10 Wrestlers That Became Stars In ONE SECOND

The rise of Batista, the fall of Hulkamania, and a Very Nice Very Evil surprise.

Donovan DanHausen
instagram.com/Beezzzzy

The discussion of what makes a star is as necessary as it is futile.

Stewart Lee and Homer Simpson alike have both sardonically noted that you can prove anything with facts, proving in turn that even solid statistics can be spun to suit a set narrative.

This is particularly relevant in an industry like pro wrestling, where exaggeration is welcome, understood and indulged in if it helps tell a particular story more effectively. Everything from heights to years in the game to - and remember, this actually happened at the first WrestleMania - the number of seconds a match took despite all of us having access to time, can be twisted to taste.

Everybody in the below list can claim something that renders them a star by supposedly objective measures, but exactly how they got there can always remain up for some debate. Beauty will thankfully always be in the eye of the beholder, and sometimes isn't it just nicer to go back and enjoy the moments rather than debate their validity anyway? That's what makes the free-flowing Stone Cold Steve Austin podcast so enjoyable more often than not.

And speaking of 'The Rattlesnake'...

10. Steve Austin (ECW, September 26th 1995)

Steve Austin ECW
WWE

When it suited WWE, they'd allow Paul Heyman or another ECW original to remind fans that Stone Cold Steve Austin "drank his first beer in Extreme Championship Wrestling". This was cute copy, but didn't cut through to what actually made him such a big deal during a relatively short stint.

Debuting as an infuriated WCW cast-off, the future 'Rattlesnake' let rip with venomous promos at the expense of Dusty Rhodes, Eric Bischoff and the Atlanta organisation in general, but his most powerful parody came at the expense of Hulk Hogan.

Targeting the biggest name in wrestling, Austin revealed a fearlessness that hadn't been noticed during his time working for Ted Turner. An already good talker became an incredible one over the course of a minute as Joey Styles looked on in disbelief at an industry icon being ripped to shreds.

Austin pledged not to "do this sh*t", correctly surmising that it wasn't going to get the job done anywhere. Like Hogan, he'd make his 1990s millions dressed all in black soon enough, but it was a brief flirtation with the red and yellow that revealed a headliner of a different kind beneath the surface.


9. Kofi Kingston (WWE Raw, November 16th 2009)

Kofi Kingston Randy Orton
WWE

Kofi Kingston's complex relationship with Randy Orton will most likely linger longer on the night Orton loudly called him "stupid" rather than any particular classic exchange between them, but at least one interaction deserved anointing as a star-making moment for the New Day man.

Buried deep in 'The World's Most Famous Arena' back when it still looked like the Madison Square Garden of old, Kingston flying off a barricade onto Orton through a table felt like the perfect spot at the perfect time for the perfect push. Ahead of defeating him at the Survivor Series as part of an elimination tag, and the heat generated by this remarkable moment seemed impervious to bad booking... until Orton beat him clean in a dull pay-per-view match the following month.

If nothing else, consider how rare it was to have a post-2001 storyline or angle replicated - WWE aped this specific spot for a reason in 2019, even if the magic of Kingston's reign was just about extinguished by then.


8. Batista (WWE Raw, November 8th 2004)

Batista Belt
WWE

By 2004's Survivor Series, Randy Orton's babyface push was as good as dead thanks to a miserable three weeks on top as Champion and one too many failed efforts to get under Triple H's skin since their post-SummerSlam split.

An elimination main event win on the Thanksgiving show was something of a last gasp victory for the 'Legend Killer', in that it granted him and his team the opportunity to book Monday Night Raw for a month and make 'The Game's life at very least worse than it had been for the majority of the last two years. But Hunter's plan to save himself before all this revealed his most dangerous threat for the very first time.

Six days before the pay-per-view, Triple H's teammates Edge and Gene Snitsky both explained that they were only working closely with the Champion to get closer to the Championship. Enraged, Hunter asked his Evolution heavy Batista to straighten them and their motivations out. Storming off, he left behind the very thing that had caused all these headaches, and 'The Animal' had it to himself for the first time.

Fans were shown the very possibility for the first time, and a swerve turn a few weeks later amplified the excitement around his eventual ascension.


7. Wardlow (AEW Dynamite, September 9th 2020)

Wardlow MJF
WWE

At All Out 2020, MJF was out-thought and out-fought by then-World Champion Jon Moxley in a contest that was something of a quiet triumph.

Literally so - the contest took place with Daily's Place still echoing the silence of the pandemic and at the end of a pay-per-view that had been received as one of the company's worst. Unbothered by the climate of the evening's prior calamities, the two paid off the Challenger's cynical belief that Moxley couldn't be a "proper" pro wrestler and made him eat a plateful of his own sh*t by using the banned Paradigm Shift to get the win after Wardlow provided inadvertent distraction misplacing his throw of the Dynamite Diamond Ring.

The big man looked none too pleased with his mistake at the pay-per-view, but a new wrinkle existed between the pair days later when MJF revealed that he paid Wardlow, not Tony Khan. An enraged Friedman had screamed at the 'Wardog' for his mistake and looked set to have his head dislodged from his body as a result until the financial reveal.

It was the first look into the reality of the relationship, and of its inevitable demise.


6. Wheeler Yuta (AEW Rampage, April 6th 2022)

Wheeler Yuta
AEW

The Wheeler Yuta story has been far from a rushed one in AEW (he debuted as a Best Friends surrogate in June 2021 losing to Karl Anderson and only earned his spot in the Blackpool Combat Club in April 2022), but the way in which he went from mere prospect to William Regal's newest killer was a nice acceleration from the norm.

His run has been defined by the matches with Moxley specifically, but it was as he drove his bloodstained sneaker through the former AEW Champion's head in the latter stages of their third encounter that the realisation of his ascension set in.

Yuta fell to Mox in just 47 seconds the first time they fought. He spent almost as long kicking the f*cking sh*t out of the hardest man in the company as came within a whisker of defeating him in their Rampage classic. Covered in blood and with a BCC membership assured, Yuta's glare down the lens was the sort of moment only this specific kind of pursuit could have earned.


5. Eddie Kingston (AEW Dynamite, July 22nd 2020)

Eddie Kingston
AEW

Eddie Kingston had always been considered one of the best talkers in wrestling even when many had (errantly, as it transpired) noted that his best in-ring days might have been behind him.

Landing in AEW via Cody Rhodes’ transcendent 2020 TNT Title open challenge run, Kingston biliously opposed the notion that Rhodes - or indeed anybody in a position even close to approaching his privilege - knew what it was to be tough.

Calling himself "one of the dirtiest fighters in independent wrestling", he went further, noting; "...you grew up around used-to-be-legends like Arn Anderson. You know what I grew up around? Alcoholics. Junkies...I had to survive. I had to grind. You couldn't last a day in my shoes, so you don't tell me nothing about grinding."

With Cody welcoming the challenge and Kingston finalising the fine print on the deal he was destined to be offered, 'The Mad King' continued; "I am a grown-ass man and I will put you in the ground and smile. Here's the best part about this whole thing...Tony Khan paid me to show up and now he's gonna pay me to kick your ass and take that championship."

He didn't manage the latter, but the former remains true to this very day.


4. Rhea Ripley (NXT, August 28th 2019)

Shayna Baszler Rhea Ripley
WWE

An amazing debut that had a significant and poignant outcome, Rhea Ripley's August 2019 arrival in NXT took a relatively unknown NXT UK Champion and turned her into a major player that could somehow dethrone an unstoppable champion.

Shayna Baszler had luxuriated in her position as an unbeatable NXT titleholder up to that point, but was cut off by Ripley's music, and physically stopped from speaking when 'The Nightmare' took the mic.

Getting right to the point, she said, "I know what you're gonna say. You're gonna say you've beaten everybody here. But you haven't beaten me, b*tch".

The typically-unflappable Baszler was stunned into silence, and bailed from the scene in an attempt to save face on the night. It was an impeccable bit of business, as profoundly proven several months later.

Their long-awaited title fight on December 18th resulted in NXT's only ratings victory over AEW Dynamite. After months of desperately trying to grab for it with weekly hot-shotting, the culmination of a months-long arc got them the result.


3. Shinsuke Nakamura (NXT TakeOver: Dallas)

Shinsuke Nakamura Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Only in WWE lore would Shinsuke Nakamura not already be considered a star before he stepped out on a company stage for the first time, but in terms of finding and nailing a brand new audience for an established act, there may be none better than 'The King Of Strong Style's debut.

TakeOver: Dallas was well on its way to peaking as one of the best shows in WWE history before the former NJPW star arrived to take it to the next level in a way even the most optimistic fans might not have imagined.

A white-hot TakeOver: Dallas crowd greeted him like a first-ballot Hall-Of-Famer and he responded with the greatest match he'd ever have for the organisation. An instantly iconic clash that gave Sami Zayn the perfect NXT send-off and Nakamura himself a cast-iron guaranteed run with the NXT Championship, the bout was a genuine company classic from Shinsuke's epic entrance through to Zayn's emotional farewell.


2. James Ellsworth (WWE Raw, July 25th 2016)

James Ellsworth WWE
WWE.com

Out of the limelight but active on the independent circuit to this day, James Ellsworth's career has been busier than ever since he turned one squash into two WWE runs between 2016 and his 2018 release.

In his own words, "any man with two hands has a fighting chance", and even though he couldn't remotely back that up in a memorable pasting from Braun Strowman, the human later labelled a "chinless insect" (and worse) by some of his colleagues cut such a memorable figure as a complete loser that he got a mini-main event stint.

Much of what Strowman got up to in those early days was of a standard the rest of his time never quite hit, but few of his foes made as much of it as Ellsworth. His separation from the 'Monster Among Men' even got him out of bother with the big man until the two were briefly reunited in a Royal Rumble.


1. Danhausen (AEW Dynamite, 26th January 2022)

Danhausen Adam Cole
AEW

A "very nice, very evil" debut that couldn't possibly have happened if the wrestling monopoly hadn't been smashed in 2019, Danhausen's arrival in All Elite Wrestling spoke to the creative freedom in a company willing to take a punt on buzz.

A strange and divisive character, the teeth-obsessed parodic persona got over enormously online in a manner that made his wrestling almost secondary to whatever he could offer in promos and segments.

That was the inherent intelligence in booking him to emerge from under the ring and place a curse on Adam Cole. Those that knew the shtick were sure to go wild, and those that didn't could only observe the wildness and take from it that he was somebody to pay attention to.

It even applied to Cole's opponent Orange Cassidy - Danhausen got such an enormous reaction in the building that the laid back Best Friend couldn't supress a rye and charming chuckle.


In this post: 
AEW Danhausen
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.