10 WWE Nightmares That Could Come True In 2024
Royal Rumble disasters, World Title misery and CM Punk causing chaos in WWE.
2019-2023 was a wild period for WWE.
AEW launched as a hopeful competitor, WrestleMania took place in a training school, the company merged under one umbrella with UFC, Vince McMahon retired, returned and was put out to pasture again. Yeah, it's been a trip, so smart money goes on 2024 being chaotic too.
You know the deal when spotting that "nightmare" title though. This isn't about anything positive that could happen to WWE. Instead, the real focus here is on everything that could go wrong. Disasters, when put another way. Take any goodness and watch it go sour! Positivity? We don't need no stinking positivity.
Financially, WWE is in a really great place. The promotion rakes it in, so all of the nightmares spotlighted pile misery on an overworked creative team. Some key decisions from Triple H and his merry band of writers could, in theory, lead to some absolute carnage behind the scenes.
Speaking of which, might CM Punk's return irk settled stars like Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, Becky Lynch and more? Nothing is off the table when pre-analysing the coming 12 months.
Could this nightmare fuel happen?!
10. NXT Call-Ups Get Mishandled
It's only a matter of time before Bron Breakker, Tiffany Stratton, Roxanne Perez and Carmelo Hayes land on WWE's main roster. Truthfully, several of them have been ready to hit Raw and SmackDown for years, but this is a delicate process. Nobody wants to see any of the NXT standouts fail.
What if they do though? Oh God, what if they do?! What if Triple H has a Vince McMahon-sized brainfart and decides to repackage any of the four. Then, when quizzed, what if Hunter spews out the same guff about 'presenting these workers for a more casual market on the main roster'?
Breakker, Stratton, Perez and Hayes are fine as they are. None of the quartet's characters need to be tampered with, especially not when there's obvious crossover between viewers from Raw/SmackDown to NXT anyway.
These workers must be given every chance to succeed at a higher level. Going Keith 'Bearcat' Lee with them would be a huge mistake.
9. Jade Cargill Can’t Live Up To Hype
WWE has done a sterling job of treating Jade Cargill like an absolute star since she joined.
She’s had face-to-face moments with everyone from Charlotte Flair to Becky Lynch, and has been tailed by Triple H on TV. Hell, 'The Game' even ducked down a bit so Jade and Charlotte looked larger than life on an episode of SmackDown. That's dedication to your craft, good sir.
Here's the problem with hype though. It can be killer. AEW found out first hand that maintaining interest in Cargill was difficult if she wasn’t allowed to show any weakness. So, as time marched on and her unbeaten stretch deepened, people showed less and less appetite for more. That’s WWE’s challenge in 2024.
Grabbing Jade away from Tony Khan proved quite the coup for WWE. They'd be shooting themselves in the foot by going the same lazy Goldberg-esque winning streak with her, but Cargill can't be some out-her-depth loser either.
Balance will be everything.
8. Creative’s Interest In LA Knight Cools
If anyone thinks WWE's writers will fawn over LA Knight forever, then they need a reality check. This is a dude who went from playing heel manager for an undercard faction of models to striking hot as a breakout babyface, so nothing is guaranteed. Knight only has a finite period of time to ride the crest of that wave.
The fab merch returns and 'flavour of the month' reactions from creative will continue so long as booming crowd reactions remain. Or, will they? WWE previously ignored similar fanfare for Zack Ryder, and nobody needs to tell Bryan Danielson what it's like to be overlooked despite fan excitement.
Granted, that was under Vinnie Mac's watch. Triple H might be more inclined to keep pushing LA as fast and hard as he can throughout 2024. That'd be the dream outcome. The nightmare is somewhat different: Knight tumbling down the cards, WWE panicking to turn him heel, and then all that magic lost.
Yeah? More like NO!
7. SmackDown Goes 3 Hours
SmackDown will officially jump from FOX to the USA Network in October 2024. That'll end WWE's five year stay on the former, and mean NFL fans will be spared Joe Buck pretending he gives a toss about Roman Reigns and The Bloodline right before calling his latest snap alongside Troy Aikman.
Early word coming out of WWE's camp is that Raw might be heading elsewhere itself. That'd immediately turn SmackDown into the 'A' show unless Monday nights find another major network home. That's likely, but...what if the company scrambles and adds on a third hour to Friday nights?
SmackDown has been a snappier watch than Raw for years simply because it's 60 minutes shorter. Yes, Raw is easier to digest in the Triple H era, but there's no call for Smackers to go supersized any time soon. That two hour window is a sweet spot, and it must stay put.
8 hours of mainline WWE TV (including NXT) sounds bloated.
6. Two Unwanted Royal Rumble Winners
Feast your eyes on the image above and then imagine the same scene backstage after The Rock and Charlotte Flair win back-to-back Royal Rumbles this coming January. Both are big stars, so what's the problem? That could be what some fans think about all of this.
Then you've got those who fancy seeing the Rumbles used to build fresher stars.
LA Knight and GUNTHER are outside bets on the men's side, and it isn't impossible that Raquel Rodriguez, Jade Cargill or Tiffany Stratton could win the women's Rumble. All of those sound fresh, not least 'cause they'd be building towards something longer term.
Rocky or Charlotte grabbing wins they don't need might lead to fan rebellion (WWE won't want another Batista at 2014 on their hands), and it's hardly like either needs that sort of moment at this stage in their respective careers anyway.
Surprise us, WWE. The Rock can always go after gold just because he's The Rock.
5. The Bloodline Saga Has No Finale
This writer will argue until he's blue in the face that Cody Rhodes losing to Roman Reigns back at WrestleMania 39 was the right call, but even he can see that this Bloodline stuff is dragging on and on. Internally, WWE bigwigs would point to money and TV metrics as proof it still has value.
Fair enough, but nothing lasts forever.
The Bloodline has been too epic a story to drag on and on before fizzling out. Sadly, many can foresee exactly that happening in 2024. After all, creative still has more matches between both Uso brothers to work with, and they've yet to pull the trigger on Solo Sikoa vs. Roman Reigns.
Booking a tight, satisfying finale would be preferable to watching one of the best wrestling narratives ever slowly die out. Leaping off the ship before it starts sinking is often smart, and that's what WWE's writers need to do heading into the new year.
Or else!
4. WrestleMania Rejects The Rock
The Rock has always stood out as a "final boss" of sorts for Roman Reigns. WWE has been chasing that dream match for a few years now, and hopes remain high they'll finally put the pieces together in time for WrestleMania XL. There, "Rocky" chants will light up Philly and Roman will be 100% heel.
Well erm...about that.
Reigns has been hearing a few sprinkles of adulation throughout this entire Bloodline drama, and Philadelphia is a rowdy wrestling market. They might reject Hollywood, boo Dwayne Johnson and embrace Roman as their chosen one come 'Mania. That'd throw the whole story WWE surely plans to tell out of whack.
It'd suck if Philly rebelled and didn't let The Bloodline's natural conclusion play out properly, but WWE isn't actually in control of how people respond on the night. The knives would be out for Dwayne if things didn't go smoothly on night one, put it that way.
3. Triple H Splits The Undisputed Title(s) Again
Technically, WWE's main roster product featured three male World Titles across two top shows. Roman Reigns has amalgamated the WWE Title and Universal belts under one Undisputed banner for now, but that doesn't mean Triple H will keep such formatting forever.
Three top prizes is at least one too many, and everyone knows it.
Can you imagine how diluted things would be if Seth Rollins was running around on Raw as World Heavyweight Champ, Roman clutched onto the Universal Title over on SmackDown, and Cody Rhodes floated somewhere in between with the WWE prize? That'd be overkill for sure.
Hunter has a key decision to make in the new year. Does he just quietly hope people forget Roman's Undisputed Title is two distinctly different straps, or do WWE ditch the Universal gold in favour of going with twin WWE and World Heavyweight belts?
Choose wisely, Papa H. Too many titles would badly hurt your programming.
2. Raw’s World Title Gets Passed Around
Then, how about this?
WWE previously treated the old World Heavyweight Title as more of an upper card experimental belt than a proper headline prize. It was deemed perfect for trying on certain wrestlers at a higher level. Fail with the big gold, and they wouldn't get anywhere near the WWE Championship.
Unfortunately, that led to a game of pass the parcel which damaged credibility and made the strap look secondary next to the real top title. WWE shouldn't go down that road again with the newer World Heavyweight belt currently held by workhorse babyface Seth Rollins - there's really no need to.
Come 2024, it's vital that Raw's main championship looks prestigious. Lengthy title reigns are a must, otherwise the thing will end up feeling more midcard than main event. For example, there's no need for Damian Priest to cash in MITB, hold the strap for a month then pass it on to the next trial champ.
1. CM Punk Causes Backstage Chaos
You knew this was coming for two reasons.
Firstly, 'cause CM Punk was the featured image for this here piece. Second, because everyone expects fighting Phil to land back on WWE TV at some point. The company might've distanced themselves from that recently, but this is pro wrestling. There's also money to be made.
Would anybody really be shocked if Punk roared back into view with a Royal Rumble berth, or if he was deemed ideal for a match vs. Seth Rollins come 'Mania? Marquee matches opposite Rollins, Roman Reigns and a few others could drum up massive interest, but they'd come with a possible price.
WWE's locker room is fairly settled at the moment. No-one there wants anyone to come in and upset things, but Punk has a proven track record of causing chaos. He's a strong-minded individual, to say the least, and there's no chance WWE wants some of the PR nightmare AEW just lived.
Be very careful here.
What other WWE nightmares could come true in 2024? For more wrestling, check out 10 Dream Matches That WWE Can Still Offer and 10 Lost Gimmicks WWE Should Bring Back!