WWE WrestleMania 41: 7 Nightmares That Could Come True

WrestleMania 41 could be another big WWE swerve that turns into an illogical mess.

WWE WrestleMania 41 Cody Rhodes John Cena
WWE.com

Be warned: There's pretty much zero room for WWE positivity here.

The clue's in the title. This is all about the worst of the worst that could blight WrestleMania 41 and turn it into a nightmare that makes matches like Big Show vs. Akebono or Vince McMahon vs. Bret Hart seem like world beaters by comparison. OK, maybe that's too far. Those will always be trash, but they might well be joined by a few friends come 2025's shindig in Las Vegas this weekend.

There are a few questionable matches littering the card on both nights, but that's not the biggest concern here. As Kofi Kingston used to say: 'Ooooooh nooooo'. Bigger worries come in the form of wrestling fans treating a popular champion like some unwanted piece of rubbish ready to be discarded because somebody's nWo-style heel cool has taken over. Think The Rock vs. Hollywood Hogan at 'Mania X8 for reference.

Other wobbles could come via important puzzle pieces being bizarrely absent from class during the biggest weekend of the year, and a soft/semi-Shield reboot that doesn't make a lick of sense when analysing WWE's recent TV output. Favours, favours, favours - Triple H wouldn't be doing any favours for his fanbase by booking this particular swerve. 

WrestleMania has always been a classic that leads to annual binge-watching sessions of old favourites. Hopefully, the latest version is a winner too, but what if it's a nightmare instead? Shoot-style disasters, swerves for the sake of swerves, rebellious fans and even successive stinkers.

It's all here. Have fun!

7. Braun Strowman Stops Jacob Fatu

Braun Strowman Jacob Fatu
WWE.com

What Could Happen: Fire-breathing, moonsault-giving, monster-bloodying ex-New Bloodline beast Jacob Fatu is just about to win the United States Title from LA Knight. Solo Sikoa has come to ringside and could get involved in the finish, but no - instead, it's Braun Strowman who makes the difference by making sure his regular rival doesn't leave Las Vegas with the gold.

Why It'd Be A Nightmare: If anyone's going to cost Jacob, then it must be the man who professes to have his best interests at heart. That's right, Sikoa. "I love you, Solo" has turned to, 'Meh, not sure about you' in recent times, and Sikoa is the only one who needs to try steal back some respect from Fatu. If anyone.

Truth be told, this should be Jacob's night. It's true that Knight is great, but he'd survive staring at the lights for Fatu and making sure Triple H has all the means to turn the brute into a WWE megastar who blows up as a main eventer later in the year. It'd be crappy if Braun interfered to blast Fatu through a table behind the ref's back and make sure he doesn't win.

Stay away, Mr. Monster!

Don't bet against something like this happening so WWE's creative team can squeeze one more match out of the Fatu vs. Strowman rivalry and possibly so Jacob can return the favour by stopping Solo from winning the belt himself come Backlash. Sure, there's no call for Braun's intrusion, but that doesn't mean the writers won't shove it in there just to get Strowman on the show somehow.


6. Jey Uso Has His Second Successive Stinker

WWE Raw Jey Uso Gunther
WWE

What Could Happen: Jey Uso feels the strain of a pressure spot and struggles to deliver the babyface performance of a lifetime against hate-filled World Heavyweight Champion Gunther. The result is a face title win that sags more than soars, and one which leaves the live crowd in Vegas wondering if Jey will ever match top in-ring singles work with his obvious star power and promos.

Why It'd Be A Nightmare: Stinking up the joint would become a bit of a trend for Jey.

Sadly, last year's brother vs. brother effort vs. Jimmy failed to really get going on night one at 'Mania 40. It was around 11 minutes of samey superkick spots that played before a live crowd who were clearly waiting around for something better. That never came. Going back to back on in-ring flops would be disastrous for Uso; he really cannot afford to bring anything but his 'A' game to Allegiant Stadium.

Everyone knows that Gunther will be well-prepared to enter another pro wrestling masterclass. That's just what the current champ does. He's a grappling machine, but he's been finding his feet on the mic over his past couple of feuds. However, if this is more Saturday Night's Main Event fare, then it won't light up WrestleMania enough to cement Jey as a top liner.

That's surely the goal. To achieve it, Uso will need to have more in his locker than he did when working a superkick party The Young Bucks would've been proud of in 2024. The heat is on, never mind the yeet.


5. Paul Heyman Sides With Seth Rollins

WWE Raw Seth Rollins Paul Heyman Roman Reigns
WWE

What Could Happen: All this chatter about Paul Heyman showing more loyalty towards CM Punk than Roman Reigns is a red herring designed to throw fans off the scent of the real treachery. Late in the match, and right as either Reigns or Punk looks like winning, Heyman causes a distraction that paves the way for none other than Seth Rollins to unthinkably go from third wheel to 'Mania night one main event winner.

Why It'd Be A Nightmare: Well, it just flat out doesn't make any sense.

WWE's spin doctors would have to be on top form to explain away why Heyman was interested in aligning with Seth. The same goes in reverse. Yes, Rollins did say Paul owed him a favour because he chose not to stomp his face into the mat recently on Raw, but...is that really enough of a plot line to justify Heyman turning his back on Punk and Roman in favour of Seth?

Not exactly. Besides, there'd be no calls for Rollins to launch his own version of The Shield with Paul as manager. If Heyman was hanging around with Seth for the rest of 2025, then there's a chance that Rollins would just look like a lesser version of the heel 'Tribal Chief' character that Reigns had been playing for years.

Punk would be left fairly rudderless too, and he'd look like a chump for failing to bring up Heyman knocking lumps out of him back at Money In The Bank 2013, or any of their other bumps and bruises during what WWE claims has been a flawless friendship.


4. Charlotte Flair Crushes ‘Tiffy Time’

Charlotte Flair Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

What Could Happen: Royal Rumble 2025 winner Charlotte Flair trades one unwanted win for another by torching Tiffany Stratton's babyface promise and taking her Women's Title away. The fanbase in Las Vegas stands stunned as they contemplate more divisional domination from someone WWE just can't seem to get enough of - even when it comes at the expense of others.

Why It'd Be A Nightmare: That last line above gives the game away. Pushing Flair to the top ahead of others used to be justifiable, but not anymore. Stratton is part of a new breed of female workers paving the way towards a bright future, and it doesn't sit well with most folks that Charlotte's elitist mindset appears to be based on at least some reality.

More to come on that soon. For now, Triple H should be wary of backlash should he strip the title off Tiffany so soon and plonk it right onto the shoulders of Flair. 'The Game' has always been a self-confessed mark for her old man though, so there's a solid chance he'd be right up for echoing Charlotte's sentiments about topping his title haul.

Nobody's saying Flair should never hold belts again, but it'd be an insane risk to squash 'Tiffy Time' (which is getting over) just because Charlotte needs another trophy in her cabinet. She definitely isn't the best worker in the women's division any longer, and even that was arguable before with names like Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks and Bayley around. 

WWE putting all of their eggs in the Flair basket could backfire spectacularly straight after 'Mania.


3. Or Their Match Turns Into A Shoot

Charlotte Flair Tiffany Stratton
WWE

What Could Happen: Contentious sit-down interviews and bizarrely off-script comments about Ludwig Kaiser sliding into Charlotte Flair's DMs boil over into the ring at WrestleMania 41. Suddenly, instead of working together for the betterment of their featured match, Flair and Tiffany Stratton start throwing bombs like they're trying to break the other woman's face for real.

Backstage, Triple H goes into meltdown mode that something so shocking could happen on his watch live at 'Mania.

Why It'd Be A Nightmare: WWE likes when talent improvise occasionally, especially if they're only spreading their wings and improving the match by doing so. However, it's dangerous to accept that any two workers could start brawling for real, and it'd be a PR nightmare if something like this happened on the biggest cards of the entire year.

Of course, there's always a chance that Flair, Stratton, Hunter and his creative team are working the wrestling media by feeding them juicy gossip about that off-script calamity on the 4 April episode of SmackDown, but maybe not. Maybe Charlotte and Tiffany really don't have a lot of time for one another and things will come to a head inside the ring at Allegiant.

If so, then that could be a wrap on Flair's time as an ongoing concern to WWE. Meanwhile, Stratton might have to eat some of the humble pie Triple H himself did after being involved in the infamous 'Curtain Call' back in 1996. She'd surely be demoted down the card for being unprofessional.

Hold onto your (WWE WrestleMania 41 branded) hats, and somebody get JR on the call for a potential slobberknocker.


2. The Rock Isn’t In Town

WWE Elimination Chamber 2025 John Cena The Rock
WWE

What Could Happen: Build towards Cody Rhodes vs. John Cena rings true and The Rock sits out everything to do with this title showdown bar what happened at Elimination Chamber in early-March. Big Dwayne Johnson reasons that he's just far too busy with everything he has going on in Hollywood, so fellow-movie star Cena is exclusively there in his stead.

Either that or WWE and Rocky decide that John's own retirement tour is enough without Rock's involvement at 'Mania.

Why It'd Be A Nightmare: One of the biggest questions surrounding Cena's heel turn back at Chamber still hasn't been broached. Like, at all. Why did he side with The Rock? We know he wanted to stick it to people who had been getting on his nerves for decades, but why Rocky? WWE has left that whopper of a question dangling in the ether like it doesn't even matter (Alexa, play that single with Wyclef Jean and Rock from aeons ago).

Hell, Cody himself has barely brought it up despite apparently going from blood-soaked enemies to great pals behind the scenes with the 'Final Boss'. This is all very unsatisfying, and that word would be on fan lips again if Rocky dipped out of WrestleMania 41 in favour of watching from a remote location like this is 2005 all over again.

Sod that, he needs to be there live in person. People are excited about the prospect of Cena either dethroning Cody or Rhodes fending him off so they can stick two fingers up at John's legacy, but The Rock is far too big a part of the story to go radio silent at a time like this.

Surely he'll be in the house?!


1. Fans Turn On Cody Rhodes

WWE Raw Cody Rhodes
WWE

What Could Happen: WWE poster boy and top babyface Cody Rhodes stands open-mouthed as Las Vegas showers him with boos amidst surprise chants of, "Let's Go Cena...Cody sucks!". It's like 'Mania X8 all over again. Back then, company hardcores turned on The Rock (who was the face during the build) in favour of cheering on old hero Hulk Hogan (despite his nWo colours).

Why It'd Be A Nightmare: The thought that Cody could be booed is outlandish, but not impossible. This wouldn't be the first time a massive pro wrestling crowd has rebelled against WWE's plans, put it that way, and there is still a lot of sentimental lovesickness for John Cena even though he turned heel at Chamber then bashed the fans for ignoring his 'Rise Above Hate' campaign previously.

Crowds are fully aware that time is running out on their chances of ever seeing Cena do his thing again, and that might well stir desperation in some. So, come WrestleMania 41, a full-timer like Cody (who will be seen every other week for years to come) could be on the receiving end of some teenage-style angst from a fanbase clinging onto the prior generation's top boy like their youth is slipping away.

The sucky thing here is that it'd be hard to spin this as a one off, and it could lead to copycat behaviour from audiences on Raw and SmackDown going forwards. The question is: Has WWE done enough to force people to hate on Cena, or will sentimentality cause hearts to rule over heads this Sunday?

Rhodes better hope the last bit doesn't come true.

What other nightmares could come true at WWE WrestleMania 41 this weekend? For more wrestling, check out WWE Black Wednesday Releases 5 Years Later - Where Are They Now? and 15 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Tony Atlas! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.