10 Worst Wrestling Publicity Stunts
MahalMania is a step above TaylorMania, at least.
Unless you've been living under a rock or some other sort of geological feature these last few days (and frankly, who can blame you? Is there any more room beneath that boulder?), you'll know that, yes, Jinder Mahal is WWE champion. No, really.
Let's not get into whether this is a good thing or not; that particular record's been spun more frequently than one of those fidget-whatjamagigs which have suddenly populated pockets of those apparently too refined to unscrew and rescrew a Biro (we've all done it).
The 'why' is so much more important. Don't kid yourself for one second: the Jinder Express is nothing short than a blatant publicity stunt designed to agitate a previously untapped Indian audience. And who can argue with the sensibilities of such a scheme?
'Legacy' be damned; wrestling has rarely been shy about trading its dignity in pursuit of cheap (or in the case of one item on this list, grossly expensive) media attention. Sticking a football player in the marquee match of your major show? Why not! Using a real life war as the starting point for pretend conflict? Sure, we've seen that. How about staging your own death to sell a few tickets? On Christmas Day, no less!
The pale's boundary really has no limits for this industry.
10. Million Dollar Mania
How many television viewers can you buy for a million dollars? Not many, it turned out.
McMahon's 'Million Dollar Mania' made solid the platitude 'more money than sense'. The contest - in which McMahon promised to give away a million bucks so long as viewers could answer a secret password - wasn't a transparent ratings-grab so much as an invisible one. The chairman himself even announced its objective of 'attracting new viewers' during his introductory spiel.
The competition itself was an unmitigated albeit hilarious disaster. The money was designed to entice new viewers, but the content was sure to dissuade them from sticking around. Large, tedious segments of Raw were squandered as Vince struggled to get to grips with this new-fangled technology, the telephone, as he cold-called countless homes which either failed to pick up or responded with total bemusement. One answerphone even Rickrolled the befuddled CEO - the highlight of the whole fiasco.
Still, the expense had to be worth it right? Wrong. Raw posted its lowest ratings for seven weeks. Yes: most people preferred to skip the show than potentially earn a wad of greens. Some indictment.
But it didn't end there, as McMahon was apparently duty bound to continue the pointlessly profligate farce the next week, all to culminate in an angle in which the set fell on top of him because... well, let's leave it there.
Talk about buyer's remorse.
9. David Arquette: WCW Champion
David Arquette's name is basically mud amongst wrestling fans. In fact, it's worse than mud: it's wet mud (hell to wash off school clothes). But perhaps that's a little unfair (both to Arquette and mud).
With Jinder Mahal's title victory at Backlash, the spleens of many fans have been vented as 'worst champion ever (!)' diatribes abound. Naturally, memories of Arquette's run as the holder of WCW's premier title have resurfaced, being the unequivocal benchmark for God-awful gold-wearers.
As idiotic as it was, WCW's suicidal decision was based on solid foundations. After the company splurged $24 million in a bid to insult the motion picture industry with their film Ready to Rumble, they were naturally keen to promote their investment, not to mention capitalise on its 'star power'. Logically then, this involved having leading man David Arquette turn up on Thunder to shill the flick.
So far, so not complete sh*t. Had matters ended there, it might not have been, you know, a travesty. But two weeks after his first appearance, the 160lb actor won the WCW Heavyweight Title. Arquette's name was now alongside such esteemed names as Ric Flair and Harley Race in the legacy of pro-wrestling.
Arquette spent just twelve days with the hallowed waist-adornment, in a largely comedic role, but it was twelve days too many. The move got people talking, but not for the right reasons. Fans absolutely detested the angle, and for many it was the final straw in breaking their Nitro viewing habit.
The Hollywood 'star' himself agreed; Arquette was reluctant to claim the title knowing full-well it was a disgrace to the profession, and to his great credit donated every penny he earned from his run to the families of Owen Hart, Darren Drozdov, and Brian Pillman. Perhaps it was worth it after all?
8. Lawrence Taylor Headlines WrestleMania
In the aftermath of the steroid trial, most of WWF's bloated roster departed the company, many of them for bloated Turner contracts. By 1995, the company had less drawing ability than a two-year old with a pack of crayons. Champion Diesel had ran out of fuel, Bret Hart had been dragged back through time to feud with Bob Backlund, and The Undertaker was digging his way out of utter plodders with lumbering bores such as King Kong Bundy and Yokozuna.
Going into WrestleMania XI, the company needed something - anything - to get lips flapping. In the most typically Vince McMahon move ever, the chairman indulged his fetish for both legitimate athletes and faded celebrity by drafting in former Giants' linebacker Lawrence Taylor for the show. But not just in a throwaway 'special event' battle royal. Oh no: the big lad was parachuted into the main event.
LT didn't just headline the show opposite Bam Bam Bigelow, but he only went and bloody won! Though Taylor was praised for surpassing expectations by not being utter tripe, the stunt quite rightly drew criticism for delegitimising wrestling in such a high profile manner. As much as it garnered the mainstream media's attention, most of it was deprecating.
In the end, the show drew just 340,000 buys - the worst in WrestleMania history.
Still, if you thought Taylor was desperate, it's worth noting WWF tried for OJ Simpson the following year...
7. Trump Vs. O'Donnell
If you're still getting over the shock of Jinder Mahal being the WWE champion, remember: Donald Trump is an actual president. And not of a WASP country club or a golfing lodge, but the United States of America. For many, the sheer incredulity (and novelty) has worn off, but it's sometimes worth reminding ourselves of this ridiculous scenario so we don't become complacent.
The further fact this list could be entirely populated with episodes of Trump's involvement with WWE hammers home the ludicrous nature of the current presidential situation. But let's not get overly political here. The ribald Republican's initial involvements with the company were based solely on business, but after The Donald became famous thanks to The Apprentice, Vince McMahon leaned on his friend's fame for publicity.
The WrestleMania 'Battle of the Billionaires' attention-grab was as flagrant as it got, but at least it drew buys. The catalyst for that showdown was far more ignoble.
With Raw airing on the same station as The Apprentice, some bright spark at the USA Network suggested Trump feature in the ring to cross-promote the show. Trump was also embroiled in his bitter, unedifying feud with television host Rosie O'Donnell at the time, and the temptation to capitalise was too much for Vince McMahon to resist.
Incredibly introduced as the 'Left-Leaning Lesbian', an unflattering O'Donnell impersonator lumbered down to ringside to square off with a Trump impersonator, with no prizes for guessing who came out on top. Somehow, this all led to the real Trump alighting on Raw, apparently eager to be involved in an angle so bad, the crowd was moved to chant "TNA!" of all things. Utter bum guff.
6. 'The Lakers' Vs. 'The Nuggets'
In 2009, the NBA playoffs left Vince McMahon dribbling with rage.
With the Denver Nuggets set for the fourth in their series against the LA Lakers, an unfortunate scheduling conflict arose which would see WWE evicted from the Pepsi Centre to make way for the game. Despite the fact Monday Night Raw had been penciled in months in advance, arena owner Stan Kroenke - who also happened to own the Nuggets - stepped in to boot Vince and co. from the venue.
WWE were perhaps justifiably peeved by the discourtesy (a basketball pun there), but their response was unnecessarily petty. And uncharacteristically.
Shifted to Los Angeles' Staples Center - not, coincidentally, the home of the Lakers - WWE spent the entire broadcast deriding the Nuggets. The show even culminated with a match pitting a group of faces bedecked in Lakers livery kicking the paint off their Denver counterparts.
It was all a bit pathetic, but it certainly got the mainstream sports media talking - a fact Kroenke claimed was more important to Vince than his fans. Vince himself had the ultimate rebuttal, however:
Even though the Denver Nuggets had a strong team this year and were projected to make the playoffs, obviously Nuggets and Pepsi Center owner Stan Kroenke did not have enough faith in his own team to hold the May 25 date for a potential playoff game.
Slam-dunk!
5. Stand Up For WWE
They may be the two greatest exports of Ancient Greece, but unlike their modern counterparts (feta and olives), wrestling and politics really shouldn't mix.
(Cheap plug: they really shouldn't, as I detailed extensively in Issue 4 of our lovely magazine.)
When they do, undignified debacles such as the 'Stand Up for WWE' campaign occur.
During Linda McMahon's first failed run for senate in 2010, political opponents were less than shy about using her association with the often tawdry WWE as ammunition against her campaign. The smear wasn't necessarily fair - Reagan wasn't belittled for the actions of his film characters, afterall - but it was inevitable. Not to mention hilarious. As a result, the WWE's name - and reputation - faced repeated bashing in a far less niche forum than the internet wrestling community.
Vince knew he wasn't permitted to use his platform to electioneer on his wife's behalf, but equally he couldn't just stand by and see his company tarnished by association. So he came up with the perfect solution to circumvent both issues: 'Stand up for WWE'.
Ostensibly, the campaign aimed to inspire fans to express their passion for the product, in effect a vocal rebuttal to all the mudslinging. Simultaneously, and sneakily, by indirectly focusing on Linda's bid, 'Stand up for WWE' could tacitly rally in her favour.
Ironically, the scheme exacerbated the problem. Quite aside from saving WWE's name being shielded from apparent slander, the campaign was criticised for its thinly-veiled motives. In the end, the company suffered further embarrassment, and even better, Linda lost spectacularly. Stand up comedy.
4. Billy And Chuck's Wedding
Like with pretty much every sensitive social issue, WWE's track record with depictions of homosexuality is, if we're being generous, patchy. It's as bald as a lawn following a tractor pull if we're not.
But you can't say the company didn't understand their audience, or at least think they did. Learning from the jeers evinced by the overly feminine, implied homosexuality of Adrian Adonis, as well as the outpouring of euphoria following Goldust's denial that he was not (in WWE's words) "a queer", the company again plumbed the depths of homophobic intolerance in 2002. Billy Gunn - whom the company had repeatedly failed to make a virtue of - was romantically paired with fellow blonde Chuck Palumbo - and creative thought that was apparently reason enough for the fans to boo the pair.
It turned out the audience of the new millennium were just a touch more enlightened than those of a prehistoric age, and were instead endeared by the two men who just happened to be in love. Quite aside from being bashed for their sexuality, the crowd entirely supported the pair - despite the multitude of obtusely homophobic skits - and pretty soon they were one of the most popular tandems on SmackDown.
The love between Billy and Chuck only blossomed, and when Chuck popped the question, fans roared in approval, even more so at Billy's acceptance. After years of vulgar misrepresentation by the business, various gay and lesbian rights were equally delighted with the company finally emerging from the dark ages. WWE were only too happy to receive their endorsements, uniting with the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) in securing mainstream coverage in advance of the nuptials.
GLAAD should have known better; they were none too glad when the wedding transpired to be nothing but a big sham. Just as the couple were about to tie the knot, they backed down, admitting it was all a publicity stunt which had gone too far. GLAAD were understandably furious with the company's deception in crudely championing a legitimate social agenda for some cheap media attention. Worse still, Chuck and Billy immediately 'manned up', making a complete mockery of any progressive ideals WWE had falsified over the prior few months.
It really was a publicity stunt which had gone too far.
3. Fritz Von Erich's 'Heart Attack'
By the late '80s, Texas-based World Class Championship Wrestling was virtually synonymous with tragedy. A spate of untimely deaths - many of them in scandalous circumstances - had rocked the company, and with most of its top stars having either passed on or snatched up by WWF's aggressive national expansion, business had dwindled drastically.
Tragedy hadn't touched anyone in the company quite as viciously as the promotion's owner and booker Fritz von Erich, who had lost three of his six sons before he'd reached his 60s, each of them in desperate circumstances. Cradling so much grief, the patriarch was the last person earth you'd imagine to court controversy by exploiting his deeply personal devastation.
But there was no escaping WCCW's imperilled position, and the elder Von Erich felt he had to do anything necessary to retain interest in his product. During a steel cage match featuring son Kevin at the company's annual Christmas Day bash, Star Wars, Fritz 'collapsed' after an attack by Iceman Parsons - the suggestion being that he had suffered a heart attack.
Obviously, the whole thing was a massive ruse designed to drum up coverage for the ailing promotion. But an audience worn out by so much anguish simply couldn't take any more. The distasteful angle turned fans away in their droves, and the company slowly faded. The fake tragedy had doomed the company, but in a cruel twist of fate, real tragedy would continue to curse the Von Erich family even after WCCW had reached its nadir.
2. Exploiting The Gulf War
In 1991, it was becoming painfully clear to the then-WWF that interest in their product was waning. Hulk Hogan's popularity was receding faster than his hairline, and allegations of steroid abuse was threatening to erode any trust in the company's family-friendly product. Suddenly, hoping to fill the 100,000 seater Los Angeles Coliseum for WrestleMania seemed ambitious.
The logical solution was a re-match of The Ultimate Warrior and Hogan's epic tussle from the previous year's extravaganza. Warrior may have failed to set pulses racing as champ, and the shine had faded on Hogan's star, but the same encounter had managed to draw just under 70,000 spectators twelve months earlier. It seemed a good bet to motivate ticket sales once more.
But for Vince, the attraction just wasn't strong enough. Desperate, he instead fell on a usual crutch: flag-waving. With the Gulf War raging in Kuwait, the chairman decided to capitalise on American involvement in the conflict by turning perennial patriot Sgt. Slaughter turncoat, even going so far as to laden the new Iraqi sympathiser with the WWF title. Naturally, all-American hero Hulk Hogan was lined up to wrest the strap from the nefarious traitor.
The build was utterly disgraceful: as service personnel were fighting and dying in the Middle East, Slaughter was vehemently advocating Saddam Hussein in order to sell tickets to a fake wrestling show.
It didn't work. People were livid with WWF's crass profiteering, and the event was forced to move to the much smaller Los Angeles Sports Arena for 'security reasons'. In other words, only a fifth of tickets had been sold, no thanks to the disgusting promotional tactic.
1. The Melanie Pillman Interview
Few reputable grief counselors advise that the best way to comfort a widow in the immediate aftermath of a bereavement is by subjecting her to a live television interview. But just a single day after Brian Pillman's sudden death, that's exactly what Vince McMahon did.
McMahon gratuitously and tastelessly promoted the segment featuring Melanie Pillman on the Monday Night Raw broadcast 24 hours after Pillman was discovered lifeless in his hotel room, as though it were simply the next chapter in a wrestling angle. Come the time, an obviously distraught Melanie struggled to fight back tears, as the boss grilled her on a series of questions relating to her husband's unexpected death, including ones regarding his past issues with drug abuse, and how she would cope raising a family of five alone.
The exercise seemed partly designed to absolve WWF of any responsibility for the tragedy - Melanie was badgered into acknowledging self-medication, not steroid abuse, was at play - but mostly as a lurid ratings grab. The screw was strategically turned as McMahon sadistically angled for a reaction, finely cranking up the emotions - and, he hoped, the ratings.
McMahon was, not surprisingly, pilloried from all corners of the industry - including his own locker-room. But he remained unrepentant, telling TSN's Off the Record that the forum had allowed the family to benefit in some capacity. Even a trio of mice being chased through a kitchen with a carving knife could see through the pretense; it was tacky, insensitive sensationalism at its absolute basest.