10 WCW Fates Worse Than Death
WCW: The land of treacherous dark matches, viagra and Yetis that aren't actually yetis.
No, not actual real-life death. Nothing is worse than that.
WCW has become a name synonymous with, 'What were they thinking?!'. The fallen company has been responsible for some truly awful ideas. It seemed like every good plan WCW had was followed up by at least 10 bad ones. Being fair, WWE has also come up with plenty of creative calamities that might've had talent wishing for a kayfabe demise instead.
Obviously, this is a lighthearted look at some of the harebrained schemes World Championship Wrestling bosses came up with between the promotion's formation from NWA ashes in the late-1980s until Vince McMahon's purchase (for a paltry sum in hindsight) in 2001. WCW asked wrestlers to put up with some pretty dreadful stuff, but admittedly did pay them incredibly well into the bargain.
Imagine wrestling on one show whilst being fired on another mid-fretting about your future. That happened to someone. So, mind you, did a humiliating first for the biz that told the watching world (or at least millions tuning into Nitro) that a few on the roster couldn't 'get it up'. All of that comes before analysing one of the most iconically embarrassing moments in industry history.
You might already know what that is. No, it isn't the 'Fingerpoke Of Doom'!
WCW was hoodwinked by one of McMahon's worst displays of arrogance, they didn't know what a yeti was, and they thought somebody's mum would make a fine champion. David Arquette was the least of their problems, and that's saying a lot.
Like on WWE's side, some onscreen mercy killings might've been preferable to this.
10. Doing The Job To Vince Russo
Booker T made the most of being thrust into the main event spotlight come Bash At The Beach 2000. He was handpicked late in the day to replace Hulk Hogan against Jeff Jarrett, and he ended the night by winning his first WCW World Title. However, if you thought it was all sunshine and rainbows for Book after that, you’re sorely mistaken.
He actually did the J.O.B to none other than Vince Russo on the 25 September Nitro. In fact, Booker lost to Russo twice in successive weeks. The authority figure became number one contender when Scott Steiner placed him on top of an unconscious Booker during a funky tag bout on the 18 September flagship. One week later, Goldberg speared Russo through the side of the steel cage on the following show, thus giving Vince the top prize in WCW.
Keep in mind that this happened mere months after actor David Arquette had been champ, so fans weren’t best pleased with everything that was going on. They'd viewed Booker's win at BATB as a soft reset for the championship, then Vinnie Ru ran roughshod over their hopes and dreams.
Oh, and Russo vacated the thing a week later, because of course he did. Spare a thought for poor Booker though - his very first World Title win (the same year he was bizarrely re-cast in his old G.I Bro gimmick!) was quickly snuffed out by Russo's bid to play Mr. McMahon in another company.
After that, he had to sit and watch the belt get vacated for the millionth time anyway.
9. Trashing Your Own Character During Its Debut
Goldust was a bolt from the blue (gold?) in the 1990s. The industry at large had never seen anything quite like the gimmick Dustin Rhodes played, at least not in the WWF. It presented Dustin as an androgynous enigma who played mind games with his opponents, but it sadly hinged on homophobia at the same time; thanks in part to that last bit being downplayed, Goldust is generally remembered fondly.
In late-1999, WCW signed Rhodes and tried to repackage him into a daring new guise. Vignettes aired for Seven, a mysterious spectre who stood outside a young boy's window (which was awkward) and generally seemed like some mish-mash of Goldust-meets-Undertaker vibes. Then, on the 8 November episode of Nitro, Seven literally floated to the ring.
Minutes later, Dustin himself was cutting a shoot-style promo on the ridiculousness of his own new persona. As you do. He bashed WCW for making him wear "this silly s***", and even took a verbal dump on the Goldust concept too. Man, way to stick a knife into the ribs of your own career then twist it, eh?
Any chance for Rhodes to make a fresh start and dazzle WCW fans the same way he had federation ones years before was ruined. He looked like a clown standing mid-ring taking pot shots at make up he'd willingly put on. Also, why on earth did he float to the ring on wires if he thought the whole thing was rotten?
None of this made any sense, and it destroyed any remaining credibility Dustin had at the time.
8. Becoming Tag Champ With Someone’s Mum
If you could pick any tag-team partner in the world, who would it be? Roman Reigns wouldn't be a bad shout, and neither would one-man wrecking crew Bron Breakker. Or, if you'd like some help on the women's division side, you could choose Becky Lynch, Stephanie Vaquer or Charlotte Flair. The choices are endless.
One thing you wouldn't do is ring up Becky's mother and ask her to have your back.
Rick Steiner pretty much did something just like that back in late-1998 when his partner Buff Bagwell turned on him. Initially, Rick picked Kenny Kaos as his new buddy, but then pivoted towards Judy f'n Bagwell in a bid to get under Buff's skin. What a ploy, huh? Even Steiner himself had to be questioning the logic of this behind the scenes. Either that or the guaranteed money made him indifferent.
To cap it all off, the stunning Steiner and Judy tag title reign ended with a vacation once Rick was struck down with an injury. Happy days. This was so WCW it hurt, although maybe it didn't hurt as much as Steiner's injury did. Who knows? Technically, Judy Bagwell would go down in history as a former WCW Tag-Team Champ despite never winning the belts herself.
Perhaps that was for the best. Wrestling has booked some atrocious tag bouts, and the last thing anybody needed was Judy trying to hit a Buff Blockbuster on some hapless fool between the ropes. Maybe she could've jumped off the forklift WCW put her on for a future pay-per-view.
Check Rick's seriously unconvincing smile above. He knew this was garbage.
7. Being Injured For Absolutely Nothing
Bash At The Beach 1999’s ‘Junkyard Invitational’ saw a whole gang of misfit wrestlers scrap hardcore match style in a literal junkyard. At least the promotion couldn't be done for false advertising, unlike WWE when they promote 'Street Fights' that never take to the streets. Lawyers shall be in touch, guys! Seriously though, WCW were coming through on their promise if nothing else.
Promises are one thing, production quality and safety is another. Obviously, it’s never good when workers get injured, but at least they normally get hurt because they were trying to do something flashy for the cameras. On this stinky mess of a pay-per-view, numerous wrestlers got physically battered and the cams didn’t even capture any of it.
The match took place at night, and the lighting was poor, so WCW’s producers failed to even catch much of the violence. Thus, several midcarders got all banged up and didn't even have anything to show for it. Picture Fit Finlay's face when he watched the brawl back and found out that his war wounds didn't even make the cut. The same could be said for Steven/William Regal.
This was a total mess from start to finish. It didn't seem like the roster had been given any instructions or proper layout at all. Instead, they were just fighting and making things up as they went along, and the camera crew just had to wing it by filming whatever they found interesting.
Again, nobody's celebrating workers going down to injury in front of millions watching, but there's a special place in hell reserved for promoters who put everyone in danger then say: 'Oops! Didn't catch that, dudes!'.
6. Getting Tricked By The WWF’s Fakes
It's so painfully clear that the promotion was full of it now, but fans in 1996 did have their interest piqued when Jim Ross told viewers on Raw that "Razor Ramon and Diesel" were on their way back to the WWF. What's more, he'd personally make sure of it. Over in WCW, Eric Bischoff and probably other members of management got so wound up by all of this that they handed Kevin Nash and Scott Hall improved contracts.
Yes, mere months after signing them to fat deals that meant they were exclusive to WCW. Work this one out! Nash and Hall were the real winners here, but Bischoff and others must’ve wanted the ground to swallow them up when they clapped eyes on Glenn Jacobs and Rick Bognar doing their best Diesel and Razor respectively on the rival channel.
Vince McMahon’s crap idea to flex his creativity and show the world that anybody could play his characters actually cost WCW money in the end. Stop to really think about that for a second: WCW got so worried about the thought of The Outsiders and their brand new nWo focal points fleeing back to McMahon that they renewed terms just incase.
Nash has described the stunned looks on countless faces behind the curtain when the future Kane and ex-ECW man 'Big Titan' strolled out as "Diesel" and "Razor" on Raw. Eek. How embarrassing for Eric and his cohorts. They'd been spooked by JR's heel promos, and they wanted to do everything in their power to make sure that Kev and Scott couldn't go anywhere.
Here's the thing: They already had by signing them over the summer.
5. Being In “The First Ever Viagra Match”
What a claim to fame this is.
Chris Jericho, Booker T, Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Rob Van Dam and Kane can all say they were in the first ever Elimination Chamber match (at Survivor Series 2002), and both HBK and The Undertaker can proudly boast about being in the original Hell In A Cell (1997's In Your House: Bad Blood), but can they say they were in the first 'Viagra On A Pole' bout? Can they heck.
That occurred on the 31 July 2000 Nitro. Both Shane Douglas and Billy Kidman hit the ring in this erm...stimulant-based showdown mid-storyline with Torrie Wilson. Apparently, according to WCW, both Shane and Billy needed the penis-popping pills so they could woo Torrie. Imagine the embarrassment of being involved in this nonsense. They were publicly humiliated.
OK, so nobody takes pro wrestling all that seriously when it delves into soap opera or so-called comedy like this, but still - Douglas and Kidman were fighting for the right to give their trouser department a much-needed push, and somebody genuinely thought this would get them over in the eyes of fans. They also presumably figured this would help win a quarter hour against Raw on the other channel.
For the record, no. No, this wasn't one of the greatest matches ever.
As if you were in any doubt, WCW even created a generic label for the bottle of pills hanging above the ring. It, rather handily, said: 'VIAGRA" in aggressive all caps. The pills were massive as well, so either the 'Franchise' or Billy could've pitched an 18 man tent after winning the day.
The real losers were the fans and both wrestlers for having to stomach such embarrassing booking. Taking a finisher on dog poo would've been better than this.
4. Getting Humped By The Yeti
Spoiler alert: WCW misunderstood what a yeti was supposed to be. Either that or they just didn't think 'The Mummy' sounded as cool.
The Yeti debuted on the 23 October 1995 episode of Nitro. He was revealed as the silly Dungeon Of Doom’s secret weapon in the fight against Hulkamania. Then, he/it would strike. Yeti attacked Hulk Hogan during his match vs. The Giant at Halloween Havoc. Again, the question must be asked: Had WCW bosses ever seen a yeti depicted anywhere?
Their “Yeti” was more like a big mummy. He was covered head to toe in bandages. The gimmick was played by future Raven’s Flock member Reese, and it was horrible. Just horrible. At one point, it looked like Giant and Yeti were double humping Hogan from both sides during a World Title match. Some decorum wouldn't go amiss, gentlemen. Please restrain yourselves, at least until fans watching this back get some sick bags ready.
Of course, Yeti and Giant were supposed to be giving Hulk a "double bearhug", but that certainly wasn't what it looked like. Score one for those who had 'dry humping' on their 1995 WCW pay-per-view bingo cards. You could tick that one off next to the equally as nonsensical, '60-man, 3 ring Battle Royal' come World War 3.
This was far from Hulk's finest hour, and it was the true nadir of his earliest days in WCW. Stick his whole feud with the Dungeon under that category, to be fair. His shocking heel turn and the nWo ascent couldn't come soon enough for Hogan and company. He went from being humped by a so-called "Yeti" to exuding Hollywood cool.
3. Having Personal Demons As Your Gimmick
Sadly, Scott Hall passed away in March 2022. He'd battled personal problems for decades, but had managed to kick out when all looked bleak thanks to the help of Diamond Dallas Page. Hall also cleaned up his act enough to look dapper as he was inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame in 2014. His fans would be grateful for that memory.
His 'Last Call' run in WCW was a disgrace though.
The group handed Scott that gimmick in 1998. His story hit too close to the bone to be entertaining. WCW's story was that Hall’s real-life alcohol issues were affecting his in-ring work. The thing is, that was true, but WCW didn’t need to drag his personal life out in front of the cameras. On TV, Hall acted visibly drunk (or might’ve actually been under the influence) at Fall Brawl vs. Konnan and in other featured matches.
It was in poor taste, especially considering the fact that Scott wasn’t in the best place away from the ring. In effect, he was brought into work, asked to sit down, then told: ‘Hey, we know you’re going through some stuff, but we’re going to put that on television and exploit it. The fans will love it!'. Nah, they didn't love it. This didn't need to happen.
Hall must've slapped a green light on this idea somewhere along the way, but he probs wasn't of sound mind at the time. In retrospect, it would've been best had WCW kayfabe killed off his character and moved on completely. The man needed professional help, not a few beers during his matches so he could throw up all over the place.
2. The Shockmaster’s Mortifying Trip
You knew this would be in here somewhere. One does not simply discuss WCW fates worse than (onscreen) death without bringing up The Sh...Sh...Sh...Shockmaster. Fred Ottman debuted under that guise at Clash Of The Champions XXIV on 18 August 1993. It’s a day he'll never forget. Not only was he wearing a glittery Stormtroopers helmet (no, really), but Shockmaster also fell through the set and made history.
On set, Davey Boy Smith could be heard saying he fell “flat on his fookin’ arse”. The modified Star Wars prop Ottman was wearing fell off, and the character was cooked. It was all rather mortifying. Apparently, following rehearsals earlier in the day, a member of the production team had nailed a piece of wood to the bottom of the frame Shocker was going to burst through.
So, poor Uncle Fred tripped over that and meme’d himself before memes were even a thing. It's impossible not to feel sorry for him all these years on. Part of him must've died inside as he landed on his hands and knees then scrambled around looking for his Stormtrooper headpiece. Can you imagine being Ottman in that precise moment?! He had to know his WCW career had just gone down the toilet.
Everything about this sucked. His outfit was lame, the Star Wars helmet was too obvious (no amount of glitter or paint was covering that up), Ole Anderson's voiceover was cheesy, then disaster struck when Fred fell down. Hey, at least people are still talking about this over 30 years on.
Not in a positive way, but they're still talking.
1. Being Fired By The Guy Who Just Bought Your Company
Vince McMahon looked like the cat that got the cream during the Raw/Nitro simulcast on 26 March 2001. He'd purchased the remnants of WCW shortly beforehand, and now he could bask in the moment on live television. The 'Monday Night Wars' were over. The WWF had won, and Vince was in the mood to brag about it. "I now own my own competition", he boasted with a sly grin.
The then-WWF leader didn't stop there. Cameras panned to show a TV with Nitro on in the background, and Jeff Jarrett was on the screen. Addressing that, McMahon unceremoniously fired 'Double J' live on air before he'd even decided anything else he was going to do with the intellectual properties he now governed. Vince said that Jarrett was "gone", and that was that.
Harsh, but this was perceived payback for Jarrett reportedly holding the WWF ransom for more money back at No Mercy 1999. Jeff has refuted these claims, but the story goes that he demanded more cash to put over Chyna in a 'Good Housekeeping' bout on the pay-per-view. If true, then McMahon never let bygones be bygones once he purchased WCW.
WCW's roster was likely sweating over their futures during the simulcast, but Jeff didn’t have to wait long. He found out during it that his services would no longer be needed. He definitely wasn't going to play a part in the upcoming invasion on WWF screens. That had to suck for Jarrett.
He couldn't even chuckle at Vince screwing up his spelling by saying Jeff was "G.O.O.N.N.E.E". He was going to play a revived Goon gimmick? Now that's a fate worse than death!
What other WCW fates belong here? For more like this, check out 10 WWE Fates Worse Than Death and 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2005!