10 Wrestlers Who DESPERATELY Need Something New In 2026
Some wrestlers in WWE or AEW need a heel/face turn or a new character completely to freshen things up
You can't reinvent the wheel, but in professional wrestling, you can at least change the tires when you've got a flat.
There is arguably more talent now in AEW and WWE than ever before, but not everyone is reaching their full potential. Plenty wrestlers are stuck going nowhere, with characters that have grown stale, or they've had a rough patch that has lasted long enough that they are stuck and need something to break the cycle.
Some could use a heel or face turn to freshen things up, like Ricky Saints just had in NXT. Austin Theory being brought into The Vision and Jey Uso returning to a tag team role, or Marina Shafir's growth under The Death Riders are all examples of turning things around for the better.
This isn't about kicking someone when they're down, but calling attention to the people who are worth saving from their downward spiral. Sometimes, a few small tweaks are all it takes. Other times, they might even need to leave the company entirely.
With the new year comes the momentum for big changes, so over the course of 2026, here are some wrestlers who are desperately in need of something new.
10. Chris Jericho
Chris Jericho has made a career out of reinventing himself, having done it numerous times over nearly 40 years.
Not every new gimmick has worked. For every "you've just made the list" catchphrase that gets way more over than anyone would have anticipated, there's a Painmaker that is met more with eye rolls.
In AEW, he's had three versions of the same exact stable with The Inner Circle, The Jericho Appreciation Society, and The Learning Tree. They're all just a group of sycophants (in the first two, mostly the same people, too) who tend not to get anything out of it by the time it ends.
Jericho's last stretch was quite literally just rehashing his "The Ocho" gimmick as ROH world champion, but this time, "The Nueve" instead. Does anyone really want "The Diez" in 2026?
Speculation has revolved around his return to WWE for a retirement run. A change in scenery and the motivation around using up all leftover creative juices for one last run could be what saves Jericho from fully turning into one of the many legends who stuck around longer than they should have.
9. Josh Briggs
The only time Josh Briggs has felt natural and gotten over with the crowd in NXT was when he was teaming with Brooks Jensen and in a faction with Fallon Henley and Kiana James, and hasn't recovered since that breakup.
In 2024, Briggs was given the obligatory heel turn to focus on singles competition, but it didn't take. Unfortunately, WWE tried to just hit the reset button and do the same idea a second time.
After teaming with Yoshiki Inamura as babyfaces, he turned on his partner, feuded with him, and quickly found himself back in the same rut as before as a singles heel as a big guy who loses to other people.
That's all his character is: a generic tough guy who complains that he sucks. He just happens to have a smoking skull on his shoulder as well, which nobody seems to care about. That doesn't give him any real personality.
Whether it's a new tag team partner, a shift to the main roster under different writers, or just trying different characters until something sticks, if Briggs keeps this same act going throughout 2026, he'll eventually be considered a lost cause, and he's better than that.
8. Jay White & The Bang Bang Gang
Jay White spent the majority of 2025 sitting on the shelf from injuries which still have him out of action. There's no telling when he'll be back, but when he does return to AEW, it will do him no justice to just resume his prior activities and pick up where he left off.
His 2024 includes holding both the AEW World Trios Championship and the ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Championship, along with two wins over "Hangman" Adam Page, but he was still supplemental on the roster. None of that actually amounted to a significant jump up on the hierarchy toward a world title, or even a midcard championship.
If the intention is for Switchblade to be in the "jobber to the stars" upper-midcard role and nothing more, then staying stagnant there is fine. But if he's going to be the main event caliber talent he's proven himself to be, something has to change.
The Gunns and Juice Robinson aren't currently "cool" enough to be super over babyfaces to the level they need to be and they aren't threatening as heels. White leading them won't change that. They'll just keep spinning their wheels, directionless.
7. Zaria
Remember when Zaria was hyped up to be on par with stars like Stephanie Vaquer and Rhea Ripley and treated like she was part of the crop of the most talented women's roster? WWE seems to have forgotten once they formed the ZaRuca tag team.
Credit where it's due, Sol Ruca deserves all the upward momentum she's achieved in 2025. She's amazing and will assuredly be on the main roster soon enough.
But in pushing her, WWE has ignored Zaria's progress. Despite being one of the biggest women on the brand, she's lost her mystique and power after being booked as the fall-girl to further advance Ruca.
Lately, she's been specifically a loser who goes on record losing a belt she's never even held, which is a rarity. Why is she Ruca's emotionally unbalanced, incapable friend, instead of a dominant warrior in her own right?
Ideally, Zaria turns on Ruca. Their feud can be Ruca's send-off to Raw or SmackDown, while Zaria can build more steam as a monster. But that ultimately has to end with her holding the NXT Women's Championship to really cement her as someone to watch out for in the future.
6. Grayson Waller
Splitting A-Town Down Under originally looked like it would lead to a big push for Grayson Waller, while Austin Theory was left in the dust. Over 2025 - and specifically in the past few weeks - that has proven to be entirely the opposite case.
Waller being paired with The New Day has been a step back for his career, which is strange considering how great Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods are. One would think being associated with arguably the greatest tag team of all time would be a positive thing.
The problem is that "Big G" just isn't Big E, and WWE isn't even trying to put any emphasis on him. At best, he's the "you said it, boss" type of underling. At worst, he's just ringside and might as well not even be there, or relegated to a promo during a commercial break nobody will see. None of this is increasing his star power.
Waller has the potential to be the next Miz, but only if WWE actually pushes him. The Miz won titles and was a prominent character. Waller is just stuck in supporting player limbo.
5. American Made
It isn't strange for a faction to revolve around its leader, but 2025 exposed just how much American Made is lost without Chad Gable.
The Creed Brothers and Ivy Nile were all discarded for the majority of this year, simply because Gable has been out of action with an injury.
If they've done anything at all, it's been sporadic losses on do-nothing shows like WWE Main Event that the company itself doesn't even acknowledge existing, meaning WWE sees little to no value in Nile, nor Julius Creed or Brutus Creed as a team or as individuals. Essentially, if they aren't standing behind Gable, they're worthless.
That is horribly hopeless for people with such talent and potential. At one point, Julius in particular was heralded as a major star in the making who only needed to work on his promo skills, but had everything else going for him.
None of them are going to succeed if they aren't even given the chance to do so, and if WWE can't figure out any way to utilize them for months other than to be Gable's lackeys, they need to move on to something else, change up their characters, or at least split up.
4. Private Party
"Oh my god, is that Private Party?" More like oh my god, where is Private Party?
Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen won the AEW World Tag Team Championship from The Young Bucks in October 2024, only to drop them at the start of the year on January 22, 2025 to The Hurt Syndicate.
That was their last appearance in All Elite Wrestling for the entire year. Their only other match anywhere, actually, was at HOG City of Dreamz in March.
Nothing has been reported that either of them are injured, so why are they just sitting out the entire year? Does Tony Khan truly have no idea how to utilize them a single time in over five hours of AEW/ROH programming per week for nine whole months?
If and when they return to AEW, having them come back as their previous selves will likely not get a great reaction or put them back in the title scene. They'll probably be back to their previous spot of being good hands who lose.
Maybe it's time to see what they can do outside of AEW in a company like TNA or even NXT, if WWE is interested. Under different writers, they could recapture the magic.
3. Michin & B-Fab
Michin has never been given much of a chance to succeed in WWE, dating back to her NXT days under her Mia Yim name. B-Fab is in an even worse spot, where it seems WWE keeps her around without even wanting her to wrestle more than once every few months.
Not everyone can be at the top, and that's okay. But when WWE actively pigeonholes someone into a particular loser spot and only ever books them to do the same three things on a loop, how are they expected to break the cycle?
It's always a pattern of Michin and B-Fab having issues with someone backstage, Michin uses her kendo stick to beat them up, only to then repetitively lose a series of matches. B-Fab is thrown in once in a while to eat a loss to "freshen things up" and fill in for Michin.
If we're to believe they're tough, they need to win matches, and if WWE can't stomach having them do that on the main roster, maybe it's time for them to move them to NXT or EVOLVE.
Otherwise, it's this enhancement talent spot forever until their inevitable releases.
2. Rusev
Someone who goes by the moniker of "The Redeemer" shouldn't need his fifth or sixth career redemption, but that is where Rusev is at after what has largely been a failure of a return to WWE.
The Bulgarian Brute had grown stagnant in WWE and left for AEW, where he struggled a bit, started to gain some ground with his TNT Championship run, and then fizzled out completely.
Upon returning to WWE after a long absence, that was his chance to be reinvigorated, but he ran into the same problem that effected Andrade and to an extent, Aleister Black: they were just the same presentation as they've been for years, except hoping for a bigger push.
Rusev in 2025 wasn't the monster he used to be, nor the fun "Rusev Day" gimmick. He's just another guy who goes out once in a while, wrestles, and sometimes wins. Put him in a tag team with Sheamus, who is in a similar position. Make him a mentor to a guy like Jasper Troy.
Or, if you want him to still do the Redeemer gimmick, put him on NXT and have him be the obstacle the younger talent needs to go through.
1. Apollo Crews
The clock has been ticking on figuring out what to do with Apollo Crews for years at this point and might very well be a few seconds to midnight.
Despite having the look and all the in-ring skills necessary to be a huge star, he's always been stuck in two camps: midcard champion that doesn't quite click, or a forgotten about reliable enhancement guy.
Admittedly, if he called it a career today, he could hold his head high for having some more success than most people with those title reigns. But considering how much more potential he's had wasted, he could have been more.
With him spending the entirety of 2025 injured, only stepping back in the ring for a match at AAA around Thanksgiving, and having a fruitless feud with Santos Escobar and tag team with Baron Corbin in 2024, it's time for a fresh start. Crews would be a perfect person to lend to TNA to be a bigger fish in a smaller pond and see what creative juices flow while under different management.
If not, maybe try the tag team route and put him with Tyriek Igwe and Tyson DuPont as their new mentor since losing Wes Lee?