10 Ups & 1 Down From Impact Wrestling Slammiversary XVI
TNA is dead, long live Impact Wrestling.

Forget everything you think you know about Impact Wrestling, because this was one of the best pay-per-views you'll see all year.
Slammiversary XVI was an unqualified success. Though the build was strong, with each of the card's top matches established through weeks of remarkably sharp storytelling, almost everything over-delivered. Impact took the wrestling's world's expectations, tore them up, and produced a whirlwind show more gratifying than anything put out by any other major American wrestling promotion in 2018, and we say that without a hint of irony.
Each of Impact's title-holders were in action, with World Champion Austin Aries vs. the hyper-athletic Moose taking top billing. Relative newcomer Su Yung put her Knockouts gold on the line against company legend Madison Rayne, Brian Cage was out to take Matt Sydal's X Division strap, and Homicide and Hernandez continued a bitter blood-feud with their LAX heirs, Santana and Ortiz. Oh yeah, Sami Callihan and Pentagon Jr.'s gruesome mask vs. hair bout was pretty special too.
Impact may never truly shake off TNA's stench, but Scott D'Amore and Don Callis are doing a sterling job. Their influence has completely transformed the promotion, and for the first time in years, this place is starting to feel like a genuine alternative again.
Slammiversary XVI felt like the start of something special. Here's how it went down...
Downs...
1. Predictable Hokum
The sole blot on Slammiversary's otherwise immaculate copybook wasn't even that bad, but Su Yung vs. Madison Rayne was a notable step down from everything else on the card.
Their Knockouts Championship bout was passable, but "passable" isn't good enough on a card of this calibre, with much of its trouble coming from predictability. It was abundantly clear that Rayne was here to lose. She was no more than a solid veteran hand brought in to put the new blood over, and that's exactly how the match transpired, with Madison falling to Su in seven minutes.
It was the right outcome, but Yung's zombie bride act is hokey in the extreme. Do we, as viewers, really need to see a corpse-painted grappler shambling to the ring with a horde of undead bridesmaids in 2018? Do we need to see the defeated party stuffed into a coffin while her husband (Josh Mathews) barely shows a shred of concern on commentary? Injured former Knockouts Champion Rosemary works a similar gimmick, but combines it with sublime performance skills, transcending these concerns. Unfortunately, Yung hasn't yet found the balance.
Ups...
10. New Fan? No Problem...
That Impact made this pay-per-view so accessible from a narrative standpoint is testament to the great work their new management have done since taking over late last year. As with any other pay-per-view, those who've been keeping up with weekly television will have taken the most from it, but the promotion put great work into ensuring that anyone could jump into Slammiversary and still be able to figure out what was going on.
They accomplished this not only through a sublime social media campaign, but by uploading a number of playlists recounting the show's biggest storylines over the weekend. Their YouTube channel became a fountain of useful primers. If you wanted to get invested in Impact's biggest event of 2018, all it took was 20-30 minutes and a couple of clicks, and you'd be all set.
Stuff like this will prove invaluable in regaining lapsed fans and attracting new ones. Impact is America's most story-rich promotion, and every Slammiversary bout meant something, but none of it was impenetrable. This was largely down to the marketing campaign, and the fantastic job the company's digital production team continue to do in 2018.
9. The Spirit Of ECW
Poor old Eddie Edwards has had a rough ride in 2018. Sami Callihan almost caved his skull in with a baseball bat back in March, leading to a series of bitter scraps held primarily in Tommy Dreamer's House Of Hardcore promotion, along with a six-man tag back at Impact's last pay-per-view, Redemption, in April.
The former Impact Champion lost his mind somewhere along the way, turning on Dreamer (whom he teamed with at Redemption) in the process. Tommy was there to tell a cautionary tale of what happens when performers get too caught up in the violence, and this formed the dynamic of their feud.
The duo met in a House Of Hardcore bout, and it was fine. You're not going to get a **** bout out of Tommy Dreamer in 2018 (if ever), but the stipulation helped mask his shortcomings, and Toronto was hot for the action. A noisy building often compensates for lukewarm work. This was the case here, as while the action was largely okay-to-decent, things like Tommy braining Eddie with a replica ECW Title belt felt forced.
A hammy post-match angle that saw Dreamer hand Edwards his kendo stick as a passing of the torch didn't get over, but the ECW-style brawl largely succeeded.
8. Blanchard & Allie Over-Deliver
Tessa Blanchard is a prospect. A fantastic wrestler with second generation pedigree, she's regularly linked with WWE, and competed in last year's Mae Young Classic. Speculation states that her inability to land a deal stems from attitude issues, but now, at 22 years old, she has found a home in Impact Wrestling, and looks set to be an important building block going forward.
Billed as a "Grudge Match," last night's clash with Allie didn't have much build, but the work compensated for this. Tessa is a heat-magnet, with her bruising, hard-hitting style unlike anyone else on the roster. Allie, meanwhile, is endlessly sympathetic. This dynamic means you could put these two in any spot on any show and they'd likely come up with something fun, as was the case here, with both performers working super-hard en route to the biggest win of Blanchard's run thus far.
Allie took a rough landing on a botched top rope Hurricanrana, but fortunately looked okay. This was the bout's sole blot. Their edict wasn't to go out and steal the show, but to deliver a solid, heated midcard bout in which the winner and loser both get over, and they succeeded.
7. Cage Powers Through Sydal
Impact's X Division has long been one of the promotion's biggest highlights, but it suffered greatly throughout the dismal Hulk Hogan/Eric Bischoff years, and has never truly recovered to its former prominence. Fortunately, things are on the up. The company have put great time and effort into rebuilding its old unique selling point by adding new blood, taking the shackles off, and letting them get over on the strength of their breathless in-ring performances, and it's working.
Last night's title fight wasn't as thrilling as the blitzkrieg opener (we'll get to that), but it still succeeded. In Matt Sydal vs. Brian Cage, Impact booked a twist on the usual big man vs. little man format, as while 'The Machine' is an inhumanly strong power wrestler, he can flip and fly like a man 70lbs lighter. He worked a strength-based gameplan against Sydal's weaselly survival tactics, but Cage's light-footedness means his bouts are never plodding. Here, him and Sydal effectively worked 10 minutes of counter exchanges, and while Matt felt like a surefire loser heading into the bout, his comebacks had the crowd believing otherwise.
Cage took victory and the X Division Title after booting Sydal out of the air, then nailing the Drill Claw. It was a rough landing for the former champion, and didn't look great on television, but not enough to spoil the action.
6. A Masterclass In Pacing
While WWE pay-per-views often feel like they've been thrown together with no consideration for how they'll flow, leading to long, laborious periods that kill the crowd and leave their shows' three-to-four hours feeling like double that, Impact nailed Slammiversary's pacing.
The PPV opened with a white-hot, action-packed opener to completely hook the audience from the first minute (contrast with Extreme Rules, which began with the insomnia-curing B-Team vs. Deleters of Worlds clash). Things slowed down from there, with Impact running through four medium-stakes bouts in succession, none of which were designed to steal the spotlight. Then, we entered the top-loaded closing stretch. The LAX civil war, Pentagon vs. Callihan, and Aries vs. Moose took Slammiversary home in breathtaking fashion, ensuring the pay-per-view peaked at precisely the right stage: as it was coming to a close.
This is how you put a wrestling show together. It shouldn't be difficult, but it's something WWE consistently fail at, and a huge reason why Slammiversary felt so watchable compared to Stamford's joyless slogs.
5. X Division Shines In All-Action Opener
There wasn't anything new or original about the way Slammiversary XVI opened. Impact stuck to their playbook, and did as they've done a thousand times before by gathering four of the X Division's most talented wrestlers in the ring at the same time, giving them 12 minutes of bell time, and telling them to go nuts.
And go nuts they did.
Johnny Impact vs. Taiji Ishimori vs. Fenix vs. Petey Williams was exactly what it needed to be. Fast, fluid, and crammed with high spots, it worked Toronto into a frenzy. Flying 'ranas, topes, Moonsaults to the outside, springboard cutters: this bout had the lot. It was one of the best popcorn matches you'll see from an American promotion all year, and an absolute must-watch from anyone who likes their wrestling high-octane.
Johnny took the victory in this classic X Division scramble, but it was Fenix who shone brightest. The former AAA man is as slick as they come. Everything he does looks effortless, and it's great to see a major American promotion give him this spotlight, even if he's playing a supplemental role.
4. Austin Aries: Top Guy
Let it never be said that Austin Aries isn't a fantastic all-round professional wrestler. Yes, he's kind of a d***, and yes, his WWE run wasn't what it should've been, but his abilities should never be in doubt. He's a cunning technician between the ropes, an engaging talker, still one of the best in the business at building a match that pushes both participants forward, and in Impact, he has found the perfect home base.
Impact have made him the man, and Aries justified it with an excellent World Title defence last night. This was no mean feat. Following two brutal hardcore-themed matches in Callihan vs. Pentagon and LAX vs. The OGz was always going to be tricky, but Aries and Moose accomplished it by executing their more traditional layout to perfection, though they weren't shy of getting crazy themselves.
Despite all this, the biggest shock wasn't the bout's quality, but its outcome. Moose's victory seemed inevitable beforehand, but his hopes were killed by a quick penalty kick/brainbuster combination in a shade under sixteen minutes. A pleasant surprise, as while Moose delivered perhaps the best singles performance of his Impact run, Aries feels like the right guy to lead this promotion forward.
3. Mask Versus Hair
Sami Callihan is a divisive performer, and not only for the way he conducts himself away from the cameras. His act is very turn-of-the-century indie, with his forced "edginess" often coming off like he's trying too hard, and his matches have a tendency to descend into sloppy walk-and-brawls. It's frustrating, because Sami is one of the best scrappers in the business on his best days.
Fortunately, this was one of his best days.
'The Worldwide Desperado's' mask versus hair war with Pentagon Jr. was utterly fantastic. On another night, it may have finished top of our 'Ups,' but take nothing away from this chaotic brawl. It was unlike anything you've seen from a mainstream American promotion all year. Sami tore Penta's mask. They drove spikes into each others' flesh. By the end, Callihan's face was coated in claret. There were chairshots, sick bumps, the obligatory baseball bat spots, and all of it resonated.
It'd take a longer word count than this to do their feud justice, but rest assured, this was a fittingly brutal conclusion. It could've done without the referee bump, but who cares? Pentagon and Callihan threw a drama-laden violence party, and as Sami, coated in his own plasma, bawled his eyes out as Penta shaved his hair, his comeuppance was beyond satisfying.
2. LAX Explode
If you've only got time to familiarise yourself with one of Slammiversary's key storylines, make it this one.
Impact have booked the LAX civil war to perfection. Eddie 'King' Kingston has shone as the saboteur, as has Konnan as the only real bridge between the heelish OGz (Homicide and Hernandez) and the new generation (Santana and Ortiz). Their beef feels real. It's bitter, nasty, and most of all, organic, stemming from a masterful storyline that has breathed new life into one of Impact's most iconic groups, with it all culminating in a berserk blow-off match.
With Homicide and Hernandez both the wrong side of 40 and two other hardcore bouts on the show, this match could've been garbage. It wasn't. The OGz and LAX damn near killed each other in a 13-minute blitz that barely let up throughout, and everything resonated with the Toronto crowd, from Hernandez's signature gravity-defying 285lb dive to Santana's match-ending thumbtack-assisted Frog Splash. It over-delivered, and it might end up being the best bout Impact put on all year.
A post-fight angle saw Konnan celebrate with his bloodied warriors, but they were jumped by the OGz. They took LAX's Tag Team Titles, sprayed "OG," across them, and the feud must continue. There'll be no complaints here. While Homicide and Hernandez can't wrestle this way every week, there's still plenty of life left in this rivalry, and if the calibre of storytelling remains consistent, this could carry Impact all the way to their next pay-per-view (Bound For Glory - 14 October).
1. Finally, An Identity
Impact Wrestling has been a consistently enjoyable show for over a year now, but it has never felt like a unique product. Good matches and fun angles only go so far. Though they'd often outdo Raw and SmackDown in terms of quality, you weren't necessarily missing anything by skipping Impact on any given week, such was their lack of identity. It was very much Sports Entertainment Lite rather than a true alternative, and this made it difficult to invest.
At Slammiversary XVI, Impact found their identity.
This isn't Diet WWE: it's a balanced, well-written promotion that rewards your fandom rather than punishes it. Feuds and storylines are built and developed with logic and purpose. When they reach their conclusion, you feel gratified, not disappointed, which should be a given everywhere, yet it's something other American promotions regularly struggle with.
The variety is astounding, too. The X Division is blooming once more, with athletic marvels like Brian Cage, Johnny Impact, and Fenix taking the breath away. In Tessa Blanchard, Allie, and Su Yung, the Knockouts have an exciting young core to build around. Bouts like LAX vs. The OGz and Pentagon vs. Callihan prove Impact does hardcore better than any of their competitors. The list goes on.
For those looking for a true WWE alternative without leaving the continent, here it is. TNA is dead. Long live Impact Wrestling.