5 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 38 (Night 2)

Roman Reigns conquers Brock Lesnar, Vince McMahon wrestles, Johnny Knoxville & Pat McAfee rule.

Roman Reigns
WWE

After a fabulous first night on which the stunning highs greatly outweighed the relatively insignificant lows, WrestleMania 38's second half was an inconsistent struggle lacking the cathartic peaks of 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin's in-ring return and Bianca Belair's Raw Women's Championship triumph over Becky Lynch.

38 ended up similar to 37 in that regard - albeit with a full crowd. This year's event was unquestionably made better by a packed-out Dallas audience that maintained its energy across both nights, only wavering when the content presented to them didn't hit. At least from the perspective of a home viewer, burnout wasn't a thing, as Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns were both received rapturously for their grand finale.

But yes, this was like WM 37 in that the first night greatly outperformed the second. A shame, though it's not like this show wasn't without its highlights.

Reigns and Lesnar settled their long-running beef in their hotly-anticipated 'Winner Take All' match, marketed, cynically, as the biggest in WrestleMania history. Elsewhere, Johnny Knoxville provided celebrity entertainment against Sami Zayn, another long-missing WWE veteran returned to the ring, Edge and AJ Styles contested their dream match, and more.

Let's get stupendous...


Downs...

6. The Undertaker (And Other Wastes Of Time)

The Undertaker
WWE.com

A problem across both nights, WWE wasted an egregious amount of time on recaps, cinematics, overlong vignettes, and unnecessary indulgences on this show, tossing around 45 minutes into the void without good reason.

The Undertaker's second consecutive Hall of Fame walk-out and a Mark Wahlberg-narrated introduction that had already aired on night one were amongst the most irritating offenders. Elsewhere, the insistence on constantly cutting to minutes-long highlights from a show that only went down 24 hours prior was extreme, even for WWE. The old line about treating viewers as if they possess a goldfish's attention span would apply if not for studies indicating the average human is now even more scatter-brained than the popular pets.

Pure filler content that makes WWE programming overly long is borderline understandable when it comes to Raw, as WWE has three hours of the network's time to fill. Here, they are streaming live on Peacock and their own WWE Network. They are largely responsible for deciding how long things go - and insist on wasting your time anyway.

Cut this stuff in half and WrestleMania 38's second night would've been a leaner, easier watch across the board.


5. Sasha Banks & Naomi Celebrate Feel-Good Moment After Lacklusture Match

Sasha Banks Naomi
WWE.com

Though it concluded on the kind of feel-good moment WrestleManias require to be deemed a success, Sasha Banks and Naomi's Women's Tag Team Title triumph came at the end of an incohesive scramble match endemic to how WWE books these titles.

Ostensibly a thrown-together cluster comprised of four thrown-together tandems, the match shot for a similar layout to the night two opener. Unfortunately, it fell short. The popping spots were outweighed greatly by the awkward, clunky ones (despite good moments of improvisation, like Queen Zelina styling an overshot dive into a flying Destino), and the bout lacked any semblance of flow or drama, making it a largely ineffective spotfest.

Banks and Naomi got the megastar treatment with their Lamborghini-assisted entrance. The finish was well-done, too, with Carmella isolated before eating comeuppance. Elsewhere, Liv Morgan and Rhea Ripley simultaneously powerbombing the rest of the field from the top ropes was a great visual.

But there was little holding this match together between the spots, despite the earnest hard work.


4. Bobby Lashley Beats Stumbling Omos

Bobby Lashley Omos
WWE.com

If nothing else, Bobby Lashley's victory over Omos was an effective first workout for this new, babyface 'All Mighty.'

Lashley was over huge. Helped by a great new ring entrance, he established the simple story of going for a suplex on the much larger man early on, then paid it off to a great reception towards the finish. That suplex preceded the match's second spear (to Omos' back, with the giant clearly out of position), then the third, which secured the pinfall.

Omos ate his first singles defeat after entering another stodgy performance. While an inhumanly strong man himself, Lashley was the underdog here, yet his work looked like it was being executed with more grace and less exertion than Omos, which shouldn't be the case. The giant hossing his opponent around needs to look effortless. The underdog needs to struggle. That wasn't the case here, as Omos struggled against beefier opposition than usual, continuing to fall short when it comes to conveying dominance, presence, and (somehow) size.

What happens next with AJ Styles' former tag team partner is unclear, given his performances since splitting from the ring veteran. A complimentary tag wrestler when utilised sparingly, he passes Vince McMahon's famous airport test on size alone, but it all goes away when the bell rings. This had never been starker than it was last night.


3. The New Day Job Hard In Needless WrestleMania Match

Sheamus Xavier woods
WWE.com

It took Sheamus and Ridge Holland less than two minutes to put Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods away last night, with Ridge scoring the pin via Northern Grit after Sheamus had struck Woods with a Brogue Kick while the referee's back was turned.

Though it was rearranged from the first night, when time constraints took hold, this match shouldn't have been on the card. It was a hurried SmackDown match better at home on weekly television than the biggest show of the year, with the minuscule runtime preventing the wrestlers from crafting any meaningful work.

And the circumstances make it worse. Woods and Kingston came out in Big E-style singlets, with Woods even pulling down his straps as his fallen partner would. The entire match was framed around The New Day scoring revenge for E following his accidental neck-break by Holland's hand. For WWE to take that story, consent to the tribute, then fast-forward through everything in under two minutes is insensitive.

The New Day deserve better.


2. AJ Styles & Edge Swing & Miss

Edge AJ Styles
WWE.com

AJ Styles and Edge shot for "WrestleMania epic" in their long-awaited dream match, crafting one of the most emotionless and cynical bouts seen on this stage in quite some time.

While the exchanges were fundamentally sound and AJ sold his injured shoulder well (with Edge targeting it for extended periods( and the counters were slick and exciting, the complete lack of anything between the moves dragged this match down. Styles and Edge were likely aiming for The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels' two late-career classics, here. Their slow, methodical pacing was built for atmosphere, with the crowd so dazzled by their sheer aura, presence, and gravitas that they'd hang on every moment, no matter how small.

Sadly, this wasn't the case.

Rather than inspiring awe, the veteran duo inspired boredom in their less kinetic moments. Michaels/Undertaker worked because the crowd were completely hooked and invested in the saga unfolding before them. Without that engagement, last night's fight felt cold, detached, and lacking in substance, despite their earnest attempts.

Coupled with Edge's inconsistent knee selling (that the veteran completely dispensed without about halfway through) and over-the-top, immersion-shattering "acting", as well as the clichéd distraction finish, this was a swing and a miss.


1. Vince McMahon Makes A Farce Of WrestleMania

Vince McMahon Pat McAfee
WWE.com

Vince McMahon is 76 years old. Of course he looked dreadful opposite Pat McAfee, who spent their match literally running into the WWE Chairman and CEO's clotheslines, throwing himself into the corner, and effectively doing all the work himself (Austin Theory's interjections aside). The guy is old. He looks like a million dollars for his age, but nobody could have reasonably expected more than what he gave last night.

This is no excuse for what deserves to go down as one of the most shambolic matches in WrestleMania history.

McMahon performed like he knew he was serving his audience a sh*t sandwich, wearing a goofy grin on his face for much of it. Here, WWE were shooting for "so bad, it's good." They asked you to switch your brain off, laugh at the wacky pensioner throwing the worst clotheslines in the world at a legitimate athlete, and Just Enjoy It. It's not that deep, bro! Touch grass.

This should never be the case. It's professional wrestling. You're supposed to suspend your disbelief, not willingly disbelieve. And besides all that, why pucker up for a billionaire and one of the most powerful men in the North American entertainment industry?

Vince is a big boy. He can take the criticism.

An embarrassment for all involved, this 'Mania farce closed on McMahon gently punting an NFL ball into McAfee's gut, which was somehow deemed enough to keep the punter down for three. Afterwards, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin hit the ring and dropped everyone involved with a Stunner, laughing as his 76-year-old career-long revival stumbled all over the place. He, too, understood how bad this whole deal was.

McMahon vs. McAfee was an omnishambles deserving of the same level of historic scorn as McMahon vs. Hart.


Ups...

5. Game Over For Triple H

Triple H boots
WWE.com

A nice, moving moment played out at the top of the show, as a surprise appearance from Triple H opened WrestleMania 38's second night.

Motorhead's 'The Game' provoked a giant pop in the building as Hunter followed up on his return to NXT at Stand & Deliver two nights prior. A trademark ring entrance, simple "Welcome to WrestleMania!", and "Thank you Hunter!" chants followed, by the 52-year-old left a pair of his old wrestling boots in the ring, ceremonially calling time on his wrestling career.

This was earned and deserved. Triple H didn't get to step away from the ring on his own terms, with last year's near-fatal brush with heart failure forcing his hand. It'd take a cold, cold soul to begrudge him what will likely be one last WrestleMania uber-pop after all he has been through over the past few months.

What matters most is that the man is back on his feet after a harrowing period that could have ended a lot worse. Godspeed to Triple H, his family, and anyone else close to him.


4. Pat McAfee Does It Again, Beats Austin Theory

Pat McAfee
WWE.com

While the same can't necessarily be said about his offerings in the announce booth, Pat McAfee is a sure thing between the ropes (when not paired with a 76-year-old man) and somebody WWE should really use in this role more often, given the effortless effervescence of his performances so far.

Magnificant opposite Adam Cole then in War Games in 2020, McAfee performed far above his experience level against Austin Theory last night. Bursts of athleticism and personality, commentating his own beatdown after commandeering a headset, and a picture-perfect missed Swanton Bomb had the crowd enraptured. Never once did Pat look out of his depth, despite this being only his third match in the company, and he was one of the most over people on the entire card from the moment his licensed 'Seven Nation Army' theme hit.

Theory did a great job, too. Constantly looking for Vince McMahon's approval (the boss sat at ringside throughout), Austin kept his control periods interesting with obnoxious charisma and facial expressions, doing his part to enhance the pop when McAfee countered the ATL into a roll-up for the win.

What happened after this is a shame. McAfee is a bonafide wrestling star, now. While WWE should be careful not to overexpose him (and risk burning the audience out), WrestleMania 38 demonstrated that he should likely have a bigger role outwith the commentary table.


3. Roman Reigns & Brock Lesnar Tread Familiar Ground

roman Reigns brock lesnar
WWE.com

You have seen matches like this latest Roman Reigns/Brock Lesnar clash before.

WrestleMania 38 closed on another Paul Heyman special. These bouts rely on the audience being gripped by wild, sudden momentum swings prompted by the biggest of big bombs being dropped back and forth. Signature move shootouts performed by captivating, larger-than-life beasts and their incredible auras, focusing mostly on fireworks over story.

That isn't to say Lesnar vs. Reigns was completely lacking in story. Paul E. sliding the WWE Championship to Roman following a referee bump was a nice call-back to Crown Jewel 2021, when Reigns felled the Beast this exact way, though Brock was better in Dallas than he was in Saudi Arabia. He thought through the shenanigans, shattering Roman's fragile ego and forcing a late-match monologue to hide his insecurities, convincing himself that he's still the Head of the Table, let alone you.

An adrenaline-pumping bout reached a somewhat abrupt finish as Roman reversed an F5, put Brock into the ropes, and hit the match-ending spear. Countless other spears, F5s, Superman punches, and suplexes were thrown prior to this, culminating in Roman being crowned WWE's Undisputed Universal Champion.

While far from this match format's most exhilarating example, the main event still inspired enough awe to finish on the positive side of the ledger. It should be a long time before these two cross paths in the ring again, though.


2. Johnny Knoxville, WWE's King Of Slapstick

Johnny Knoxville
WWE.com

If Johnny Knoxville didn't raise the high, high bar set by Bad Bunny at WrestleMania 37 and Logan Paul the night before, he at least maintained their celebrity standards opposite Sami Zayn.

This Jackass-inspired stunt show was a big, messy hoot. Chris Pontius interfered and freaked Zayn out with his 'Party Boy' schtick, backing Sami into a corner, before Wee Man came out from under the ring later on and ended up bodyslamming the full-timer. Zayn cruelly booting him in the face drew monster jeers while Michael Cole struggled to contain himself on commentary, endearingly breaking his glossy facade to get swept up in the sheer fun of it all.

A crutch, baking trays, trash can lids, a swinging low-blow machine, and a table lined with mousetraps were the tip of the plunder's iceberg. Sami running face-first into a comedically huge hand outside the ring provided slapstick pops, as did Knoxville's bowling ball to the family jewels. Finally, the entire Jackass crew got involved to shuffle a giant mousetrap under the ring, with Johnny using it to trap Sami for the fall.

Zayn vs. Knoxville was always going to live or die on WWE's ability to create an environment Johnny would be comfortable in. Here, they did that. This felt like a half-episode of Jackass playing out live.


1. RKBro Win Great Spotfest

RKBro movez
WWE.com

While perhaps not as ballistic as the Tag Team Title Triple Threat from Raw's 7 March episode, RK-Bro's triumph over Alpha Academy and The Street Profits opened WrestleMania 38's second half with an almighty bang.

This was a pure popcorn match. A total spotfest, it was all about eliciting a sugar rush from the crowd with tight, well-executed sequences, cutoffs, and stunts. There was no effort at crafting a grander story here, which worked to the match's benefit. Sometimes, you just want to throw an entire share size bag of Skittles down your throat, not a $60 steak.

Montez Ford was particularly impressive in the way he threw himself around the ring here, while Otis and Chad Gable did a great job of trying to spoil everybody's fun with their cutoffs. Elsewhere, drama came through a close two-count following Street Profits' awesome Doomsday Brainbuster, RK-Bro hitting simultaneously rope-hanging DDTs to the crowd's delight, and Riddle's incredible springboard RKO to Ford, who was perched on the top turnbuckle for a Frog Splash.

Randy Orton scored the win for his team, nailing Gable with an RKO as the Alpha man flew from the top rope. His friendship and appreciation for Riddle now truly at the forefront, the veteran deserves immense credit for reinventing himself in this role, whatever happens next.

It's a shame that the post-match angle featuring Gable Steveson suplexing Chad didn't land, but we can't have everything.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.