10 WWE Title Changes That Shocked The World
Title switches you just didn't believe.
Standing tall and sending thousands of fans wild simply by thrusting his hands in the air repeatedly, new WWE Champ Daniel Bryan reached the end of his journey upon winning the title at WrestleMania XXX. Meanwhile, some were shocked that WWE had vindicated Bryan's immense popularity by putting the belt on him.
At the same time, there was a sense that the title switch had to happen in 2014, because people were crying out for the change. That simply cannot be said for any of the WWE Title changes going under the microscope here.
The best title switches are often those that come completely out of left field and leave jaws on the floor. They don't always work out, but it's hard to criticise WWE for attempting a surprise. It would be a far bigger problem if there were none at all.
Whilst it's true that WWE softening their approach towards the importance of a lengthy reign over the years has hurt title credibility, it's also true that this outlook has fostered some of wrestling's most astonishing moments, for better or worse...
10. Eddie Guerrero (No Way Out 2004)
Bruce Prichard revealed during an episode of his 'Something To Wrestle With' podcast that Vince McMahon's first reaction upon meeting Eddie Guerrero in 2000 was, "he's so damn small." The boss's outlook on the Latino sensation's chances as a headliner had changed drastically by 2004.
How else could anyone explain why Guerrero was booked to defeat WWE pet project Brock Lesnar and become the promotion's top titleholder at No Way Out in February of that year?
It's true that Lesnar was on his way out of WWE and that Eddie had been a real success story as part of SmackDown's blooming Tag-Team and United States Title divisions since 2002, but there was still a sense of genuine shock when he hit a Frog Splash on Brock and pinned the muscle-man to become WWE's new champ.
Lesnar had seemed to be heading for a WWE Title showdown with Bill Goldberg at WrestleMania XX. Instead, that match was a mid-card washout compared to Guerrero's cracking tussle with Kurt Angle on the same show.
9. Edge (New Year's Revolution 2006)
Money In The Bank was still a fresh concept when Edge 'cashed in' his privileges on John Cena to become WWE Champion at New Year's Revolution on 8 January 2006. That freshness really helped sell the shock value of Edge's first WWE Title win, and coming hot off the heels of Cena's Elimination Chamber victory also didn't hurt.
The entire Money In The Bank premise is played out now, making Edge's cruel removal of the belt from Cena's grasp in '06 all the more entertaining for being so original. Even Cena toppling Edge to reclaim the gold less than a month later at the Royal Rumble pay-per-view can't take away from the exasperated feel of the audience at New Year's Revolution.
This was a brilliant moment, one that helped usher in Edge's stint as an established main event star in WWE without really harming John Cena's reign of dominance either. Still, nobody could quite believe what they were seeing when the Canadian stood with Lita and held the belt aloft as the show went off the air.
In terms of heel title wins, this was one of the best, no to mention one of the most sudden.
8. Andre The Giant (5/2/1988)
Andre the Giant's shady defeat of Hulk Hogan on 5 February 1988 would be much higher on this list if the monster hadn't then been stripped of the belt for trying to hand it off for money to the 'Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase straight afterwards.
Deemed a vacation of the title by then-WWF President Jack Tunney, the deal between Giant and DiBiase was also a key component of shock when fans realised the mighty Hulk Hogan had been beaten for the gold he had worn since 1984; watching The Main Event bout's conclusion now is stunning, because it was as though air had been sucked from the building when Hogan's shoulders were counted to the mat.
This would set the scene for Randy Savage as champion. It was swish of the WWF to deftly avoid the need for Savage to beat fellow babyface Hogan for the title, and Andre's 'victory' is still one of the most controversial moments in WWE history.
It's just a shame there was no genuine heel follow up for either Andre or DiBiase, because attention quickly turned to build for Savage vs. Hogan the following year.
7. Seth Rollins (WrestleMania 31)
As memorable as Edge's Money In The Bank cash in over John Cena was in 2006, it's true that the 'Rated-R Superstar' elected to trade his briefcase for gold after Cena had already won a match. Cunning heel Seth Rollins was booked to do things differently at WrestleMania 31.
During the match between Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar in the show's main event slot, the hand-picked Authority centrepiece intruded whilst the bout was still in progress and ended up leaving as the new WWE Champion. The in-and-out nature of Seth's win left both Reigns and Lesnar crestfallen, and the live audience were dizzy with drama.
The beaming smile of Rollins made his Money In The Bank surprise one of the most clever in history. Nobody had ever cashed in during a match before, so he instantly looked like one of the smartest heels the WWE roster had seen in years.
This was one heck of a way to close out the biggest show of 2015.
6. Kane (King Of The Ring 1998)
Nobody was a bigger star in pro wrestling than 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin in the summer of 1998; raring to go as a headliner for well over a year, the popularity of Austin was most rampant once he bagged the WWF Heavyweight Title from D-Generation X leader Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XIV.
Subsequent defences against all odds were to come, and matches against Dude Love at Unforgiven and Over The Edge were superb in their execution. It was as if the evil Mr. McMahon character would never be able to wrestle the title from his hated enemy, at least until the 1998 King Of The Ring and Kane came along.
For some reason, the WWF decided to temporarily end Austin's successful title reign for 24 hours, just so Kane could briefly hold the belt.
In a 'First Blood' battle on the June pay-per-view, The Undertaker's brother won his first WWF Title. Austin recaptured the strap the next night on Raw, but there was a hushed surprise over fans inside Pittsburgh's Civic Arena when their beloved 'Rattlesnake' was dethroned.
5. Sgt. Slaughter (Royal Rumble 1991)
Vince McMahon's decision to replace Hulk Hogan with The Ultimate Warrior as the WWF's face of the 1990s wouldn't pan out in the long run. In fact, the attempt to run with Warrior would barely last a full year, and he was stripped of the title just as calendars settled into 1991.
Instead of an established, hard-bodied WWF heel like Mr. Perfect or 'Ravishing' Rick Rude being chosen for the role of successor, the soft physique of Sgt. Slaughter (at least compared to Warrior's heaving level of muscle) was brought back and recast as a traitorous villain who aligned with Iraq against his native United States.
If only because of McMahon's desire to capitalise on real-life tension, the unlikely Sarge became WWF Champ come the '91 Royal Rumble at Warrior's expense.
Most probably knew that Hulk Hogan would be the one to defend the honour of his country and vanquish Slaughter at WrestleMania, but it was still striking to see the ageing military man return to the company and take the WWF's top prize from someone who had been shoved down fan throats as the guy who would lead them through the next decade.
4. The Undertaker (Survivor Series 1991)
Hulk Hogan was the one to bring babyface heroism back to the WWF Title throne by beating Sgt. Slaughter at WrestleMania VII. After The Ultimate Warrior experimentation, most likely believed the WWF would revert to type and Hogan's reign would be lengthy.
It most certainly wasn't: the Hulkster would lose the strap to The Undertaker (thanks to the help of Ric Flair) at Survivor Series 1991.
Admittedly, this in itself was an experiment; Vince McMahon wanted to produce more pay-per-views, and so he had Hogan's quest to reclaim the title from 'Taker in mind to help promote the This Tuesday In Texas show a mere six days after Survivor Series.
Nonetheless, seeing the pale 'Deadman' beat the heroic Hogan gave the November event a historic moment that could be talked about for years. This was Undertaker's first major title win too, and it definitely put him on the map as a top guy in the company. Any fallout fan shock from his brief foray as champion was worth that.
3. Ivan Koloff (18/1/1971)
There will never be a title reign like Bruno Sammartino's first in pro wrestling ever again, because the mere thought of anyone holding championship gold for 2,803 days is preposterous at best and laughable at worst. That's just not the way things work in the modern era.
Sammartino was a revelation as champ between 17 May 1963 and 18 January 1971, and the prevailing feeling from researching his time in the title hot seat seems to be one of consistent box office through fan happiness; wrestling enthusiasts loved seeing Bruno beat heels like Killer Kowalski and Buddy Rogers, and they were happy to continue paying for the privilege.
Imagine the shock then when his near eight-year reign was ended by the vile Ivan Koloff in Madison Square Garden.
The sense that Sammartino was unbeatable was washed away in an instant, and although he'd hold the title for a second time (again for an extended period of 1,237 days), his eventual defeat at the hands of 'Superstar' Billy Graham in April 1977 couldn't top the Koloff moment of years before.
2. Bob Backlund (Survivor Series 1994)

Bob Backlund's return to the WWF in 1992 would be akin to Vince McMahon sitting behind the Raw announce desk every week in 2017, delivering his trademark guffaw and commentating like it was 1995 again. In other words, Backlund's presentation was completely at odds with the time and he stuck out like a sore thumb as a babyface.
As a heel however, well, he had some serious steam. Fans detested the out-of-touch promos Bob delivered, even more so when he wrestled an old-school style that they had been conditioned to view as dull next to dynamic performers like Bret Hart or Shawn Michaels.
It was Hart that Backlund would beat at the 1994 Survivor Series to become WWF Heavyweight Champion at 45 years and 101 days old.
Bob sold the moment with aplomb, and he must have revelled in the fact that most fans in attendance for the pay-per-view couldn't believe their eyes. Bret, the leader of the 'New Generation', had been beaten by a fossil from before even Hulk Hogan's time. This was a seriously bold move by the WWF during a period when business was struggling.
1. Shawn Michaels (Survivor Series 1997)
The infamous 'Montreal Screwjob' has been recanted perhaps more than any other event in WWE history since it happened, but it's true that no list looking at shocking title switches in the company would be complete without what went down at the Survivor Series in 1997.
Few need the backstory at all, so it's interesting to instead focus on fan reaction that night in Canada.
It took a few moments for the live crowd to realise that Bret Hart had been legitimately screwed over by Vince McMahon, Shawn Michaels, and Earl Hebner. Had people recognised the subterfuge straight away, the WWF would have surely incited a riot on 9 November 1997.
It was only when Hart began throwing a tantrum post-match that people started to cotton onto what had happened. The 'Screwjob' remains the single most controversial and shocking WWF/WWE Title switch in history, if for no other reason than because it was real.
-
What other WWE Title switches do you think shocked the world? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!