14 Best WWE Title Changes At SummerSlam
The title changes that reverberated through the wrestling world.
When SummerSlam first entered our homes 28 years ago,
wrestling pay-per-views were still in their toddler phase. WrestleMania IV had just
taken place a few months earlier, and the first Survivor Series occurred the
previous Thanksgiving. But the (then) WWF knew even back then that one of the
biggest draws for a major PPV was to give fans a significant title change, as
the first SummerSlam produced one of the most memorable title changes (more on
that later).
SummerSlam is often billed as “The Biggest Party of the Summer”, and Sunday night’s 29th instalment will probably ensure it continues to live up to that billing. With six title matches on the 11-match card, it’s likely we’ll have a couple new champions to add to the more than 30 new champs that have been crowned at SummerSlams gone by.
Throughout SummerSlam’s history, some of these matches have been truly memorable affairs – the sight of the new champ hoisting the title high is a visual that sticks with fans for years afterwards.
These selections are not based solely (or even mainly) on match quality, but also how important said title change was going forward. Did it create a new star? Did it cause a major shift in future storylines? These are the title changes that matter, the ones whose reverberations are felt well after the match ended and the PPV ceased transmission.
Let’s take a look at some of the most significant
title changes in WWE SummerSlam history…
14. Million Dollar Championship (1991): Ted DiBiase (c) Vs. Virgil
While the Million Dollar Championship wasn’t an
officially sanctioned WWF title, it still was defended from time to time and was even stolen once. When Virgil finally had enough of Ted DiBiase’s abuse and
finally stood up for himself, it led to a SummerSlam showdown for DiBiase’s
prized possession.
The match itself was pretty pedestrian compared to others (including another title change on the same 1991 card), but the crowd reaction throughout was off the charts. People bought into the entire angle and were firmly behind Virgil, making his victory and capturing of the belt a really special moment.
Honourable mentions go to 1989’s
Intercontinental Championship match between champ “Ravishing” Rick Rude and The
Ultimate Warrior, and 1997’s IC scuffle between Owen Hart and Steve Austin, which
is more infamous for how it altered Austin’s career trajectory than for being a
great title change.
13. World Tag Team Championship (1990): Demolition (c) Vs. Hart Foundation
This would be the last hurrah for Demolition, and
the second (and final) tag title reign for the Hart Foundation. As with many of
the great tag title matches back in the day, this was two out of three falls.
Demolition were using the “Freebird Rule” at this point, with Crush sometimes
defending the titles alongside Ax or Smash. In this case, it was Crush and
Smash defending the straps.
With each team winning a fall, it was the deciding third fall where things got a little crazy. Ax came out and switched off with Smash, giving Demolition a fresh man to beat down the Harts. The Legion of Doom came down to put a stop to the Demos’ cheating ways, and the Harts would pick up the victory and the titles.
This marked the downward slide for Demolition
and gave the Hart Foundation one good final run as tag champs before Bret would
break out on his own (more on that a little later).
12. World Heavyweight Championship (2009): CM Punk Vs. Jeff Hardy (c)
At this point in his career, CM Punk already was a
two-time World Heavyweight Champion, having twice cashed-in his Money in the Bank
briefcase successfully. The second time, he defeated a spent Jeff Hardy,
who had just bested Edge in a ladder match to capture his first WHC.
Hardy would reclaim the title about seven weeks later, setting up the rubber
match at SummerSlam.
This time, Punk won his third world championship in a hard-fought battle, erasing any stigma that he was an accidental champion. His celebration would be short-lived, however. While standing over a fallen Jeff Hardy, Undertaker’s gong rang out and the lights went out. When they came back on, Taker had taken Hardy’s place under Punk’s feet.
After a chokeslam to close out the PPV, it became obvious where Punk’s reign was headed next.
The SummerSlam victory should have launched Punk into the stratosphere as a main-event player, but instead his title was sacrificed to The Deadman less than two months later. Punk would go on to head up the Straight Edge Society as we moved into 2010 before finally reaching the summit again in 2011.
11. WWF Hardcore Championship (2001): Jeff Hardy (c) Vs. Rob Van Dam
One theme that runs through this list is how many of
these title changes helped “legitimise” a wrestler as a top performer and
brought them up to the next level in the company.
During the 2001 InVasion angle, several WCW and ECW stars were introduced to a WWF audience. Ideally, WWF should have portrayed the invaders as equals to their own superstars, building them up and making several new stars in one fell swoop. As we all know, that’s not at all what happened…
With one exception, that is. For whatever reason, WWF decided to treat former ECW standout Rob Van Dam as the real deal, giving him victories over several top WWF wrestlers and protecting him despite being part of the Alliance. Fans got a good look at RVD at SummerSlam 2001, when Van Dam toppled WWF’s resident risk-taker Jeff Hardy for the Hardcore Championship in a ladder match.
That match helped establish Van Dam and launched his
WWF career. It’s hard to believe, but at one point early in his run, RVD was
probably one of the two or three most popular performers on a pretty bloated roster.
10. WWE United States Championship (2015): John Cena (c) Vs. Seth Rollins
When John Cena and Seth Rollins squared off at SummerSlam
last year, both men were title-holders, but that was where the similarities ended.
Cena was the United States Champion, defending his belt on a weekly basis in
what often was the best match on Raw. Rollins, by contrast, was a chickensh*t WWE World Heavyweight Champion who held onto his title by hook and by crook.
Both titles were up for grabs at SummerSlam in a match that was destined to make history: no man had ever held both titles simultaneously. But in addition to that first-ever moment, the Cena/Rollins match was notable for another reason: It featured the physical prowess of a chair-wielding Jon Stewart, who dropped Cena with a shot, helping Rollins become the first World/U.S. champ.
In the end, Rollins’ reign as a dual champ would only last a month, but he still made WWE history and got a sweet bronze statue out of the deal… that is, until Sting stole and destroyed it. And odds are, we won’t see a wrestler hold two singles titles in WWE anytime soon, so Rollins might end up being a trivia question ten or fifteen years down the line as the last man to hold two singles championships.
9. WWF Intercontinental Championship (1991): Mr. Perfect (c) Vs. Bret Hart
Ah, remember back when the Intercontinental
Championship was traded between young, rising stars? And you could almost count
on a really good title match for the IC strap at any given time? Remember that
next time you look at Intercontinental champ The Miz.
But in 1991, Curt Hennig defended his
Intercontinental Championship (which he had held for 13 of the previous 16
months) against former tag-team specialist Bret “The Hitman” Hart. Hart had had
a taste of singles action previously, but this was essentially his coming out
party. He and Perfect traded moves until Hart caught a legdrop attempt and
turned it into the Sharpshooter for the submission victory and his first singles
title.
The IC title victory would launch Hart into a new
phase of his career after spending about six years predominantly as a tag team
wrestler. He would go on to capture multiple world titles and become one of the
WWF’s biggest stars of the 90s, a WWE Hall of Famer and a revered icon in
professional wrestling.
8. WWF Intercontinental Championship (1998): HHH Vs. The Rock (c)
This was another classic Intercontinental Championship match between two up-and-coming stars who would help define the Attitude Era.
In this case, Rocky and HHH had a lengthy ladder match for the IC
title at the peak of the D-Generation X/Nation of Domination feud that lasted throughout the
second half of 1998. The feud helped boost both factions, but the
Intercontinental Championship match would show that Rock and HHH could steal
the show.
Both beat the hell out of each other for upwards of 25 minutes, with Rock damaging HHH’s knee and Hunter using a chair to subdue Rocky. In the end, HHH would overcome Rock and capture his second IC title, but it wouldn’t be long before both men would be fighting for the WWF Championship, showing how two mid-carders can elevate each other to the next level.
What makes this tough to swallow today is seeing how often this happened in the 90s and how that is the opposite of what’s happening with the Intercontinental Championship now. Miz clearly isn’t a star on the rise anymore (although he’s doing just fine as a midcard champ), and while Apollo Crews is supposedly on the upswing, his character development has been practically nonexistent at times.
A title victory alone isn’t going to
vault him to greatness.
7. WWE Tag Team Championships (2015): Prime Time Players (c) Vs. New Day Vs. Lucha Dragons Vs. Los Matadores
It’s hard to believe that it’s been nearly a year
since the New Day recaptured the WWE Tag Team Championships, ending the interim
reign of the Prime Time Players and kicking off an era of Booty O's, Francesca,
unicorn horns and Francesca II.
New Day lost the tag titles to Darren Young and Titus O’Neil at Money in the Bank last year and PTP defended the titles at Battleground, but a fatal four-way title defense against New Day, Lucha Dragons and Los Matadores (remember those guys?) would not go their way. New Day would steal the pinfall (they were heels at the time) to capture their second title reign.
Since then, New Day has gone on to become the longest-reigning tag team champs (with this version of the titles) and become one of the most entertaining parts of WWE. Some weeks, they were the only entertaining part of Raw. They underwent a transformation from cheating villains to fan-favourites, all while keeping fans laughing.
This Sunday, their tag title reign will reach an
astounding 52 weeks. Even if this is the end of their run, New Day certainly
has left their mark on the tag team division, and it all started at SummerSlam
2015.
6. WWF Intercontinental Championship (1992): Bret Hart (c) Vs. The British Bulldog
This is how you build up a secondary title change as
a big deal. The fact that the match was the 1992 SummerSlam main event didn’t
hurt, either.
The British Bulldog was fighting against his brother-in-law in front of his countrymen at a sold-out Wembley Stadium in London. Bret Hart was the technically-gifted IC champ who was being groomed for a WWF Title reign (in fact, he’d win the WWF Championship two months later). Hart was a proud champion, while Bulldog was a proud Brit fighting on his home soil. It’s little things like that that make title matches mean something.
Hart and Bulldog dug out every little trick in their books and tore the house down until Davey Boy countered a sunset flip with a pin for the title, giving him a career win and freeing The Excellence of Execution up to pursue the world title. Unfortunately, Smith’s IC title reign and WWF career would grind to a halt a few months later when he was found to have been experimenting with human growth hormone.
5. WWE World Heavyweight Championship (2014): John Cena (c) Vs. Brock Lesnar
“It wasn’t even close”, said Michael Cole
This was an earth-shattering title change. Brock Lesnar absolutely mauled John Cena to win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship in 2014. During the course of the 16-minute match, Lesnar hit Cena with two F-5s and 16 German suplexes, while Cena barely managed more than a minute’s worth of offense in.
Despite the lack of blood, which was present during their previous encounter at Extreme Rules 2012, this match was equally gruesome – if not more so.
As a statement match, this was an exclamation point. Lesnar beat WWE’s answer to superman just four months after conquering the Undertaker’s “unbeatable” WrestleMania undefeated streak. Aside from a brief flurry in the middle of the match where Cena hit an Attitude Adjustment, at no point did Cena come close to winning, much less give his fans any hope.
Granted, Lesnar’s limited dates would lead to the
WWE World Heavyweight Title disappearing from the scene for long periods of time. But it also
would set in motion events that culminated in Roman Reigns winning the 2015
Royal Rumble and seemingly put him on course to win the title at WrestleMania XXXI,
only to have Seth Rollins cash-in his Money in the Bank briefcase and win the
title without pinning Brock.
4. WWE Championship (2011): John Cena (c) Vs. CM Punk (c) & Punk (c) Vs. Alberto Del Rio
After CM Punk defied the odds and walked out of
Money in the Bank (and temporarily, WWE) with the WWE Championship in 2011, HHH
went about the business of crowning a new champ. After all, you can’t have your
world title be vacant for months, that would be ludicr… oh wait, they did that
in 2013? And again in 2014? Never mind...
Anyway, once John Cena toppled tournament winner Rey Mysterio, Punk returned and set the stage for a showdown at SummerSlam, champion versus champion. The question here was whether Punk’s victory was a one-shot deal, or if he truly was ascending to the top to stay. A victory over Cena would mean that CM Punk had finally arrived.
Punk would capture that win after the usual high-quality affair between him and Cena. Seconds later, however, Kevin Nash would powerbomb Punk, leaving him helpless and susceptible to an Alberto Del Rio MITB cash-in. While this would take the title away from Punk temporarily – he’d regain it three months later and hold it for more than 14 months – the Second City Saint was now a made man.
A crappy feud with HHH and Nash would only delay the inevitable. That fleeting title reign had sent the message: CM Punk was one of the big dogs now.
3. WWE Undisputed Championship (2002): The Rock (c) Vs. Brock Lesnar
This match could also be known as “How to Make a Star 101”.
In 2002, Brock Lesnar was still known as the Next Big Thing rather
than the Beast Incarnate. He was a rookie who was tearing his way through WWE
superstars left and right. What happened at SummerSlam 2002 capped that
meteoric rise to the top.
Whether a heel or a face, The Rock had been the top guy in WWE for several years. He’d beaten all comers through the years, having toppled Hulk Hogan a few months earlier at WrestleMania X8. But Lesnar represented a new challenge for the Brahma Bull.
In a changing of the guard moment, Rock put over Lesnar clean as a sheet to kick off the Next Big Thing’s run on top of WWE. Had Lesnar not left after WrestleMania XX, there’s no telling how big a star he would have been through the 2000s. But for a solid two years, Lesnar was an unstoppable force, and this title win kicked that run into overdrive.
2. WWE Championship (2013): John Cena (c) Vs. Daniel Bryan & Bryan (c) Vs. Randy Orton
WWE hadn’t corporate-ised the “Yes Movement” yet in 2013, but Daniel Bryan certainly had a huge following heading into his big SummerSlam matchup against John Cena. He was the undersized, underdog superstar fighting for respect and accolades. On this night, he won both.
Bryan and Cena had a classic match that proved two things: Cena can wrestle, and Bryan can out-wrestle Cena. Bryan’s victory cemented his ascension to the top of promotion, but it was the screwjob that followed with HHH and Randy Orton that would really catapult Bryan to other-worldly stature in the fans’ eyes.
Bryan went from the underdog achieving his dream to the underdog who had authority figures actively trying to prevent him from living his dream.
It was that win-loss combo that solidified Bryan’s position within the company and gave WWE a major storyline to play up for the next several months. Yes, the company got seriously sidetracked for a while and very nearly went the route of making Batista the guy with his hand raised at WrestleMania XXX.
Thankfully, WWE came around and did what was best for business.
1. WWF Intercontinental Championship (1988): Honky Tonk Man (c) Vs. Ultimate Warrior
Use whatever cliché you want, but this much is certain: Timing is everything in creating a perfect moment. And on August 29, 1988, all the stars aligned.
Consider:
Honky Tonk Man basically had backed into an Intercontinental Championship reign, as he happened to be wrestling Ricky “The Dragon” Steamboat on the night they decided to take the title off him. He wasn’t supposed to be anything more than a transitional champ, but through circumstance, he continued to hold onto the title for nearly 15 months.
After a while, Honky’s title defenses became a major draw on the house show circuit, with HTM and manager Jimmy Hart looking for any way possible to keep the belt around his waist whether via count-out, disqualification or other nefarious means. It worked against every other challenger up and down the card.
Ultimate Warrior had debuted in WWF 10 months earlier, captivating audiences with his high-octane performances, running roughshod over jobbers and lower-card wrestlers (think Goldberg in facepaint and wearing tassels.) He was quickly becoming a major star in WWF, but he needed some direction in his career.
This brings us to the inaugural SummerSlam at Madison Square Garden. Honky Tonk Man’s scheduled opponent, Brutus “The Barber” Beefcake was injured, so Honky grabbed the mic and said “Get me somebody out here to wrestle, I don’t care who it is!”. They turned out to be famous last words, as Ultimate Warrior’s music hit and he stormed the ring.
Thirty seconds later, Honky was flattened by a big splash and we had a beand new Intercontinental Champion.
As a match, this was nothing more than a very basic squash. But in terms of paying off a long-term storyline and making a new star instantaneously, this was perfect. The roar of the crowd from the minute the music hit was overwhelming, and when Warrior pinned Honky, it was deafening.
It’s highly unlikely we will ever see a title change like this again, and for
good reason: moments like this are damn near impossible to create.