3 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (17 Oct - Results & Review)
WWE crowned a new champ and made the best of a bad situation on Friday night.
Monday's episode of Raw saw Seth Rollins get dumped from his own faction amidst an injury-related flurry of booking changes and redirection. Come Friday night, WWE boss Triple H was forced to get his thinking cap on again, but there was talk of Jacob Fatu vs. Drew McIntyre taking place anyway despite conflicting reports that he'll be on the bench until some unknown point in 2026.
It turns out the 'Samoan Werewolf' is injured, so the writers had to come up with a hasty 'whodunit' and book Cody Rhodes like mid-2000 Ric Flair on WCW Nitro by having the champ wrestle "in his street clothes". The finish WWE went with on SmackDown has split opinion amongst fans already, but it looks like a Cody vs. Drew rematch is on the early format sheets for Saturday Night's Main Event come 1 November.
SmackDown also boasted a Women's Tag-Team Title match that's worth seeing, and a stunning United States Title change involving comeback king Ilja Dragunov. Hopefully, he's set to continue the great work now-former champion Sami Zayn was doing with his 'Open Challenge' segments every week - those led to some sparkling matches, and there's little doubt that Ilja could follow suit with aplomb.
Downsides came in the form of repetitive booking in the tag ranks, and WWE bizarrely rubbished their own Crown Jewel Championship gimmick less than one week after hyping it up as important. Why the company does things like that is anyone's guess. It's a rotten way to build then trash fan excitement, and it's why few take the international belts seriously to begin with.
Here's all the good and bad from Friday's effort.
Downs...
3. Solid, But What Are They Fighting For?
Normally, a match like Motor City Machine Guns vs. Los Garza would reach automatic 'Ups' territory without hesitation, but the whole thing actually felt pretty pointless. Sure, it was a tidy effort from all involved, but...what were they fighting for? The Wyatt Sicks are champs and have something going on with the MFT stable, so it’s not like the Guns and Garza were striving to become number one contenders or anything.
The one year anniversary thing Motor City had going on was flimsy, because they actually don’t have a lot to celebrate. This writer enjoyed the match just fine, but it’s hard to rubber stamp an ‘Up’ when the booking is so weak for things like this; even the announcers didn’t really know what to say about where these squads are going. That sense the division is drifting was hammered home after the match when Fraxiom and DIY set up their own match for seemingly no reason.
Tommaso Ciampa said he and Johnny Gargano decided to “stay out of the way” for the past 2 months. Wow, talk about weak. Get the belts off The Sicks, please. They’ve strangled this division’s momentum throughout 2025. It used to be one of SmackDown's biggest plus points, but now far too many of the squads are wandering around coming up with the lamest excuses for having matches or even being on television.
Why anyone thought to script that line for Ciampa is baffling. So, he and Gargano just decided to let firm rivals The Street Profits go after gold they've hunted out of the kindness of their own hearts? Nah, not having it. Way more is needed to contextualise these matches. Otherwise, they're just bouts for the sake of it and achieve sod all.
2. They Did This Again? Really?!
Firstly, the menace shown by Solo Sikoa and his MFTs was great elsewhere. They interrupted a photoshoot with Rey Fenix and beat him up just because they could, then Sikoa's troops (complete with returning face paints) laid out Fenix, Sami Zayn and Ilja Dragunov later in the night. At that point, once Solo had grabbed the mic and warned that his family runs SmackDown, they looked badass.
Cue The Wyatt Sicks.
A quick video by the absent Bo Dallas played on the tron, then Nikki Cross, Erick Rowan, Joe Gacy and Dexter Lumis appeared on the ring apron behind MFT. This was a rinse and repeat of last week's booking, but then things got worse. Technically, it looked like Sikoa was running away from Nikki more than anything. She was the one he was looking at when he encouraged his team to back off.
Their reluctance to start throwing punches made no sense considering they'd just taken out 3 other stars to make a statement. So, the Sicks monotony continues. Even the crowd’s “HOLY S***” chant felt a little more halfhearted this week. There was no call for running a repeat on this confrontation without any physicality, there really wasn't.
Then, on top of that repetition, Solo seemed to fill his drawers at the prospect of Cross more than Rowan, Gacy or Lumis. That'd be acceptable had Nikki been shown to be a difference maker in recent weeks/months, but that hasn't been the case. Making Sikoa and the MFT faction look dangerous then cowardly within the span of a few minutes really was a poor choice.
1. Way To Palm Off Crown Jewel As Meaningless
Both Cody Rhodes and Tiffany Stratton pretty much said their losses to Seth Rollins and Stephanie Vaquer didn’t mean much last weekend in Australia. Great. OK then. Wow. Way to totally squash your own Crown Jewel concept, guys. WWE are finding new ways to make those championships meaningless, it seems. Does anybody even double check the logic of these statements before they're thrust onto TV?
The fact that Stratton’s promo followed a grand video package recapping Vaquer’s win is annoying. The production staff member responsible for putting that vid together could be rightly irked that Triple H then immediately instructed one of his top female stars to downplay her defeat as nothing to worry about. Urgh. That self-sabotaging, 'who cares about this PLE anyway?!' stuff will never be fine and dandy.
It doesn't help that Tiffany is still struggling to convince as a babyface champ too. She’s so stale, and that’s a shame considering how talented she is. As if having her palm off her loss wasn't bad enough, WWE then immediately ran a ‘Did You Know?’ stat about Stratton’s 17-1 win-loss record in 2025. Yes, they actually did that following a promo that also dumped on Crown Jewel’s results.
Senseless would just about cover it.
Both Vic Joseph and Corey Graves (this week's commentary team) worked overtime to justify what Tiffany was saying, and that only heightened thoughts that Crown Jewel's outcomes didn't matter at all. All of this was extremely counterproductive and frankly daft. Sure, who gives a toss that Vaquer beat Stratton anyway? WWE don't seem to, so why should you?
Behave, creative team. Get AI to write your promos, or something. Ahem.
Ups...
3. Routine But Fun Women’s Tag Title Defence
Following a modest amount of build in recent weeks, Friday's show also saw Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss beat Sol Ruca and Zaria to retain their Women's Tag-Team Titles. Overall, the match was routine and the belts were never changing hands, but the biggest takeaway here is that neither Ruca nor Zaria looked out of place next to the champs despite Flair and Bliss being bigger stars.
Fans came with the quartet from the start, and the whole ‘We’re Not Friends’ thing Charlotte and Alexa have going on is really working for them. Of course, the next step is giving them a proper feud to sink their teeth into, but a few more quickly-built title defences like this could work in the short term too. This is the kind of match that’ll stand the NXT’ers in good stead, that’s for sure.
Admittedly, some spots in the match weren’t exactly silky smooth, but nothing looked outright sloppy or bad. This bout got the job done, and there was even a bit of build for NXT Halloween Havoc with Blake Monroe watching from ringside and cackling when Sol tapped out to the Figure Eight. What a cackle it was.
The former Mariah May really knows how to work the cameras when they're on her. This is how someone maximises their minutes without threatening to take away from the match at hand. Good work, Blake.
Submitting to Flair isn't some crushing negative for Sol either, especially since Charlotte has shed that star suffocating aura she previously had earlier in the year. 2025 has been good for her character. Long may this tag run with Bliss last.
2. They Made The Best Of A Bad Situation
WWE were placed in a rough spot here.
Originally, we were supposed to have a number one contendership match between Drew McIntyre and Jacob Fatu, but Fatu’s injury issues took that off the table. So, management thought swiftly on their feet to have Cody Rhodes blame Drew for attacking Jacob and leaving him bloody mouthed backstage, then they had a short WWE Title match that ended via DQ.
Can’t lie, folks: Yours truly is intrigued to see where all of this is going, because there’s a slight chance Cody is the one who attacked Fatu and that’ll come out in the wash later. He also hit McIntyre with his belt to cause the disqualification finish, which isn’t exactly dignified top babyface behaviour. Splice in some heelish vibe in promos lately and something special could be brewing with Rhodes. It's worth keeping an eye on to see if he triggers that elusive heel turn before 2026 dawns.
This closing bit was chaotic, at least. WWE came up with the whole thing at short notice and it showed, clearly, but it also worked out just fine. Lord only knows where they go from here with Saturday Night’s Main Event on 1 November, but it’ll be fun finding out and that’s often what makes for good TV. Not everything needs to go to plan or be picture perfect in order to have fun as a viewer.
Cody and Drew packed in enough action to make their short title sprint worth it, and there was really nothing anybody could do about Jacob's sucky injury situation anyway. This was a prime example of WWE making the best of a poor hand.
1. Ilja Dragunov Stuns Sami Zayn
The Miz put himself forward as a challenger for Sami Zayn (who was determined to wrestle whether GM Nick Aldis wanted it to happen or not), but Carmelo Hayes attacked his old tag partner and to put a stop to that. Seconds after that, the returning Ilja Dragunov answered the call instead, and he ended up dethroning Sami to win the United States Title.
What a cracking moment this turned out to be, and it was an unexpected one considering the strength of Zayn’s ‘Open Challenge’ segments and all of his beef with Solo Sikoa/the MFTs in general. Dragunov coming back from injury to win the gold wasn't on many predictions lists heading into Friday's show. The fact this was a really good match between Sami and Ilja won’t surprise anyone though.
Dragunov’s intensity is infectious and adds a layer of drama to his bouts that often make them must see, and his selling stands out. The way he crumpled to the mat several times after eating a Sami boot looked awesome. This was just really enjoyable wrestling from 2 guys who regularly have some of WWE's greatest matches, and it was lovely to spring another genuine surprise with the title change. Fingers crossed the ‘Open Challenges’ persist, right enough.
SmackDown kinda needs a hook like that every single week.
There's a lot going on with the US Title at the moment. Shinsuke Nakamura is due a rematch after the MFT attack wrecked his first chance, Solo Sikoa is still sniffing around the gold, Sami will want it back as we screech towards WrestleMania season, The Miz may feel he's due a shot at the prize due to Melo's actions (which mirrored his!) and now Ilja is champ. You've got to love that mix of cast members, sub-plots, comebacks and surprises.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2005 and 8 New Directions For WWE After Crown Jewel 2025!