10 Worst PPVs Of WWE PG Era
Counting down the top 10 worst PPVs of the PG Era in WWE.
When WWE transitioned into PG in the summer of 2008, fans didn’t know how the quality of the product would be impacted. They had concerns that without the TV-14 rating, WWE would be restricted in their storytelling, thus meaning feuds and PPV events would suffer as a result.
Over the past 12-years, WWE has delivered some of the best PPV events of all time. Money in the Bank 2011, Royal Rumble 2018 and WrestleMania 31 are all beloved to this day. However, there have also been some horrendously executed events. These range from WWE being forced to re-book the card due to notable injuries or clearly not putting in any effort.
For the purposes of this list, a 'bad' PPV is one comprised of overwhelming negative reaction, for both the quality of the matches themselves, and the direction of the booking. As you'd expect, most of the examples cited fall foul of both of these - some with the added bonus of immoral international dealings.
So with that being said, here are the 10 worst PPVs of WWE's PG era.
10. Survivor Series 2013
Survivor Series 2013 is without question the worst Survivor Series event in the established history of the big-four event. The 2013 version took place at a weird time for the company. WWE fans had a strong desire to see Daniel Bryan as the top guy in the company. Sadly, WWE had other plans, and instead they placed The Big Show in the top babyface position in the company. This translated to one of the worst PPV main events ever with Randy Orton successfully defending the WWE Title against Big Show. The live audience in Boston made their voices heard with audible chants of Daniel Bryan being heard throughout the lacklustre match.
Elsewhere on the card, John Cena won the World Title from Alberto Del Rio in the best match of the show. Team Total Divas won a traditional Survivor Series match against Team Divas which was a total mess where almost every major spot in the match was botched. Future WWE top guy Roman Reigns would be the sole survivor in a traditional Survivor Series opener, in a sign of things to come. Former WWE Champion, CM Punk, and the aforementioned Bryan would team up against The Wyatt Family in an unmemorable match in the semi-main event that felt more like a RAW main event.
The close of the PPV featured John Cena coming to the ring to confront Randy Orton, to set up a Champion vs. Champion match at the next PPV. Sadly, it was met with negative reception from most fans who thought the Cena vs. Orton feud was on its last legs in 2009, never mind 2013.
9. WrestleMania 32
WWE had a lot of problems on the road to WrestleMania 32. Notable injuries to top stars such as John Cena, Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt resulted in the company needing to change plans and create a card with the talent they had available.
The PPV itself is memorable for a lot of reasons and sadly the majority of them are negative. Roman Reigns defeated Triple H in an underwhelming WrestleMania main event, during which fans were more interested in chanting for Bayley and Sami Zayn. Brock Lesnar and Dean Ambrose competed in a No Holds Barred Street Fight which under-delivered due to Lesnar not wanting to do any of Ambrose's ideas in the match, resulting in an incredibly lacklustre affair.
Elsewhere on the card, Zack Ryder won the Intercontinental Title in a great opening Ladder Match but his reign would only last 24 hours. AJ Styles lost his WrestleMania debut to Chris Jericho in a booking decision that made little to no sense.
The Undertaker and Shane McMahon competed in a 30-minute Hell in a Cell match, which though it had some great spots, served no purpose as the storyline was rendered pointless the next night on RAW. The Rock appeared for an 8-second match when he pinned Rowan, however, this was after he and John Cena had both laid out the entire Wyatt Family.
WrestleMania 32 did have one highlight. The match for the Women's Title between Charlotte, Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks was the best match on the card and arguably the best women's match in WrestleMania history.
8. Crown Jewel 2018
The relationship between WWE and Saudi Arabia is one of the more distasteful subplots of the modern wrestling industry. This issue was further developed during the lead up the Crown Jewel PPV in 2018. Due to the controversy surrounding the killing of Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi, WWE faced criticism for continuing the PPV and was asked to stop its business ventures in the country by numerous parties.
WWE instead opted to continue the event but opted not to mention the fact that it was taking place in Saudi, in a frankly bizarre move. The controversy also led to two of WWE's top stars, John Cena and Daniel Bryan, boycotting the show completely and deciding to distance themselves from the event.
The PPV featured the in-ring return of Shawn Michaels after nearly a decade of retirement, teaming in an horrendous tag match with Triple H vs. The Undertaker & Kane. The match was a complete mess, where seemingly everything that could go wrong in the match eventually did.
Additional matches included Shane McMahon winning a tournament to become "the Best in the World", which naturally fans didn't appreciate. Other matches included Braun Strowman being squashed by Brock Lesnar and AJ Styles defeating Samoa Joe.
7. TLC 2019
The majority of fans hold the belief that gimmick PPVs shouldn't exist. The gimmick matches in question such as Hell in a Cell and TLC should be kept special and be incorporated into storylines when and only when they are needed.
TLC 2019 was a testament to this as the PPV was an absolute mess from top to bottom. The main event featured The Kabuki Warriors defending the Women's Tag Titles in a TLC match against Charlotte and Becky Lynch. Sadly, Kairi Sane was concussed early on, meaning the main event match fell apart and the talent involved just started calling the match on the fly, meaning it looked incredibly messy.
Elsewhere, Roman Reigns and King Corbin had a TLC match which received criticism as the TLC match type wasn't used to end the feud. Instead, it was used as a plot device to keep the underwhelming affair going. Additional matches included Universal Champion Bray Wyatt facing The Miz in a non-title encounter, in a match that was met with utter silence from the live crowd.
Bright spots on the show included a fantastic match between Aleister Black and Buddy Murphy and a great ladder match between The New Day and The Revival for the SmackDown Tag Team Titles.
6. Over The Limit 2012
Over The Limit 2012 was a PPV that was met with extremely poor reviews from fans. Not just from a match quality perspective, but also because the match card was so lazily booked out that it made fans look stupid for paying for the PPV.
This PPV was notable for featuring the first-ever match between Daniel Bryan and CM Punk on WWE PPV. This was a dream match and instead of main eventing the PPV, that slot was given to John Cena vs. non-wrestler John Laurinaitis. What's worse, Laurinaitis won the comedy match thanks to interference by The Big Show, meaning fans were then forced to sit through Big Show vs. Cena as the top feud on RAW for the millionth time.
Elsewhere, the show featured two complete squash matches that belonged on TV rather than PPV, as Ryback pinned Camacho in 50 seconds and Brodus Clay pinned The Miz in five minutes. In terms of the World Title scene, Sheamus retained his belt in a fun fatal four-way which also consisted of Randy Orton, Alberto Del Rio and Chris Jericho. Sadly, it wasn't enough to save the show.
5. Battleground 2013
The first-ever Battleground PPV in 2013 didn't exactly get the Battleground PPV lineage off to the greatest of starts. In fact, the event was so bad that it was voted as the worst PPV of the year by the readers of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter.
The main event featured Randy Orton and Daniel Bryan facing off for the WWE Title. Sadly, WWE decided to book The Big Show to interfere in the match forcing a no contest, which left an extremely negative impression on the legacy of the 2013 instalment of the PPV.
Elsewhere on the card, we had CM Punk wrestling Ryback in one of Punk's worst matches ever, whilst Curtis Axel and R-Truth competed for the Intercontinental Title, in a match that belonged on WWE Main Event rather than a PPV. The opener featured Alberto Del Rio facing off against Rob Van Dam for the World Title in a Hardcore Match; the fact that it was the PPV opener, gives you an indication of the prestige of the World Title at the time.
The PPV did have a bright spot with The Shield facing off against Goldust and Cody Rhodes. The match was acclaimed by fans and critics alike, and was a top contender for 2013's Match of the Year.
4. Fastlane 2017
The idea that WWE needs two PPV events between the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania is certainly a questionable one. Over the years, Fastlane has become a PPV that serves little to no purpose other than to bridge the gap between Elimination Chamber and WrestleMania.
The 2017 edition of the PPV became infamous for being one of the worst PPVs of all time, due to one of the worst booking decisions of the PG Era. In the main event, Goldberg squashed Kevin Owens following a distraction from Chris Jericho to win the Universal Title. This decision was not a popular one with fans as they questioned why a 50-year WCW legend needed to pin WWE's top heel and go into WrestleMania 33 as Universal Champion.
Elsewhere on the card, there was an overwhelming amount of filler. Jinder Mahal would wrestle Cesaro and Big Show would wrestle Rusev. Both of these matches had no purpose as neither of the individuals in the specific matches were feuding at the time.
The PPV highlight was a match between Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman. Both men showed signs of things to come later in the year as the two men had fantastic chemistry.
3. Backlash 2018
The PPV after WrestleMania is notable for being WWE's reset show. It should be one where new or casual fans can jump onto the product, and will be able to follow the storylines that are about to occur. Backlash 2018 was an example of how not to book a post-WrestleMania PPV and is arguably the worst example of the genre.
The main event of the PPV featured a match between Roman Reigns and Samoa Joe. Unfortunately, the match didn't belong in the main event slot. The crowd audibly reacted badly to its placement, and you could actually see people leaving during it. The rest of the card wasn't much better: Carmella and Charlotte had one of the worst matches of both of their respective careers and Daniel Bryan's first PPV singles match back after injury was against Big Cass, something nobody wanted to see.
One of the few highlights of the PPV was a match between The Miz and Seth Rollins for the Intercontinental Title. The match that was so acclaimed by fans that many called it the best match in the career of The Miz.
2. Super ShowDown 2020
The most recent Saudi Arabian WWE PPV also happens to be WWE's worst, with another baffling booking decision on their behalf. For Super Showdown 2020, they decided to have Goldberg beat The Fiend Bray Wyatt for the Universal Title. A decision that could be one of WWE's worst-ever, as they sacrificed the credibility of their most exciting character since The Undertaker in favour of a star that peaked in 1998.
Elsewhere on the card, Ricochet lost a WWE Title match to Brock Lesnar in one minute which did little to benefit anybody. The Undertaker won a Gauntlet Match for the Tuwaiq Trophy after pinning AJ Styles with a chokeslam and he managed to do this and pin the former WWE Champion without even taking off his jacket and hat.
Roman Reigns and King Corbin had a Steel Cage match that would finally be the end of their feud, which fans were certainly thankful for. Bayley and Naomi had the second WWE women's match in Saudi Arabian history, but it sadly killed Naomi's momentum that she had built up a month prior at the Royal Rumble.
1. Battleground 2017
Sometimes a PPV can peak during its first match on the card. There isn't a better example of this than Battleground 2017. It opened up with The New Day beating The Usos for the SmackDown Tag Titles in an absolute classic. Sadly, every match that followed on the card seemed to get worse and worse.
Shinsuke Nakamura and Baron Corbin had a match that never got into second gear, which resulted in Nakamura winning via DQ. Natalya won a messy Fatal-5-Way elimination match to become #1 contender for the SmackDown Women's' Title. Kevin Owens and AJ Styles had one of the worst matches of both of their careers for the United States Title, with a botched finish meaning the crowd didn't react to the title change.
The semi-main event featured John Cena defeating Rusev in a Flag Match. WWE rekindling the Rusev and Cena feud was extremely lazy and the storyline of Russia vs. USA going into the match was completely outdated and did little to generate fan interest.
The main event featured one of the worst PPV main events of all time. Jinder Mahal retained the WWE Title against Randy Orton in an infamous Punjabi Prison match after The Great Khali made a one night only return to the WWE to help Mahal win. The match was messy and confusing as fans could barely see anything thanks to the structure of the Punjabi Prison itself.