10 Wrestlers Who Turned Down Title Reigns
Millions of fans dream of being champion, but these performers decided it wasn't for them.
If you are reading this, the chances are good that you have once dreamt of holding a professional wrestling championship above your head. We've all dreamt of that moment of realisation, where all the hard work has culminated in holding gold aloft in front of cheering fans. Okay, some might have imagined such a moment with all the fans booing, but the point stands. For many, winning gold is the reason for getting into wrestling.
Why on earth, in that case, would a performer decline a championship reign? There can be a lot of reasons, from pressure to politics to injury and more, but it remains an occurrence that manages to be simultaneously rare and more common than you may realise. Booking plans are always subject to changes, and every now and then that change comes because a man or woman has decided that being champion isn't for them at that particular time.
Each to their own, of course, but fans can be forgiven for finding the idea perplexing. Aren't championships the crowning glory of all this? Isn't the wrestling industry famous for a 'by any means necessary' attitude that involves scrambling over the heads of peers in a race to the top? In such an environment, who would dare turn down the chance to be champion?
These performers, that's why.
10. Bret Hart
The WWE Intercontinental Championship is one of the most misunderstood titles in WWE history. Many fans still have it in their heads that the belt is one of magnificent lineage, the perfect stepping stone for a midcard performer to make the vaulted leap to the main event. Sure, that happens, but nowhere near as often as it should for such a reputation to stand. For every Triple H, The Rock and Steve Austin, there was a Godfather, Rikishi or Ezekiel Jackson. After all, only 43% of Intercontinental Champions also won World Championships in WWE.
When fans think of their idealised IC title, it is Bret Hart that they are really thinking of. In 1991, Hart was a tag team guy ready to break into the big time, a break that came with a win over Mr Perfect at SummerSlam 1991 for the secondary title. Within a year, Hart was WWE Champion, solidifying an idealised existence for the championship in the process.
A few short years later (1997, for the record), The Hitman was in line to become Intercontinental Champion once again. That sounds all good and well, but Bret was a bona fide main eventer at that point. What's more, the man he was in line to beat for the title was a blossoming newcomer by the name of Rocky Maivia. Luckily for the future Rock, Hart wasn't one to fall prey to petty politics, and the Calgary-born star refused to take the title from the third generation performer.
Bret won the WWE Championship again shortly after, holding it through the year until dropping it to Shawn Michaels at Survivor Series, in a match that wasn't controversial at all. Nope, not in the slightest.
9. Chris Benoit
For the sake of brevity, please insert the usual Chris Benoit disclaimer here. Talking about Benoit is a difficult subject for obvious reasons, but expecting to navigate the choppy waters of modern pro wrestling history without his name coming up is naive at best. Separating Chris Benoit the professional wrestler from the Chris Benoit who committed those horrific acts is easier said than done.
By the beginning of 2000, Benoit was the figurehead of a group of performers who had had enough of WCW's ineptitude. Along with Dean Malenko, Eddie Guerrero and Perry Saturn (and Konnan and Shane Douglas, but that didn't come to pass), Benoit was on the way out, and there was nothing that WCW could do to change his mind. Not even a run with the WCW World Heavyweight Championship.
Undeterred, WCW went ahead and put the belt on Benoit at Souled Out 2000, having him defeat Sid Vicious in a main event refereed by Arn Anderson. Less than 24 hours later Benoit had relinquished the belt and left for WWE, rejecting the title reign that WCW had desperately offered him at the very last.
While on the subject, go back and take a look at that Souled Out card. Yikes. Oklahoma vs. Madusa? Vampiro vs. David Flair & Crowbar? Kevin Nash vs. Terry Funk in 2000? Yeeesh. It is incredible that WCW made it to 2001.
8. X-Pac
First thing's first, the term 'X-Pac Heat' needs to be removed from wrestling parlance. Sean Waltman was one of the best wrestlers of a generation, a genuine trailblazer who paved the way for smaller guys in the business and had a conveyor belt of great matches along the way. If anything, 'Jeff Jarrett Heat' makes a lot more sense, right?
Despite his excellence, X-Pac found himself stuck in the cruiserweight/lower midcard part of the roster, winning WWE Light Heavyweight and European Championships regularly without really advancing. By the time the Monday Night Wars came to a close in 2001, Waltman could be forgiven for thinking he was in line for a more prominent space on the card. Instead, he found himself exactly where he had been beforehand, feuding with Tajiri over the Light Heavyweight and Cruiserweight Championships.
X-Pac did all he could to avoid this, largely because it meant less money. However, the former Syxx is unique in this list in that he was unable to avoid his destiny. Vince McMahon got his way, and X-Pac was the junior heavyweight champion once more. Two months later he dropped the title to Billy Kidman, and that was Waltman done in a position of any prominence in WWE.
7. Eddie Guerrero
More than 15 years have passed since the death of Eddie Guerrero, but Latino Heat is as missed by fans today as he has been ever since the horrible news broke. Where Eddie was in his career at the time of his passing shouldn't come into the discussion - he'd be terribly missed whatever - but the fact that he had seemingly put his demons behind him and was primed for another run at the top made it sting that little bit more. Eddie Guerrero died with a single World Championship reign on his résumé, but his career was worth far more than those numbers suggest.
It could have been more, but Eddie himself turned down the title for fear of the damage the spotlight could do. The first refusal actually came when Eddie himself was WWE Champion, and Latino Heat requested the title be taken off him so that Eddie could deal with some personal issues. If you were ever wondering why Bradshaw seemed to fly from the middle of the card to the top, you have your answer.
A year later, Eddie was once again in position for a run as champion. Batista was WWE Champion but The Animal was nursing several injuries, so management decided to go with Guerrero on top. Latino Heat reportedly declined the championship reign, just a few short months before he passed.
With Eddie Guerrero, there are always going to be many 'what if' discussions, but they do seem trivial in the face of what happened. We were lucky to be able to watch Eddie, no matter the list of titles.
6. Chavo Guerrero
There is a little bit of word of mouth with this one, but such is the world of professional wrestling. Either way, you'd have probably given Chavo Guerrero a big title run at some point in his career on the strength of his entrance music alone, right? That "Ooooh, Chavo" is arguably the most underrated piece of entrance music in the history of WWE, and that is a hill your writer will gladly die on.
Still, Chavo Guerrero, WWE Champion? That seems like a stretch, even considering the strength of that marvellous theme. That is exactly the scenario that Chavo claims he was offered in the wake of his Uncle Eddie's passing in 2005. Chavo had actually segued into a bizarre run as Kerwin White at the time, only to revert back to Chavo soon after. The multi-time WWE Cruiserweight Champion claims that WWE offered him a whole heap of stories at the time including a major title reign, but Chavo turned them down.
Of course, this had led some to speculate that the Rey Mysterio World Title reign was initially intended for Chavo, but that also seems like a stretch. When Eddie passed, Rey was a main event star waiting to happen. Chavo? He was Kerwin White.
5. The Undertaker
What could have been. Wrestling history is full of those discussions, so let's jump into another one. We already know that Eddie Guerrero reportedly asked to drop the WWE Championship in the summer of 2004 and that John 'Bradshaw' Layfield ended up dethroning him. Was JBL the only option? A look at SmackDown's roster in 2004 makes it clear that the obvious was the case. The Undertaker, Big Show, Booker T and Kurt Angle were alternative options, although injuries scuppered one or two of them.
The first of those Hall of Fame names was pitched the idea of dethroning Latino Heat as champion, but the Deadman decided against the move. Undertaker had only just returned to his zombie mortician persona, after all, and obviously felt that rushing into the title scene wasn't the best of ideas. Besides, Eddie was a beloved babyface champion; better to have a dastardly heel knock him from the mountain he so desperately scratched and clawed his way up.
So The Undertaker said no, and the world was given Bradshaw: WWE Champion and main eventer. What would have happened had 'Taker decided to run with the title? Would JBL have still become JBL? Butterflies, hurricanes, and all that jazz.
4. Stacy Keibler
Who is the greatest female performer in WWE history to never win the Women's Championship? It is an interesting discussion point, largely because the lack of respect afforded to the division by the very company booking it has made for some curious champions and even more curious neglection. Stars like Emma, Maria and Summer Rae make solid arguments of their own, while current names like Liv Morgan, Dana Brooke and Sonya Deville have plenty of time to add their names to the annals of history.
In terms of crossover appeal and sheer star power, it is hard to look past the argument made by Stacy Keibler. A cursory glance at her Wikipedia page shows that the only titles Keibler won in her seven-year career in WWE and WCW were the prestigious 'Babe of the Year' (2004) and Nitro Girl Search (1999) awards. Sure, Stacy was never a constant presence in terms of actual matches, but that wasn't exactly a prerequisite to winning gold in WWE.
Keibler was offered title reigns on several occasions, most notably via a potential WrestleMania 21 showdown with then-Women's Champion Trish Stratus. Each time, Keibler decided against it, preferring instead to work primarily as a valet as opposed to an in-ring talent. Who can blame her?
3. Torrie Wilson
Torrie Wilson wouldn't be far behind Stacy Keibler on the list of best women to never win gold in WWE, and for many of the same reasons. Torrie was hardly Dean Malenko in the ring, but she was about as far away from Dean Malenko as it got outside of the squared circle. Wilson was the apple of many a young man's eye in the dying days of the Monday Night Wars and the years that followed, so it is somewhat surprising that WWE never capitalised on that by putting the title on her.
It tried, most notably with the introduction of the WWE Divas Championship in 2008. Wilson was reportedly bandied about as a potential inaugural champion, but the Boise, Idaho native didn't consider herself the right choice to kick off that particular lineage. That honour eventually went to Michelle McCool, who defeated Natalya for the title at The Great American Bash in 2008.
Some reports suggested that Wilson rejected the title run because she didn't consider herself a worthy first champion. This could be true, but it is worth remembering that by the time McCool was defeating Natty for the title, Torrie had retired from wrestling. Wilson went into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2019, so all's well that ends well.
2. The Rock
That wretched JBL run with the WWE Championship sure is coming up a lot here. Eddie Guerrero requested to drop the title in the summer of 2004, The Undertaker wasn't overly keen on taking the belt from Latino Heat, so the world was given Blackjack Bradshaw as a main event talent. We all know how the reign ended, of course, with John Cena picking up the first of 16 world championships in an underwhelming match at WrestleMania 21.
Was Cena always in line to dethrone JBL? From a certain point on the calendar, it did seem as though Cena was the next cab off the rank, but reports at the time suggested that WWE management wasn't so sure. Funnily enough, they weren't entirely sold on Cena as the face of the next generation, so they made a play for The Rock to come back and dethrone the dastardly Texan.
Unsurprisingly, The Rock declined the opportunity. Rocky was well and truly in Hollywood mode by that point, and doing battle with Justin Hawk Bradshaw in a semi-main event at WrestleMania 21 wasn't going to light up the schedule, no matter how many Hollywood tags the company added to the event. Cena ended up getting the rub, and the rest is history.
1. Shawn Michaels
The career of Shawn Michaels really was a tale of two halves. In truth, there is little point in considering them two sides of the same star's career. Shawn Michaels 1.0 was the king of backstage politics, an elite performer obsessed with perception and position, no matter who it hurt. Championships were everything, relationships meaningless. Michaels held titles when he wanted, and relinquished them without being defeated when he wanted.
Shawn Michaels 2.0 was the polar opposite of that. A cursory glance at the championship record will tell you that much at least; in the eight years of his second coming, Michaels only held one singles title, and that came right at the beginning of the return. The Heartbreak Kid was offered world title reigns on several occasions during that second coming, only to turn them down in favour of feuds that would make new stars and allow HBK to put on great matches without the politics of being champion. In a word, maturity.
Every wrestling fan dreams of lifting a championship above their head, preferably at the end of a WrestleMania main event with, I don't know, 100,000 fans celebrating. Lost in all of that is the pressure and politics that championships bring. Shawn Michaels 2.0 was fully aware of such things, fully aware of the pitfalls that come with titles.