4 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (30 Oct - Results & Review)

Danhausen brought back Finn Bálor's 'Demon' on a spooky SmackDown special.

Danhausen Tiffany Stratton Cathy Kelley
WWE.com

So, if the timeless catchphrase 'Raw Is Jericho' will ring true forever, does that mean 'SmackDown Is Danhausen'? Perhaps not, but WWE did turn the blue brand's latest episode into a spooky special in honour of their resident Halloween goblin. That led to the return of the Gingerbread Man and Finn Bálor's 'Demon', but at least the former was a lighthearted nod towards painful moments earlier in the year and nothing else.

You've really got to wonder exactly where Triple H sees Gunther going in 2027. He can bounce back from all of this supernatural silliness, of course, but the 'Ring General' will take some rebuilding.

Elsewhere on this "Very Nice, Very Evil" SmackDown, WWE hit the repeat button on Money In The Bank (and will presumably continue to do so for a while yet) and Chelsea Green worked an unconvincing Women's Title defence vs. Nikki Bella. On a brighter note, another match in the female ranks acted as a neat surprise, and it looks like creative will come through for Blake Monroe after all.

In the main event scene, Sami Zayn retained his WWE Title by beating Trick Williams in an action-packed match which bettered anything they'd done when jousting for the United States belt, and Cody Rhodes kept things purring before his 'Last Man Standing' bout vs. Randy Orton at Crown Jewel.

Speaking of which, the PLE's main hook feels rather lacklustre despite a fun Sami vs. Roman Reigns match, so weekly TV could be a bit up and down in the short term. Here's all the good and bad from Friday fright night!


Downs...

4. A Demonic Return, But…

WWE.com

...where do we go from here?

OK, let's get this potential misery guts entry out of the way. It's worth saying that the live crowd on hand for SmackDown popped big for Finn Bálor returning to his 'Demon' guise. That must be such a thrill for people in attendance, but it does raise major question marks about what happens next.

Gunther vs. Finn Bálor’s ‘Demon’ is still an odd fit for the ‘Ring General’, and it doesn’t sit right that he’s mixing it in borderline comedy stuff vs. Danhausen either. Honestly, it really doesn’t seem like there’s a satisfying conclusion for anyone - if Gunther loses to Finn, then he’ll be creatively stranded, but if he convincingly thumps the ‘Demon’ then that’s another nail in the coffin for Bálor’s offshoot gimmick.

WWE can't really afford either outcome at the moment. Arguably, having Gunther beat Finn before rebuilding the Austrian up to World Title level is the way to go with all of this, but how many dings can a 'Demon' take? That persona doesn't come across as the invincible monster it's supposed to be, and there will be worries if Danhausen is still sniffing around ringside when push comes to shove on a blowoff match.

Turning Gunther into a Ryback-style heel bully has certainly been a choice. He's gone from retiring the likes of Goldberg, John Cena and AJ Styles to bumping Minihausens through tables and cowering away from Finn's alter ego. It's quite the slide.

He's good enough to bounce back, but WWE's writers sure aren't helping the wrestling machine out.


3. Not Sure We Needed A Third Chapter

Rey Fenix Ricky Saints
WWE.com

Friday's AAA Cruiserweight Title match pitting Rey Fenix vs. Ricky Saints was another slog for this pair. They had a fun bout on the 11 September SmackDown, but it’s been all downhill between them since then. The 16 October rematch fell flat, not just because of the DQ result, and things felt similar in this third stab at it.

Sadly, this live crowd didn’t come with them, which is likely the result of WWE almost exclusively dumping their feud in online exclusives. People will never care much about stories told that way. It’s a shame, because these dudes should be killing it every single time they hit the ring, but they’re meandering.

Fenix winning cleanly here should let both move on, at least.

The duo did spring into life for a better end sequence post-ad break, but everything before that was boring. Michael Cole can call these Cruiserweight “classics” all he likes. They’re not, and that's an insult to true classics like Eddie Guerrero vs. Rey Mysterio at WCW Halloween Havoc 1997 or even Dean Malenko vs. Scotty 2 Hotty from Backlash 2000.

Everyone understands that pro wrestling commentators are there to hype up the here and now, but let's not insult the audience or what came before eh? Fenix vs. Saints won't be remembered the same way those aforementioned matches have been, and no amount of announcing hyperbole is going to change that.

This whole exercise has produced exactly one good match and a few disappointments. It's time to find fresh rivals for both.


2. Women’s Title Match Found Wanting

Chelsea Green Nikki Bella
WWE.com

As expected, Chelsea Green vs. Nikki Bella didn’t really feel like it got going before the small package finish gave Chelsea the win. Bella’s recent match with Paige was surprisingly watchable, and Green vs. Roxanne Perez was good too. This…sadly wasn’t.

Nikki dominating practically the entire match was a choice. We all get that Chelsea is supposed to be an underdog champ, but she can’t look out of her depth in every single bout or it’ll get boring. Nope, your writer just wasn’t feeling this one at all.

The heat section was agonisingly dull, and there wasn't much vigour behind Green's comeback before she scored the victory either. Not many will be too shocked to hear that another Bella match struggled to entertain - that's been the way of it (aside from that Paige bout) since Nikki returned. Remember her sluggish efforts vs. Stephanie Vaquer and Becky Lynch?!

Ideally, Chelsea needs a physically dominant villain to play off of, and Bella just isn't that. She works as a sneaky cheat when heel, and that doesn't jive with Green's own 'I'm in over my head here, guys' style. There's nowhere for Chels to really go if Nikki is pacing around the ring hitting exactly zero power moves.

Chalk this one up as a bad night for both, in fairness. Sometimes, wrestlers just don't mesh well or exhibit any chemistry to speak of. Here's hoping Hunter and the rest of his writing staff realise there's nothing in a rematch between these women.

Like, ever again. There'd be no appetite for it.


1. Rinse & Repeat MITB Fare

Tiffany Stratton Money In The Bank Chelsea Green Raquel Rodriguez
WWE.com

Seriously? We're gonna do this again and again?!

Liv Morgan came out post-match to cut a so-so promo on Chelsea Green before Tiffany Stratton emerged with her briefcase for another samey teased cash-in spot. This was nothing you haven’t seen super-recently, which kinda spits in the face of pushing people towards watching SmackDown. IYO SKY also rushed out to make the save, because apparently that’s all she does these days.

Even Corey Graves shouted at Tiffany for taking too long to cash in, and this is getting old in a hurry. It’s literally the same segment over and over. Here, everyone looked idiotic: Morgan for looking surprised that Stratton was there, and Tiffany for failing to cash in on a layup yet again.

The way she stares at the ref/Green/whomever whilst clutching the case does nothing for Stratton. People have also pointed out on social media that this is almost identical to her approach back in 2024. Some of the cash-in skits, like Monday's one from Raw, are almost frame for frame copying what came before.

It's looking increasingly likely that Tiffany will just go rogue on Chelsea and cash in on her. Fair enough, but can we at least have some variety to this Liv stuff before then? Generally, if your segments make everyone look silly then they shouldn't be booked in the first place.

There are only so many times fans can stomach these implied cash-ins without payoff, especially when you're using copy then paste on the formatting of TV skits when they happen.


Ups...

4. Not The Worst Follow Up For Blake Monroe

Blake Monroe Paige
WWE.com

Back to back weeks of positivity about Blake Monroe. What is this witchcraft? Seriously though, yours truly was worried she’d go on to do absolutely nothing after beating Giulia in last week’s gamey ‘Street Fight’, but Blake had a tetchy confrontation with Paige backstage that dropped hints at a match between the pair.

Programming an eventual win over her fellow Brit wouldn’t be the worst plan for Monroe. She kinda has to go for gold at some point and become a bigger part of the division soon, but she mentioned that here, and beating Paige could push her into the title picture. Blake probs isn't going after the Women's US strap whilst fellow heel Jacy Jayne holds it, but she would be a fine foe for Chelsea Green.

That fully depends on what's coming with Tiffany Stratton's MITB moment, naturally.

One thing's evident: Blake has great poise in speaking segments like this. She's world class at coming across as a snooty little bitch, but she does so without sinking into Diva-esque levels like Paige herself and Nikki Bella did when sparring about who slept with who. Fingers crossed we don't dip back into that territory for this mini-feud.

Paige might also benefit from having someone as keen to impress as Blake. In-ring, there's no reason to predict they'll fail, and that's doubly true if things get heated enough for another 'Street Fight'-style brawl. Yep, book a screwy finish in the first match then we can get down to a proper scrap that pushes Monroe up another rung on the ladder.


3. Cody Comes Through For WWE Again

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

It's a bit of a luxury for WWE to know that they can simply send Cody Rhodes out in front of a live crowd with a microphone, give him some bullet points and watch him thrive. No, not every single solo promo has cut it since this became the norm for the 'American Nightmare', but he has to be one of the most dependable stars in this kind of spot.

Once more, Cody found himself kicking off the show with an opening promo skit designed to sell a major match. We saw this countless times when he was feuding with John Cena, and Cody is at it again vs. Randy Orton. Being honest, there isn’t much garnish left to put on their ‘Last Man Standing’ match at Crown Jewel anyway, but you can’t just leave 2 top stars like that off SmackDown until then.

Thus, it was cool that Rhodes was in the house to pop the crowd early and do his thing.

What a cracking fiery babyface promo this was from him too. Cody put over the eye injury he suffered at WrestleMania really well before vowing to punt Randy’s skull into the third row. He also teased that the winner will be number one contender to the WWE Title, so he did have something new to talk about.

Well, new in the context of this Crown Jewel build; not new in terms of either man going after the top prizes. They've been there, done that. Still, tacking on the number one contendership gimmick does bolster their 'Last Man Standing' tension in a logical way.


2. Jade & Tatum’s Spirited Showcase

Jade Cargill Tatum Paxley
WWE.com

Nah, that subheading isn’t a Halloween joke about spirits etc. Don't worry.

Spirited is the right word to describe what Jade Cargill and Tatum Paxley did as rivals on Friday night though. Their work was solid, Jade’s heat section made sense, then Paxley’s comeback before the interference-heavy finish was perfectly executed. The match was much better than Chelsea vs. Bella and even Fenix vs. Saints before it, which few could've predicted on paper.

This grumpy git had a boo boo face over the Women's Tag-Team Title change recently, largely because it cut short a promising run for Alexa Bliss and Tatum. However, if we're being completely fair about everything going on, Paxley will be totally fine in the long run. She can be mighty proud of the shift she and Cargill put in on SmackDown too.

Trips should take 2 simple notes coming out of the show: 1. Never book Chelsea Green vs. Nikki Bella again. 2. Circle Tatum vs. Jade as a possible singles title feud for later on down the line. Why not? You've got to reward those tandems that show off some chemistry, and these women certainly did.

Paxley seemed to relish taking a kicking from Cargill during the heat section, and her comeback post-break before the ending was going over well with the live crowd. Oh yes, there's something brewing away nicely between these ladies. It'd be sweet to see that on a bigger platform in the future.

Possible Women's US Title feud, perhaps? Or, how about a full blown Women's World Title showcase? Don't rule it out.


1. A Functional Main Event As Sami Survives

Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Sami Zayn vs. Trick Williams turned out to be better than this fan thought it might be going in.

An early disqualification result saw GM Nick Aldis come out to restart the match and turn it into a ‘No DQ’ affair. That'll come up in conversation between he and Zayn when the reigning WWE Champ does his conspiracy chat. Aldis also banned Lil Yachty, Johnny Gargano and Candice LeRae from ringside for good measure.

The second half’s brawling helped, and Trick looked really good here. He's on a precipice of greatness in the company, and it could genuinely go either way. On one hand, he's a star in the making and has main event potential. On the other, Trick maybe needs to ditch his short sentence promo style that leans on comedic flourishes and flowery lingo.

That's up for debate, definitely. Some folks out there will love it and view things differently.

Friday's story emphasis was on Sami finding new ways to survive as WWE Champion, which is a fun wrinkle he has going on. He worked a throwaway title match here for sure, but it was a nice ride and did get Williams into the convo for possible showdowns with Roman Reigns in the future.

Zayn is a bit of a wrestling cheat code in 2026. He can do it all. Sami and Trick did stumble during their US Title feud earlier this year, right enough, so it was nifty to see these old enemies produce something better for the top belt.

Onto Crown Jewel and some Bloodline bashing for Zayn.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Banned Segments WWE Had To Censor and 12 Cursed Comparisons That DOOMED Promising Wrestlers!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.