6 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE Raw (April 24 - Review)

Judgment Day, Bad Bunny try to salvage tepid show blotched with a major disappointment.

Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Holy hell.

The wheels really came off Raw quickly on Monday night, didn’t they? It was bad enough the show started with an impromptu match being made and then another one being booked a couple segments later, but the show got derailed when Triple H decided that what WWE really needs to counter a double world champion who rarely defends his titles is another world title.

That announcement is going to be one of the most scrutinized – and likely criticized – moves WWE makes for a while. It was… something, for sure.

The rest of Raw was pretty pedestrian overall. The Cody Rhodes/Brock Lesnar story treaded water for another week, Damage CTRL is continuing its slow circling of the drain, Trish Stratus followed up her big heel promo with a dud, and Bobby Lashley and Austin Theory are feuding again. Yay.

The Judgment Day continues to be the savior of Raw, with Bad Bunny delivering a strong finish to the show, but by then, things were pretty far gone. The Bloodline also got some shine through segments with Sami Zayn to revitalize that story throughout the night.

But overall, this was a pretty drab show that was made much worse by that new piece of hardware.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

7. Another Impromptu Marquee Match

Cody Rhodes Finn Bálor
WWE.com

Pop quiz: What was going to be one of the signature matches on Raw Monday night if Finn Balor hadn’t interrupted Cody Rhodes and triggered a series of events that led to the American Nightmare challenging Balor to a match?

It’s such a WWE thing that many fans have just become numb and accept that Raw is going to go on the air without a complete card, and it’ll be fleshed out and filled out as the show wears on. In this case, it was Rhodes/Balor at the top of the third hour, filling a good-sized chunk of programming with a match that is the kind you’d typically want to advertise ahead of time.

And that doesn’t take into account the six-woman tag match that was made on the fly during Raw, because that’s how WWE rolls. Just another day in sports entertainment.


6. This Better Be Leading Somewhere

Bianca Belair Bayley
WWE.com

The Raw Women’s Champion should not be running around grabbing two random partners to fill out her side of an impromptu six-woman tag match, but here we are, with Bianca Belair thrown into the role of matchmaker and recruiter.

The six-woman tag pitting Damage CTRL against Belair and Raquel Rodriguez & Liv Morgan was fine for what it was, which was yet another loss for the heel stable, as Bayley ate yet another defeat. Bianca also once again was thrust into a supporting role in her own feud, as a lot of the mid-match shine went to the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions (understandably).

But once again, Damage CTRL was on the losing end of things, which left Iyo Sky pissed, as she now heads into her title match against Belair without any wind in her sails.

Now, there is some saving grace here, if WWE is smart enough to follow through on Iyo’s frustrations with Bayley interjecting herself into things and making the feud about the whole group instead of just Sky. It also doesn’t help that Bayley once again lost a match for the group.

If there’s follow-through there, then this is moot. But we’ve seen this story drag on before, so it’s a negative until WWE proves it can advance the angle and make it work.


5. Tepid Trish

Trish Stratus
WWE

After a promo last week that laid the foundation for her heel turn, Trish Stratus had an opportunity Monday night to build on that.

Instead, she flopped. Cathy Kelley didn’t help by asking the most random question: Why was Becky Lynch not at Raw again? Stratus took the chance to pretend that Becky told her a secret: Lynch was not doing well and not able to deal with the pressure of being The Man, a mom and the face of the division. Trish, however, was thriving as a mom and a Hall-of-Famer, while Becky was cracking and crumbling.

And that was how Stratus followed up her big heel promo last week. It wasn’t even enough to be considered a whimper, as Trish just took a bad question and ran with it in a way that did nothing to follow up, elevate, advance or even supplement the storyline. “Becky Lynch has cracked after one Chick Kick and title loss” is a pretty bold thing to stake your claim on. But if you’re going to, maybe connect it to yourself a bit more to drive yourself as the antagonist.

It felt like this one was thrown together quickly without a lot of thought, because they could have easily saved this promo.


4. Treading Water

Cody Rhodes
WWE

Cody Rhodes has proven that he can be masterful on the mic, driving a storyline with just a few passionate words, his delivery elevating the quality of the text immensely.

But his show-opening promo taking aim at Brock Lesnar rang a bit too much like a typical WWE promo than a guy who has been cast as being unique and somewhat above the fray. Cody started by reminding us about the WWE Draft, because that’s what a good host does. He then turned our attention to the tron, so we could look at pictures of Brock beating him up three weeks ago, because every superstar has to use the screen at some point.

Cody still cut a good promo about how his scar is a reminder of how he beat Seth Rollins with a torn pec because the fans – in the same Chicago arena – carried him across the finish line. It was a cool visual, but he never really got to make the connection back to Lesnar or really make a solid point. It was a nice moment, but none of that really advanced the Brock storyline.

We already know: Rhodes thinks Brock’s a coward, Cody will face adversity head-on, and the fans having his back will be a huge boost. Beyond that, there wasn’t much to this part of the promo.


3. Let’s Just Make A New Title!

Triple H
WWE.com

For more than a year, Roman Reigns has hauled around two championship titles: the WWE Championship and the Universal Championship. The conventional wisdom surrounding this decision was that you could (and likely would) always split the titles up again sometime in the future so you’d have two world champions again.

Well, we’ll soon have two world champs again soon, but it won’t be due to Roman giving up a strap. Triple H announced on Monday the creation of a new World Heavyweight Championship, with the first champ being crowned at Night of Champions in Saudi Arabia.

There’s so much to unpack from this terrible announcement: The entire (kayfabe) basis for this was rooted in Roman holding both titles hostage and rarely defending them, which Triple H said wasn’t fair to the fans (he’s not lying). So rather than breaking up the titles or forcing Reigns to defend the straps more often (because he apparently negotiated a deal to not show up and defend the title), they just created a third world title.

We’re supposed to accept that Reigns has carted around two titles on both brands for a year and now will just be shunted off to one show with two titles and WWE will create a new “world” championship out of thin air because they incapable of re-splitting the titles and Roman is all-powerful. This also means one brand will have a workhorse world champ and the other will have a lazy, part-time boss.

Once a new champ is crowned, does that mean Roman is no longer “Undisputed” WWE Universal Champion? Kind of tough to be “undisputed” if there are two world champs.


2. A Consolation Prize

WWE World Heavyweight Championship
WWE.com

Beyond Triple H’s horrible explanation of why WWE is establishing a new world title, this move evokes bad feelings of previous attempts to create a new world championship… only worse.

Triple H being crowed World Heavyweight Champion by Eric Bischoff was an all-time terrible move (and makes this announcement even more ironic), but Brock Lesnar had only been WWE Champion for a hot minute. In this situation, Roman Reigns has held a world title for nearly three years. He’s literally beaten every main event superstar along the way.

And that’s a huge problem here. Right away, you had guys like Finn Bálor and Seth Rollins eyeing this new title with zero history rather than the title they’ve failed to win. They’d rather chase a new piece of hardware than succeed in dethroning Roman.

And don’t get us started on the possibility that this new title could end up around Cody Rhodes’ waist. That would be the biggest fail of them all, with Cody literally changing his story from winning the title his father couldn’t to just shrugging and accepting another “world” title as a consolation prize.

Any of Roman’s failed challengers should be looking to win the title(s) with all the history, not a new strap created out of thin air. Even with a really good mini-tournament, this title is going to be secondary as long as Reigns is the other world champion.


1. And Finally…

Triple H
WWE.com

If you needed more proof that WWE badly botched the booking of Cody Rhodes and the main event of WrestleMania 39, look no further.

It’s impossible to both defend the decision to beat Cody at Mania and applaud this new title as smart, well thought-out booking. If WWE was intent on having a second world title, it was right there.

It would not have been hard to have Rhodes win the Royal Rumble and declare he’d challenge for just one of the two world titles (the WWE Championship his father failed to win). You could have had Adam Pearce declare Roman needed to defend the Universal Championship at Elimination Chamber (again, against Sami Zayn) in that situation.

Just like that, Cody is a world champion on one brand, and Reigns is still continuing on a near-three-year run as Universal Champion on the other. That also would solve the “one world title is inferior to the other” problem, as well as have two prestigious titles instead of one being brand new.


UPS…

6. Impromptu, But Still Good

Cody Rhodes Finn Balor
WWE.com

We’ve taken our swipe at the Cody Rhodes/Finn Balor match being thrown together during the show, but let’s give some credit for yet another good performance from two pros.

The outcome was never in doubt, but Balor kept Rhodes on the defensive for a while, and the two countered each other quite a bit as well, including a finishing sequence that saw each man escape the other’s finisher and signature moves.

But we knew Cody needed the win to right the ship and set himself back on the path toward facing Brock Lesnar in a couple weeks. Balor, on the other hand, can eat the loss and just continue to be the mouthpiece for the Judgment Day as the group heads into Backlash.


5. Advancing By Losing(?)

The LWO
WWE.com

In an ideal world, factions that need to get off the ground would make headway by actually winning matches and building up some capital in the ring.

But for the LWO, just getting a televised match against the Bloodline and hanging with them for a while was a pretty big step forward. Since forming just before WrestleMania, their members have lost far more matches than they’ve won, and the original Legado Del Fantasma haven’t competed together at all, despite being a fine-tuned machine in the ring.

The LWO’s match on Raw allowed Santos Escobar, Cruz del Toro and Joaquin Wilde to compete as a trio for the first time in more than six weeks, and they made sure to hit stereo dives and some other high-flying action, keeping the Usos and Solo Sikoa off-balance until the brothers distracted the referee long enough for Solo to hit a Samoan Spike on Cruz for the win.

No one was buying the LWO beating the Bloodline here as the faction wars ramp up, but giving them the opening match and allowing the trio to hang for a bit was a decent boost for them. Next step: win a few matches and continue to wow fans. If they don’t, this little “up” will evaporate quickly.


4. A Logical Offer

Finn Bálor Cody Rhodes
WWE

No one in their right mind expected Cody Rhodes to seriously contemplate Finn Balor’s offer to join the Judgment Day, but that doesn’t mean that the offer itself wasn’t rooted in reality.

Balor started out his sales pitch Monday night by noting that both men have been screwed over by Roman Reigns and the Bloodline, because neither man had backup of their own. Finn then made the connection that this drove Cody to trust Brock Lesnar, who immediately turned on him. All of this was to say that Rhodes needed some people in his corner who would have his back, like the Judgment Day.

Cody very quickly shot that offer down, but Balor continued his pitch by pointing out the group’s success, but Rhodes still wasn’t biting, which set up the impromptu main event. We’ve already criticized that very WWE part of the promo, but kudos to Finn for making a pretty good and grounded case for why the American Nightmare should join the group.


3. Retconning A Reason For Rollins

Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Wrestling fans were likely confused and/or amused by the graphic last week declaring that Seth Rollins was facing Omos at Backlash next month with literally no buildup or story. It was a very un-WWE thing to do, so you had to hope they’d explain it somehow on Raw.

And then we got our explanation: MVP requested the match for his monster, pitting Omos against someone Porter respects to really put the Nigerian Giant on the map.

That’s not an unreasonable move for a manager looking to advance their charge’s career. Why not go to management and pitch a big money match out of the blue? You don’t need to have a fake reason to fight all the time. Sometimes, just wanting to push yourself is enough of a motivation to make things work.

And from there, it wasn’t a stretch for Rollins to fire up and threaten to bounce Omos’ head off the mat with a stomp or three. Things are still rooted in competition rather than a storyline, which is more than fine here. And the match itself should be a spectacle.


2. Bloodline Mind Games

Jey Uso Sami Zayn
WWE

Just when you thought the Bloodline stories were getting downplayed and ratcheted down in significance, WWE actually came through with an interesting wrinkle Monday night.

Sami Zayn and Jey Uso continued their strained relationship, with Zayn trying to convince Jey that it was weird how the brothers said they were going to win the tag titles back on SmackDown for Roman Reigns rather than for themselves. He also put doubt in Jey’s head by pointing out that if they lose now, Roman will be embarrassed and could take it out on the Usos.

Jimmy Uso took this development and flipped it back on Sami, suggesting that Kevin Owens only reconciled with Zayn to win the tag titles, so if they lose them on Friday, KO will turn on his best friend (again), which then put doubt in Zayn’s head. Owens didn’t help matters by blowing up at Sami for even talking to the Usos, but Matt Riddle managed to calm things down and assuage Sami’s fears.

All of this was an interesting way of adding stakes to a tag title rematch that closed out night one of WrestleMania 39. It’s now more than just a tag title match; it’s a battle to remain intact and in good graces, to save face. To lose could mean disaster. For the Bloodline, it could mean facing the Tribal Chief to explain themselves.

That alone makes this all the more interesting.


1. Bad Bunny Swings For The Fences

Bad Bunny Damian Priest
WWE.com

Even if you’re someone who isn’t a huge fan of celebrities getting the better of trained wrestlers, you’ve got to give it up to someone like Bad Bunny, who has thrown himself into the role with gusto.

Bunny already was hosting Backlash because it’s taking place in his native Puerto Rico, but he stepped that up Monday night after coming down to ringside with kendo stick in hand to neutralize Damian Priest. The Punisher of the Judgment Day had just drawn a DQ by throwing a steel chair at Rey Mysterio, and Bunny made a beeline to the ring, immediately waffling Damian with multiple shots.

Afterward, Bad Bunny jumped on the mic to declare he was no longer hosting Backlash, but going as a competitor, challenging Priest to a street fight between the two Puerto Ricans.

We’ve seen plenty of flashes to know that Bunny respects the industry and enjoys being part of the show, and WWE excels at protecting celebrities in these kinds of matches, so you can almost expect a really entertaining garbage match between Priest and Bunny here. The feud is believable, and the crowd noise will be deafening for this one. It was a pretty easy decision to book this match, and it’s reasonable to have faith that it’ll deliver.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.