4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (30 May - Results & Review)

John Cena's retirement tour sags in the middle; NXT stars help WWE SmackDown.

Ethan Page WWE SmackDown
WWE.com

Unpredictable MVP alert.

No, not AEW's Montel Vontavious Porter. NXT's very own Ethan Page was an unforeseen highlight on this week's episode of WWE SmackDown, and all the guy did was join commentary then poke his nose into a tag-team match. Page's performance would've impressed all the right people backstage though - he was really, really good throughout, and the guy came across as a real star.

There was plenty of star power in the 'main event segment'. Cody Rhodes returned to the blue brand for the first time since WrestleMania 41, and he was joined by Jey Uso, John Cena and Logan Paul. Unfortunately, all four hit a snag en route to their tag bout at Money In The Bank. There's just something painfully uninteresting about the whole thing, and it pales in comparison to say...Cody hunting down revenge on Cena to regain his title.

On the plus side, two matches hit the heights, Damian Priest set his stall out for a welcome title challenge, and there was more emotional goodness between fractured friends. Bianca Belair and Naomi worked wonders way back on the 7 March edition of SmackDown pre-'Mania, and they were at it again on this week's show. That live crowd in Knoxville was super-into seeing them butt heads.

Soon, people. Soon.

Reports spread this week that WWE and USA Network plans to persist with these 3 hour episodes of the show. This week's offering was almost an argument for returning to the old 2-hour format. No, that's not a compliment. Here's all the good and bad!


Downs...

5. The Wyatts Do Literally The Same Thing

The Wyatt Sicks
WWE.com

Firstly, seeing The Wyatt Sicks roar back into view on last week's show then wish fallen brother Bray Wyatt a happy heavenly birthday was awesome. It's also worth saying that they should add a lot to the SmackDown tag-team division overall, but not if WWE's writing team keep hitting the repeat button like they did on Friday night.

This sucks to point out, but nobody had anything new to say during the segment. The Street Profits bragged about being leaders of the SmackDown tag division, Fraxiom said they’re still owed a fair shot, Motor City Machine Guns put their name in the frame, and DIY moaned as usual. Then, the lights went out so Uncle Howdy and The Wyatts could attack and lay waste to everyone. Yeah, this is pretty much exactly what happened last week, and it doesn't help that nobody in the division seems to have a voice/point worth listening to right now.

SmackDown's tag tanks have been hot in-ring, but this was a repeat of last week’s show for the most part and came across as filler as a result. Later, Howdy appeared in a spooky pre-taped vignette to say he and his Sicks won't stop until they get what they're owed. Perhaps it's harsh, but it's also coming across loud and clear that WWE's creative squad just don't really know what to do with The Wyatt Sicks after writing a cool first chapter.

If this keeps up, then they'll veer awkwardly towards Dark Order in AEW territory, and nobody wants that. The mere thought should send shudders up spines.


4. Why Is This Still Going On?

Chelsea Green Piper Niven Alba Fyre Secret Her-vice
WWE.com

Zelina Vega vs. Alba Fyre was the latest chapter in Vega’s issues with Chelsea Green and crew. Personally, this fan loves Chelsea’s act, but her feud with Zelina is as interminable as the Michin one was. WWE are feeding these women scraps. Scraps, we say! Also, is anyone else still unconvinced that putting the Women’s United States Title on Vega was the right call? She even got a jobber entrance here, for crying out loud.

Hey, maybe Triple H is about to gift her some better music and they’re busy working on that. A boy can dream, because her current track really is terrible. It isn't doing much to add excitement to shows, which is surely what Zelina would want when she's bouncing out in front of crowds as a babyface champion.

There are only so many times peeps can see Vega find fresh ways to put egg on the face of the Secret Her-vice before everyone gets bored and wants something else. Admittedly, there is hope now that Giulia has confronted Zelina backstage - maybe she's the tonic to making that Women's United States Title relevant again. It does seem like Green and cohorts need something new and to move away from the belt for a while.

This guy wouldn't be against Chelsea challenging Tiffany Stratton at some stage over the summer. Why not? Anything would be better than watching her run the same plays against the likes of Zelina Vega. Their rivalry isn't cutting it. It's starting to stink up the joint, being brutally honest.

Next.


3. Something Isn’t Clicking With JC Mateo

R-Truth JC Mateo
WWE.com

WWE had a clear goal in mind for JC Mateo's soft squash-esque win over R-Truth on Friday's episode of SmackDown: Present Mateo as a powerhouse who uses his low centre of gravity to trick opponents into thinking he isn't strong as an ox. The bout was short, but it wasn't snappy enough to get the job done and tick off that 'JC is a beast we should care about' box.

This writer hopes he’s wrong in the long run, but Jeff Cobb in WWE as Solo Sikoa’s muscle Mateo isn’t really working thus far. He had a fine enough win over Truth here, and his finisher looks great on the right people, but yeah - something is missing. Dude has tag-team guy written all over him, so that could be his ceiling during this surprise run with the company.

The sooner WWE gets to the stuff between Sikoa and Jacob Fatu with Mateo sandwiched in between, the better. In fairness, it was nice to see JC attacking Jimmy Uso when Solo was trying to recruit though. Slowly casting him as a brute Sikoa doesn't have the leadership to control would amplify a story Solo has already been telling with Fatu anyway, and at least that'd give Mateo some menace.

Would anyone really be shocked if Fatu burned through both these guys then moved on to pastures new (Damian Priest, for example) whilst Solo and JC attacked the tag-team division? That wouldn't be the worst use of Mateo in particular, because something isn't hitting the way WWE wants it to.

He's only just arrived on the WWE roster and he's already up and down.


2. Women’s Triple Threat Fails To Get Going

Naomi Jade Cargill Nia Jax
WWE.com

Cards on the table. There was a bit of buzz heading into Nia Jax vs. Jade Cargill vs. Naomi in a MITB qualifying match. All three have history together, and the trio have been inspired as characters lately. That's especially true for Naomi. Sadly, the match turned out to be fairly dull. It never really got going, and was hurt bad by spotty logic.

Nia and Naomi working together after Jax nearly took the latter’s head off with a leg drop from the turnbuckle? That made little sense. It was a temporary alliance, sure, but still. The timing was off. There was a lot of both standing around audibly telling Cargill what to do and where to be, so the bout looked disjointed and was a bit of a disappointment overall too. Jade’s offensive bits were the best thing about it, because the live crowd seemed really into them.

Their midway through, “This Is Awesome” chants were so forced though. Bless you for trying, Tennessee, but this wasn't a match worthy of that singalong.

Most will be glad to see Naomi win, at least. The way she escaped Nia’s squash to then roll her up was slick, and it fit into the opportunistic heel aura the former 'Glow' favourite has going on these days.

Dunno, at times it seemed like these women were rehearsing their match before doors opened. It was clunky, had zero flow, and both heels seemed far too concerned with holding Jade's hand the longer it went on. Definitely a Triple Threat that looked better on paper than it did inside the ring, and that's a pity.


1. Final Segment Drags Bad

John Cena Logan Paul Cody Rhodes Jey Uso
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes, Jey Uso, John Cena and Logan Paul didn’t actually have a lot of material to work with or much to say, but their segment right at the end of the show still went long anyway. OK, got to be brutally honest and speak freely. The fan writing this piece is not into WWE's bumper tag-team bout at Money In The Bank at all. It's coming across as a house show main event more than something worthy of PLE.

Why is Cody content to go after Cena in a tag-team match? Shouldn't he be right up for avenging his WrestleMania 41 loss and winning the title back from a retiring ex-hero who turned his back on everybody? Further, this leg of John Cena’s retirement tour is sagging in the middle badly. Maybe running with Cena vs. R-Truth then this exhibition tag back to back isn't the best idea.

The biggest issue here is that there...isn’t much at stake come MITB, and that’s a problem. Jey has already beaten Logan Paul, Cody seems happy to forget about the title he should be obsessed with, Cena is blatantly only teaming with Logan because the celeb turned wrestler campaigned for it backstage, and nothing is up for grabs on the next supershow.

In fact, the only real gem in this entire skit was Rhodes and his, “Polish his Peacemaker” line aimed at Paul for sucking up to Cena. That was clever, but it was too little too late for a segment that chewed up time for the sake of it. Are people honestly happy to pay inflated ticket prices just to see entrances these days?! No judging, but it's a valid question.


Ups...

4. Damian Priest Targets Jacob Fatu

Damian Priest Jacob Fatu
WWE

This will be bloody epic.

Damian Priest came out to talk with a black eye and put Drew McIntyre over for the duo's vicious steel cage match at Saturday Night's Main Event last weekend. Then, Priest said McIntyre is firmly in his past and that he plans to move on to new things. Without hesitating, Damian called his shot vs. Jacob Fatu for the United States Title. That works, and it could wind up being one of the best midcard feuds of WWE's 2025.

When Priest went to leave, Fatu emerged for his three-way MITB qualifier and the pair shared a respectful staredown. That, if nothing else, shows just how much Jacob is changing now he's moving away from Solo Sikoa. The US Champ does more talking than he did before, and he's even playing up to positive fan reactions during his matches; Fatu is 100% babyface now.

Bring on the battles with Damian, Trips. They'll beat the crap out of one another and have some scorchers for sure. This is also the best possible use of Priest following his on/off year long rivalry with Drew. The hardworking big Scot has taken some well-earned time off to heal up, so creative can get busy on drumming up fresh scenarios for his return soon.

For now, they've got one hell of a United States Title series to tackle. Solo and JC Mateo will be involved in things too, but Fatu vs. Priest is more tantalising than that. Hopefully, WWE don't throw this away at Money In The Bank with one week's worth of build. It could be something special.


3. More Emotion Between Fractured Friends

Naomi Bianca Belair
WWE.com

Man, there’s just something magical in the air when Bianca Belair and Naomi get face to face like this. They've mastered the art of making exchanges feel realistic whilst still maintaining a little sports entertainment style pizzazz, and there’s a money program coming between them once Bianca’s injured fingers heal up. Not sure the same can be said for more of Naomi warring with Jade Cargill, but there’s plenty of frost to explore between Jade and Belair too.

Naomi and Belair worked a really slick opening segment which fed into the first match on the show. It's sweet to have Bianca back on Fridays. She was missed around here. Sure, Naomi claiming to have broken into Belair’s parent’s house and looking through a photo album that happened to be on the coffee table is obviously unbelievable and terribly convenient, but it does push the story forwards at least.

Everything has come together for WWE with these two former Women's Tag-Team Champs. Belair is a main event level piece of talent, Naomi is thriving as a heel, Jade Cargill got some shine by avenging what happened to her during WrestleMania season, and now Naomi vs. 'EST' is dangling beautifully in front of everyone's faces.

SummerSlam showdown in waiting? Yes please.

Other members of the WWE roster could learn a lot from studying how these women interact with each other. They've done a bang up job of pushing the idea that there's still some love between them despite everything that's happened. Then, Naomi goes and ruins that by making uncalled for remarks about Bianca's mother. It's good character work.


2. A Bouncy Boy Tag!

Los Garza Rey Fenix Je'Von Evans
WWE.com

Je’von Evans and Rey Fenix vs. Los Garza was tons of fun.

Evans showed out with the kind of bouncy work he’s become known for on NXT, Fenix was his usual self doing stellar work aerially, and Garza are just such a well-oiled tag-team. As a bonus, and as aforementioned during the intro, Ethan Page sitting in on guest commentary was sensational. Honestly, the NXT North American Champ came across really well every single time he opened his mouth, and he actually has announcer potential once he retire if he so wishes - he’s got a good voice for it.

Ultimately, this match means nothing to the core SmackDown product, but it was a fun watch and gave the announcers an an excuse to plug Worlds Collide for next weekend regardless. Yep, there's a wee bit of AEW Forbidden Door about this, which isn’t for everybody, but the match was solid and it’s something different for the blue brand.

Plus, Page looked like a star, and people watching will likely want to see more of Je’Von to boot. Triple H and Shawn Michaels (who naturally has a keen eye on the NXT side of things) will be chuffed with how things panned out here. Here's hoping Hunter is ready to give Angel and Berto their flowers in 2025 too. They richly deserve some good moments for all the hard work they've put in alongside Santos Escobar.

If this was a test for Je'Von to see how he'd bed in on the main roster, then he passed it with flying colours. Sometimes literally in the flying department.


1. Men’s Qualifier Ticks A Lot Of Boxes

Jacob Faru Carmelo Hayes Andrade
WWE.com

Andrade winning this match was a bit of a surprise considering Jacob Fatu was involved, but ‘El Idolo’ will work some nice spots at MITB and deserved something to hang his hat on after an unhealthy chunk of time spinning his wheels. Carmelo Hayes and Andrade have natural chemistry, so having them wrestle with Fatu in the mix was some laugh, and it acted as a welcome reminder of their stunning series last year.

This had bags more energy than the women’s three way earlier in the show. Jacob ending himself by crashing through the barricade looked crazy, Andrade likely had a spring in his step because he knew he was going over in an important match for once, and there's the sense that Hayes is ready for more focus from WWE's writers soon too. Y'know, unless they're still interested in making he and The Miz a tag-team threat.

JC Mateo and Solo Sikoa costing Jacob at least motors that story forwards. With Solo/JC then Damian Priest on the back burner, things look rather swish for Fatu and for the United States Title hunt generally. There's a lot to like about how this one ended up. It had a slightly shocking winner, Carmelo Hayes looked confident and on his game, and Fatu is still getting top star level reactions from live crowds no matter which town WWE visits.

Credit to all of these men for picking up the pace and having some fun out there without sacrificing story. That's the most important thing to WWE, and it was nice that the three-way understood that.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From John Cena On Stephanie McMahon's WWE Show and 15 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Muhammad Hassan!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.