8 Wrestlers WWE Pushed In The WORST Way Possible

Broken down by a WWE system designed to build you up, starring Roman Reigns, The Fiend and...Mr Ass?

Roman Reigns
WWE

More than ever before, WWE is hell-bent on giving off the impression that it is the all-seeing eye of professional wrestling. They know us their fans, they know their performers, and they know how to connect the two in the most effective way possible because they are the all-knowing WWE. Only we all know this is a big old load of baloney, and sometimes, WWE sabotages itself and its performers.

WWE are as guilty as anyone of not seeing what they have with world class performers. They're only human after all. There has been some incredible misjudgment of what makes a superstar great over the years, leading to botched pushes that have sunk even the best of wrestlers in the eyes of the audience.

At its worst, WWE can push a character that is so far from the zeitgeist that it's truly a wonder how a character ever made it to television. Plenty of other times, the world's biggest wrestling company has failed to understand what makes someone great in the first place or what will make the audience connect with that superstar. These are some of the worst pushes that WWE creative have ever cooked up. 

8. Dean Ambrose

Dean Ambrose vs. Dolph Ziggler
WWE

If you've read Jon Moxley's excellent 'Mox' autobiography, you'll know that he is deadly serious about the art of professional wrestling. The smell of the canvas, the contrast of styles that each performer brings to the table, the sheer physicality and grit of combat; these are the reasons that Moxley is in love with the squared circle. Nothing about the man is contrived or wacky, and his ridiculous run as Dean Ambrose is largely why his post-WWE career has evolved around gritty realism.

Dean Ambrose is one of the most egregious cases of WWE fundamentally misunderstanding a character in company history. When debuting in The Shield, Ambrose was the group's unhinged agent of chaos. WWE creative saw this psychotic menace and decided to turn it wacky.

Ambrose went from being viciously maniacal to being portrayed as an idiot who was out of control. The "Lunatic Fringe" (shudder) was no longer a feral berserker; he was so out of his mind and "zany" that he'd have a feud over a potted plant or bring a hot dog cart to the ring, squeezing ketchup and mustard into people's faces like something out of a Saturday morning cartoon. WWE had a killer on their hands, but instead decided to turn Pennywise the Clown into Krusty the Clown.


7. Roman Reigns

WWE TLC 2015 Roman Reigns Tater Tots Sheamus
WWE

Another member of The Shield that WWE completely misunderstood was Roman Reigns. If Rollins was the wrestling technician of the group and Ambrose was the brute force, Reigns was meant to be the group's cool factor. Laid back and methodical with a look to die for, Reigns' appeal was that he had ice in his veins and would be the embodiment of cool. The problem with this was WWE's creative did not understand cool whatsoever.

After Seth Rollins took a steel chair to The Shield and broke up the group, Reigns character floundered for years. Some of that was down to fans over being force-fed a guy after over a decade of eating John Cena for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, but a lot of it was down to Vince McMahon booking "a cool guy" with no idea of what it meant to be cool. 

As soon as Roman had Paul Heyman in charge of that concept, he became one of the coolest characters in WWE history. He delivers his lines like a mob boss, wearing the coolest shoes and clothes on the market. It's a long way from having to say "suckering succotash" to someone in a promo. His matches involve drama instead of being elaborate squashes. Vince McMahon's idea of cool is crushing all that stands before him, while fans love post-Vince Roman because he tells great stories. 


6. The Fiend

Bray Wyatt THE FIEND
WWE

Bray Wyatt suffered WWE creative not understanding his vision like few others in company history. His initial run worked so well because pro wrestling had never seen a horror-driven backwater character that had more in common with the grizzled protagonists of The Devil's Rejects and Wolf Creek than it did dry ice and Papa Shango-style shenanigans. Wyatt was forced to go back to the drawing board after WWE's main roster crashed this character into a wall, and he did so with aplomb with 'The Fiend'.

'The Fiend' was a macabre menace who debuted with superb, sinister vignettes and squashing Finn Balor in a devastating and visceral manner. It felt as though this was surely going to be Wyatt's time to shine, but WWE creative's fundamental inability to sell a horror-led character intervened in infuriating fashion.

Wyatt was part of one of the worst pro wrestling matches in modern history, losing to Seth Rollins via stoppage at Hell In A Cell, before being handed a cartoonish mallet that made him seem like something out of a Looney Tunes cartoon more than a member of Slipknot. To add insult to injury, this masked menace was then booked to lose the Universal Championship by jobbing to a 53-year old Goldberg in less than 3 minutes. 


5. Ryback

Ryback WWE
WWE.com

If we are to talk about Goldberg, the conversation must swing to Ryback. A 6'1 bald-headed monster who looked like he could benchpress a car, the idea was to push Ryback to the moon by brute force. WWE utilized his brutish look to have him maul opponents every week and soar to the top of the card. It worked for Goldberg in the late 90s, why wouldn't it work in 2013?

The problem was that fans were in a very different place at this point in time. This was the post-Pipe Bomb era, when fans were rooting for CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Dolph Ziggler, and workhorses who could go in the ring. Underdogs were the order of the day. People who felt like they weren't a product of the WWE machine, who were built to tell great stories more than to sell action figures.

Ryback appeared on WWE with an in-ring style akin to a kid playing an unbeatable video game character. He hit the same moves every week, won in the same fashion, and shouted catchphrases that felt like they'd come straight from a cheesy 80s action movie. Yelling "feed me more" while pumping your hands like a toddler and slapping your head like a linebacker felt dated, stale, and completely out of touch with the era he worked in.


4. EC3

EC3 WWE
WWE

Not everyone excels in every area of wrestling. The job of a creative team is to accentuate the positives of a superstar's arsenal, making him appear more than the sum of his parts. This is the exact opposite of what WWE did with EC3 when the two-time TNA World Champion and one of the most beloved wrestlers of that company's era hit their main roster. 

The concept was that EC3 was more suited to WWE's flagship shows than NXT. This felt like savvy thinking, as the black-and-gold era of NXT was about in-ring excellence, and EC3 excelled with a mic in his hands. He was charismatic and knew how to make fans feel their emotions, with a solid grasp of being an adored babyface or a despised heel.

There is absolutely nothing about this man that lent itself to being a mute, and yet that was the character he was given when appearing on the main roster in 2019. He would flex in front of mirrors, not saying a word. This nonsensical booking stripped EC3 of everything that made him stand out, making him dead in the water on WWE programming. He lasted less than a year before leaving the company for good. 


3. Muhammad Hassan

Dark Side Of The Ring Muhammad Hassan
VICE/WWE

The spicier side of a WWE fan's timeline is currently awash with the idea that the company would have had an ICE gimmick on Raw or SmackDown if Vince McMahon were still in control of creative. On the surface, it's just people poking fun at the disgraced billionaire's poor taste in his penchant for including the zeitgeist in his product. Muhammad Hassan's role in 2005 makes the grim prospect far more realistic.

Being frank about it, Muhammad Hassan was cartoonish rot. His over-the-top xenophobic promos, cliched attire, and masked henchmen who came in balaclavas to attack opponents were the kind of characters that embarrass fans for liking WWE. It was tone-deaf and childish, and made wrestling fans seem like simpletons who got off on reducing nuanced global issues to mindless parody.

As WWE becomes more of a global product than ever before, hosting multiple PLEs in Saudi Arabia no less, a character like Muhammed Hassan feels more like a bad fever dream of wrestling's past. In the words of Diamond Dallas Page, that is a good thing. 


2. King Mabel

King Mabel SummerSlam 1995
WWE

As a tag team wrestler, Mabel was a fan-favourite as part of Men On A Mission. At a time when WWE's New Generation was more cartoonish than ever, the tag-team was one of the few gimmicks that fans got behind as the company tried to find its way in the post-Hulk Hogan era. When a duo gets popular, head office are often guilty of wanting one of the team to become the star, and so Mabel was pushed into going solo when it didn't suit him at all.

As the bigger and stronger of the pairing, it was easy to see why WWE chose Mabel over his partner, Mo. The reality of the situation, however, is that Mabel was much better suited to being one half of a tag-team to hide his negatives and accentuate his strong suits. He was in no way ready to carry matches and the weight of a big push in WWE.

Mabel was pushed as King of the Ring in 1995 and headlined SummerSlam against Diesel that same year, but he was green in the ring and didn't have the personality for a role of this magnitude. To show how much this push failed, King Mabel was squashed in 8 seconds by Diesel on a December 18th, 1995 Raw taping, less than 4 months after the pair had headlined SummerSlam together. 


1. 'The One' Billy Gunn

billy gunn
WWE.com

'Bad Ass' Billy Gunn is one of the most recognizable talents of the Attitude Era. As part of D-Generation X and alongside Road Dogg in The New Age Outlaws, Gunn found a new lease of life for himself after falling short of the big time in The Smoking Gunns through the New Generation era.

After years of domination with Road Dogg and winning the tag-team championship 5 times with The New Age Outlaws, Gunn had a good thing going as 'Mr Ass'. While that feels like a ridiculous thing to say out loud, it fit perfectly in an era where asses were very much part of the WWE landscape. When changing gimmick to 'The One' Billy Gunn, he gained a great new entrance theme and a new haircut, but lost all momentum and relevancy.

Gunn won the Intercontinental Championship from Eddie Guerrero on the 21st November, 2000 episode of SmackDown, but lost it less than three weeks later. This felt like it hindered Gunn more than helped him, and he found himself without a place on the historic WrestleMania X7 card a few months later as the gimmick failed to get off the ground. Gunn later had a new lease of life with Chuck Palumbo, so 'The One' didn't kill his WWE career, but it certainly had him on life support for a minute there. 


Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.