5 Most Controversial WCW Gimmicks Ever

Slaves, child abductors and alcoholics - WCW wasn't always family-friendly...

dustin rhodes seven.jpg
WWE.com

The WWF get a lot of credit for being edgy during the halcyon days that were the Attitude Era. In the late 90s and early 2000s, characters like porn star Val Venis, the ambiguous and androgynous Goldust, and the mother-loving Beaver Cleavage showed up on WWE screens.

The results were mixed at best, but this particularly period has been lionised to the extent that a third multi-disc Attitude Era DVD box set is due to drop this year, celebrating all of that weak, distinctly un-PC goodness (as well as actual megastars like Stone Cold, The Rock, and The Undertaker of course).

WCW were generally not afforded the luxury of being so obviously risqué since they were Turner Broadcasting-owned, had a PG rating, and had to answer to a very stringent set of standards and practices. They were supposedly family-friendly entertainment, but there were a handful of out-there gimmicks down the years that caused controversy.

Indeed, several characters caused alarm bells to ring and one even resulted in a lawsuit. Others were so misjudged that they caused fans to question the product, while some were supposed to be cutting-edge but just ended up causing confusion.

On the whole, WCW characters weren't controversial but these five certainly had their naysayers.


5. Harlem Heat

Harlem Heat
WWE.com

Harlem Heat were one of the most decorated WCW tag teams ever, winning the WCW World Tag Team Titles a whopping ten times during their five year run together, but they had a very inauspicious debut with the Atlanta-based company.

Previously known on the indies as 'The Ebony Experience', Harlem Heat originally made their WCW starts as a pair of wrestling prisoners (read: slaves) who had been won by Colonel Rob Parker in a card game. I'm not making that part up, honestly. This was good old boy WCW southern wrasslin' as its worst.

Billed as 'Kole' (Booker T) and 'Kane' (Stevie Ray), the brothers came to the ring wearing wrist and foot shackles. This was all apparently the idea of Sid Vicious, the man who had gotten the Heat their jobs with the company.

Naturally, some folks saw this as problematic. Then-WCW President Bill Shaw was not happy that the idea almost made its way to a TV taping (the team worked wearing prison garb but had their prison ID numbers covered by masking tape) and quickly saw about getting it changed.

But seriously, guys, how do you pair up two African American men with a dude who looks like a plantation owner? This might not have become a full-blown thing but it was certainly controversial at the time.


4. Arachnaman

Brad Armstrong, of the famous Armstrong wrestling family, was probably one of the most underrated guys to ever wrestle for a major organisation. He was a tremendous athlete, a great wrestler, and by all accounts a hell of a guy, too.

Despite all of his positive traits, he never managed to rise above midcard level and pretty much hung around the tag team and light heavyweight divisions, wrestling solid matches but never receiving much of a push or any sort of creative direction.

Then one day in 1991 WCW had an amazing (read: idiotic) gimmick idea for him.

He was going to be ARACHNAMAN! The pro-wrestling man-spider guy, or something. Basically, he was a real-life version of Spider-Man, okay? Only he wore purple and yellow, so that's totally fine and not violating any copyright laws, right?

Wrong. Marvel caught a whiff of what WCW were up to and threatened to sue them for copyright infringement unless they ceased and desisted with the character.

And that was the end of Arachnaman. Shame, really. His silly string finisher was MONEY. This was an embarrassment for WCW, since it was so very blatant what they were trying to do and were completely shut down by the comic book giants.

Side note: WCW also needed to receive an agreement from Marvel Comics in 1998 when they were renewing Hulk Hogan's WCW contract, because Marvel actually owned the name at the time.


3. 'Last Call' ScottHall

WWE.com

It's often been said that the best and most successful gimmicks are the when the person that's portraying them turns their personality up to '11'. There's certainly some truth to that assessment, and you need only look at a guy like 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, one of the biggest stars ever in the business, as evidence.

It is never, however, a good idea to take a real-life personal problem and incorporate it into a person's character. That's exactly what WCW did in 1998, though, with the utterly dreadful and very controversial 'Last Call' Scott Hall.

The former Razor Ramon's battles with alcohol have been well-documented, and in 1998/99, Hall was arrested numerous times for drunken behaviour, including on October 2, 1998 when he was arrested for keying a limousine outside of a strip club.

He had been to rehab that year and the year previously for thirty-day stints, but they didn't have the desired effect. Hall continue to drink. A lot. And WCW decided to incorporate it into his character. He'd show up on Nitro and on pay-per-view with a beer or a cup of vodka in his hand, slurring his speech and vomiting outside of the ring, all while the announcers talked about how they were fearful for his life and how he needed to seek and receive professional help.

Which was true, of course, but WCW obviously weren't very serious about getting Hall the help he needed if they were having him portray an alcoholic on-screen. It was a shameful thing to do, and fans and critics rightly lambasted the company for going ahead with it.

People watch wrestling for an escape, not to be reminded of real-life problems that affect thousands of ordinary people every day.


2. Brian Pillman

Brian Pillman WCW 1995
WWE.com

Where does one start with Brian Pillman's stunning character transformation?

Towards the end of 1995, the former Cincinnati Bengals player and Four Horseman member switched up his look, ditching the clean-cut pure athlete thing for an altogether edgier appearance, while also undergoing a serious attitude adjustment.

The high-flying sensation suddenly became wholly unpredictable and would regularly go "off-script", surprising fans and convincing them that while everything else might be fake, he was definitely real. Even his co-workers had no idea whether Pillman had actually lost his mind, or whether he was just acting, so convincing was his portrayal and dedication to the role.

Eric Bischoff, Kevin Sullivan, and a couple of others (Terry Funk, Dave Meltzer and Kim Wood) knew that it was a work, but they gave the impression that they too were bewildered by Pillman's antics. One person who didn't know it was a work was Bobby Heenan, who was grabbed by Pillman during a Clash of the Champions broadcast, causing the veteran manager and announcer to lose his cool and shout 'what the f**k do you think you're doing?' live on the air.

Pillman was working the boys in the back, the dirtsheets and, as it turned out, his own boss. After losing an 'I Respect You' Strap Match with WCW booker Kevin Sullivan (during which he broke kayfabe by sarcastically saying 'I respect you, booker man' over the house mic), Pillman was fired by WCW President Eric Bischoff.

Bischoff has since revealed that this was all part of the work and that he was 'firing' Pillman so that he could go to ECW and further develop the gimmick. Little did he know that Pillman legitimately wanted out of his contract so that he could sign a big-money deal with the WWF. Whoops.

Although things would get a whole lot more controversial in ECW and WWF, Pillman's 'Loose Cannon' beginnings were in WCW and his blurring of fact and fiction helped get people talking (and worried).


1. Seven

Seven WCW.jpg
WWE Network

You've got to hand it to Dustin Rhodes. Few men would have been able to make a character as outlandish and controversial as Goldust work, but he did it. Regardless of how questionable the content he was given was, Rhodes went out there and gave it his all, oftentimes turning chicken s**t into chicken salad in the process.

When Rhodes left the WWF in the summer of 1999 and headed for WCW, many wondered under what gimmick he would be going back to Atlanta with, or if he'd even be wrestling under a gimmick at all. After all, Rhodes had enjoyed a successful run wrestling under his given name and without a fancy gimmick in the early 90s before he mad the jump to New York.

Vignettes began plying on WCW television hyping the forthcoming debut of a character named 'Seven', to be played by Rhodes. The vignette showed Rhodes, his face covered in white makeup (which made him look like the title character from the film Powder), standing outside of a child's bedroom window and asking him to come with him in order to 'live forever'.

They were eerie and creepy and it was hard to know what to make of them.

The character was quite blatantly modelled on The Strangers, the villains from the 1998 neo-noir Dark City, right down to long black coat and hat. To a lot of people, though - including Turner Standards and Practices - it looked like it could be easily misinterpreted as being a child abductor/molester.

The character made its debut on the November 9th 1999 edition of Nitro, levitating his way to the ring with the aid of a zip wire. It was a cool visual, but as soon as Rhodes got into the ring he broke character and delivered a bizarre 'worked shoot' promo aimed at the WCW 'powers that be' (writers Vince Russo and Ed Ferrara), the Goldust character and the WWF.

Seven was the brainchild of Rhodes and a temporary booking committee, but then Russo was hired and he didn't like it so had convinced Dustin to ditch it.

The Seven character was over before it got started and Rhodes went back to wrestling as 'The American Nightmare' Dustin Rhodes. Which was just as well, really, since the Seven character had some seriously sinister undertones to it and was just asking to land WCW in hot water.


In this post: 
WCW Goldust
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...