10 Weirdest Fake Deaths In Wrestling
Death scenes create major dramatic moments. Except in wrestling, when they just make things weird.
Wrestling is a peculiar form of storytelling, because at its best, it sits on the razor-thin edge of reality and fantasy. The end goal? Creating compelling, entertaining viewing, peppered with shocks and memorable moments, by combining simulated combat, carefully crafted storylines, and dynamic personalities.
Naturally, over the years, the stakes need to be raised. Two competitors battle over the promotion's top prize, things get personal, and then you've got a vendetta. Sometimes loved ones or family are involved to up the ante. Aggression and tension grow with every passing exchange, every slight, every betrayal, every time one character crosses another line. To paraphrase Jim Cornette, a shooting follows a stabbing.
And sometimes, when a rivalry is meant to reach a fever pitch, the spectre of death itself looms over a storyline. And although it's intended to heighten the drama even moreso, most of the time, it just makes for a very weird evening of professional wrestling.
Programs involving deaths, whether actual deaths or ones faked for dramatic purposes, rarely turn out well. One need only look back at the Eddiesploitation of 2006 to remember that.
But today, we're focusing on the weirdest fake deaths in wrestling, where kayfabe killings and simulated slayings tried to bring the heat, but only left us cold.
(Sorry, Chikara and Lucha Underground fans, but since deaths are canon in their narrative universes, and to be expected at this point, neither makes the cut this time around.)
10. Vince McMahon
Let's start with the fake death that inspired this list. It's been ten years since Mr. McMahon's limo exploded in one of the most spectacular closing segments in Monday Night Raw history.
Although the storyline had to be quickly shut down after the Benoit tragedy - and led to the illegitimate son storyline where Hornswoggle was revealed as Vince's bastard son - you can't deny how eerie and effective this sequence was.
You had Vince's long, slow walk through the arena, surrounded on all sides by superstars and divas looking on, stone-faced, as the befuddled Mr. McMahon plodded through the halls. You had his nervous glances backward at the two men sitting outside the arena. And finally, that long pause when he reached for the door handle of the limo, before stepping inside.
In the aftermath, WWE stock prices took a hit because apparently some investors were unsure if Vince had really died or not.
The entire sequence was weird, but very well done. And left many of us smiling like Paul London as the show faded to black.
9. Al Wilson
I really, really tried to find a reason to exclude this one from the list, because ick, but here we go...
In the midst of a four-month rivalry between Torrie Wilson and Dawn Marie, Torrie's father Al was seduced by Dawn Marie and began an onscreen relationship with her. His daughter Torrie was understandably upset by this.
Dawn Marie promised Torrie that she would break things off with Al if Torrie spent the night with her in a hotel room. This later turned out to be a ruse, as Dawn Marie married Al in a ceremony on Smackdown while both of them were in their underwear.
The next week, Al Wilson "died" from a heart attack after too much sex with Dawn Marie. Because nobody does a dignified sendoff for dads like WWE. And, naturally, this beef was settled with a match at the Royal Rumble, which Torrie won.
Now just try to get the image of Al Wilson out of your head.
8. Pepper And Boots The Cat
We've got a pet-centric double-header here, as beloved furry companions became storyline fodder for detestable heels.
In the more famous of the two angles, The Big Boss Man kidnapped Al Snow's dog Pepper, only to feed Pepper to Al in his hotel room in a move Eric Cartman would quite appreciate. This led to the cr*ptacular Kennel from Hell Match where Al Snow defeated The Boss Man while eluding the friendly, not-at-all-vicious puppies around the ring. And apparently that was considered suitable justice for poor innocent Pepper.
As for Boots the Cat, this Smoky Mountain Wrestling feline was Boo Bradley's only friend, but became a pawn in the game between the diabolical Chris Candido, the manipulative Tammy Sytch, and the kindhearted Boo (aka the future Balls Mahoney). Boots was held hostage by Chris and Tammy, but after Boo refused to do Candido's bidding, Candido took Boots into the ring (in a burlap sack), and splashed the cat from the top rope. As Boo cradled the bag containing his only friend, fans looked on in horror.
There have got to be other ways to get babyfaces sympathy.
7. The Big Boss Man Gets Hanged
The Big Boss Man collided with The Undertaker in a Hell in a Cell match at Wrestlemania XV as part of the rivalry between The Corporation and The Ministry.
Taker's streak extended to 8-0 when he dispatched Vince McMahon's hired gun in a match that included chair shots and a handcuffed beating with a nightstick. It wasn't Mick Foley HIAC brutal, but it was still a heck of a fight. But it's what came next that everyone remembers, as the Brood descended from the ceiling onto the cage, and lowered a noose down to The Undertaker.
Yes, live on pay-per-view, The Undertaker hung a man to death.
It remains one of the most unsettling endings to a match in WWE history. The image of The Boss Man's lifeless body hanging from the Cell gives me chills to this day.
6. Ric Flair Buried Alive
It's one thing for The Undertaker to be buried alive. He's the Phenom, an unstoppable force of nature. It's quite another for a similar fate to befall The Nature Boy Ric Flair.
During his fued with the tweener stable The Filthy Animals, Flair was kidnapped, taken out into the desert heat, and buried alive outside Las Vegas. This was how they got Flair off TV for a bit. By treating him like Joe Pesci at the end of Casino.
And the weirdest part? The next time WCW came to Vegas - weeks later - Flair turned up no worse for wear. No starvation, no nightmares, heck, not even much of a tan to show for what was presumably a full-on Kill Bill escape from the coffin, complete with Flair chopping the coffin lid to splinters and then strutting his way to freedom.
And you thought The Dungeon of Doom was stupid.
5. The Death Of The Fake Stan Lane
In 2011, an obituary for Stan Lane appeared in a major Memphis newspaper. One-half of the Fabulous Ones, one-half of The Midnight Express, and one-half of The Heavenly Bodies, gone from this earth forever.
This came as a shock to many, including Stan Lane, who was very much alive.
As it turns out, a man named Samuel Ticer told the woman he married in 1983 that he used to wrestle as Stan Lane, and had retired from wrestling. Since Stan Lane was still wrestling at the time on local television, this would be the equivalent of someone today saying he was Andrew Lincoln of Walking Dead fame, and it only working if you never watched AMC.
So when he died, his wife sent in an obituary mentioning his career as Stan Lane, revealing an incredibly stupid and easily-disproven twenty-year ruse. The final twist? Apparently, some of her family knew it was a lie, and set up a table of Stan Lane merchandise at the funeral to make some quick cash.
Because wrestling.
4. The Giant Falls Off Cobo Hall
Hulk Hogan's crimes in wrestling are legendary. From his theft of the Wrestlemania IX spotlight from Yokozuna and Bret Hart to his role in The Fingerpoke of Doom, which was one of many dominoes in the fall of WCW, Hogan has been the villain in a lot of stories. And then there was that time he accidentally murdered the son of Andre the Giant.
After a monster truck battle atop Cobo Hall for Halloween Havoc 1995, Hogan and The Giant tussled for a bit. When Hogan broke free of The Giant's grip, it sent The Giant over the edge of the building and plummeting to his doom, either into the Detroit River or the parking lot below. Hogan and the announcers sold this like a real accident (while the crowd cheered in the background).
And then, 15 minutes later, The Giant shows up for his match, none the worse for wear. *Shrugs*. Not dead after all.
To be fair, WWE tried their hand at this gimmick once, but on a smaller scale, when The Rock tossed Austin off of a bridge. But they made us wait more than 15 minutes to find out Austin was okay.
3. Ricky Banderas Gets Tossed Into A Volcano
Ricky Banderas has wrestled under several gimmicks in Mexico, including El Mesias, though you may know him better as Judas Mesias from TNA or Mil Muertes from Lucha Underground. What you probably don't know about him is that, in storyline, he was once thrown into a volcano and killed.
AAA booked a casket match between Banderas and the luchador Cibernético over control of La Secta Cibernético. When Banderas recruited several members of Cibernético's sect to join him in La Secta Diabólica, the rivalry culminated in a casket match.
But once Cibernético beat Banderas badly enough to get him into the casket, he and his allies tossed it into a volcano, killing Banderas off in the most epic stretcher job of all-time.
I say that because, of course, he returned from the dead a few months later.
2. Paul Bearer, Buried In Cement
The devious Paul Heyman tried to control The Undertaker by striking his one weakness (you know, other than the urn): his friendship with manager Paul Bearer.
Employing The Dudley Boyz to kidnap Bearer, Heyman blackmailed 'Taker into servitude. But The Deadman proved difficult to control. At the 2004 edition of The Great American Bash, he put Taker in a handicap match against The Dudleys, with the stipulation that if he didn't lay down for The Dudleys, Paul Bearer would be buried alive in cement. The Undertaker waged war with Bubba Ray and D-Von that night, summoning lightning to frighten off Heyman and rescuing his long-time friend.
And then he murdered Bearer himself.
Because swerve.
Yup, after a heartfelt goodbye, he told Paul was a liability, and then he killed him.
But, when you think about it, it makes sense. Considering how many times Taker had "died" by being buried alive, trapped in burning caskets, and later getting his powers stolen or being beaten into a vegetative state, it was really Paul's turn to take one for the team.
1. The Big Show's Dad Goes For A Ride
Yes, both The Boss Man and The Big Show return one more time for the grandaddy (or just plain daddy) of them all.
During their feud for the WWF Championship, The Boss Man crashed the funeral of Big Show's father, chaining the casket to his car and driving off with it. Big Show valiantly tried to stop this by riding his father's coffin behind Boss Man's car for a bit, before hilariously tumbling off of it to the ground. Although The Big Boss Man would also involve Big Show's mother in the feud, getting her to call her son a bastard on national television, that wasn't nearly as bizarre or as entertaining as the funeral sequence. To this day, it seems absolutely mad that they would stage this.
Wrestling is really fun sometimes.
In reality, Show's father had passed away years ago, making this a fake death for the ages.