10 Worst Booked WWE Champions Of All Time
A top ten list detailing the top ten worst booked World Champions in WWE history.
Being a world champion in WWE means you are the top guy in the company, or at least that's how it should be. Traditionally, the WWE or World Champion was the guy the company was built around, and they would feature at the top of the card for the duration of their reign.
Despite this, over the years, WWE has had some frankly terrible World Title reigns that fans wish to forget. These reigns rarely come at the fault of the talent in question and the reason for their tenures being poorly received ranges from the champion in question being booked like an absolute joke meaning the audience is unable to take the wrestler seriously, to the champion being booked as a complete afterthought. It is also extremely easy for a decent World Title reign to turn into a poor one.
WWE is notorious for giving up on a talent, meaning that they try to book the champion into the ground, rather than make them a marketable attraction during their reign. With that being said, here are the 10 worst booked WWE World Champions of all time.
10. Jack Swagger
Jack Swagger winning the Money in the Bank at WrestleMania XXVI was an interesting booking move on behalf of WWE. Swagger had all the ability in the world but he struggled with his character and promo work. The MITB victory gave WWE an opportunity for him to grow over the next few months and then finally put the World Title on him once he was ready.
Sadly, WWE didn’t want to wait. They put the World Title on Swagger on the SmackDown following WrestleMania, where he would cash-in on a beaten down Chris Jericho. The reign for Swagger actually started off well. Clean wins over Chris Jericho and Edge in a triple threat match and then against Randy Orton at Extreme Rules were all encouraging signs.
It wasn’t until he entered into a feud with The Big Show that the wheels fell off. It was as if Vince McMahon had suddenly given up on Swagger as he started losing TV matches, and his PPV match with Big Show ended in a DQ. The month after, Swagger would lose the World Title in a Fatal 4 Way match to Rey Mysterio. It was a shame that the reign started off so well but WWE decided that they weren’t interested in booking Swagger as a top guy any more so they simply booked him into the ground.
9. The Big Show
The Big Show’s first WWE Title run came about from a matter of circumstance. Stone Cold Steve Austin needed immediate neck surgery in late 1999, which resulted in The Big Show taking his place in a triple threat match at the Survivor Series 1999 which also included The Rock and Triple H. Big Show would win the match as Vince McMahon wanted to try something “new and different” and Big Show winning the WWE title was certainly both of those things.
The problem with Big Show winning the WWE title was that he was in the middle of a feud with The Big Boss Man, which involved the infamous segment of Boss Man invading the funeral of Big Show’s dad and stealing the casket in the process. This meant that WWE were forced to finish the feud, meaning that a mid-card affair between Boss Man and Big Show was now suddenly a feud over the WWE Title.
Big Show faced the Boss Man at the Armageddon PPV in 1999, which would be his only PPV match as WWE Champion during this first run, a three minute squash that had no place on a PPV. On the 3 January 2000 edition of RAW, Big Show lost the WWE Title to Triple H, closing off his first World Title run at a lacklustre 50 days.
8. Sheamus
The highlight of Sheamus’ first WWE Title run was unfortunately the victory itself. Sheamus won the WWE Title at TLC 2009 in a Tables Match against John Cena. The match result came as a surprise as Sheamus was extremely new to RAW and he was yet to build up a compelling character or connection with the audience.
Sheamus’ first run with the WWE Title was strange. His first feud was with another heel in Randy Orton which didn’t make a lot of sense and their PPV match at the Royal Rumble fell completely flat and ended in a DQ. The following PPV was the Elimination Chamber - where Sheamus would lose the WWE title after being eliminated in the Chamber itself by Triple H.
Sheamus would only win four-matches by pinfall during his WWE Title reign and each of them was a non-title encounter. Sheamus would go on to have better World Title reigns including a memorable babyface run with the World Title in 2012.
7. Goldberg
It’s a common sentiment that WWE’s booking of Goldberg in 2003 was one of their biggest ever creative mishaps. All WWE needed to do was follow the WCW formula. Instead, they vastly over complicated Goldberg’s presentation and by the time he left WWE at WrestleMania XX, fans were happy to see him go.
Goldberg’s World title run was certainly no exception to the aforementioned creative failures. By the time WWE finally put the belt on Goldberg at the Unforgiven PPV, some fans believed it was too late, and should have come one month prior at SummerSlam inside the Elimination Chamber instead.
The run itself lasted 84 days and Goldberg only managed to feud with Triple H and Kane during that time period. The problem with the booking was that it revolved around Triple H putting a bounty on Goldberg’s head which in turn made Goldberg vulnerable and ultimately the underdog, which was the complete opposite of the way Goldberg should be booked.
6. Chris Benoit
The closing moments of WrestleMania XX with Chris Benoit celebrating winning the World Title as he embraced WWE Champion Eddie Guerrero was one of the most emotional moments in WWE history. With that being said, how Benoit was booked following the win would be met with mixed reviews by fans at the time and looking back 16-years later, it does raise the question of whether or not Vince McMahon ever truly saw Benoit as a top guy.
Benoit had a lengthy run as champion. His title run came in at 154 days, which for the Ruthless Aggression Era was some achievement. The problem was that during his reign, he was always playing second fiddle to another story. For instance, his first singles feud was with Kane and the PPV match between the two wasn’t the main event; instead Triple H and Shawn Michaels’ 45 minute Hell in a Cell match was put in the position instead.
Then following the Kane feud, Benoit would feud with Triple H. However, Benoit nor the World Title was the focal point of the feud. Instead the focus point would be surrounding whether Eugene was going to realise that Triple H wasn’t actually his friend. Benoit was the third most important man in the story, despite being World Champion. Just a month later, Benoit’s incredibly underwhelming World Title run would come to an end as Randy Orton became the youngest World Champion in company history at just 24-years of age.
5. Randy Orton
As was previously mentioned, Randy Orton became the youngest World Champion in company history at SummerSlam 2004, but his World Title run would be short lived and he would lose it to Triple H just a month later at the Unforgiven PPV.
The problem with Orton’s brief run was that he was booked as a babyface despite the audience never being given a reason why Orton was someone they should root for. In the eyes of the fans, he was still this awful human being that did awful things and the only reason they should be cheering for him was that Triple H no longer wanted him in the Evolution stable.
There was a clear disconnect in the booking of Orton as a World Champion and WWE failed to present fans with a reason to gravitate towards the young babyface. WWE Hall of Famer Jim Ross would comment on the booking of Orton as World Champion in 2004 during his Grilling JR podcast. JR stated:
"I’m not sure that Vince at that point in time had confidence that Randy was gonna be a great long-term champion. He wasn’t sold on the idea. He wasn’t sold on — I don’t know if he trusted Randy, or still had some doubts because of his dishonorable discharge, which was an issue getting him hired. But you know, we prevailed and it worked out pretty well for Randy, and the WWE, and the fans."
4. CM Punk
Don’t be alarmed: CM Punk did indeed have one of the most legendary WWE Title reigns between 2011-2013. However, his first reign was booked unbelievably poorly. If you recall, Punk won the World Title after cashing in on Edge during an episode of RAW in the summer of 2008 and would go on to have a 69-day reign with the Big Gold Belt.
The problem with the booking of Punk’s first reign was that he wasn’t a strong enough babyface to carry the title to begin with. This was at a time when Batista and John Cena were still very much full time stars, meaning that Punk’s storylines as World Champion were never the focal point of a show or a PPV. Punk would have two PPV matches as World Champion. One would be at The Great American Bash PPV which resulted in a double DQ in a match against Batista and the second would be a ten-minute win over JBL at SummerSlam. Neither of these matches were main events or positioned as top matches on either PPV.
Punk was supposed to have a third PPV match, defending the title in a Championship Scramble at Unforgiven. Sadly, WWE opted to take him out of the match by way of Randy Orton punting him in the head, and Chris Jericho took his place and won the World Title. Punk’s underwhelming first reign ended without him even wrestling in the match.
3. Jeff Hardy
Jeff Hardy’s WWE Title win at Armageddon 2008 is one of the most celebrated moments in WWE history. At this point in 2008, Hardy had become the #1 babyface in the company and was even outselling John Cena when it came to merchandise. Fans expected Hardy to get a lengthy WWE title run and for him to defend the title at WrestleMania 25 just a few months later. But what they got was a poorly booked reign that served no purpose.
Hardy's entire month as WWE Champion incorporated a storyline where he was involved in a range of accidents, including a hit-and-run automobile accident and an another involving his ring entrance pyro. Hardy’s first defence would be at the Royal Rumble, where he lost the title to Edge following his brother Matt Hardy turning on him. Hardy didn’t manage to defend his first WWE title successfully even once, absolutely terrible treatment towards the hottest babyface in the company at the time.
2. Jinder Mahal
When Jinder Mahal became a WWE main eventer overnight in 2017, fans didn’t know what to make of it. On one hand, WWE were bringing a new star to the main event scene. On the other hand, it was Jinder Mahal… Mahal was a well established jobber and was never positioned as anything remotely credible on WWE programming before.
Naturally, when WWE went all the way and put the title on Mahal at Backlash, it took people by surprise. Mahal would go on to have a 170 day reign as champion and the reign was met with a lot of disdain from fans who loathed the SmackDown product during this time period. The issue with the booking of Mahal was that the audience was supposed to view someone who was a jobber three weeks prior and take him seriously as a legitimate champion. It was hard for fans to process, and was made even worse by Mahal cutting outdated, stereotypical anti-American promos that did little to build up a meaningful, interesting character.
Mahal was booked strongly on PPV events, with wins against Orton and Shinsuke Nakamura, but the booking didn’t want to make fans see Mahal lose, it just made them not want to see Mahal in the main event scene at all. Therefore when AJ Styles beat Mahal for the title in November, fans rejoiced and hoped Mahal would never return to the main event scene ever again. And he hasn't.
1. Rey Mysterio
Rey Mysterio’s World Title win at WrestleMania 22 was a great babyface moment for one of the most popular superstars of all time. However, it was clear rather quickly that WWE and Vince McMahon had no desire to push Rey as a top guy despite putting the title on him at the biggest show of the year.
Rey would be labelled on commentary as an “underdog champion”, which was clearly the belief of McMahon who decided that Rey’s first feud as champion should be with JBL. To build towards the PPV showdown at Judgment Day 2006 between Rey and JBL, JBL would put Rey against mystery opponents each and every week. These names included Mark Henry and The Great Khali who both pinned Rey with ease in featured matches on SmackDown. It was really hard to see just what booking Rey in this manner was achieving, as it just made him look like a weak champion.
Rey would win the PPV match against JBL by cheating, which did no favours in making him legitimate or credible. Following a loss to Rob Van Dam at ECW: Head to Head, WWE clearly decided it was finally time to take the World Title from Rey.
The title loss would come at The Great American Bash, as Rey lost to King Booker after Chavo Guerrero turned on him. Rey managed to have a 112 day reign as World Champion and he wasn’t once presented as credible, which raises the question: why did they bother putting the belt on him in the first place?