5 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage: Fyter Fest Week One (July 15)
Sting's standoff; Claudio Castagnoli targets ROH gold; Brody King goes backwards?

Listeeeeeen!
The Acclaimed are officially on the babyface warpath these days, and it's a welcome change for both Anthony Bowens and Max Caster. The rowdy pair had one of Rampage's most engaging segments this week too, which is promising, and they're heading for a sleeper hit tag match.
If only everything on the 60-minute show was that solid. Friday's show marked the 50th edition of AEW's third major hour, and it carried the Fyter Fest branding - that was a bid to make Rampage feel bigger, but it didn't really work. Being honest, only one of the four bouts on offer were actually worth your time.
That was a fine match though, and there was enough elsewhere to keep the 'Ups' count high. A messy main event and totally duff women's portion couldn't harsh the buzz of ROH robustness, Claudio Castagnoli's next move, Miro adding some mystery to his game and quite the staring contest.
Here's all the good and bad from the latest bump on the road before build properly starts for September's All Out. Oh yeah, and Ring Of Honor has a pay-per-view next week. There was hype for that too...
Downs...
3. Back In His Lane

Credit to the commentary team for trying their best to talk Brody King up during the opener, but the truth is that he's gone from challenging Jon Moxley to selling far too much for Dark Order. That's not meant as a knock on Alex Reynolds or John Silver, but they got waytoo much in here.
Whilst it is cool that AEW wants to make everything competitive...not everything needs to be. House Of Black are really suffering from this. One minute, fans are supposed to believe that they're maulers who can't be stopped. The next, they're huffing and puffing against the lowest teams on the tag food chain.
It's jarring.
Rampage's first bout had some questionable moments. Silver hitting a German suplex on Brody was impressive, but just seemed to happen 'because spotz', and Reynolds visibly asked if Malakai Black was in position to break up the resultant pin on camera.
2. Such A Waste

Wow, this sucked.
The Renegades aren't in any position to do so, but they'd be forgiven for marching into Tony Khan's office and asking what the point of killing it on Dark is if they're treated like jobbers on the main shows; Robyn also had a fun bout vs. Ruby Soho on this show several months back.
That, apparently, counts for nothing. They were sacrificial lambs for Kris Statlander and Athena (who aren't even a proper team!), and they deserve so much more than this utter tripe. Honestly, AEW should've switched the first two tags and had HOB run straight through Reynolds/Silver instead.
Worse, All Elite instantly negated the point of the squash by having Jade Cargill and Kiera Hogan run out to dispatch the victorious babyfaces with ease. Thanks for coming, Renegades. Maybe half-ass it on Dark next time and thumb your nose at Tony.
1. Messy Main Event

Referees need to start actually counting the illegal man during tag-team matches in this promotion, because things are getting ridiculous. Private Party vs. The Lucha Bros wasn't supposed to be a Tornado Tag, but it played out more like one than anything else.
There were a few rough spots and botches in there too.
Chris Jericho called it "one hell of a match", presumably 'cause it's his job to hype things up. In reality, the headliner was messy and very meh. This whole mask-stealing story between Andrade/Rush and Penta/Rey Fenix is terribly half-baked too.
AEW has produced some real tag-team classics during its first three years as a company. This wasn't one of them, and it's the kind of match that shows there's still a long way for Party to go before they belong in the upper echelons.
Some psychology would be lovely.
Ups...
5. Not Today

Onto the good.
The segment between Gunn Club and The Acclaimed was as slick as they come. Nobody did anything revolutionary, but it didn't overstay its welcome and solidified the Caster/Bowens duo as babyface sensations in the making. Live crowds are super-into these dudes.
The Gunns knocking back a challenge is exactly the sort of thing they should be doing too. There's certainly nothing wrong with old school wrasslin' 101, and that's what this was. Separating both squads (their union was a little sudden and weird) from one another will do them both good in the long run.
Tip of the cap to Tony Khan if the plan all along was to re-emphasis the Gunns as heels and turn The Acclaimed baby. If that was the boss man's intention, then he's executed things to perfection. Some Rampage promo skits are uncoordinated - this worked a charm.
4. Having A Word With God

Miro's AEW career is worthy of a full 'Ups & Downs' article itself. He's gone from the bad (being Kip Sabian's "Best Man") to the good (that TNT Title run) and everywhere in between. Mediocrity is not where the former Rusev belongs, so it was sweet to see him add an air of mystery on this week's Rampage.
Putting a big question mark above Miro's head isn't the worst idea.
He delivered a short, punchy promo about possibly joining House Of Black. During his speech, which was laced with footage of the incident, Miro asked his God if Malakai Black blowing mist into his eyes was a sign to punish them or join the group. Ooooh, intrigue!
Black's collective doesn't badly need a new member, but Miro would be that standalone singles star to pin their hopes on. All Elite would just need to be careful that he doesn't step on Brody King's toes as the go-to enforcer.
3. Make The First Move!

Welcome to AEW: Staring Contest. It's a simple premise, granted, albeit one that works well when the star power is there. Rampage featured quite the staredown between Malakai Black and Sting, and it's something they can link back to at a later date.
They must.
Black and the Stinger teased throwing hands before going their separate ways down individual entrance/exit tunnels. There was a rippling sense of anticipation from the audience about seeing these fellas lock horns, which is exactly what both must've been shooting for.
Side note: Darby Allin was like freakin' Batman as he leapt from the shadows onto Brody King. Good job from JR on comms to point out that Darby going after a big man like King "is a testament to his guts". Everything about this segment, including Black eyeballing Sting, clicked.
2. A Cracking Little Showcase

If you're only going to watch one match from Rampage, make it the ROH World Title humdinger between Jonathan Gresham and Lee Moriarty. Things started off on the front foot when Moriarty begrudgingly adhered to the 'Code Of Honor' handshake rule before grounding Gresham and raining down elbows.
That was a hot start.
Caprice Coleman on commentary jumped in to remind viewers that Jonathan had left Moriarty high and dry in a tag bout last week, hence the anger from Lee. Then, Coleman expertly set about the task of explaining that Gresham's chin is a weakness Lee might try to exploit. He offered superb analysis.
No, there was never really any threat of Moriarty taking the ROH strap, but this was a fine way to get Gresham and the ROH Title on AEW TV; they got there with some simple set up, had a tidy match then lined up the champ's next challenger...
1. Claudio Castagnoli Gets A Good Spot

...this guy.
Regular readers will know that this writer isn't typically delighted about all that AEW vs. *insert promotion here* crossover stuff, but complaining about a match as good on paper as Jonathan Gresham vs. Claudio Castagnoli seems silly. They're about to have a scorcher at Death Before Dishonor.
Next week's pay-per-view will mark Claudio's first showing on a Dishonor card since teaming with Chris Hero to face The Briscoes in June 2010. Is it the tippy-top spot some were hoping he'd have in AEW? Well, no, but it's preferable to spinning wheels in the midcard like Keith Lee did for months.
Castagnoli's star power undoubtedly elevates ROH's show too, and that has to be considered a good thing. Remarkably, the former Cesaro has never held a major singles World Title before. Keep an eye on the match vs. Gresham, because this could be Claudio's time.
It's a good spot for him regardless of the outcome.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more like this, check out 4 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (July 8) and 10 Wrestlers Who Knew They Were DOOMED On Day One!