with his trusty Golden Shovel at this point in his career, he absolutely bumped his ass off for Taka throughout.

But the icing on the cake was all the peripheral drama, which saw the Acolytes (who Taka brought to ringside for protection), Kai En Tai, and the McMahons all getting involved, not to ignore Earl Hebner standing up to Trips.

For a match nobody knew was happening until the show started and which could've been a garden variety squash, it's telling that fans are still fondly reminiscing over it 20 years later.


5. Shawn Michaels Vs. Mankind (In Your House 10: Mind Games)

Mankind Shawn Michaels Mind Games
WWE.com

Though Shawn Michaels and Mankind's title bout at In Your House 10 suffered from a scarcely existent build and many were skeptical that their disparate in-ring styles would gel together, the end result was nothing short of incredible.

Despite basically just being a stepping-stone match until HBK was beaten for the strap by Sid at Survivor Series two months later, it's often cited by Mick Foley as one of his all-time favourite fights.

A masterful compromise between Michaels' technical finesse and Mankind's penchant for brutality, the near-half-hour slug-fest sees both men forced to change up their house styles somewhat, resulting in a unique contest which, in an ideal world, would've led to a more prolonged program.

Foley gets the absolute tar knocked out of him throughout, but this is far more than a stuntman showcase for him: it's one of the best matches of his entire career, even with its iffy DQ ending.


4. Bayley Vs. Eva Marie (NXT, November 25, 2015)

WWE NXT Bayley Eva Marie
WWE.com

Nobody could really be blamed for scoffing at the prospect of Eva Marie challenging Bayley for the NXT Women's Title, but this shockingly entertaining November 2015 match proved how smart booking could elevate inexperienced in-ring talent.

This wasn't simply a case of Bayley carrying Eva Marie to a solid match, but the creative stacking the odds against Bayley in a totally organic and self-aware way.

The match was laid out with the very idea that the Authority-backed Eva Marie didn't deserve this spot, and so Bayley was going to have to fend off stooge referees and Nia Jax in addition to her actual opponent.

In turn, this allowed the bulk of the physical demands to fall upon Bayley, while Eva Marie could focus more on playing to her character strengths than putting on a technical clinic.

What could've been a sloppy botch-fest or pure mediocrity was instead ingeniously booked for the best possible outcome, boosting the stock of both women in the process.


3. Sheamus Vs. Big Show (Hell In A Cell 2012)

Sheamus Big Show Hell In A Cell 2012
WWE.com

In terms of matches that were way more fun than they had any right to be, there are few better answers than the Big Show capturing the World Heavyweight Title from Sheamus at Hell in a Cell 2012.

Even back in 2012 this was a groan-worthy prospect of a title fight, but honestly might be one of the most low-key entertaining hoss fights of the last decade.

Despite the Big Show going into the match without much credibility to speak of, on its own terms it was a thrilling battle of the bulls, as both men made every hard hit count, impressively going the distance over a potentially concerning 20-minute runtime.

As much as this might've seemed like a toilet break match in theory, the sheer physicality of it and the dramatic near-falls quickly got the crowd invested, in turn delivering one of the greatest matches of the Big Show's career.


2. "I Quit" Match: John Cena Vs. JBL (Judgment Day 2005)

WWE Judgment Day 2005 John Cena JBL
WWE.com

After their rather underwhelming WrestleMania 21 bout, there wasn't much reason to expect anything but an also-ran clunker of an "I Quit" match from John Cena and JBL at Judgment Day 2005.

But shifting the focus away from a pure wrestling match was a smart move given JBL's strengths, allowing him to way brutal waste to Cena for long stretches, while emphasising Cena's never-say-die attitude.

It's probably pointless to call an I Quit match of all things overbooked, but in this case the overbooking is exactly what makes it so much fun. It's also extremely bloody, with both men spilling colour which only further heightened the drama.

Even the screwy finish, in which JBL quits before John can beat him to a pulp with a metal pipe, feels consistent with JBL's established character, while demonstrating just how far Cena is willing to go to win.

As both a barmy rollercoaster ride and a smart piece of smash-mouth storytelling, this was outstanding.


1. Dean Malenko Vs. Scotty 2 Hotty (Backlash 2000)

dean malenko scotty 2 hotty - backlash 2000
WWE.com

Backlash 2000 very nearly had the show stolen outright by its second match, as Dean Malenko defended his Light Heavyweight Championship against Scotty 2 Hotty.

The manner in which these two had been booked up to this point suggested this would be nothing more than a competent-yet-forgettable TV-caliber fight, but on this night both men brought their absolute A-game to the fore.

This was a shockingly physical match, with Malenko relentlessly working Scotty's knee and Scotty taking some absolutely hellacious bumps throughout, especially with the top-rope DDT which finally finished the job.

Malenko got one of his few true opportunities in WWE to show off his technical potential, but the real story here might just be how Scotty kept pace every step of the way. Without question, this is the best singles match of his entire WWE tenure.

If you haven't seen it or don't remember it - and given how it came and went without much fanfare, nobody could blame you - do yourself a favour and check it out.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.