3 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE SmackDown (18 Apr - Results & Review)

John Cena and Cody Rhodes bring it; TLC announced; WWE stars cut empty promos pre-WrestleMania.

Cody Rhodes John Cena
WWE.com

This week's SmackDown risked creative burnout before WrestleMania 41.

WWE obviously viewed Friday's show as a means to add some last-minute garnish on incoming Las Vegas treats, but the three hour run time felt double that length due to several nothing promos that took ages to get going then had paltry payoffs for fans tuning in. Worse, Triple H just insulted an entire hardworking division and fans caring about it in one fell swoop!

Worryingly, some of 'The Game's' decision making in the lead up to the biggest weekend of 2025 has been all over the place. He should be real thankful there's so much interest in top stars like Cody Rhodes and John Cena's heel turn/retirement, because otherwise this 'Mania build would have some fuming. Truthfully, if you glance around online, there are people scratching their heads by the complete lack of The Rock since Elimination Chamber; he's too big a part of Cena's heel turn to leave out, but WWE have been doing just that thus far.

Back on the plus side, there were momentum boosting moments for Carmelo Hayes and LA Knight on the episode. The usual Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal is never going to win any 'Match Of The Year' awards, but it might give Melo's biggest fans some hope for the coming summer. Meanwhile, Knight has done everything in his power to keep the US Title scene ticking.

Here's all the good and bad from WWE's final TV stop before the brightest of bright light cascade down and WrestleMania 41 begins.


Downs...

6. Seth Rollins Gets Generic

Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Some reading will disagree wholeheartedly with this and that's fine. This is just one guy's opinion, after all, so here goes. Is anyone else really, really sick of the lengthy singalong entrances and that obnoxious laugh thing Seth Rollins does? It grates, and the entrance routine has become akin to a handy time-filler for WWE when they don't have a ton of material to work with.

Seth's speech on SmackDown was one of the most blatant ‘go out there and fill time for 10-15 minutes’ promos you’ll ever see. Rollins has felt like a bit of a third wheel sandwiched between CM Punk and Roman Reigns for a while, being honest. WWE has tried to change that by sprinkling in some stuff involving Paul Heyman owning Seth a favour, but this promo laid it bare that people don't care much about that, and didn’t really do Seth any favours overall.

Credit to the man for trying to get heated, but he was right up against it from minute one. After all, Rollins had literally nobody to bounce off of - he was a one man ranting machine, and it became clear there'd be no Roman, Punk or even Heyman the longer he talked. The absolute last thing WWE would want Seth to be is generic. Oops.

He needs a bit of a rethink post-WrestleMania once some fresh faces start showing up. It feels like Rollins could do with going full blown heel again and showing a little more menace. All the laughing and posturing has become tedious.

Again though, just one person's opinion.


5. The Women Go Revolving Door

IYO SKY
WWE.com

Oh dear.

This revolving door style promo did give the women plenty of folks to bounce off of when ranting, but it still wasn't particularly interesting. Rhea Ripley, IYO SKY, Bianca Belair, Naomi and Jade Cargill delivered a 'now it's my turn' style promo segment that really didn’t go anywhere. It was just another blatant time killing exercise from Triple H’s creative team.

Sometimes, that’s fine, but there wasn’t a lot to chew over here. Also, big laugh for Bianca claiming that this could be her last night on SmackDown if she wins the belt. WWE rubbishes its own brand separation thing weekly, and there were multiple workers from Raw on this same episode. So, Belair’s claim didn’t exactly hold any weight. Why would anybody believe that she'd be barred from showing up on Fridays even if she moved to the flagship on paper?

Bizarrely, because she's been largely plucked out of the Naomi and Jade Cargill issue then put between Rhea and IYO, Bianca has lost a little of the emotion she carried as a character. A segment opposite Naomi on the 7 March SmackDown was simply outstanding, but then the writing staff pressed pause in favour of other things.

Therefore, when Naomi and Belair tried to get something going here, it fell a tad flat. There is money in the thought of Ripley and Cargill locking horns someday, but this part of the show generally came across as hollow and lazy. Chucking loads of bodies through the curtain and hoping for the best isn't good enough.


4. Randy Orton Kills Even More Time

Randy Orton
WWE.com

Look, it was pretty clear early on that WWE didn’t have a whole hell of a lot in terms of material for this week’s episode. It wasn’t so much just that WrestleMania’s build is pretty much done though - they could’ve given Randy Orton more to work with here, and he was far from the only one suffering that problem in the building on Friday evening.

WWE can't be blamed for the fact that serious neck injuries to Kevin Owens ruled him out of WrestleMania and left Randy without someone to work with. They'll be as bummed out by that as anyone else. However, Orton took the mic in hand and said pretty much said nothing other than what people already knew here. He’s getting a mystery opponent at ‘Mania due to KO’s injury derailing plans.

Next.

It could be Rusev, it could be Aleister Black, it could just be Solo Sikoa. Who knows? WWE has to realise that announcing the mystery opponent thing was enough. They absolutely did not need to send Orton out in front of the live crowd to repeat things he's already said or waste more time on a show that could ill-afford it. Incredibly, that's precisely what they did.

Randy discussed how much 'Mania means to him, and vowed to hit an RKO on some fool in Vegas. Cool, but why did this need to be repeated over and over again? Maybe Trips just wanted to give fans in attendance for SmackDown an excuse to see Orton at all.


3. No Los Garza Or Pretty Deadly?

DIY WWE
WWE.com

Brand GM Nick Aldis announced a TLC match between The Street Profits, Motor City Machine Guns and DIY for next week’s edition of SmackDown. That’s cool and all, but both Los Garza and Pretty Deadly should really be involved in that too. After all, both squads have been a major part of the reason why the blue brand’s doubles division has ruled in recent months. It sucks that they’ll apparently be squeezed out.

Something else is irking people too: Why isn't this happening over WrestleMania weekend?! The famous event series has a long and beloved history with ladder matches. Throw in some tables and chairs for good measure and...yeah, you've got something that'd be ideal for tearing the house down inside Allegiant Stadium. It's strange when some other bouts that did make the cut for 'Mania seem less-than.

The War Raiders vs. New Day is nowhere near as enticing as the TLC, put it that way. Where's the reward for squads like The Profits, DIY, PD and Garza after months or fighting to show their worth? Seriously, how is Raiders vs. New Day more exciting?! The same goes for Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez vs. Bayley and Lyra Valkyria; that was chucked together quickly for the sake of it.

Nobody trying to punt others off the lineup at 'Mania, but SmackDown's tag-team ranks deserved way more respect than they've been given during a crunch period. There are no reasonable excuses for booking this match on next week's SmackDown rather than at WrestleMania, or for ignoring Deadly and Los Garza when it matters most.


2. Rey Mysterio’s Possible Injury = Bummer

Dragon Lee Chad Gable
WWE.com

Bonafide legend Rey Mysterio appeared to get injured during the six man tag pitting him, Dragon Lee and Rey Fenix vs. American Made. If that rules him out of ‘Mania and the match vs. Chad Gable’s masked alter ego, then that’ll be a serious downer for everybody. Worst of all, there was no need for this six man to take place. It definitely wasn't essential to the Gable story arc or SmackDown as a show.

Fingers and toes crossed that Rey Rey is still able to go vs. El Grande Americano on Saturday night. The high-flying favourite doesn't have too many WrestleMania matches left in him, so it'd blow if one was cruelly snatched away from him around 24 hours before bell time. Rey Fenix would be an ideal, ready made replacement, but still. You've got to feel bad for Mysterio if he can’t make it.

Kudos to everyone else in this match for pulling things together on the fly, but it’s hard to be positive when a cherished legend gets hurt like this. WWE medics were being very careful with Mysterio before he vanished for proper treatment, and things didn't look good for him. Again, here's hoping this was precautionary and the bout vs. Americano can still go ahead as planned.

The shining positive in all of this bleak negativity is that Fenix looked great out there again, but yes - difficult to be upbeat and all smiles when Rey might be the latest big name to kiss goodbye to a spot in Las Vegas and live his own WrestleMania 41 nightmare.


1. Chelsea Green Feels Wasted

Chelsea Green Zelina Vega
WWE.com

Zelina Vega picked up the clean upset win this week, which was WWE's way of trying to rescue things after that mess last time out on the 11 April episode. Unfortunately, the feud still doesn’t feel compelling or like it’s clicking, and management shouldn’t be bungling someone as talented as Chelsea Green; but they are.

Her Women’s United States Title reign has been a creative disappointment on the whole, but she deserves immense credit for still being over in spite of that. However, there’s pretty much zero interest from fans in seeing this Zelina stuff continue. Like Michin before her, Vega doesn't have a strong connection with the fanbase right now. People do like her, but she's a background figure at best.

Someone as charismatic as Chelsea should not be missing out on 'Mania either. Sorry, but she just shouldn't. Triple H has had ample time to come up with something that'd justify putting her title on the card across both nights, but Hunter has apparently decided that dull, lifeless rivalries against babyfaces with next to no steam is the way to go.

Baffling. Truly baffling.

Look at the image above. What do you see? Babyface Vega is up against it and struggling to fight back against Green. Meanwhile, fans in the front row have ignored that so they can salute with Chelsea instead. When the villain is getting more people onside than the baby, then you know there are problems.

It isn't much to ask that Green gets a credible opponent and a feud folks care about ASAP.


Ups...

3. At Least Carmelo Hayes Gets Something

Carmelo Hayes The Miz Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal
WWE.com

Melo won the annual Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal shindig then did that familiar pose with the trophy. No, this win hasn’t done a whole hell of a lot for many guys, but it’s certainly one Hayes will take considering his bumpy road on the main roster to date. He hasn't had it easy since moving up from NXT.

Personally, this fan liked that the match came down to Andrade vs. Carmelo too. They've had a rich, relatively recent history as opponents, and their series of bouts together could be considered one of Melo's high points since jumping to SmackDown in last year's 2024 Draft. All in all, his performance was ace and this was a decent Battle Royal.

These matches are usually a tough sell and hard to make interesting, but everybody worked hard here and the winner was definitely unpredictable going in. Andrade, Chad Gable, Karrion Kross, Ludwig Kaiser, Rey Fenix, Shinsuke Nakamura, The Miz and Hayes himself all seemed like strong candidates to take home the 'W'. That's more than could be said for most Battle Royals in the modern era.

The fun and games will come when Miz either tries to take credit for Carmelo's success and thus facilitates an unlikely Hayes babyface turn, or when Melo tells Miz they can go after tag gold and hunt down more trophies. If nothing else, it was heartening to see someone who's regularly overlooked these days get a bit of the spotlight to himself.

Carmelo is talented beyond belief, but he just needs WWE to believe in him a bit more.


2. LA Knight Stands Tall

LA Knight Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

Credit where it's due. Everything involving LA Knight, Solo Sikoa, Jacob Fatu and pals was on the stronger side this week. Knight ambushed Tama Tonga to kick off the show, then tried to cut down Solo as well so he can concentrate 100% on Jacob at ‘Mania. That was a decent story thread, and creative even managed to get Braun Strowman involved for some tag-team fun too.

The singles between Knight and Solo which fed into the eventual tag had purpose, and that's important. WWE is trying to weave multiple stories at once here. Fatu is becoming more and more dominant, Solo is somebody still reeling from losing his 'Tribal Chief' bid to Roman Reigns during Raw's Netflix debut in January, and LA Knight knows everyone carries a real threat to his United States Title.

He's been feeling like a champ backed into a corner, which is why he's come out swinging. That's an easy and relatable plot for fans to get behind, and it'll help Knight in the long run even if he drops his belt to Jacob. Typical WWE booking suggests that he'll do just that after getting to stand tall here on TV. Normally, that means the opposite will ring true next time.

That'll be music to Fatu's ears, because it means he'll have gold over his shoulder shortly. Yep, this Knight vs. Sikoa singles lead-in worked, and so did the tag fare once Jacob and Braun joined the chat. Sometimes, simple booking is the best kind of booking (especially when it has meaning).


1. Cody & Cena Bring The Intensity

Cody Rhodes John Cena
WWE.com

There's no sense in ignoring it, somewhat ironically: The Rock being absent from promos between both Cody Rhodes and John Cena remains puzzling. it’s kinda weird that he's barely been mentioned at all this close to ‘Mania, but WWE is out of time to get something going there; he could still show up on the night though, of course, but it does feel like Dwayne should’ve been a bigger part of the build between Elimination Chamber and now.

Cody and Cena were up and at 'em on SmackDown regardless. There was a decent buzz once they came face to face, and both guys matched the other's intensity as the live crowd ebbed and flowed with their comments. Like with LA Knight standing tall, there is a chance that Cody Cross Rhodes on Cena means John is getting the belt this Sunday.

It remains to be seen. We'll see how things pan out.

There’s some mystery to the outcome, which is no bad thing. Triple H must be thrilled to bits with that, because no promoter ever wants their main attraction to feel predictable and safe. Cena going for his Attitude Adjustment but Cody slipping out of it to hit the latest in a series of finishers on JC does seem notable. That spot could be repeated in Vegas.

Overall, Cody and John worked a solid 'go home' segment that defo didn't hurt interest in seeing them collide. Rock involvement aside, one can't ask for much more than that from them.

What did you think of this week's episode of WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out WWE WrestleMania 41: 20 Things That Must Happen and WWE WrestleMania 41: 7 Nightmares That Could Come True!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.