7 Babyface Wrestling Tag Teams Which Flopped As Heels
Oh, you didn't know?
Every wrestling fan knows it's easier to get over as a heel than it is to play babyface, right? Not so fast! Eliciting genuine heel heat from the watching audience has become progressively harder in the modern generation. Just ask WWE's creative team; they have a hell of a job crafting legitimate baddies.
Those pesky crowds just won't react the way they're supposed to, and this leads to situations where promoters are forced to try something different. Nobody could have imagined that a group hinting at racism or gospel singing like The New Day would go on to sell cereal and make copious penis jokes, for example.
Everyone's favourite Booty-O selling jokesters aren't alone. There are numerous examples of tag-teams that - for whatever reason - just couldn't convince fans of their villainy and had to seek solace playing baby...
7. The Godwinns/Southern Justice
The cartoonish landscape of mid-90s WWF was perfect for good ol' Southern boys like The Godwinns. Pig farmers might not be the first thing people think of when talking wrestling, but Phineas I. and Henry O. were very much over as a tag-team when slopping heels and mule-kicking their way through the roster.
With the grinning Hillbilly Jim by their side, The Godwinns had a purpose. That all changed in 1997 when the country bumpkins kicked Jim to the side and started turning rogue. Suddenly, all that countryside charm evaporated and the WWF expected that heel farmers would receive scathing heat.
They didn't, and so The Godwinn gimmick gave way to Southern Justice. Now sporting suits and a cleaner overall look, the team failed to do much other than cause fans to sit on their hands. Should have stayed as babyfaces, boys, because at least that alignment garnered a reaction.
6. The Road Warriors
Looking like the War Boys from Mad Max had suddenly discovered their local gym, The Road Warriors were a breath of fresh air when they hit the North American scene in the mid-1980s. Eventually making their way to Jim Crockett Promotions and the NWA, Hawk and Animal were face-painted bad asses that fans lapped up.
That wasn't the original plan. The Road Warriors were supposed to be vicious heels who battered babyface heroes like Dusty Rhodes and Sting, but the people couldn't get enough of them. In order to get cheered against the 'American Dream', you have to be over, and Paul Ellering's spiky shoulder pad-wearing muscle men were surely that.
This had been true in the AWA too. There, The Road Warriors struggled to elicit boos even though they were battering hapless jobbers by the dozen and being booked to look like killers. Fans loved the team's fresh feel, and The Road Warriors became characters destined to be career babyfaces from that point on.
5. The Outsiders
It shouldn't be forgotten that Kevin Nash and Scott Hall were supposed to be invading forces from 'up North' sent to take over poor little WCW in 1996. Long before they were selling t-shirts by the truck load as the nWo and causing fans to view opponents like dorks, the invasion storyline WCW flirted with definitely wanted The Outsiders to hear boos.
Retrospect makes it clear that was never going to happen, simply because Hall and Nash were everything that WCW wasn't. Hip and happening, the laid back cool of both revealed just how behind the times 'Dubya-C-Dubya' was, and fans were only too willing to jump on the bandwagon to cheer this slick new revolution.
Quickly, Eric Bischoff changed tact and the New World Order became renegade heroes more than anything else. The anti-establishment feel of Hall and Nash fed this craze, turning WCW into pro wrestling's most chic product. So much for the heel takeover then, because The Outsiders were treated like wrestling royalty and embraced by fans.
4. Too Cool
Show younger WWE fans a picture of Too Cool today and they'll deem Grandmaster Sexay and Scotty 2 Hotty anything but - nothing screams 2000 like a promo image of the popular tag-team. Things could have been so different had they not completely flopped as a heel duo for a few years before randomly finding success.
Initially called Too Much, the pair were straightforward, narcissistic heels who believed themselves to be prettier than pretty. It was all fairly standard stuff until Brian Christopher (Sexay) and Scott Taylor (Hotty) began introducing outdated hip hop hallmarks into their act. Suddenly, the re-dubbed Too Cool struck gold.
As heels, Too Cool were a low-level squad who had no chance of winning the WWF Tag-Team Titles. Slap a bucket hat on one and a pair of goggles on the other though, add a little Rikishi and watch them fly. Too Much were just that, and the original heel run of Too Cool proved flat, but that babyface run was awesome.
3. Breezango
An NXT graduate who had failed to excite WWE management and a dancing fool seemingly destined to be remembered only for his catchy theme song. That was all Breezango had to boast when Tyler Breeze and Fandango were put together in true 'creative has nothing else for you' fashion in May 2016.
First signs weren't good for the duo, because fans just didn't care about them whatsoever. Working as heels wouldn't pay dividends for Breezango, but they have oddly found some measure of success as goofy characters turned babyface by an audience who can't deny their entertainment value. The 'Fashion Police' segments both have produced are undeniably funny.
Check that reaction to Breeze and Fandango at Backlash for proof that they have legs as a babyface team. Even though it remains to be seen just how long people will continue to react to Breeze playing dress-up during matches, there's something endearing about Breezango as babyfaces that they lacked when playing heel.
2. New Age Outlaws
Who would have guessed that the bland 'Double J' Jesse James and dreadful Honky Tonk Man protégé Rockabilly would go on to become the WWF's coolest tag-team of the entire 'Attitude Era'? Both gimmicks were a death sentence career-wise, and the renamed Road Dogg has since admitted that WWF creative only put them together as a unit because they had no other ideas.
Road Dogg and 'Bad Ass' Billy Gunn may have gone on to join D-Generation X and hear thousands chanting along with their catchphrases, but The New Age Outlaws didn't get off to a hot start. Indeed, one feud against The Legion Of Doom as calendars turned to 1998 proved ironic; the Outlaws called LOD old and boring, yet they were the ones struggling to stop fans yawning.
Suddenly, something clicked when the Outlaws joined forces with Triple H, Chyna, and X-Pac to revamp DX in the spring of 1998. Rethought as cool babyfaces, Road Dogg and Gunn completely reversed their fortunes and became one of the most viable teams of the entire '90s.
They did this by being original. Road Dogg's constant chatter throughout the team's entrances was better suited to fan interaction than as an attempt to gain heat, and the anti-authority vibe of DX in general worked best when complementing the federation's new 'Attitude' rather than poking holes in the past.
1. The New Day
Would The New Day have become the longest-running WWE Tag-Team Champions in history had they flogged a dead horse and used racism as their motivation? Probably not, so it's for the best that WWE moved away from an obnoxious gospel gimmick or 'black power' vision for the trio. Xavier Woods, Kofi Kingston, and Big E deserved better than crude use of their skin colour anyway.
One thing that's often forgotten is that New Day were supposed to start as babyfaces. Fans booed the hell out of them though, which necessitated a heel turn. That villainous run didn't work either, because suddenly the try-hard techniques of all concerned captivated fan imagination.
Obnoxiously dancing, playing trombones, and inviting fans to clap along grated at first, but people eventually started to come round to New Day and accept them. It was hard not to when the team were consistently one of the most charming acts on WWE television throughout 2015.
As militant heels who threatened to veer into an unnecessary use of race to gain attention, The New Day wouldn't have worked. By allowing the group to show their natural charisma and presence though, WWE hit pay dirt.
-
Which other babyface teams flopped as heels? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!