10 Worst WWE SummerSlams Ever - According To Dave Meltzer

Sunburnt.

The Rock Mr Ass
WWE Network

'The Biggest Party Of The Summer' has, not without an uphill struggle, become a WWE institution on par with WrestleMania, the Royal Rumble and the Survivor Series, despite not sharing a discernible gimmick or hook to grab curiosity eyes or fans of the wrestling novelty.

What SummerSlam has supplied for thirty years has been a feast of exciting encounters where mere in-ring is king.

As paragon of virtue for all that happens within the matches themselves, Wrestling Observer creator Dave Meltzer is bastion of the bell-to-bell. His ratings have ensured that certain SummerSlam cards are considered amongst the finest supercards in the history of the industry, but the even-handed journalist isn't shy of reducing a show's status to rubble if the card fails to inspire.

With certain incarnations of the supercard either lacking one true blockbuster match, or regrettably circling the drain throughout, the average rating of a show often shines a harsh light on underperformance in the extreme.

A long way short of a reputation that precedes them, these editions of the August classic threatened to destroy the 'SummerSlam' brand long before it became an iconic staple of the WWE calendar.

10. SummerSlam 1998 (2.57)

triple h the rock ladder summerslam 1998
WWE.com

The public fight for wrestling industry supremacy between WCW and WWE reached something of a zenith in mid-1998, with Vince McMahon's organisation on an unbelievable upswing during a period where things at least appeared rosy for the internally unravelling Atlanta outfit.

Eric Bischoff's decision to run a monster first meeting of Bill Goldberg and Hulk Hogan for free on Monday Nitro instead of drawing a potentially huge buyrate on pay-per-view reeked of desperation, but for one week at least reminded the audience at large that WCW could still be a force with the right product. Unfortunately for 'Easy E', across summer, WWE were proving it time and time again.

Driven by style over substance and the increasing influence of Vince Russo, less attention was paid to match quality in place of high octane segments and riotous promos. And it worked.

Though little shone bell-to-bell on this explosive edition of the Summer spectacular, Madison Square Garden was white hot for virtually every contest thanks to a deep emotional investment in every character on the roster. Whilst Steve Austin, The Undertaker, the New Age Outlaws, Mankind, X-Pac and Jeff Jarrett didn't move mountains in matches, fans still rose in awe for every little move they made.

Triple H and The Rock dragged the average up with an absorbing ladder match. Foreshadowing their eventual successes in the company, the two had perhaps their finest ever battle, with the reaction for Triple H's victory even louder than Stone Cold's later that night.


9. SummerSlam 1996 (2.37)

Bearer Undertaker Mankind SummerSlam 1996
WWE.com

Bruce Prichard's podcast phenomenon 'Something To Wrestle' recently covered SummerSlam '96, with Prichard making the shrewdest observation at the very beginning of the discussion - it's a slow show.

There's very little to grumble about on the card overall, but it's an impossible show to love due to an anaemic atmosphere that highlighted how detached Vince McMahon's vision still was from his audience.

Owen Hart and Savio Vega's opener made it apparent from the off. Both were capable, but neither had a reason to fight, and the days of motivation-free matches making pay-per-view were passé. Similarly, a flagging feud between Marc Mero and Goldust resulted in the perplexing decision to unveil Mero's glorious 'Wild Thing' shooting star press...but then not win the match with it. In a brutally boring four-way tag team elimination match, Skip from The Bodydonnas failed even to tag in thanks to a neck injury, and a genuinely engaging brawl between Mankind and The Undertaker was hamstrung by an uncharacteristically lousy presentation of a pre-tape to the live crowd.

Even Shawn Michaels and Vader - two of the more reliable 'big match' performers - had an off night. An infamous flub from 'The Mastodon' put 'The Heartbreak Kid's nose out of joint early on, and their chemistry crumbled as a result.

The sad irony was how close the company were to their eventual saviour. Steve Austin was in the building that very night, but a 1:52 victory over Yokozuna on the pre-show wasn't exactly destined to change the game.


8. SummerSlam 1991 (2.34)

Virgil Ted DiBiase SummerSlam 1991
WWE.com

Suffering through Meltzer's lens perhaps due to WWE's pedestrian match quality in the early 1990s, SummerSlam '91 is at least a joyous festival of fan service even when action bell-to-bell sometimes stumbles.

It's a card fondly remembered for torch-passing Intercontinental Title clash between Mr Perfect and Bret Hart that fused high octane physicality with glorious emotional triumph, but Dave's low snowflake count doesn't take notice of the explosive reactions triggered from a raucous Madison Square Garden crowd across the evening.

Lifting the company's tag straps to complete a AWA/NWA/WWE triple crown, the Legion of Doom gave The Nasty Boys a cathartic kicking, whilst the Big Boss Man looked at his physical peak in disposing of The Mountie, which itself triggered a series of hilarious vignettes of the Canadian lawman's journey through a host of New York prison clichés.

Though again a contest not on par with New Japan's output today (or All Japan's in 1991), Virgil claiming his ultimate reparation in the form of Ted Dibiase's Million Dollar Belt was a career high for the former bodyguard, and a credit to the magnificence of Dibiase on his best day. Effectively the payoff to a four year story, it it exemplified WWE pathos done right.


7. SummerSlam 1999 (2.29)

X Pac Undertaker SummerSlam 1999
WWE.com

Like the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania before it, SummerSlam '99 suffers from being a major pay-per-view from a time where television was king.

The monthly specials still brought in humongous revenue for the company of course, and stood alongside merchandise and gate receipts as the financial pillars of the WWE empire, but the mainstream audience engaged on a diet of short matches, chaotic segments and catchphrase-heavy promos.

With Vince Russo at the wheel, the pay-per-views tried to blend the traditional match-heavy format with the ratings-grabbing checkpoints, leading to shorter-than-acceptable contests between wrestlers that were often far more over talking than they were working.

As well has playing host to one of the worst SummerSlam main events ever, the show offered little on an undercard in desperate need of at least one creditable contest.

Tag team wrestling's dynamic reboot in 2000 couldn't possibly have been foreseen just four months earlier, with an interminable 'Tag Team Turmoil' effort and the Undertaker/Big Show vs Kane/X-Pac title match highlighting that every unit in the division bored the audience to tears when actually required to perform for longer than two minutes on a random Raw.

The 'Kiss My Ass' match was the evening's biggest disaster. Billy Gunn's laughable main event push ended underneath the elbow of The Rock, but served only as a temporary demotion for 'The Great One' in the meantime. Defeating Gangrel the next night, he even acknowledged it, and immediately elevated himself back into the WWE Title picture by sheer force of will.


6. SummerSlam 1993 (2.26)

Bret Hart Jerry Lawler SummerSlam 1993 Sharpshooter
WWE.com

As with so many 1990s pay-per-views, Bret Hart's herculean efforts in the middle can't support listless affairs at either end.

In this case, his breathtaking displays against Doink and Jerry Lawler back-to-back almost turned an underwhelming card into something very special indeed, if not for a wretched main event regrettably undermining his sensational work.

Booked originally to take on 'The King', Lawler shone in a prematch promo in which he painstakingly described a hit-and-run accident with a grandma that had ultimately put him out through injury. Sending Doink out to do the dirty work, Jerry struck as Bret had the clown beat, waffling him with a crutch and kicking off the second of two impassioned displays.

Elsewhere though, things just didn't quite click. You could drive a red, white and blue bus through the gaping void left by Lex Luger's count out victory over Yokozuna, and in a rare misfire for both, Shawn Michaels and Mr Perfect hugely under-delivered in their Intercontinental Title match.

It wasn't just that the bout wasn't up to either man's lofty standards, more that the company had basically promised and assured it would be outstanding, such was their assured collective brilliance. When that didn't transpire, it not only made the performers look weak, but WWE as an entity, too.


5. SummerSlam 2007 (2.19)

Rey Mysterio Chavo Guerrero SummerSlam 2007
WWE.com

The first 'Big Four' pay-per-view following the death of Chris Benoit had all the unfortunate hallmarks of a company still struggling to cope with the terms of the crisis.

Tucking away longstanding main eventers to lead with two comebacks highlighted a sense of panic that existed in the promotion at the time, and it was a nervousness not extinguished by rushed and inferior displays from the returnees.

Drawn into the Signature Pharmacy steroid distribution scandal whilst out injured, Rey Mysterio made his re-entrance under a cloud, and it looked to be the case literally with an ill-advised spray job on his chest stealing headlines away from his moribund match with Chavo Guerrero.

Getting in and out quick enough to almost be forgotten by the end, Mysterio was merely the evening's subplot. The night was unapologetically centred around Triple H's latest heroic rehabilitation from a quadricep injury. Sound familiar? As is usually the case in wrestling, the second verse was the same as the first but a little bit louder and little bit worse.

There was no Madison Square Garden mega-pop for 'The Game' this time around, and his lousy in-ring efforts in 2002 were passable in comparison to his disparate burial of a soon-to-depart King Booker. The 'King Of Kings' took back his throne for sure, but yet again it sat atop crumbling foundations.


4. SummerSlam 1997 (2.08)

Shawn Michaels bret Hart SummerSlam 1997
WWE.com

It's likely this card wouldn't feature on such a list had Owen Hart not inadvertently nearly paralysed Stone Cold Steve Austin, but then much would be different about the industry in general today had 'The Rattlesnake's neck not horrifically folded in on itself on that fateful night.

Match-by-match, it's apparent why Meltzer's ratings leave this one lagging, with the Brian Pillman/Goldust, British Bulldog/Ken Shamrock and Los Boricuas/DOA matches all failing to deliver both a passable match and a satisfying conclusion, but the Observer chief is unnecessarily harsh on the contest that bookend an infamous show.

In only awarding the Steel Cage opener between Triple H and Mankind **1/2, Meltzer neglects the raw emotion exhibited by Foley as he scaled the structure to relive a childhood dream in a nuanced character portrayal that couldn't be further away from the present day product.

And though it's sometimes spurious to debate such things, a mere *** for the epic Bret Hart/Undertaker WWE Title main event seems insane, especially in an era in which he's expanded the ratings system to over double that in the last year alone.


3. SummerSlam 1989 (1.87)

Rick Rude Ultimate Warrior SummerSlam 1989
WWE.com

Limping along as a longform broadcast in part due to constraints of the era (more on that later), SummerSlam '89 has peaks and valleys but never quite lives up to qualitative potential outside of a staggering midcard effort from Ravishing Rick Rude and The Ultimate Warrior.

Their absorbing Intercontintenal Title encounter was for a period the Warrior's best match by a mile, and still gets overlooked now when compiling the relatively short list of his best bits.

Beyond that, the Hulk Hogan/Brutus Beefcake/Randy Savage/Zeus foursome drew monster numbers for the show itself, but the Hollywood redux repeatedly failed to inspire in the way that replicated the insanity of their silver screen showdown. Zeus was beyond useless in the match, and only Hogan and Savage's typically brilliant chemistry dragged the main event along to something bordering on respectable.

Quickie jobs were par for the course in early WWE pay-per-views, but the harsh reality was that so few of them were particularly entertaining.

The Red Rooster took a knock in his match against Mr Perfect to hijack what could have been the best singles match on the undercard, and multi-man matches only scratch the surface of what the collected talents were capable of.

A brightly-coloured festival of late-80s pomp it may be, but a stellar advert for action, it ain't.


2. SummerSlam 1990 (1.83)

Marty Jannetty SummerSlam 1990
WWE.com

Professional Wrestling is many things to many people, but the core of Vince McMahon's model is predicated on stars. 'Superstars', as he'd eventually force into the parlance.

Throughout the late 1980s, Hulk Hogan was his ticket-selling star, but with his push came a complete reclassification of the way WWE matches traditionally played out in order to cater to a new money-making machine.

It's perhaps this ideology that drowns SummerSlam '90 in a Meltzer mire, so fabulous are the moments of joy rooted within a heel-heavy pay-per-view.

Victories, be it decisive or otherwise, for Hogan as well as the Ultimate Warrior, the Hart Foundation and the Texas Tornado leave an audience glowing with pride for their worthy heroes. But elsewhere, the show is a night for squashes, and the matches that service the nefarious ne'er-do-wells and dominant do-gooders are either short, boring or a combination of the two.

Completely distracted by the show-long 'Where's Sapphire?' angle, Dusty Rhodes is callously brushed aside by Randy Savage in a waste of both, whilst quick wins for Warlord and a Jim Duggan/Nikolai Volkoff send the show careering off a cliff.

With the Harts/Demolition doubles duel stealing the show in the middle, only the opener comes close to it, in a gloriously one-sided match that allows the legitimately injured Shawn Michaels to rest on the floor whilst partner Marty Jannetty takes an unapologetic kicking from the wicked Power & Glory.


1. SummerSlam 1988 (1.64)

British Bulldogs Rougeau Brothers SummerSlam 1988
WWE.com

First really is the worst then, as SummerSlam '88's parade of meaningless matches fail to inspire Meltzer beyond **3/4 for any one bout. Even that's predominantly for the superlative showmanship of Hulk Hogan, Randy Savage, Ted Dibiase and Andre The Giant in a main event that served only to squeeze the last droplets of juice from the Hogan/Andre conflict whilst tacitly continuing the growing discord between the babyface superpowers.

As with many early pay-per-views, it's of course unfair to judge the pairings against modern conventions. Though the medium was becoming a firmly profitable venture for the company, WWE was still predominantly a live event industry at the time, with the weekly television still more focussed on filling arenas nationwide than inflating a buyrate for a quarterly mega event.

Over the course of several years, the two priorities would naturally merge before swapping places altogether, but the lack of decisive feud-ending encounters on the ten match card make the show quite the slog.

It would be unfair to discredit its place in history though. As a successful venture, it became an integral part of the WWE's supershow calendar, and as an individual event, it at least provided a stage for The Ultimate Warrior's 31 second decimation of The Honky Tonk Man.

Liberating the Intercontinental Title from the Elvis wannabe marked Warrior's first giant leap towards superstardom, and for many still remains the highlight of his tumultuous tenure.


In this post: 
SummerSlam
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.