10 Wrestlers Vince McMahon Couldn't Get Over

Don't cross (this specific version of) the boss! It hasn't gone well for Austin Theory...

Vince McMahon slap
WWE.com

There are evidently way more than 10 wrestlers Vince McMahon can't get over.

One need only look to the WWE Personnel Wikipedia page to find a majority of names that the Chairman has profoundly failed in recent times, and that doesn't include the folk binned off in the last two years - so great in number in fact that they helped make that destination Wiki's most edited link.

This is not that list, but will instead focus on those McMahon has directly included himself in the misadventures of. The talent he's deemed worthy enough of his precious time in between gaslighting midcarders, b*llocking commentators and tearing up Raw scripts. Special cases, and yet not that special at all, because it wasn't his fault when these pushes failed.

In much the same way Hulk Hogan got over in one specific way and McMahon subsequently went looking for a direct replacement, or John Cena reimagined the expectations of a top star and his boss applied them to every wrestler that attempted to headline, the Chairman gets fairly set in his ways with something if it works once.

Austin Vs McMahon worked really, really well. Unlike...

10. Bobby Lashley

Bobby Lashley Vince McMahon
WWE

Bobby Lashley's 2021 return to television came with an in-built spot in the next pay-per-view WWE Championship match.

Yes, he had to jump through various kayfabe hoops to gain a spot in the multi-man match, but these all contributed to an IRL inevitability. The 'All Mighty' is now a former titleholder himself, and one that looked better with the belt than most that came before him.

It was - in Vince McMahon's defence - this he saw over fifteen years ago when the ageless Lashley arrived in World Wrestling Entertainment, but a combination of wrestler inexperience and McMahon's heavy-handed over-promotion very nearly doomed the standout for good.

A run as ECW Champion for big Bobby was loathed for what it wasn't (a push for CM Punk, another roll of the dice on Rob Van Dam) rather than beloved for what it was (a transparent power play by Vince McMahon in a one-sided war against Paul Heyman). Lashley had chance after chance to beat, brutalise and embarrass McMahon following his Battle Of The Billionaires win over Umaga, but fan sentiment was already skewing south and so too was Lashley's enthusiasm.

After taking time off with injury that summer, he'd leave the following spring as an impossible wasted opportunity. It took both sides a decade to start writing those wrongs.


9. Roman Reigns

Vince McMahon Roman Reigns Low Blow
WWE

In which the last credible boss commits a cardinal sin that ruins his aura forever.

By late-2015, Roma Reigns was a long, long way from being a top babyface and even further from being where the company had had him pegged to be when they split The Shield in 2014. The sludge culminated in a Survivor Series 2015 title win that was immediately taken from him by Sheamus in a Money In The Bank cash-in designed to ape the devastation of what happened to Daniel Bryan at SummerSlam two years earlier. When that failed to resonate, in strutted Vince McMahon himself.

Only, why would he hate Roman Reigns so much? It was never really explored. It was one thing for countless spineless tossers pretending to start pointless wars with the babyfaces in the never-ending tribute to Austin Vs McMahon. It was quite another for The Chairman to do it himself.

The feud felt like an open acknowledgement of failure on the Roman Reigns front. Ratings briefly spiked for the pair's interactions, but Reigns' eventual victory over Sheamus took the company into Royal Rumble season with an objectively cold Champion and a list of potential challengers dwarfing his popularity.

The duo didn't even have particularly good on-screen chemistry. Here, or three years later...


8. Roman Reigns (Again)

Roman Reigns Vince McMahon
WWE

There are just certain turds no amount of polish can shine up.

"Vince McMahon doesn't want Roman Reigns to be WWE Champion" and/or "Roman Reigns isn't Vince McMahon's chosen one" are two of the nuttiest floaters.

Vince McMahon is a promoter who has asked for all kinds of suspension of disbelief over the decades. He's asked fans to buy into clowns; murder, evil and wholesome alike in various guises. He's requested that his audience imagine that ice hockey players, taxmen, mobsters and even possessed demons from another realm are best served making real money in his pro wrestling racket. He even tried to sell the concept of Triple H as a suitable replacement to The Rock and Steve Austin for about three years, bless him.

He could not sell this.

By 2018's WrestleMania build, Roman Reigns' status as a WWE office favourite was so crystal clear that the company had seemingly given up trying to resist it. His planned WrestleMania opponent Brock Lesnar was and is a McMahon favourite too, but Reigns racing to gorilla to give the gaffer a piece of his mind about his pet project was richer than Vince himself.

It all lead to the most sh*t-upon 'Show Of Shows' headliner in the event's history. There was nothing of any standard left to shine.


7. Drew McIntyre

Drew Mcintyre Vince McMahon
WWE.com

A career kickstart so bad that it became the stick to beat a returning Drew McIntyre with nearly a decade later, the "Chosen One"s initial anointment doomed a fresh-faced SmackDown star to half a decade of failure.

Tall and with a good head of hair, McIntyre was hardly the wildest outside bet Vince McMahon had ever made on one of his young stars, but there was something particularly odd about how he structured this entire introduction.

In a heavily promoted segment that McMahon promised would change the future of the show, the Chairman first plugged an October 2009 show that would celebrate a decade of SmackDown that was set to feature a host of stars past and present. In the meantime, the crowd in Oklahoma were forced to make do with Drew McIntyre, a recent debutant who'd assaulted R-Truth a few times like any old blue brand midcarder.

He might have been McMahon's personal signing, but the boss seemingly couldn't wait to get out the ring and McIntyre's shrill and drab heel promo did nothing to assuage the nagging sensation that the whole thing was destined to fail.


6. Kevin Owens

Vince Mcmahon Kevin Owens Headbutt
wwe.com

Not over because of things that had already happened to his character rather than anything a fairly exhilarating Vince McMahon headbutt segment could have done, Kevin Owens drawing blood the hard way from the Chairman was an undeniably awesome piece of television.

It did not result in the world begging for Owens Vs Shane McMahon's feud to continue to Hell In A Cell and beyond.

In fact, this SmackDown beating marked an interesting turning point for the McMahon character, and one WWE still haven't really gotten a grasp of in the years hence. McMahon is getting up there in years. He's 76 - the same age as your writer's Father at time of publication and theoretically around the same age as a lot of fans' grandparents. There's an unapologetic sympathy towards the plight of an old man getting battered, but when this specific old man is an evil billionaire, it creates little more than a tonal dissonance.


5. The Legacy

Shane McMahon Triple H Vince McMahon
WWE

The above image is not really as preposterous as it might first appear.

Yes, it's totally ludicrous that a mid-ring Randy Orton, Cody Rhodes and Ted Dibiase Jr (then 29, 24 and 27 respectively) should fear the wrath of an ageing Vince McMahon, his ageing non-wrestler son and the past-his-prime WWE Champion Triple H. But only in reality, not in WWE.

Their "Then, Now, Forever" tagline refers mostly to how this is Vince McMahon's organisation and world, no matter how divorced it is from anything resembling normality. And in this world, McMahon is an alpha male, and an alpha male can wear his f*cking khaki slacks to work and still kick the f*cking sh*t out of you as long as his sleeves are rolled up, pal.

All of this bluster was supposed to aid the younger trio either side of Orton's rotten WrestleMania 25 main event with 'The Game', until Vince wisely took himself out of things in favour of Batista when it evidently wasn't working. The biggest laugh comes from the idea of him thinking it might.


4. Vince's Devils

Vince Candice
WWE

He got over them alright. Or at least one leg amirite?!

No, imwrong, as was the Vince's Devils gimmick ostensibly designed to give Candice Michelle, Torrie Wilson and Victoria something to do as the Divas division on Raw divided sharply between those that could wrestle and those that were flooding the show thanks to the "Athletic Tens" mandate.

As Michelle and Wilson strived to get better and Victoria did her best with some of the dross, McMahon put himself in amongst them - Michelle specifically - at the height of his megalomania. In 2006, he was five years into a monopoly, working Shawn Michaels in a WrestleMania show-stealer and getting his admittedly very impressive boobs out on the cover of Muscle & Fitness magazine. He was all of these things, and truly believed he could be anything else he wished.

This might have resulted in finding a cure for labiagytus, but it certainly didn't prep the decimated division for the impending departures of Trish Status and Lita.


3. The Anonymous Raw General Manager

Vince McMahon
WWE

In defence of an inanimate object that made real a classic Simpsons' carbon rod gag, there were other feeble authority figures that would also qualify for this.

At various points, Vince McMahon went to bat for Vickie Guerrero, Brad Maddox, John Laurinaitis and anybody else voted in by boards of directors he had some kayfabe say over, all despite the fact that they were objectively useless at the role. The role, if we're sticking to the story here, being to put on such an entertaining wrestling show that the company arrests a 20 year ratings slide. None of them did, and it didn't help that a lot of the time the promos and builds sucked too.

The Anonymous Raw General Manager (before it was revealed to be Hornswoggle all along, and honestly WWE could book The Big Bang and it'd probably end up being him and Kane playing marbles) needed more than Michael Cole's nasal tones to get it over - it needed McMahon to get it off the ground.

He failed at the first hurdle, thus it did too. Particularly rich coming from the cheeky b*stard that made Eric Bischoff and Renee Paquette sell brooms and biros respectively. There's porn on laptops, pal, and you could take some tips on scripting and direction there too.


2. Austin Theory

Vince McMahon Austin Theory
WWE

An Austin Theory that didn't even appear to be about Austin Theory until it hatched out of a golden eyg at 2021's supremely stupid Survivor Series, the push for the youngster has folded an increasingly odd Vince McMahon back into Monday Night Raw as something resembling the old coot rocking on his porch shooting cans with a cap gun.

Once a week, he b*llocks Theory for something or other, gaslights him into get up to mischief at ringside and speaks with a compelling profundity about his lonliness, bitterness and a sense that he doesn't belong in the world now. If he ever even did.

It's the strangest and most unlikely character twist from a man and character that appeared to age 100 years over the space of five, and Theory couldn't look more like a dolt going along with it. He might be allowed to slap him about a bit by the end, but it's not like that's a magic wand fix for everybody...


1. The Nexus

Vince McMahon
WWE

Everybody seemed to enjoy sticking one in at the expense of the flailing and failing Nexus, from Mark Henry out-running half of them during a chase scene, CM Punk forcing them to endure physical and emotional trials after usurping Wade Barrett as the group's leader or John Cena getting his way over a SummerSlam 2010 finish that derailed them for good.

This was at very least not that, but Vince McMahon might have overestimated just how much heat beating the sh*t out of him could realistically generated when Barrett and co destroyed him during their original surge.

Believing himself to safe against their gang attacks, McMahon was in fine mood as a sh*thouse special guest referee having witnessed Nexus see off longstanding rival Bret Hart, but he was next on the list as the group increased their vice-like grip on control of Monday Night Raw.

It was sort of awesome in and of itself, what with McMahon having that stodgy selling energy and the newcomers obviously being told to go big on the big boss. Unfortunately, there was no follow-up beyond a gag several months later where he awakens from a coma due to the heavy losses incurred by wife Linda in her state senate campaign, that itself was was part of a Stephanie McMahon dream sequence.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.