5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (18 Sept - Results & Review)
Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens work another scorcher; Cody Rhodes continues teasing Paul Heyman alliance.
SmackDown's main event scene can seemingly do no wrong. This stuff is gripping even when the finishes are all out of whack and referees are having brain farts! Seriously though, not even a colossal dropped ball from the official during Friday's main event could stop Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens from tearing the house down in Corpus Christi.
It's Money In The Bank qualifying season, and you know what that means. A boatload of Triple Threat matches started in earnest on Raw recently, and that continued on the blue side of things. SmackDown's shorter runtime meant that WWE could only squeeze 2 such bouts onto the format sheets, but they showcased everything that's right and wrong with this formulaic approach.
The tag-team division is also in dire straits too, and the same can be said of most midcard work on Smackers. Thankfully, that headline scene is pulling the nose up in a big, big way. Speaking of which, one Cody Rhodes continued his slow descent into madness via a pre-taped sit-down interview with Michael Cole on this week's show.
WWE kept the cameras rolling afterwards so Triple H could share some juicy footage on social media. It shows a darker side of Cody emerging from the shadows of a psyche ruined by the actions of others. There was also room for yet another Paul Heyman tease in the mix too. Just really cool work all round from the 'American Nightmare' as we march towards the final few months of the year.
Here's all the good and bad from SmackDown's latest round.
Downs...
3. Women’s Triple Threat Fails To Hit Heights
Firstly, it’s a positive that Jacy Jayne won to qualify for Money In The Bank, because she’s a good fit there. However, this women’s match wasn’t as good as the men’s counterpart on this week’s SmackDown. Look, it’s only being compared to that because both were Triple Threats, but this trio even copied the same superplex spot from the guys - an agent backstage really should’ve avoided that like the plague. Weren't they paying attention? These things should be ironed out ahead of time, especially in samey matches.
Overall, the bout was slightly disjointed. It wasn't ever outright bad by any means, but this is a recurring problem with samey qualifiers. These Triple Threats get old rather quickly, especially if there are multiple on the same 2-hour broadcast. That's going to be something to look out for if you're already bored of them. WWE still has some spots to fill in both ladder matches, so it's Triple Threat Mania and that's that.
Also, Jade Cargill didn’t actually stop the ref from counting after Alexa’s Sister Abigail on Jayne. That looked a bit rubbish, and the official was forced to stop her count even though nothing was impacting her hands/arms. Things would've been different had Jade got there just a split second earlier.
Jacy, Alexa Bliss and Cargill suffered because Randy Orton vs. Trick Williams vs. Rey Fenix was so much better and came before it. All 3 were kinda hung out to dry by creative and those aforementioned agents who simply weren't paying close enough attention.
2. Bakusai Takes A Step Back
Shinsuke Nakamura and Kyoki had a solid debut recently against The Miz and Kit Wilson, but maybe this week's slide was always going to happen when WWE’s grand plans for the tag-team division could be written on a napkin. Bakusai vs. MFTs went to a DQ in around 7 minutes, but it was a bit of a snore before that. No, that…isn’t a good sign for their coming rematch.
This whole division needs a rethink, man. It’s been hitting the skids for a long time now, and there’s just nothing to get excited about even if you adore tag-team wrestling. Sure, it is interesting to see someone like Kyoki on the roster, but it’s hardly great that his second televised match was mere time filler. The announcers barely even spoke about him on commentary or put over why fans should be buzzed about seeing him team with Nakamura.
Honestly? Your writer really wanted to like this more, but it’s tough to recommend.
Haku getting involved for the finish does give him some impact around ringside, to be fair. Someone needs to have a word with Talla about how painfully awkward and slow his big man offensive stuff is though. It's like pulling teeth, and he doesn't even complement Tama well as a partner either. MFTs are gonna have to do a whole heck of a lot better than this if they want their tag title reign to mean anything.
Meanwhile, it's plain to see that WWE will give up on Kyoki pronto. He already feels like just another dude who has nothing to help him stand out.
1. Did The Ref Screw Up?
Eek! What happened here then?
The official only counted to 2 after CM Punk nailed Kevin Owens in the main event. That was clearly supposed to be 3, because KO didn’t kick out at all and Sami looked mighty confused. Yeah, everyone should be real grateful that fans were too busy chanting for Punk to notice, because that was messy and uncoordinated to say the least. Zayn hit a Helluva Kick to score the win regardless, but it would’ve been better had he capitalised on Punk’s actions like he was obviously supposed to.
There’s space in the ‘Ups’ for this match, because it was tremendous on the whole, but that finish sucked the life out of things a little. Credit to veterans like Sami and Kev for sticking with it and going into the Helluva Kick. Some on social media have suggested that Owens called an audible, but he didn't even really haul his shoulder off the mat. If he wanted to extend the match another 30 seconds or so, then he would've kicked out with some force, so that doesn't add up.
Plus, we've all been watching pro wrestling long enough to know from a ref or wrestler's face when something's gone awry. Zayn was perplexed, and the official had that sheepish look in his eye. It was a proper clanger in such an important match. Thank God it didn't spoil things completely, but it is worth noting in the 'Downs' section here.
Oh well, better screwing up on TV than in the main event of WrestleMania huh?
Ups...
5. “Uncompromised” Cody Rhodes Sits Down
Cody Rhodes sat down with Michael Cole for one of those solemn, serious interviews that pop up every so often. Footage was shown of his inability to punt Randy Orton at SNME, which cost Rhodes. Cody then said that he’s had so much success since returning to WWE because he’s stayed true to who he is despite all of the noise about his “morality”. He even sneaked Paul Heyman’s name in there by complimenting the ex-ECW kingpin for spotting something in him few others could.
That’s interesting, because Rhodes had previously borrowed Heyman’s “not a prediction that’s a spoiler” line on SmackDown too. Personally, yours truly still thinks this is heading towards a heel turn, but the cracks in Cody’s psyche when asked about whether he’s turning to the dark side worked here. They didn’t go too over the top. They don’t need to. Rhodes is letting the story breathe.
To further add to the intrigue, Corey Graves asked Cole about the interview afterwards, and Michael said it amazes him what people will say off camera compared to on. When Graves asked him to elaborate, Cole moved on quickly. Those on socials will know that Triple H posted a post-chat clip of Rhodes standing up with a cold look in his eye, then telling MC that he wouldn't hesitate to punt Orton the next time.
This was all handled deftly, and it shows a sinister side to Cody's personality. On camera, he tries to be WWE's babyface hero. Off it, there's menace seeping through. The constant Heyman name-dropping and referencing is worth keeping a beady eye on as well.
4. Trick In The Bank!
The first Triple Threat fared much better than the second, as previously discussed.
Trick Williams beat Rey Fenix and Randy Orton in a 3-way qualifier for the men’s Money In The Bank ladder match next month. It's always gonna be a surprise when a star like Orton doesn’t win these things, but the crew worked this well and Fenix was really only there to take the fall anyway. That isn’t an issue, because Trick winning acted as a slight shock considering Randy’s main event status.
There was a lot to like here, and Rey actually got given a ton (particularly by Orton). As always and as aforementioned, these Triple Threats could get tedious the more of them we see heading into MITB, but this was an entertaining kickoff for SmackDown's side full of fun spots and urgency.
Randy hit a springboard RKO on Fenix before Williams Trick Kicked him out of the way to grab the pin. Trick, Bron Breakker and Je’Von Evans make a good early lineup for the men. All of them are cast as future stars more than current ones, so there's a recurring theme to those involved. That's a good thing, and it's really what Money In The Bank should be all about.
It's worth pointing out just how slick Williams looked when he had more than one wrestler in the ring with him. Some of his singles bouts have sagged since he joined the main roster, but Randy's instincts and Rey's movement managed to offset that. Check it out even now you know the result - there's a lot to enjoy.
3. Sami Slithers Out Of A Deal
Time for a generous helping of stunning character work.
That's nothing new for Sami Zayn, but the way he sneakily backed out of the deal he’d made with Johnny Gargano last week was majestic. First, the new WWE Champion said that it was Johnny who booked himself in a WWE Title match if he helped Zayn become champ against CM Punk. Then, when Nick Aldis interrupted to say he’s the one who makes championship matches, Sami shifted blame onto the GM and corporate BS like it was nothing.
That's sensational character work, for the record, and it must be said there wasn’t a ton of excitement for Sami vs. 'Johnny Wrestling' from the Corpus Christi crowd anyway. They didn't actually want to see Gargano match up against Zayn for the belt, so Triple H will have to stick that match in his back pocket and pick the right spot for it. Perhaps it'd be ideal for the next visit to Ohio for TV? Just a thought.
Sami's slithering and the way he got under Nick's skin was wonderful to see. This is the kind of personal issue that Hunter warned Aldis not to get involved in after that Gunther business at SummerSlam too, but here he is falling into exactly the same trap with another heel on his watch. That can't go unchecked. There's surely a PLE showdown coming between Aldis and Zayn in the future.
On that subject, there's a lot more to say about it. So, Aldis vs. Sami is getting its own entry. What a time to be alive.
2. Nick Aldis Sows Seeds For The Future
After all of the shenanigans with Gargano, Kevin Owens came out to argue that he should get a WWE Title shot instead. He ran through all of the “bad behaviour” Sami has exhibited for months now, then Zayn kinda’ lost his composure and grabbed Aldis by the suit jacket. That ticked the GM off, so he booked Sami vs. KO in the main event for the belt.
When closing, Nick said: “Your last WWE Title reign lasted 9 days. Let’s see if we can get past 7!”. What a snappy line that was, and the GM's delivery of it? Excellent. WWE has been slowly building towards Zayn vs. Aldis for a while now. It realistically doesn’t need to happen anytime soon, but it’ll be a lot of fun when it does, and it has PLE in the UK written all over it.
Hey, a fella can dream; Aldis challenging Sami for the WWE Title on home turf would certainly be a dream come true for the Brit. Better yet, it wouldn't feel like an exhibition. They've got a story here. The big burning question is obviously whether or not Zayn is still champ by the time the company books another major event in England. Probably not, being brutally honest, but it's a lovely thought.
These lads can still do top business even if the strap is elsewhere. There's enough distaste between them to make things work, 'cause Aldis is getting real sick and tired of Sami thinking he can push him around or force the issue whilst simultaneously acting like a total coward.
1. The Main Event Action Pre-Finish
There can be no issues with the interference during that headliner, because it’s in keeping with the chaos in the WWE Title picture. It must be said though: It’s clearly impossible for Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens to have a bad match at this point. They were on fire here before Johnny Gargano, Candice LeRae then CM Punk ran in. Their main event was a slow burner, but in a good way.
At times, it was veering on ‘Attitude Era’ mayhem.
That’s a compliment, by the way. It also made sense for Punk to crack Owens like he did after last week's drama. On the whole, confusing non-kick out aside that was ripped to shreds in the 'Downs', this was really good and is well worth going out of your way to watch. The way KO and Sami lace their matches with little love letters towards ROH, PWG and NXT battles of old is incredibly endearing, and they've got an almost telepathic amount of chemistry in 2026.
That's actually what makes one think that the ref has to be at fault for that screwy 2 count following Punk's belt shot. There's surely no way Owens and Zayn would mess things up that badly at this stage in their "Fight Forever" saga, right? Clean finishes be damned. This SmackDown match needed all of the bells and whistles Gargano, LeRae and Punk brought to the dance, because they're all trying to weave a cool story here.
Mission accomplished, in that sense. What a great, great showing from old friends turned enemies.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 11 Legendarily BAD Wrestling Runs (With One ICONIC Moment) and 7 Weirdest Times WWE Accidentally Predicted The Future!