5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (3 Oct - Results & Review)

Tension between Seth Rollins and Paul Heyman; WWE spotlights fresh SmackDown stars.

The Vision Seth Rollins Bron Breakker Bronson Reed
WWE.com

There was a bit of tension between Vision stablemates Seth Rollins and Paul Heyman on this week's episode of SmackDown. Not too much (a rift isn't imminent, or anything), but enough to put over Heyman's genius when it comes to seeing around corners. Handily, Rollins ignoring him to go after Cody Rhodes also sold the idea that the reigning WWE Champ is inside Seth's head after all.

All of that came at the end of the watchable main event that put Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed over as one of the strongest tag-team forces in wrestling. Spotlighting newer stars was at the top of Triple H's agenda on Friday. He also drafted in a bunch of other newbies from NXT (maybe not ones people expected), and that gave the blue brand a fresh coat of paint.

One duo is being lined up for a crack at the Women's Tag-Team Titles, and another young daredevil looks set to steal headlines aplenty over the next few months. That's assuming the creative team maintains interest in him - Je'Von Evans could ask Carmelo Hayes something about that. On "Him", Hayes split from The Miz during this episode, and he'll be praying that this isn't another main roster false dawn.

Negatives came in the form of a drab contract signing segment and the fact that several midcard stars are treading water terribly at the moment. Back on the positive side, Sami Zayn's open challenges for the United States Title are becoming a regular highlight well worth going out of your way to see.

Here's all the good and bad from the penultimate Smackers before WWE heads to Australia for Crown Jewel.


Downs...

3. Not The Greatest Opening Segment

Cody Rhodes Randy Orton Paul Heyman Bron Breakker Bronson Reed
WWE.com

A minor positive to start: Yours truly liked how Paul Heyman tried to drive a wedge between Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton by saying “this can’t last”, but there really wasn’t much to the opening promo segment other than catchphrases and that plot point. All of this honestly could’ve been achieved with a brief backstage skit at some point in the show.

It didn’t tell fans anything they didn’t already know. At least it was on the shorter side and to the point, but yeah - it isn't exactly news that Randy would like a shot at the WWE Title again someday. If that was all Heyman was saying, then...why bother? He did allege that neither man could trust the other, which is fair enough, but that didn't even play into things come headliner time anyway.

Quite obviously, Triple H only formatted this for the top of the show so Cody's entrance would pop the live crowd. Rhodes barely said a word before being interrupted by The Vision, and Orton said nothing himself after riding to the champ's rescue. This was all Paul E, which isn't the worst thing in the world but even he can't turn nothing material into something essential.

The match pitting Rhodes and Orton vs. Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed had already been announced ahead of time too, so it isn't like WWE planned to set the thing up during this bit. Thus, it proved to be wasted minutes, and a 2-hour show like SmackDown doesn't actually need to spin wheels and chew up time.

Harmless, but flawed.


2. Several Midcard Acts Are Struggling

Solo Sikoa MFTs
WWE

A few brief moments on Friday's show laid bare just how paper-thin direction is for acts like Solo Sikoa, his MFTs, Jacob Fatu, The Street Profits and The Wyatt Sicks. All of them are struggling to convince right now, which is a shame. The Profits have abandoned their simmering tensions to get back on the same page, but The Sicks are still pushing their supernatural rubbish.

It's largely the same thing each and every time they appear.

There's a total lack of oomph behind Fatu at the moment too, and that sucks considering how red hot he was earlier in the year. How did we get here?! The dude's lost of all that edge and menace he had when he was ripping through Braun Strowman or winning the United States Title. It turns out that being one dimensional was a blessing for Jacob.

Also, if Sikoa is talking about adding more members to his wannabe Bloodline, then don’t bother please! The last thing pro wrestling needs is yet another bloated faction full of folks who aren't over or barely make an impact. AEW already has the stuffed Don Callis Family for that, and there's just no way these MFTs can be anywhere near as effective as The Vision.

If anything, it'd be best to strip back on numbers and see what Solo can achieve as a midcard heel with comedic splashes. He was doing well with that a few months back, but now he's lost his way heading into the final 3 months of 2025. Giving him more minions probably won't help his plight.


1. Contract Signing Wastes Time

Tiffany Stratton Stephanie Vaquer Nick Aldis WWE Contract Signing
WWE.com

Tiffany Stratton and Stephanie Vaquer didn’t have much to say during their face to face contract signing. Further, the way WWE talks up the Crown Jewel Titles as “prestigious” when they don’t mention them all year round and they’re forgotten as soon as the event is over = laughable. It's seemingly lost on Triple H that nobody actually cares much about these things, largely because they've never been given any reason to.

Cody Rhodes and Liv Morgan snagged the belts on last year's card, then they were probs left in storage over in Saudi Arabia before being flown over to Australia for this latest procession. The Crown Jewel belts are token trinkets at best, so it's legit hard to get dizzy with excitement about anyone competing for them.

Meh, at least Stratton vs. Vaquer will be a solid match eh? If you need another downer, then consider this: Tiffy and Stephanie will be teaming up on next week's SmackDown to work with Kiana James and Giulia. Oh, it's that old 'opponents team up' dynamic again. When on earth will WWE realise that this just isn't compelling? It's boring, actually.

You know what'll happen here. Stratton and Vaquer will combine as a super-team to mop the floor with the heels, then something will happen that puts across tension between them. That's so dull, and both deserve better. Tiffany has been on autopilot as a character for far too long now (maybe even since her WrestleMania match with Charlotte Flair), and this babyface vs. babyface respect thing is so painfully lifeless it hurts.

Enjoy seeing one of them hold a title they'll leave at the airport.


Ups...

5. 'Melo Don’t Miz' Is Over, But…

The Miz Carmelo Hayes Melo Don't Miz Split
WWE.com

Well, it finally happened. One of the greatest tandems of this or any generation has splintered. OK, clearly that's just one internet writer thinking he's funny, and it's a bit cheeky when he's had some love for 'Melo Don't Miz' in the past. That's a short past though, because The Miz and Carmelo Hayes have only been buddying up since February, so their split feels a little sudden.

On the bright side, there is some potential here for Miz to make Melo look like a million bucks in some singles matches before Hayes hopefully moves up a rung on the SmackDown ladder. He could really use something meaningful. Is anyone else lowkey worried that this will be another false dawn? If one's choosing to look on the positive side, then they should receive an 'Up' for now. If nothing else, both men executed the split well here.

Fans in attendance live for SmackDown did react when The Miz rushed out to stop his now ex-partner's United States Title open challenge with a thudding Skull Crushing Finale, so that's promising. Hey, could Hayes be about to spin out into one of the most unlikely babyface turns of 2025?! It's just a thought, 'cause Miz was the clear villain here.

Cue all the 'Miz ain't Melo' jokes that are coming soon. That's a freebie you can have, WWE. Carmelo babyface'd himself by walking away calmly and with dignity before his so-called mentor stabbed him in the back just to be vindictive. Yeah, let's stay cheery on this for now and see where it takes us.

Carmelo Hayes could be a breakout success as a face, who knows?


4. Je’Von Evans Shines Again

Rey Fenix Je'Von Evans Los Garza
WWE.com

NXT high-flyer Je'Von Evans looked magic vs. Sami Zayn, and he shone here again in tag action with Rey Fenix vs. Los Garza. You'd be forgiven for feeling they could’ve done even better with slightly more time too, but this was a snug TV match and the finishing stretch is well worth checking out if you like urgency and pinpoint accuracy.

Sure, you've got to feel slightly sorry for Fenix, ‘cause he’s turning into someone who’s spinning his wheels creativity. He’d also blatantly be little more than a bridesmaid to Je’Von on the main roster if they keep teaming, but the dude still puts on strong performances inside the ring. Finally, it's always nice to see Berto and Angel on SmackDown.

They’re criminally overlooked.

Booker T deserves credit for marvelling at Je'Von's flying and general style the way he did on commentary. The 5-time, 5-time, 5-time, 5-time, 5-time champ gets some heat for his announcing (there are those who have never liked and will never like him in this role), but he put across how exciting and dynamic Evans is. There were real, 'He's the future' vibes from Book on comms, and Michael Cole fed on that frenzied buzz.

This has been a watertight start to life on WWE's main roster for Je'Von. He should be chuffed with how things are going, and it's clear he's somebody with bags of potential. Sticking him in as a replacement for AEW new hire Andrade next to Fenix is a grand idea for now. It shouldn't be his long term goal, but it'll work for a few months at most.


3. Fresh Names Look Like Stars

Sol Ruca Zaria
WWE.com

A sneaky aspect of star-making performances comes from those doing the star-making. So, immense credit must go to Alba Fyre and Chelsea Green, because they understood the assignment on Friday night. Their tag bout vs. Zaria and Sol Ruca existed to make the latter NXT pair look like stars in the making that fans should pay close attention to (rather than developmental failed experiments), and the quartet packed a lot into 4 minutes.

Make no mistake, this represented a fab start to life on the main roster for Sol and Zaria. Both women came across really, really well. Neither missed a beat, and both brought something different to the party throughout the bout; Zaria was the sheer brute force and power of the pair (her lifting sleeper on Alba in the corner looked the business), and Sol's athleticism is stunning (that finisher alone is money).

It'll be interesting to see this fresh pair wrestle Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss, so job done. That was really the mission of this match, and the marching orders for Fyre and Green. They were on the show to ready a new tag for the tag champs, and they did that better than most could've. You've got to admire wrestlers who are team players without completely clowning themselves in the process.

Good workers, man.

There's still a definite split between main roster WWE fans and those who take the time to check out NXT weekly, so some in the audience didn't seem to know who Ruca and Zaria were. That's fine. They will soon, especially if this quickfire effort is anything to go by.

Attention, Triple H: Lil' bit extra cheese on Chelsea and Alba's whoppers wouldn't go amiss this month for that performance. Green is generally fabulous at her job.


2. Another Top Open Challenge Match

Sami Zayn Aleister Black
WWE.com

For Christ sake, Sami - leave some good matches for other wrestlers, son!

Oh yes, Mr. Zayn is knocking it out of the park with this United States Title open challenge shindig. This time, it was Aleister Black who stepped up when Carmelo Hayes was laid out by Miz, and he had a predictably solid match with Sami. The live crowd enjoyed this one, and no wonder. Zayn is so, so good at fighting from underneath, and this was a rare chance for Black to look physically dominant as he came eerily close to winning the belt time and time again.

Some will roll eyes at the finish, but it does also make sense given everything that’s been going on between Aleister and Damian Priest. Their feud isn’t the hottest thing ever, or anything, but logic matters and that Razor’s Edge through the announce table looked awesome. Besides, Damian didn't actually put hands on Black until after the match, which is something he can point to before their 'Last Man Standing' clash next weekend.

This has been said before, and it won't come as a shocker to anyone who's followed his career for longer than a few years, but it’s a really good idea to give Sami lengthy matches every week. It's also sweet to see him winning with the Blue Thunder Bomb rather than a Helluva Kick, because he doesn't get to do that enough.

This is perhaps the best Aleister has looked in a longer match since returning to WWE. It wouldn't be surprising if he was all smiles and high fives backstage afterwards, because that was his kinda match.


1. The Vision Score A Major Tag Win

Bron Breakker Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Bronson Reed and Bron Breakker looked like equals out there with Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton, which is something they should be seriously proud of. Fans believed they had more than a fair chance to win even without Seth Rollins getting involved, which goes to show how credible the duo have become. This whole Vision thing is paying off big time for the pair.

A house show style pinned down this main event at times, but that’s not a bad thing. Orton and Cody played the hits, everybody took their time to let every punch, kick or move breathe, then Rollins stomped Randy so Bronson could Tsunami the ink right off Orton’s body for the pin. They still managed to get across how devastating Reed is as a monster despite Seth helping him out, which is cool.

Lastly, this fan kinda liked Rollins ignoring Paul Heyman and paying for it with a Cody Cross Rhodes too. Listen to your ‘Oracle, Seth! The thought that Cody is inside the World Heavyweight Champion's head going into their Crown Jewel match is a tad more interesting than the show of babyface respect Tiffany Stratton and Stephanie Vaquer have going on elsewhere.

Lots of green ticks next to this match, by the way. Breakker continued his power-based assault, Reed looked every bit the killer, Rollins got involved, Cody and Randy did their thing (2 masters right there), and then Heyman pulled strings by showing his true value to The Vision.

A fun ride all in then.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE Fates Worse Than Death and 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2004!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.