6 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (17 Jan - Results & Review)
Elements of Friday's sneakily great SmackDown episode felt like a WWE PLE.
The third three-hour long SmackDown was yet another winner of a show for Triple H and company. 'The Game' did say that Smackers might not be this length permanently, but those who crave as much good wrestling as possible every week will be hoping it does. Of course, WWE can still squeeze a few lengthier bouts into the traditional two-hour format too. They have that power!
Friday's offering saw mega matches like Kevin Owens vs. Rey Mysterio and Tiffany Stratton vs. Bayley take centre stage. Those delights were ably backed by a couple of banging tag-team scraps, a lowkey stomper between Jimmy Uso and Carmelo Hayes, and some nice storytelling that fed into upcoming pre-Royal Rumble business on the next Saturday Night's Main Event.
Charlotte Flair's return was announced, KO continued being the best troll (with an edge) in the industry, creative humanised somebody who badly needed that more than lazy laughing promos, and the whole evening just raced along with a neat pace to it. The only downsides were minor, but are defo worth examining; one match didn't stand a chance when stacked next to others, and this writer is scratching his head over what Trips hopes to achieve with a lower card straggler.
Good outweighed the bad by a metric crap ton though. WWE know they can crank out an episode like this every now and then. Y'know, one that doesn't break the internet but keeps everyone entertained due to the strength of the roster. Little sprinklings of story helped keep things purring anyway.
Here's the review!
Downs…
2. This Didn’t Stand A Chance
Man, it must be starting to feel like this guy just doesn't like Michin. That's not true, but she does frequent the 'Downs' on these SmackDown recaps a lot nowadays. WWE must do better when it comes to giving fans a reason to care though, and Michin's ongoing feud with Chelsea Green already feels like one issue that's well past its sell by date creatively.
B-FAB vs. Piper Niven was the odd one out on Friday's match card. It was too short to accomplish much, and it’s a strange choice to put someone like FAB (who needs reps and ring time) in such a brief loss like this one. It's hard to completely dump on the thought of B siding with Michin, but it’ll take more than this to get that story over - that's true of Michin generally, as discussed.
Look, there's an age old phrase in wrestling that veterans like to shout: 'Maximise your minutes'. Almost every worker has to deal with truncated ring time or writers who don't meet them halfway at some stage in their careers, but it's frustrating to see that happen when WWE has so much TV time to work with on these shows.
If they want people to care about Michin challenging Green again and think this sort of fare will get them there, then they need a reality check. Under normal circumstances, Piper leading B-FAB through a standard heel vs. baby match would be fine, but the company didn't give these woman a hope in hell of doing proper business.
Hmm.
1. What Is He Even Gaining From This?
One benefit shouted loudly when WWE announced that SmackDown was beefing up to three hours? That previously overlooked talents would get more time onscreen to show what they can do. On the whole, that's true, but...what even is this stuff between Apollo Crews and Pretty Deadly? It's legit hard to know whether or not this deserves a chance and some patience.
Right now, Crews is sticking his nose into the tag-team scene without a partner. Maybe he'll get one eventually, but this does appear to be one of those mini-stories that WWE creative cares about for three weeks before getting bored and moving on without helping the worker in question. It could just be that this is Apollo's fate on the main roster. His promos are so jarring.
Here's a stark contrast: Bayley, Rey Mysterio, Kevin Owens, Cody Rhodes and more came across as realistic human beings with real, evolving emotions on Friday night. Meanwhile, poor Crews looked like some extra in a backstage skit during 2K24's MyCareer. Nothing about his interactions with the PD boys feels natural, and it's tough to get pumped for a match between Apollo and Johnny Gargano knowing it'll only exist to plug a gap.
Sure, Crews is the victim of Baron Corbin's release, but it's hardly like WWE went all in on that duo either. Someone needs to sit down, bang some heads together and figure out a pathway for Apollo's character, because this ain't it. He's only on camera for around 60 seconds every week, and even that feels like a waste.
Ups…
6. Jimmy & Melo Were Cooking
File this one under 'unexpected thrillers'.
Jimmy Uso vs. Carmelo Hayes was a real good time before the run in from Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga. Zero problems with the disqualification finish, by the way. It came after Melo had kicked out of a superkick for a convincing false finish, and it makes sense that Solo Sikoa’s troops would try to regain some lost momentum by targeting perceived weak link Jimmy. Some fans out there hate on DQ endings as a general rule - this one doesn’t have a problem with them on the weekly shows if they’re backed up by some significant story context.
Uso takes a bit of flak for...not being his brother Jey. That can be slightly unfair, so it was lovely to see him go all out to show his wares. Hayes has a lot to prove on blue pastures himself. He's been hit and miss since jumping up from NXT, but the dude always thrives when he's stuck in longer matches against guys who can go. Jimmy sure can. That's never been in doubt.
This pair were cooking before Solo's clan romped out to take centre stage. That led to Sikoa shooting blanks on the mic before walking away, then Jacob spat some threats over the mic. Eventually, he and Tonga brawled with LA Knight and Braun Strowman. Fatu vs. Braun has been announced for SNME, which is cool. 2025 is shaping up to be a big year for Jacob.
Special mention for Jimmy vs. Carmelo first and foremost. They've got chemistry.
5. Guns Get It (Whilst Los Garza Shines Again)
Companies like ROH once understood that promoters could hurl two fine tag-teams at fans, give them a fair chunk of time, then sit back and enjoy the spoils as everybody watching got lost in the magic. Old-school Honor fanatics would've seen some parallels between Motor City Machine Guns vs. Los Garza and prior tag classics like The Kings Of Wrestling vs. The American Wolves. Look that 2010 bout up if you've never had the pleasure.
Overall, this Garza vs. Machine Guns effort was a cracking little number one contenders match that enhanced everybody involved in it. Angel and Berto have been getting more spotlight than usual recently, and the Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley pairing is starting to settle into a neat groove after a hot start to WWE life. The incoming partnership with TNA should also be interesting for those lads, 'cause it could send them back towards Impact for a cameo spot or two.
Pretty Deadly stuck their noses in to try and help Garza, but the bumbling Englishmen actually cost them the chance to win. That side story keeps going, which is nothing to moan about. Now, WWE has PD vs. Garza and a fine Guns vs. DIY title match that could feasibly rock the house come the next Saturday Night's Main Event (assuming that's the plan).
It'll be another winner for this revived division no matter when Trips pulls the trigger. The paranoid vibes he's giving Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa have been working for the champs too. It's genuinely great to see the tag pack get this kind of attention.
4. Women’s Tag-Team Goodness
That's also true on the women's side of the fence.
Naomi and Bianca Belair beating Nia Jax and Candice LeRae was a zippy, fun match that included two rather interesting tidbits. Firstly, Nia accidentally planted a leg drop on Candice near the end, so there could be developing friction that brings an end to their creative marriage of convenience. Second, Belair was the one who did most of the work for her team, then Naomi swanned in to scoop the glory with the match-winning pin.
Wade Barrett calling Naomi “the nicest person in the locker room” had to be subtle setup for this Jade Cargill reveal too. It just has to be. Either that or WWE are deliberately laying it on thick with Naomi hoping nobody smells a rat with Bianca. She isn't out of the running as Cargill's aggressor just yet, but it's awesome this plot has so many possible branching paths. In the interim, Naomi and Belair work real well together as champs.
The match was really tidy overall. Again, Naomi is in the perfect spot as Belair’s sub partner. She's inarguably more experienced than Jade, so there are none of the awkward miscommunications Bianca occasionally had with Cargill. Those were understandable and worth putting up with, but they could play a part in the story's next chapter.
This is the sort of bout that might've been relegated to 3-4 minutes in the two hour days, so it's pleasing to see everyone get enough time to let important story beats sink in. Nia and Candice potentially splitting and/or Naomi/Belair being outed as Jade's attacker both deserve your eyeballs.
3. Bayley’s Candour
Where was this sort of human touch during Bayley's mediocre title reign last year?! The 'Role Model' lived an inspired journey during the first half of 2024; from Royal Rumble win to beating ex-Damage CTRL pal IYO SKY at 'Mania 40 for the belt, she was on fire, but then her Women's Title reign sagged and felt like it ended with a whimper at SummerSlam. WWE let Bayley down by turning her back into a giggling mess of a character who had nothing to say.
Adversity has changed that.
On Friday, the company aired a nice pre-taped interview in the empty arena with Byron Saxton to hype up Bayley’s title opportunity vs. Tiffany Stratton. This wasn't standard WWE stuff, being honest. Bayley freely admitted that she didn’t have the best title reign possible, which eats at her. She clawed her way back to another title shot so she could right some wrongs and do things properly this time.
Bayley works when she’s frank as a character and has that human touch. She sure works a heck of a lot better doing this than she does saying daft, annoying nonsense like, "Ding dong...hello!" or laughing because she's run out of material. Fingers crossed the writing team learn their lesson here and give her more of this realistic air going forwards.
SmackDown's promo was a short skit, but a damn good one. It presented Bayley as someone of stature who's at a low ebb in her career and doesn't know how to arrest that. Keep this story going post-defeat to Tiffany, please. It'll work out and help Bayley reforge a connection with the audience.
2. Stratton Ticks Off Her First Title Defence
Not many tuned into SmackDown thinking they were going to see a title change. This was Tiffany Stratton's first title defence since cashing in Money In The Bank to win the strap, and it's obvious it'll be 'Tiffy Time' for a good while. Stratton is a real breakout star, not to mention a success for WWE's signing policy. She's the future of the women's game, not Bayley.
Their main event was a well-paced and well-worked match from start to finish. It didn't bother trying to cram every spot or move both could think of into the runtime, but instead played out as a scrappy veteran looking to regain her edge whilst being met head on by someone who is full of confidence without even being the best version of herself quite yet.
You've got to love the way Roxanne Perez was shown around ringside without getting physically involved. That would've been far too easy, and it means more to the simmering NXT feud that Bayley lost clean. Now, Perez has some more ammunition to blast at her babyface foe, and Bayley has another mental hurdle to overcome.
The headliner was yet another example of Triple H giving major matches room to breathe. This and Kevin Owens vs. Rey Mysterio could be classed as borderline PLE quality. That's how good they were. Plus, seeing Tiffany swiftly move on from Nia Jax and Candice LeRae then beat a credible ex-champ? Yeah, that's the best use of her.
Onto Charlotte Flair. That's who's in Stratton's crosshairs next. Here's hoping WWE don't get cold feet and put the belt on Charlotte just for the sake of it. Tiff should dominate 2025.
1. Just A Magic Match Worth Seeing
Fellow older fans will agree it's a real treat to see Rey Mysterio wrestle in matches just like this one nowadays. Who knows how many excellent showcases the masked legend has left in him, y'know? Rey was in fine fettle as a hometown babyface hero for San Diego, and KO is riding high as a vile piece of crap who mixes claims of respect with clear evidence to the contrary.
He went to hit a package piledriver on Mysterio post-match before Cody Rhodes sprinted in to make the save. That was logical, because Cody had apologised for not having Rey's back earlier in the night. The champ was going through a medical to make sure he's 100% cleared for Royal Rumble. This was all elegant build towards a one-off match (KO vs. Mysterio) and the Rumble ladder war Cody and Kev have next.
Trolling dirtbag Owens is on top of his game, people. He's absolutely nailing everything about this heel run on the mic, and he's having some wonderful matches into the bargain as well. KO even "accidentally" shoved the referee into the ropes to stop Rey from winning after a 619, then tried to injure another hero afterwards. That would've been payback for Mysterio having the cheek to point out that Kevin isn't actually WWE Champ during the opening face to face.
You may never get the chance to see Owens vs. Rey again, so drink it in and savour this. The way they eased in some storytelling for the Rumble with Rhodes was genius too.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 20 Most RANDOM WWE Royal Rumble Entrants and 10 Most ANNOYING Wrestlers Ever!