5 Ups & 5 Downs For WWE Raw (6 Oct - Results & Review)
WWE falls into bad booking habits; Roman rubs off on Jey, Rollins lays out stakes for Saturday.
If you turned on Monday Night Raw in the hopes that WWE was going to turn around the past few months of booking and a television product that has vacillated from “good” to “uggh,” you probably came away disappointed.
WWE in 2025 is nowhere near as bad as 2019 WWE, but it’s pretty clear that 2023-24 WWE is in the rear-view mirror. The company has fallen back into bad habits with its booking. The main event scene is stale, repetitive and extremely low-stakes on a week-to-week basis. And the wrestling – once a huge bright spot where the best match on Raw could give AEW Dynamite’s best a run for its money – has fallen off tremendously
Raw on Monday night had a few good moments, including a couple really great segments, but the show was dominated by lazy, in-show booking, a hugely disappointing main event, a flat opening segment, and average wrestling. It’s hard to get hyped about that.
Even with a few positives coming out of Raw, the show overall left a bad taste in the mouth. There always will be bright spots, glimmers of what could be, but it feels more and more like the “new normal” will be mediocrity.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
5. Wrestling Happening
It was bad enough that the six-man tag between Judgment Day and Penta, AJ Styles and Dragon Lee was booked a full hour into Raw Monday night, but then the wrestlers turned in what could best be described as a perfectly competent and forgettable match.
There really isn’t anything to point to as a negative here, but other than Rusev appearing and chasing off Dominik Mysterio, there wasn’t anything that stood out during the match. Moves happened, people got slammed, kicked and suplexed, and ultimately JD McDonagh ate a Styles Clash and was pinned for the loss.
Perhaps Styles and Lee will get a World Tag Team Championship match against the Judgment Day, despite being just 1-0 in tag action. Maybe Rusev will get his rematch for the Intercontinental Championship. Or maybe Penta (who inadvertently kicked Rusev) will earn the title shot. And there’s a chance that Dragon Lee takes the AAA Mega Championship off Dominik.
Despite all those title possibilities, this still felt very much like a background part of Raw rather than a focal point. That’s never a good sign.
4. Smoke And Mirrors
Was WWE trying to play a joke on Maxxine Dupri, or were they trying to give her a baptism by fire when they sent her out there to wrestle Becky Lynch for 14 minutes Monday night?
If the social media videos are to be treated as fact, Maxxine clearly has been putting in the work to improve in the ring. But reps in the new Dungeon doesn’t instantly make you a good wrestler, and Dupri showed Monday that there still are plenty of holes in her game. She threw one of the most pathetic, Erik Watts-like dropkicks in memory. Her punches look weak, and her fire-up spots felt rehearsed.
But Maxxine did land a few nice moves along the way, with Lynch guiding her through several sequences that included a hotter-than-expected series of pin attempts. Dupri clearly was outmatched, with Becky appearing to wrestle herself at a couple points.
Even the finish was a product of Lynch doing 100% of the work, arguing with the referee repeatedly to set up a moment where Becky posed on the announce desk and jawed with fans while Maxxine rolled back in the ring at seven. Ref Jessika Carr, having been tormented throughout the match, rapidly counted to 10, ending the match with a loss for Becky as payback.
It’s tempting to give this positive marks because of the accomplishment of Maxxine getting through a lengthy match without outright embarrassing herself. But it’s tough to do that when you still can see the strings. Still, if you were thoroughly entertained by this, that’s more than fine as well.
3. Vegemite As A Weapon
Did you know that WWE signed Bronson Reed from his home country of Australia because he mastered a specific match and made it famous?
Yes, WWE signed Reed because of his dominance in the dreaded Australian Street Fight. Sorry, that’s a serious statement. Paul Heyman said it during the opening segment of Raw, so it must be true.
Heyman also said that Roman Reigns fears Bronson – despite having beat him cleanly five weeks earlier. True, Reed laid Reigns out with a couple Tsunamis and he had to be stretchered out of the arena – apparently for the first time in his career (though he sat out half of the 2016 Royal Rumble, but that’s another story). But no one is buying that Roman is even remotely concerned with Reed, especially after getting the better of him at the close of this segment.
The Australian Street Fight has to be a gag. There’s no way they sent Heyman out there to talk up Bronson’s expertise in a special match in his native country, only for it to be “[INSERT LOCALE NAME] Street Fight.”
What are they going to do, smack each other with a didgeridoo?
2. Half-Assed, Half-Booked
When you talk about the bad habits WWE has fallen back into in 2025, their penchant for making impromptu matches during the course of a program has to be near the top of the list.
Monday night, more than half of the five-match card was booked during the show, with the main event announced less than an hour before the match started. Literally the entire final hour of Raw consisted of matches made after the program went on the air. That’s embarrassing.
Asuka demanding Kairi Sane face Iyo Sky was easily the least offensive of the bunch, with an angry Empress demanding that Raw GM Adam Pearce book the match. Who would defy Asuka? The six-man tag was a trademark WWE impromptu match, set up by a backstage argument and just served to occupy time and get people on television.
The main event is far and away the biggest offender, but it deserves its own entry.
Once again though, WWE rolled out a program with an incomplete card and staged it after the cameras were rolling.
1. What Are We Doing Here?
Serious question: Does WWE have any idea what it’s collectively doing these days?
Raw’s main event was a disaster on multiple levels, covering numerous WWE tropes: impromptu match made 90 minutes into the program; a “can they coexist” makeshift tag team facing an experienced duo – and winning; a Raw main event featuring the same interchangeable parts that have dominated the closing bout slot for nearly four months.
The tag match pitting the Usos against LA Knight and CM Punk also was yet another Raw main event in a long line of them where the match itself was unimportant. The result somewhat mattered – with the talking point that Knight stole the pin of Jey Uso from Punk and Jey likely sliding further into Roman Reigns’ camp.
But this was little more than a hastily thrown-together match between the same cast of characters, with average wrestling, no stakes, no heat and minimal crowd reaction. We’re supposed to receive at least three of the four men as huge stars, but fans aren’t exactly living and dying with the actions or story being told in the ring – in fact, they aren’t really what you’d call a “hot” crowd at all.
Gone are the days when Cody Rhodes would team with someone (Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens, Jey Uso) to take on the Judgment Day in 2023, when the buildings were LOUD for everything. This is a far cry from just two years ago, and it’s truly sad.
UPS…
5. It’s The Wrestling
Put Lyra Valkyria and Roxanne Perez in the ring. Ring the bell. Lather, rinse and repeat.
Even when they aren’t churning out their best work, the two wrestlers are skilled enough to make things work and put together an entertaining little match, which is what we got from them Monday night.
Perez targeted Valkyria’s arm throughout the match, inhibiting Lyra’s ability to lock in some moves. Just when it appeared that Lyra still would fall short due to outside interference, Bayley attempted to even the odds by interjecting into the match herself, grabbing Valkyria to prevent her from being launched off the top rope.
However, things escalated on the outside, and both Roxanne and Lyra abandoned the match to attack on the floor, giving Perez the opportunity to hit Pop Rox for the win.
Instead of getting screamed at by a mentally disturbed Bayley, the Role Model yelled for the two of them to exact revenge on the Judgment Day women – which they did backstage later. By minimizing the B-movie-level acting from Bayley and Lyra, it instantly elevated everything, even if the match wasn’t both women’s best.
Bayley still had an “episode” during the match and went from happy-go-lucky cheerleader to vengeful second boisterously demanding an attack. And doing this won’t make the overall angle better. But for one week at least, things were relatively tolerable.
4. Keep It Simple
The Kabuki Warriors’ heel turn has been more of a means to an end, with that end being what should be a fantastic tag match at Crown Jewel this weekend against Iyo Sky and Rhea Ripley.
The turn itself has been fine from a story perspective, but questionable when viewed through a performance lens. Overly dramatic scenes and poor acting have hampered this story at times.
Monday night, WWE let Asuka dominate a backstage segment where she demanded a match between Kairi Sane and Iyo, further establishing her domineering, villainous side – at one point slapping Kairi to get her in line. Iyo (hopefully) ended any question of whether she would waver during the tag match by declaring in a pre-recorded video that she, Asuka and Kairi weren’t family anymore and that she and Rhea are.
The match between Iyo and Kairi was fine, though Sane still did her “half in, half out” routine as she lamented attacking Sky. She didn’t spend hours debating an Insane Elbow, but her brief delay cost her the win at that moment. Asuka would get involved and assist Kairi with a rollup, giving her the victory over Iyo.
Afterward, the Kabuki Warriors attacked Iyo and laid her out (Rhea was in Australia), which again came without too much protesting from Kairi. This overall was fine as the story churns toward what hopefully is an excellent tag match on Saturday.
3. Roman The Puppeteer
For the past few weeks, Jimmy Uso has been warning his brother Jey about the dangers of continuing take pages from Roman Reigns’ playbook, noting that it will only lead him down a bad path.
Monday, however, Reigns continued to push his cousin, riling him up about CM Punk getting a prime in-ring promo segment, which led to the breakdown between everyone in that segment. Roman also called out Jimmy, saying he was aware of Uso talking ill of copying his behavior.
Jimmy, to his credit, said he saw Roman pulling the strings and messing with Jey’s mind, but Reigns countered that Jey is now more like Roman than he is like Jimmy, and perhaps he should get out of his brother’s way.
This is the first time since returning last year that Roman really has been presented with any kind of real heel edge. He’s been widely cheered despite not doing anything truly babyface-like, but he hasn’t explicitly done anything evil or negative. Monday, he more or less admitted to manipulating his cousin with a “yeah, so?” and then suggested Jimmy get out of the way.
Whether fans accept this character direction for Roman and Jey and actually respond accordingly (rather than just blindly yeeting and raising their fingers) remains to be seen. But if you enjoy Bloodline lore, this is pretty decent stuff here.
2. Deteriorating Relationships
For the past several weeks, CM Punk has been on a side quest of sorts, assisting his wife, AJ Lee, in her returns to WWE and her first match in a decade.
While the move pulled him away from the World Heavyweight Championship, it did keep him in the title’s orbit with the mixed tag involving Seth Rollins. Still, Punk had been nowhere to be seen the last couple of weeks.
Monday, Punk explained that because he had no role for the upcoming Crown Jewel (with Rollins facing Cody Rhodes for the Crown Jewel Championship), he held to respecting Cody and steering clear. With the match imminent, Punk clarified that he hadn’t lost focus and wanted Rollins – and the world title – immediately after Saturday’s PLE.
Cue LA Knight, who suggested that Punk had abdicated his spot in line to chase the World Heavyweight Championship while being a good husband to Lee. He noted that Rollins had pinned Punk twice this summer. That’s when things got chippy between the two, with Punk getting a dig in about Knight never winning a world title.
Cue Jey Uso, who laid his claim to the World Heavyweight Championship because he had never been afforded an automatic rematch. Knight ran down Jey, saying he wasn’t Roman Reigns (which was a good thing, from his perspective), which led to Uso superkicking him. Jimmy, who had walked down during this, tried to play peacemaker between Jey and Punk but he ended up superkicking the Second City Saint.
As soft heel activity and dialogue-heavy segments go, this was fine, even if it looks like they’re just setting up a four-way title match for after Crown Jewel. Alternatively, WWE could book a triple threat for the title shot. Either way, predictable isn’t always bad. Knight held things together, and Jey’s (and now Jimmy’s) descent toward becoming heels continues to be well told.
1. What’s Really At Stake For Rollins
The more they get away from talking about “control of the WWE for the next two decades” and just frame Saturday’s men’s Crown Jewel Championship match as influence and pride, the better the bout between Seth Rollins and Cody Rhodes looks.
The lengthy video package Monday night summarized the second part of their story, leading up to and through WrestleMania 40, with Rollins pointing out that he helped Rhodes slay Roman Reigns, despite it costing him his world title and his health. What set him over the edge though, was Cody welcoming Roman back to WWE less than six months later.
Back in The Vision’s locker room, Rollins confronted Paul Heyman to explain the stakes in terms of what would happen if he loses on Saturday. Rather than talk about Cody controlling the future of WWE and other foolishness. Heyman painted an image of Seth losing the locker room, the support of Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed, the belief that his vision for WWE was correct. He would become “a de facto, wannabe secondary champion.” Heyman himself would have to question why he chose Rollins over Roman.
That little nuance worked well. They still were talking broadly about Rollins’ vision for leading WWE, but the match now is more about validating Seth than anything else. Losing would more or less end The Vision in its tracks simply by disenchanting Breakker and Reed and reducing Rollins in fans’ and wrestlers’ eyes.
Those are more real stakes that make sense, which is why this worked well in concert with the video. The match now feels like hit has some serious heft to it, which is difficult to pull off in a “bragging rights” match.