10 Wrestling Matches One Second Away From Perfection

Ridiculous analysis of the sublime - these iconic matches were only missing one second of magic.

Bret Hart Mr Perfect
WWE.com

The title of this list isn't intended to sound as pernickety as it might first read.

Wrestling's an art form and an enormously subjective one at that, and the idea that men and women could ascend towards objective perfection in such a thing is remarkable without some spineless dork on the internet reducing the achievement.

The broad church of opinions often dominates the discourse more than the content of the contests themselves. When Wrestling Observer doyen Dave Meltzer broke his own star rating scale (yet again) for the the fourth battle between Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega in 2018, there were likely as many people debating the supposed legitimacy of the rating as there were unpicking every last glorious moment.

Strange, possibly, but not unexpected. Perhaps the performers themselves weren't concerned with the conversations taking place as they were the overarching quality of their latest classic, but Meltzer's adoration sent many picking for nits. This remains an unfortunate reality of life in the upper echelon - the standards you've set are suddenly higher than ever. Lucky you, pro wrestling genius. You made it!

If we linger a little longer on the titular "perfection", it reduces the power of the ruinous "one second". All these matches ruled and you should watch them (again?) after reading this. Every bit of them. Even the part where...

10. Shawn Michaels Vs Mankind (WWE In Your House: Mind Games)

shawn michaels mankind
WWE.com

A total classic from a long run of them in 1996, Shawn Michaels and Mankind criminally only committed one match to camera during what may well have been the best in-ring year either ever had. But what a piece of work it was.

Though not booked or labelled as a hardcore match, this epic summoned all the blood and thunder one needs to be truly considered as such. Weapon use was kept to a minimum - they had their bodies for that.

Michaels was a Champion on the edge, whilst the deranged Mankind was a Challenger who didn't care to think about what his limits even were. The pair meshed impeccably, drawing genuine concern for 'HBK's reign and the sanctity of the "Boyhood Dream" he'd been living that summer.

It was impossible to pick a winner. Unfortunately, WWE identified that too. A screwy finish involving interference from Paul Bearer, Vader and Sycho Sid didn't just feel cheap, but looked it too. Bearer's urn shot to Michaels was enough to draw the disqualification, but extracted only groans from an otherwise elated audience.


9. Bayley Vs Sasha Banks (WWE Hell In A Cell 2020)

Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Intricate, layered and vicious, the Hell In A Cell 2020 SmackDown Women's Championship battle between Bayley and Sasha Banks was one of the best matches the pair ever had.

Consider the ground that covers, then remember that this one took place in the ThunderDome deep in the bowels of the global pandemic, and that this was the emotional climax of a feud that had lasted the better part of a year and that all of this had taken place in WWE of all places. Achievement on top of achievement on top of achievement, save for one spot that was cursed from the off all the way through to the 'Role Model' jacking it in at the end.

Banks was selling on the floor as Bayley pulled out some duct tape. The amount of time it took the Champion to find the end of the roll was relatable, but bordered on excruciating to watch. As was the outcome of her battle with it - an attempt to attach two kendo sticks together failed miserably, and whatever plan she had was quickly abandoned.

The match snapped back to its brilliant best just seconds later, but weaker pros might have struggled to squeeze past this plunder blunder.


8. London & Kendrick Vs David Taylor & William Regal Vs MNM Vs The Hardy Boyz (WWE Armageddon 2006)

Joey Mercury
WWE.com

Awesome as much because it ostensibly wasn't even supposed to happen let alone the fact that it simply ruled as a stunt-and-bump show, Armageddon 2006's four-team ladder war for the WWE Tag Team Championships may have flown under the radar as a genre gem had it not been for what turned out to be a rather life-changing split second.

When Joey Mercury's face was exploded by an errant (and even when it goes well, the margin for error still makes it worth avoiding) seesaw ladder spot, the contest entered the corridor of infamy rather than any kind of hall of fame. Mercury was a mess, and his rehabilitation contributed to issues he had with medication in the years that followed. The impact on his life was more than just a grisly visual for the night. The impact on the match was that it became almost entirely meaningless.

More's the pity - six of the eight took some utterly insane risks, and last two men David Taylor and William Regal were fish so far out of their water that it was mined for one of the more joyous (and safest) spots of the night.

It totally holds up, though cover your face even tighter than the former MNM man did if you're of a squeamish disposition.


7. Shawn Michaels Vs. The Undertaker (WWE WrestleMania XXV)

WrestleMania 25 Undertaker Botched Dive
WWE.com

It spoke to the quality of this match and both men in it that a potentially disastrous spot was instead converted into a moment of enormous drama by one of the quick-thinking competitors.

The Undertaker had just about hit the zenith of his in-ring career by WrestleMania 25, but he went some way to expediting its end after spiking himself during his iconic dive.

The planned spot called for a planted cameraman played by Sim Snuka to catch 'The Deadman', or at very least give him a softer landing than the arena floor. It infamously wasn't to be, and for a split second it looked as though a confirmed classic was climaxing early.

Fortunately for all involved, 'The Deadman' was able to play through the pain, arguably adding more lore to a 'Show Of Shows' masterpiece in the process. Not that he should have had to, of course. The gnarly bump dates the contest somewhat - it's possible and even probable that the match wouldn't have continued if this happened today.


6. The Quebecers Vs The Hart Brothers (WWE Royal Rumble 1994)

Owen Hart Royal Rumble 1994
WWE.com

"And that's why I kicked your leg outta your leg!"

Words that haunted Owen Hart in the immediate aftermath, even if the flub wasn't anywhere near disastrous enough to derail one of the best turns in company history. And what a match to build it off of.

The tag team title match at 1994's Royal Rumble existed mostly as a backdrop for the Hart Brothers fallout, but it f*cking ruled too. 'The Hitman' sold his bad leg as if The Quebecers had separated it from his body, and still shaped his body in such a way that Owen's post-match treachery felt exactly 1% justified.

This was art. Owen's impassioned and enraged post-match promo just one stumble away from being the same.

It happened again after the luxurious WrestleMania X classic between the brothers. In celebrating his victory over his more experienced sibling, Owen forgot to wipe the spittle from his face. It was distracting to the viewer if not 'The Rocket', ever-so-slightly tarnishing his crowning moment's post-script.


5. Owen Hart Vs Stone Cold Steve Austin (WWE SummerSlam 1997)

Steve Austin Injured Summerslam 1997
WWE.com

All fantastic until the final flourish, too many people know about the last few seconds of this SummerSlam classic without going back to review what made it so great in the first place.

Steve Austin's last technical masterclass until he finally got the surgery that temporarily rectified this very injury, this was a vintage display from a 'Rattlesnake' that had figured out exactly how to flit between brawler and mechanic. Owen Hart wasn't quite as perfect a foe as his older brother for Austin, but it begs the question what else they might have done had the closing moments not gone down as they did.

Keeping pace until the very last reversal, Austin met 'The King Of Harts' measure for measure in an unfathomably well-worked battle considering the crass stipulation attached. That made all the difference at the finale too - 1997 protocol wouldn't have allowed Austin to renege on his promise to kiss Owen's *ss if he'd lost, but the piledriver that just about broke his neck forced a cover that's as amazing as it is worryingly listless.


4. The Young Bucks Vs The Lucha Bros (AEW All Out 2019)

The Young Bucks and The Lucha Bros only know how to have classics, and while the risk has always proven worth the reward between the insane quartet, this was one near-miss that could have ended much worse than it did.

Wrestling's strange in this regard.- when the objective is to make it look like you're hurting your opponent, inflicting the most damage should theoretically add to the spectacle and realism. Unfortunately for the performers, most fans have seen more than their fair share of matches, and have an aye for something isn't quite as it should.

The spot here was one fairly familiar to genre fans, even if the correct execution of the move still isn't exactly an advertisement for health and safety. Penta's ladder push looked like any other until it became clear that Nick Jackson's trajectory was going to come up a little short.

The graceless tumble through a single table (and he almost didn't make that) didn't provide the noise nor visual most are accustomed too, and the landing didn't look quite as kind as the double tables splat often provides.


3. Razor Ramon Vs Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania X)

Shawn Michaels Razor Ramon WrestleMania X Ladder Match
WWE.com

Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon didn't devise or invent the Ladder Match at WrestleMania X, and WWE were wrong to gleefully perpetuate that myth for so many years.

And why lie? The truth was engaging, absorbing and amazing enough.

Fought over the disputed and once-prestigious Intercontinental Championship, this revolutionised not only what a Ladder Match could be, but what a stunt match could look like between just two wrestlers and very few bells and whistles other than the titular prop. Michaels and Ramon beat the f*ck out of each other with the dangerous implement of destruction, but at no point did it not seem in service of their respective attempts to win the secondary strap.

The violence was immaculately performed too, elevating the contest's status as an instant classic. All apart from an ending salvo where a trapped Michaels actually escaped from being tied in the ropes long enough that he believably could have stopped 'The Bad Guy' from scoring victory. Had the camera missed this - or Shawn simply undersold the situation instead of trying to give the New York faithful one last memorable moment - the pair probably would have gotten away with it.

Neither will lose sleep over it, of course. Not least when a follow-up presented a far greater gripe...


2. Shawn Michaels Vs Razor Ramon (WWE SummerSlam '95)

shawn michaels razor ramon
WWE.com

Razor Ramon and Shawn Michaels' WrestleMania X Ladder Match made history for all the right reasons in 1994, but their SummerSlam sequel just over a year later now finds itself criminally underrated as a result.

Theoretically tougher to tell stories with due to both guys now being babyfaces and the match only really existing because WWE knew it would be better than 'HBK's planned bout with Psycho Sid, the encounter called back to the Madison Square Garden classic while simultaneously pitching Michaels as gutsy and brave the second time around in contrast to the cold and calculated way he attempted to win their first war.

All of this was supposed to feed into a finish that put over the Champion's incredible athleticism even more so than his iconic splash at the 'Show Of Shows'. Rather than simply grasping the gold, he was supposed to jump from the ladder and grab the belt en route to a crash landing below. Unfortunately, it was hung too high.

After an awesome superkick across two ladders, Michaels dived for the swinging prize and whiffed. The pair improvised a finish that left Razor on the floor, but yet again the title was out of reach and he hit the floor. An almighty and of-the-time tantrum followed before he shinned back up and finally took down the (lowered) belt. It was clumsy and clunky, but it couldn't deny a classic.


1. Mr Perfect Vs Bret Hart (WWE SummerSlam 1991)

bret hart mr perfect summerslam 1991
WWE.com

It's fitting that the one second of frustration in this stone cold classic came not from a Perfect Intercontinental Champion nor a victorious challenger who justifiably called himself "The Best There Is, The Best There Was, and the Best There Ever Will Be", but from a referee who took the match home just slightly before it reached its epic peak.

Hart had barely locked on the Sharpshooter when the bell rang to award him his first singles title and confirm his overdue ascension up the card. Somewhat ironically, this was perhaps in keeping with reality - MMA's overtaking of pro wrestling in popular culture has revealed the instantaneous nature of the submission, and Perfect's back was absolutely f*cked IRL - but we didn't know that then.

Every other moment from this Madison Square Garden masterclass was measured impeccably, save for leaving just a little bit of room for fans to root for their hero as he seized his opponent's legs as well as his treasured belt.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.