10 Wrestlers Who Shouldn't Return For WWE's Brand Split 2016 This Week
Not every former WWE star has a place in the company's future.
This is a time of great opportunity in World Wrestling Entertainment. The 2016 brand split is on the horizon, and the company is preparing to split its talent roster in two and divide them among Raw and SmackDown. Even if WWE don’t succeed in putting their two top shows on an equal footing, slicing each show’s available talent pool in half will open-up plenty of airtime for underused, under-pushed wrestlers.
But with WWE already struggling to fill-out their shows as it is, their existing roster just isn’t big enough. They’re almost certainly going to have to throw a few new faces into the mix, and with rumours of former stars returning and “up to a dozen” NXT callups, WWE look set to completely revitalise their talent pool.
The internet has been buzzing at the mention of names like Kurt Angle and MVP ever since, and the free agent pool is bursting with former WWE performers who could be brought back in next week’s draft. Some should be welcomed back with open arms, but others? Not so much…
For myriad reasons ranging from age to attitude problems, there are some wrestlers that WWE should steer well clear of.
Here are 10 wrestlers who shouldn’t return for the 2016 Brand Split...
10. Ezekiel Jackson
Making his WWE debut in 2008, Ezekiel Jackson was absolutely fine in his role as The Brian Kendrick’s bodyguard, where all he had to do was stand still, look scary, and tip the scales in Kendrick’s favour.
Jackson was even able to hide his weaknesses and maximise his strengths while working as Kendrick’s tag partner, but his shortcomings became very apparent as soon as he stepped-out of the former Spanky’s spotlight and into his own.
A plodding, unexciting power wrestler with little in the way of personality, Big Zeke looked like the Incredible Hulk, but moved like a snail in peanut butter. Vince McMahon’s obsession with size over skill afforded Jackson a considerable push, but his run as Intercontinental Champion fell flat, and the less said about his status as the last ever ECW Champion, the better.
The 6’4”, 300lbs+ Ezekiel Jackson is a free agent after a prominent run during Lucha Underground’s first season, and can currently be found moonlighting in a host of different indies across the United States and Europe. In an era where smaller, faster, more dynamic wrestlers are finally prospering over plodding giants, Jackson is exactly the kind of wrestler WWE doesn’t need.
9. Tommy Dreamer
One of the most beloved ECW wrestlers of all-time, Tommy Dreamer wore-out his WWE usefulness a long time ago. His career’s best work came close to two decades ago, and while Dreamer will always deserve recognition for his incredible work ethic and helping to put ECW on the map, there’s little purpose for him on Raw or SmackDown post-draft.
WWE have regularly dipped into ECW’s legacy for nostalgia-based pops ever since the ill-fated Invasion angle. From the One Night Stand pay-per-views to their own ill-fated ECW reincarnation, Vince McMahon’s creative team aren’t shy of pilfering ECW for the sake of a quick buck.
This has cooled-off in recent years, but Dreamer was at the heart of the most recent example, having teamed with The Dudley Boyz and Rhyno as “Team Extreme” in a brief 2015 feud with The Wyatt Family.
Tommy’s still good for the odd one-off novelty appearance every now and then, but that’s about it. There’s absolutely no reason for him (or any other ECW original, for that matter) to be taking-up air-time ahead of younger, hungrier athletes whose best years are still ahead of them.
8. Mr. Kennedy
One of WWE’s most entertaining superstars through his initial 2005-2009 run, Mr. Kennedy was a solid wrestler and an A+ microphone worker. His old-school mic spot and trademark over-the-top introductions gave him an instant character hook, and he built a great deal of fan support by producing solid gold every time he was allowed to talk.
Once earmarked as a future main eventer, Kennedy’s WWE career met a disappointing end amid several reports of botches from other wrestlers, most notably Randy Orton. He’d go on to find success as a two-time TNA World Heavyweight Champion under the Mr. Anderson monicker, but left the company earlier this year after failing an on-the-spot drug test.
Coupled with the botches and an alleged history of PED abuse, this makes it unlikely that we’ll ever see Mr. Kennedy in a WWE ring again, but you never know with Vince McMahon. It’d be nice to hear his introduction again, sure, but Kennedy never evolved into the elite-level professional wrestler that everyone thought he would, and at 40 years-old, it’s unlikely he will.
7. Cryme Tyme
Shad Gaspard and JTG were a lot of fun as a mid-level comedy act in WWE’s Tag Team division throughout the late 2000’s. The gimmick grew stale over time, but Cryme Tyme were an entertaining act with great chemistry who always delivered in their backstage skits, especially throughout their 2008 feud with John Morrison and The Miz.
So what’s the problem? WWE already have the Golden Truth and BreezeDango to fill their low-tier comedy tag team quotient, so there’s no real use for them in 2016. They’re also not all that good in the ring, and the last thing WWE’s tag division needs is another subpar set of wrestlers as they attempt to rebuild their long-suffering Tag Title scene.
Then there’s the gimmick. You can argue that it crossed the line of bad taste back in 2008, but now? It’d sink like the Titanic. Cryme Tyme always portrayed themselves with a strong hint of irony, but in an increasingly PC world, there’s no place for an act that leans so heavily on negative stereotypes.
6. Scott Steiner
Scott Steiner is a borderline crazy person who’s done nothing but criticise the WWE’s operations since his 2004 release. His longstanding issues with WWE management make him the least likely to return of anyone on this list, but if Vince McMahon can forgive the Ultimate Warrior, he can forgive anybody.
One of many big name superstars that chose to wait-out their lucrative WCW contracts rather than slash it in half and join WWE for the Invasion angle, Steiner eventually debuted in late 2002. Handed a huge contract by McMahon, WWE had high hopes for the former WCW Champion as a main event-level performer, but the experiment was a huge failure.
The Genetic Freak faded badly after losing his first big match with Triple H, and went on to work extensively with the unheralded likes of Christopher Nowinski and Test before his eventual departure.
Once one of the best wrestlers in America, Steiner is long in the tooth and well past his prime. At 53, he’s perfectly suited to his current role as a novelty act on smaller scale independent shows. He’s too old, slow, and unpredictable for another run at this level.
Here’s hoping WWE agree.
5. X-Pac
From his relationship with Chyna to his well-documented troubles with drugs and alcohol, X-Pac has endured more than his fair share of personal turmoil over the years. It’s great that he’s been able to clean up and get back on track in this regard, but his time as a big stage performer has long since come and gone.
Though heavily criticised in the latter stages of his WWE career, X-Pac was always one of the company’s better wrestlers. He got himself over as a small guy during a time period when WWE was very much a giant’s playground: he deserves immense credit for that, but the industry has changed.
In an era where smaller athletes like Seth Rollins and Sami Zayn continue to grow in prominence, X-Pac has lost his unique selling point.
Then there’s the “X-Pac Heat”: a negative crowd reaction brought-on not because the recipient is an effective heel who the fans want to see lose, but because the fans just don’t want to see him/her wrestle at all.
X-Pac will always have this stigma attached to his name, and while he’s still fine for the odd DX regurgitation here and there, fans would soon grow tired of him should he re-emerge as a full-time performer.
4. Rob Van Dam
RVD was outstanding upon entering WWE during the Invasion. Despite technically wrestling for the heel Alliance faction, Van Dam was universally cheered by the WWE audience who admired his eye-catching in-ring style and flashy move-set.
One of the few former WCW/ECW talents to truly break out after the angle’s conclusion, Van Dam remained one of the company’s most popular wrestlers throughout his first run, and held the WWE Championship for a brief period of time in 2006.
Unfortunately, things started to fall apart shortly after RVD was chosen to spearhead WWE’s ECW revival. Once suspended due to his fondness for smoking a certain medicinal plant, Van Dam never recovered his lost momentum, and had completely ran out of steam by the time he returned to WWE in 2013 following a 3-year TNA run.
RVD was tired, uninspired, and unexciting throughout his second WWE spell. He’d lost much of the speed and agility that made him famous in the first place, and should he return next week, it would only tarnish the 45-year-old's legacy as a high-flying pioneer.
3. Rey Mysterio
An exciting, trendsetting high-flier who reached great heights and amassed immense popularity throughout his runs with WCW and WWE, Mysterio was released in 2015 after a long, drawn-out contract dispute. He’s since played a starring role for Lucha Underground and Mexico’s AAA, and while not the wrestler he was 10 years ago, Mysterio continues to produce the goods on a gentler schedule at this late stage in his career.
Unfortunately, Rey had sunk into irrelevancy long before his WWE release. The company lost faith in him and his seemingly perma-injured legs, so they pulled far away from the main event scene and left him floating around the midcard as Sin Cara’s tag team partner.
His fan support dwindled as a result, and by the time he left, nobody was really mourning Rey Mysterio’s WWE departure.
It’s just too soon for him to come back. Mysterio might return under a limited appearance Legends deal in the future, but it’s barely been a year since he left. The staleness that had plagued his WWE career’s latter stages hasn’t fully dispersed yet, and likely won’t for at least another couple of years.
2. Goldberg
Another ex-WCW’er who skipped the Invasion and debuted later, Goldberg’s long-awaited WWE run should’ve been impossible to mess-up but, lo and behold, they found a way.
WWE rushed Goldberg straight into a high-level program with The Rock and tried to present him as the monster of old, but the fans couldn’t buy into it. Booed in his first match with The Great One, throughout his feud with Chris Jericho, and even while working against the company’s top heel, Triple H, Goldberg’s “monster face” persona failed miserably.
Goldberg’s appeal came from his look, presence, and power. These are the qualities that helped get him over throughout his supposed 173-match WCW winning streak, but fan interest started declining as soon as the streak ended. “Unstoppable” has a shelf-life, and Goldberg’s had long since expired.
Bowing out with an infamously bungled WrestleMania XX match against Brock Lesnar, throughout which both wrestlers were booed relentlessly, Goldberg’s WWE run was an unmitigated disaster on the whole. The thing that made him special in the first place - his mystique - died a long time ago, and he was always a basic, un-engaging wrestler in the first place.
There’s no reason to bring Goldberg back at this point, particularly if it’s going to be at the expense of the younger, more exciting wrestlers currently sitting atop WWE’s card.
1. The Great Khali
Think about all the great professional wrestlers that have risen to prominence in WWE lately. Consider names like Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens: elite level performers with athleticism, technical ability, and charisma. Seasoned on the indy scene and polished at the Performance Centre, they’re the kind of wrestlers who make WWE worth watching.
Then consider The Great Khali. Gigantic, slow, unsteady, and incapable of mumbling anything other than the odd slurred sentence or incoherent grunt, he is the antithesis of a modern day WWE wrestler. Khali is the perfect example of a wrestler being signed solely for his image, and to bring him back at this stage would be a huge step backwards for a company that’s made great leaps and bounds with its signing procedures.
Other than the man himself, nobody’s clamouring to see The Great Khali back in WWE. The guy could barely execute a big boot without botching, and genuinely looked like he had trouble walking around the ring at times, let alone trying to wrestle. Being huge just isn’t enough, and The Great Khali is living proof of that.
From 2007’s infamous Punjabi Prison match to his WrestleMania 23 stinker against Kane, The Great Khali’s back catalogue is a mess. He might’ve been useful as WWE’s Indian ambassador, but he had no value as an in-ring competitor or personality in 2006, let alone 10 years later.