6 Most Successful WWE Hell In A Cell Wrestlers Ever

Which of these men went through Hell and came back with the best record?

Batista Triple H Vegeance 2005 Hell in a Cell
WWE.com

Next month, WWE will host its seventh annual Hell in a Cell Pay-Per-View live from Los Angeles, California, where The Undertaker is set to go toe-to-toe with the Beast Incarnate, Brock Lesnar for what will presumably be the last time, inside the cell. 

It seems almost poetic, seeing as thirteen years prior, in the same month, the two squared off inside Hell in a Cell for the WWE Championship at No Mercy. That was a great match and moment, one of many to have taken place in the cell.

Whether it’s Mick Foley being thrown off the top, only to scale it once more and be chokeslammed through it, or the debut of Kane during the inaugural cell match, some career-defining moments have taken place inside that cage.

Foley himself has stated that you walk into the cell as one man and emerge another, and there are a number of guys who have not only competed in the cell several times, but have amassed impressive records when it comes to time spent between those walls. That can be determined by the number of appearances in the cell, or simply by their win-loss ratio.

I'll be counting down the six most successful performers in the history of Hell in a Cell. And no, while his name may be synonymous with the structure at this point, Mick Foley is not on this list. The only thing he ever won inside the cell was our respect. 

6. CM Punk

804671

Out of four appearances inside Hell in a Cell, CM Punk has won two, against Ryback at Hell in a Cell in 2012, and against Ryback and Paul Heyman in a two-on-one handicap match at Hell in a Cell in 2013. This gives CM Punk a winning percentage of 50%.

CM Punk was very close to being edged out of this list by John Cena, who has the same amount of victories inside the cell, but since one of those came during the dark match after a live broadcast of Monday Night Raw in 2011, I felt it shouldn’t count considering there was no way the championship would have been changing hands.

Punk’s two victories inside the cell both came against Ryback,  albeit under very different circumstances. In 2012, Punk was the top heel champion, and Ryback was the up-and-comer getting his very first big-time opportunity after four months of squash matches. 

He went into the match without a hope in hell of emerging with the WWE Title around his waist but a turncoat referee (Brad Maddox) would take matters into his own hands when he delivered a low blow to Ryback before helping Punk get a snappy three-count.

The following year, things were quite different. Punk was looking for revenge against Paul Heyman for stabbing him in the back at Money in the Bank, and he was going to get his chance inside the cell. After coming up short against Brock Lesnar, and overcoming Curtis Axel, Punk had to go through Ryback one more time, and go through him he did. 

The night ended with Punk laying waste to Paul Heyman with a kendo stick atop the cell, delivering Heyman’s just desserts months after he turned his back on the ‘Best in the World’.


5. Batista

Batista Triple H Hell In A Cell 2
WWE.com

Out of two appearances inside Hell in a Cell, Batista has won both of them, first against Triple H at Vengeance in 2005, and then against The Undertaker at Survivor Series in 2007. This gives 'The Animal' a winning percentage of 100%.

Given a few more appearances inside the cell, Batista could have found himself atop this very list. His first appearance came shortly after winning the World Heavyweight Championship against his former mentor in Evolution, Triple H at WrestleMania 21. 

The two men tore each other to sunders in Las Vegas at Vengeance, and after delivering an emphatic Batista Bomb to Triple H, it would be four months before we saw ‘The Game’ on our screens again.

The second saw Batista take on The Undertaker at Survivor Series in 2007, which ended in a much more controversial fashion. As The Undertaker delivered a second Tombstone Piledriver, on top of the steel steps for good measure, Edge would remove the referee from the situation, having disguised himself as a cameraman during the match. 

He would then pull Batista’s arm over the deadman’s chest to give him the victory, allowing him to retain.


4. Randy Orton

Randy Orton John Cena Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

Out of six appearances inside Hell in a Cell, Randy Orton has won three. These came against John Cena at Hell in a Cell 2009, Sheamus at Hell in a Cell in 2010, and Daniel Bryan at Hell in a Cell in 2013. This gives Randy Orton a winning percentage of 50%.

All three of Randy Orton's victories inside the Devil's Playground came at the event's annual PPV, first against John Cena over the course of their long-running feud that saw the WWE Championship change hands a number of times. This became very personal, and Orton would deliver a rare-seen punt kick to retain the championship and continue the rivalry.

Orton would successfully retain the WWE Championship again the following year against Sheamus, and his next victory would come in a high-stakes match against Daniel Bryan three years later in 2013. In a brutal match in which Orton delivered a huge Superplex to Daniel Bryan onto a pile of steel chairs, appearances by Triple H and a superkick from Shawn Michaels to Daniel Bryan would be all it took to allow Randy Orton to retain the WWE Title yet again.


3. Shawn Michaels

Triple H Shawn Michaels Hell In A Cell - Bad Blood 2004
WWE.com

Out of four appearances inside Hell in a Cell, Shawn Michaels has won three. These came against The Undertaker at Badd Blood in 1997, Vince McMahon, Shane McMahon and Big Show at Unforgiven in 2006, and Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase at Hell in a Cell in 2009. This gives Shawn Michaels a winning percentage of 75%.

'The Heartbreak Kid' Shawn Michaels is one of the best professional wrestlers of all time, and it's only fitting that he would be the very first man to win inside Hell in a Cell. With the help of a debuting Kane, Michaels would be able to topple The Undertaker, despite having been nearly decimated at the hands of The Deadman.

His next two victories would both come alongside his D-Generation X counterpart, Triple H, first at Unforgiven 2006 where they defied the odds in a three-on-two handicap match, involving Michaels dropping an elbow on Shane McMahon with a chair around his neck, and Triple H literally breaking a sledgehammer across the back of Mr. McMahon's head. 

They would then reunite to combat Legacy in 2009, walking out victorious once again at the Hell in a Cell PPV.


2. The Undertaker

Undertaker Randy Orton Hell in a Cell Armageddon 2005
WWE.com

Out of twelve appearances, The Undertaker has won six, against Mankind at King of the Ring in 1998, Big Boss Man at WrestleMania XV in 1999, Randy Orton at Armageddon in 2005, Edge at SummerSlam in 2008, CM Punk at Hell in a Cell in 2009 and Triple H at WrestleMania XXVIII in 2012. This gives The Undertaker a winning percentage of 50%.

The Undertaker's victory against Mankind at King of the Ring is one of the most awe-inspiring moments in the history of pro wrestling. The image of Mick Foley's body cascading from the top of the cell through the announce table is one that has been etched in our memories forever, and a moment that Foley himself is still suffering the effects from. Not to mention being chokeslammed through the ceiling almost immediately afterwards...

The Undertaker picked up cell victories against Big Boss Man at WrestleMania the following year, but it would be six years until his next win inside the cage, when he defeated Randy Orton (accompanied by his father, Cowboy Bob Orton) at Armageddon.

In 2008, The Undertaker got revenge over Edge after having been forced out of the WWE in a Tables, Ladders and Chairs match at One Night Stand. Then General Manager of SmackDown, Vickie Guerrero would reinstate The Undertaker, and announce that he would take on Edge for the World Championship at SummerSlam. The following year, he would defeat CM Punk to become the very first man to win a title in a Hell in a Cell match.

Undertaker's most recent cell match came against Triple H at WrestleMania XXVIII, a match I was lucky enough to witness as part of the live crowd, and would see The Undertaker take his undefeated streak on the grandest stage of them all to an unprecedented 20-0. 

The Phenom is the only man to have faced every other person on this list inside Hell in a Cell, and at this year's PPV he has an opportunity to increase his winning perecentage to 53%, as he faces Brock Lesnar in the cell for the second time, the first having come at No Mercy in 2002, where Lesnar walked out with the WWE Championship still around his waist.


1. Triple H

Triple H Chris Jericho Judgement Day 2002 HEll in a Cell
WWE.com

Out of nine appearances inside Hell in a Cell, , Triple H has won six. These came against Cactus Jack at No Way Out in 2000, Chris Jericho at Judgement Day in 2002, Kevin Nash at Bad Blood in 2003, Shawn Michaels at Bad Blood in 2004, Vince McMahon, Shane McMahon and Big Show at Unforgiven in 2006, and Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase at Hell in a Cell in 2009. This gives Triple H a winning percentage of 66%.

Triple H makes it to the top of this list by tying The Undertaker’s six impressive victorious in three fewer appearances. 

His first win was arguably his most brutal, as he went head-to-head with Cactus Jack, forcing the man into retirement. He would find himself in the cell against Chris Jericho at Judgement Day 2002, where he defeated the Ayotollah of Rock ‘n’ Rolla. The following year, he would topple his former friend Kevin Nash to retain the World Championship at Bad Blood in 2003.

Triple H’s next most memorable cell moment came at Bad Blood in 2004, where he finished off his long-running singles rivalry against Shawn Michaels in a bloody encounter that saw tables, ladder and chairs in action. HBK put up a valiant effort, but in the end, with the aid of Batista and Ric Flair, Triple H walked out with the World Heavyweight Title, his fourth victory inside the cell.

Triple H would find himself in the cell with Shawn Michaels yet again at Unforgiven merely two years later, this time together as part of the reunited D-Generation X, with the odds stacked against them in a three-on-two handicap match against Vince McMahon, Shane McMahon and The Big Show.

The two would then defeat Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase in another gruelling tag-team Hell in a Cell match in 2009.

When it comes to Hell in a Cell, The Game is in a class of his own. 


Contributor
Contributor

Editor/Author of 'Under the Spotlight' for SLTD Wrestling. Games Development Student. @AdamOB_UTS on Twitter.