5 Ups & 4 Downs For AEW Collision (May 25 - Results & Review)
Fire from Willow, idiocy from Moxley, and a Double J main event as Double or Nothing looms large.
Another week, another AEW Collision in the books.
This time out, Collision was in the tough spot of taking place just one day before Double or Nothing. As is always the case with a show that takes place on the eve of a PPV, there's almost a sense of a holding pattern sitting over the episode. Nothing too major can take place once the PPV line-up is already set, and the various stories heading into that event may already start to feel well overdue a resolution.
Still, this week's Collision did have several plus points to it, even if some familiar issues did frustratingly rear their head once again. Much like is the norm for AEW, though, the in-ring element of the show was fairly solid throughout, and the episode did about as much as it could to hype Double or Nothing while not being able to have any particular stakes on the line. However, one of the more baffling moments here was a rare, rare case of Jon Moxley being made to look like a total buffoon. Regardless, Collision navigated the road to Double or Nothing in fairly decent fashion with a pretty solid but pretty unremarkable offering that did just about enough to get by.
As Elton John has long told us, Saturday night's alright for fighting...
Downs...
4. Dumb Babyface
This is the sort of thing so often synonymous with WWE over the years, but AEW Collision opened with Jon Moxley being a dumb, naive, idiotic babyface.
The Moxley character has always been shown to be smarter than the average bear when it comes to outsmarting the heels of the day and seeing what the audience could all see coming a mile off. In Collision's opening minutes, though, Mox was made to look like a total fool.
Anybody with even a passing interest in pro wrestling was well aware that Don Callis' in-ring interaction with Moxley was simply a set-up for the Blackpool Combat Club man to be attacked by Konosuke Takeshita. From what we've seen from Moxley during his AEW run, he's the sort of badass babyface who is always aware of such ploys.
Rarely in AEW has Jon Moxley been made to look like a moron, but he absolutely was here.
3. What Was The Point Of This?
Right, the match itself was a decent, chaotic one that had some particularly fun spots from the always-impressive Buddy Matthews and Brody King. But really, what was the point of Collision's four-team contest?
This was the very definition of pointless TV filler, throwing eight bodies together to take up ten minutes of time. Much like is often the case with AEW programming, the work was good but just with zero to be invested in as the shadow of Double or Nothing looms large.
Of the eight men in this match, only the Acclaimed and the Gates of Agony are booked for Double or Nothing. So, did one of these teams pick up the win here in order to build further momentum for their respective PPV match? Of course not.
Instead, Matthews and King grabbed the win over the Infantry. In and of itself, that's not an awful decision considering how prominent a presence House of Black is on TV these days, but it is a somewhat questionable decision when the W here would've been better served going to one of the tandems that are actually in action at Double or Nothing.
Also, having the Acclaimed and the Gates of Agony brawl to the back was just a lazy way to excuse either team from being involved in the finish.
2. The Worst Of Edge
Adam Copeland is a modern-day great, a Hall of Famer by any metric, an 11-time World Champion, and is someone involved in so many iconic pro wrestling moments from the past 25 years.
That said, there were times during Copeland's final couple of Edge years when his worse instincts came through when it pertained to overly dramatic, chin-stroking, smartest-man-in-the-room promos that served merely as an opportunity for the Canadian to show off the acting chops he'd honed over the years. It made for dull, rambling promos that were positioned as deep and meaningful but that came off as pretentious bullsh*t.
On Collision this week, those bad Edge habits came to the fore as the legend delivered some words to the House of Black following Buddy Matthews and Brody King's win in that four-way tag match. Devils on shoulders and in hearts were discussed, questions were asked of Buddy and Brody maybe joining with Copeland, and the Kerrang!-bating House of Blood name was even floated.
As mentioned, Adam Copeland should be viewed as one of the greatest of his generation, but at times he does need to be pulled back from going too, well, Preachy Edge, ala his ropey Judgment Day days.
1. Four Minutes Of In-Ring For The Women
Mariah May is one of the most talented women on the AEW roster, and 'Legit' Leyla Hirsch is always a favourite of your writer for her fearless, no-nonsense persona and array of suplexes, strikes, and submissions. However, May vs. Hirsch has to unfortunately fall on the Downs side of this article.
Sure, we had a fantastic in-ring promo from Willow Nightingale and solid promos from Toni Storm and Serena Deeb, but this was yet another AEW episode that gave short in-ring shrift to its ladies. Across this two-hour Collision, we had one seven-minute women's match which spent three of those minutes in a picture-in-picture break.
Four minutes of properly televised ladies wrestling on a two-hour broadcast is absolutely ridiculous here in 2024, especially when considering just how stacked the AEW women's roster is. And yes, it's painful to write about this nearly every single Collision, but it's something that has to be called out each and every time.
Mariah May and Leyla Hirsch did fine - May getting the win with her running knee - but what sort of impression can you really expect these two to make with just four minutes on the standard TV broadcast?
I'd say "Do better, Tony", but it's clear such sentiments are wasted on someone who seems to have such contempt for letting his hugely talented female roster wrestle on TV.
Ups...
5. A Welcome Surprise
An appearance from Hiroshi Tanahashi is always welcome, even more so when the Ace of New Japan Pro Wrestling - and the President of NJPW nowadays, of course - arrives unexpectedly and is ready for in-ring action.
Collision teased that Claudio Castagnoli and Daniel Garcia may take on Lance Archer and the Righteous in a two-on-three handicap match before Claudio paused as the attention turned to the entrance ramp. There, Tanahashi shocked the MGM Grand Arena crowd by making his way out to team with Castagnoli and Red Death.
The match itself was a fun if unspectacular one, with long-time New Japan fans likely getting a kick out of seeing Tanahashi and Archer mixing it up, and also the sight of Tana playing the air guitar while Garcia danced receiving a nice pop - plus the post-match moves of Hiroshi and Danny.
Framing this as a Team AEW vs. Team Elite scenario didn't really click - does anyone care that Archer and the Righteous were hired goons of the Elite last week? - but the action was kept concise, clocking in at just under ten minutes and culminating with Tanahashi hitting Vincent with the High Fly Flow for the win.
While it can become nauseating at times when AEW regularly features so many non-AEW talents as so many valuable AEW-contracted names are kept on the sidelines, this Tanahashi appearance did at least serve to whet the appetite for next month's Forbidden Door PPV.
4. Lucha Bros. Jrs!
A quick Up here for the awesome sight of Penta El Zero and Rey Fenix's sons accompanying their fathers to the ring. Pro wrestling can be a truly heartwarming place, and this was certainly something that likely raised a smile from even the coldest of hearts.
Also, it was just great to see the Lucha Bros. back in action, with the tandem having not teamed since October due to Fenix's injury problems. One of the very best tag teams in the world, Penta and Fenix brought plenty of their usual athleticism and charisma to the table here against Austin and Colten Gunn in a table-setter for Double or Nothing where the reunited Death Triangle of the Lucha Bros. and PAC challenge the Gunns and Jay White for the Unified Trios Championship.
As a reintroduction to the Lucha Bros., this was great, doing enough to impress as a match on its own merits without overstaying its welcome and giving too much away before Double or Nothing. In terms of the finish, a spike Fear Factor on Austin was an emphatic way for Penta to score the win as Fenix then dived to the outside to take out Colten.
3. What It Needed To Be For KOR
It may have only been a short squash match victory, but it was still a win for Kyle O'Reilly at a time when the hugely talented Canadian needed it.
Since returning to action earlier this year, O'Reilly has come up short each and every time there's been a match with any sort of stakes. Against Roderick Strong for the International Title at Dynasty? Kyle lost. Against Adam Copeland for the TNT Title on Dynamite earlier this month? Kyle lost. A Casino Gauntlet to earn another shot at the International Title? Kyle lost. Against Malakai Black on last week's Dynamite? Kyle lost.
Given the trajectory of AEW storytelling, that's not to say O'Reilly should've won any of those four matches, but if you put someone in a position where they lose several notable matches in a row, the perception of them is that of a loser. Kyle tapping out KM in barely a minute clearly isn't any sort of game-changer, but it is at least a TV win that's not hidden away on the barely-watched AEW Rampage.
Kyle O'Reilly is a little in limbo right now, loosely tied to the ongoing Adam Copeland vs. House of Black rivalry, and the more wins the better for the former reDRagon man if he's to hopefully be featured in a meaningful way for AEW in the future - even if the win here was a non-event squash that merely served to keep Kyle in fans' minds.
2. Willow Spits Fire
If you don't get a kick out of Willow Nightingale, chances are you're already dead inside.
While Willow makes for a phenomenal, sincere, fun babyface who delivers the goods between the ropes, recent weeks have seen the TBS Champion get the opportunity to showcase her promo skills - and with each passing promo, Nightingale gets better and better.
This week's Collision was no different, with the New Yorker delivering arguably her best promo so far, managing to still be that fun-loving Willow we all know and love, but brilliantly throwing in a more serious side once again.
Nightingale made it clear that, while she has immense respect for what Mercedes Moné has achieved in her career, Willow won't be giving up that TBS Title without a hell of a fight. And much like Mercedes has had her own injury issues, Nightingale referenced how she herself nearly ended up paralysed five years ago due to a broken neck.
The dialogue here was perfect for what it needed to, and the fired-up delivery from Willow Nightingale was likewise pitch-perfect in hammering home that Nightingale isn't just a happy-go-lucky sort who Mercedes can walk through.
1. A Decent Main Event
Whenever Jeff Jarrett is in the main event, you know you're in for something special. And here, the seeds were brilliantly sown for what should be a huge money-drawing feud down the line between Double J and Bryan Danielson.
While your writer is admittedly a big fan of ol' Slapnuts, that opening passage was obviously just for sh*ts 'n' giggles. Either way, Jarrett and Danielson did have some nice exchanges through Collision's main event which pitted the American Dragon and FTR against Jeff, Jay Lethal, and Satnam Singh.
This Collision-closing bout was decent - nothing more, nothing less - and somewhat of a mixed bag for this man's particular tastes. The action flowed really well, the offense from the babyfaces was electric, Dax stood out with some stellar sell work, and Jarrett and Lethal were great as the bumping heels when called for, but the 'old man shouts at clouds' mindset had heads shaking at the prolonged periods where multiple men were in the ring without any hint of a warning from referee Aubrey Edwards about a lack of tags.
Overlooking that sadly all-too-common AEW problem, the story here was a logical one: the Elite once again offering a pay-off to anyone willing to take out Danielson and FTR, and Jeff Jarrett and his crew being the ideal scumbag heels who'd jump at that chance. Of course, those villains would ultimately come up short as the babyfaces picked up a win ahead of Double or Nothing, but the in-ring fundamentals were on point... well, apart from whenever the physically impressive but limited Satnam Singh was involved.
A Busaiku Knee from Danielson was enough to take out Jeff Jarrett, and that was immediately followed by a Shatter Machine on Jay Lethal for the win. Post-match, Cash Wheeler and Dax Harwood had some impassioned, spirited words about AEW and the company's importance ahead of Team AEW battling the nefarious Elite at Double or Nothing, and that was that for this week's Collision.