7 Ways WWE Screwed Up At SummerSlam 2018
Problems aplenty at the 'Biggest Party Of the Summer'.
What SummerSlam 2018 lacked in cutting edge in-ring action, it made up for in talking points, as WWE delivered a long string of bold booking decisions throughout their latest marathon pay-per-view, suggesting that they may finally be awakening from the annual summer slump.
Constable Corbin, Kevin Owens, and Raw Women's Champion Alexa Bliss were squashed, barely mounting a crumb of offence between them. New champions were crowned in Seth Rollins, Charlotte Flair, Ronda Rousey, and Roman Reigns. The most organic babyface in the company turned heel, Braun Strowman's Money In The Bank cash-in attempt was thwarted, and The Miz stole a victory in his first major clash with Daniel Bryan.
A significant upgrade on the past few years, SummerSlam 2018 was a largely successful night, but far from perfect. A company as inconsistent as WWE will inevitably drop the ball several times on any given night, particularly when said night lasts six hours. Such runtimes create huge scope for f*ck-ups, and while this pay-per-view may ultimately be remembered for what it did right, WWE gave fans plenty of reasons to feel bemused, frustrated, and aggrieved as well.
And no, we're not talking about the squashes...
7. The Revival Fall Short... Again
WWE have revolutionised the concept of "developmental" in many ways over the past few years, and not all of them positive. There once was a time when fans would look forward to seeing their favourite NXT stars on the main roster. Now, you never want them to leave the black and gold brand, knowing that the careful, attentive booking that had them soaring in in Full Sail University will come crashing down as soon as they hit Raw or SmackDown.
Along with Asuka (absent from last night's card), The Revival are one of the biggest reasons for this.
Joining the main roster last April has turned them from one of the most compelling tag teams in the world to a couple of absolute geeks, and it continued at SummerSlam, as Dash and Dawson fell to The B Team. It lasted little over six minutes. Though they hit Curtis Axel with the Shatter Machine early, The Revival soon lost control, eventually falling to the former Intercontinental Champion's opportunistic pinfall.
Caring about their plight isn't even worth the frustration anymore. Their credibility has gone the way of the dodo, and they might not even be salvageable.
6. Sullying A Solid Match
The New Day vs. The Bludgeon Brothers was a change of pace for the reigning SmackDown Tag Team Champions, as Harper and Rowan looked to be in true jeopardy for the first time since rebranding.
Big E and Xavier Woods pushed their limits, resulting in a fun, all-action sprint of a bout with plenty of big bumps. Woods' elbow drop to the outside was a highlight, but a disappointing finish followed. Harper, sensing the danger, grabbed his goofy hammer, battered Big E as he and Xavier were going for the Midnight Hour, and the referee called for the disqualification.
A detrimental move, as this was comfortably the Bludgeon Brothers' best title fight so far, and was en route to becoming something great prior to the finish. The hammer spot detracted from it, though. On a night rife with dirty, shenanigan-filled finishes, the least WWE could've done was let two talented teams with excellent chemistry show their best work, but it wasn't to be.
Though this will likely lead to a rematch, surely WWE could have kept things open for a second without detracting from the first?
5. A Complete Waste Of Time
Pointless. Utterly pointless.
Elias' SummerSlam performance was advertised before the show, but anyone assuming it'd actually lead somewhere was left disappointed. The former 'Drifter' sat in the ring, said his piece, and readied the crowd for a song. Unfortunately, he strummed a little too hard. His Fender acoustic's neck snapped at the joint, he looked mildly peeved, then lashed out at the set behind him.
That was it. There was no sign of recent rival Bobby Lashley, or even a new face to lead him through a Hell In A Cell programme. Elias came down, d*cked around, took a huff, the cameras cut elsewhere, and that was the extent of it.
Such filler segments might be forgivable on Raw or SmackDown, but not one of the biggest pay-per-views of the year. That WWE would even bother advertising Elias if this was the best they could come up with is mind-boggling. It furthered nothing, got nothing over, and provoked only confusion in the building, as the fans (like those at home) were left waiting for an interference that never came.
4. Bellas Everywhere
There was no reason for Brie and Nikki Bella to be highlighted on last night's pay-per-view, but WWE did so anyway, pushing the duo to the forefront in ways that made little narrative sense.
Their first appearance came via backstage interview with Renee Young. They promoted Total Bellas, Total Divas, and various other ventures for a minute, then we got on with the show. This would have been fine on its own, but the siblings had to announce they'd be ringside for Ronda Rousey vs. Alexa Bliss, and that's when things became irritating.
Brie and Nikki joined Rousey for her post-match celebration. Why? Not even Simon Miller could solve such a conundrum, They have no affiliation with 'The Baddest Woman On The Planet,' and no prior relationship, making this an utterly pointless exercise.
That the Bellas will likely be pushed to the forefront during WWE's Evolution build is inevitable, but questionable. They have merit as performers, but aren't anything like the architects WWE will promote them as, and largely used a platform built by others to establish their position in the industry, and have profited from it ever since.
3. So Much For The WWE Title
It's great that AJ Styles, the most consistent in-ring performer in the company, has usurped JBL as the longest reigning SmackDown-exclusive champion of all time, but aside from a handful of good-to-great matches, what does his run really mean?
The gold feels more important around Styles' waist than it did Jinder Mahal's, but it isn't as prestigious as it should be. This isn't down to AJ, though. The company must shoulder the blame for continuing to marginalise their most storied championship with poor pay-per-view positioning, and it continued last night.
Styles vs. Samoa Joe went fifth on a ten-match card. Among other bouts, Finn Balor vs. Baron Corbin and the US Title bout were given stronger positions. That's nuts, but far from an anomaly.
The WWE Championship hasn't headlined a single dual-brand pay-per-view since the 2016 draft. It is, for all intents and purposes, a midcard belt that just happens to be held by one of the most popular guys in the company. This is despite SmackDown continually trouncing Raw for quality since WrestleMania 34, and some excellent work from both Styles and Joe in the SummerSlam build.
2. Another Month, Another Marathon...
Everybody knew SummerSlam would be gargantuan. On top of the 120-minute Kickoff Show, WWE had allotted five hours of Network time for the main card. This left fans staring down the barrel of a seven-hour show, which would be particularly problematic for UK viewers, who'd be forced to stay awake until 5am to consume everything live.
The good news is that WWE shaved a full hour from their initial estimates. The bad? SummerSlam still felt like a giant slog.
Whether watching at home or in the building, it's exceptionally tough to focus on one thing for six hours straight, particularly if they in-ring action isn't out of this world. SummerSlam certainly had a handful of great matches and big developments, but not enough to cure its runtime woes.
The pay-per-view's slog had a demonstrably negative effect on the live crowd, whose decibel level dropped to surprising lows several times throughout the night. Even during Daniel Bryan vs. The Miz (perhaps the most anticipated bout on the whole card), Brooklyn feel silent, despite the intricate chess battle unfolding before their eyes
WWE's steadfast use of "hours watched" as a metric of success means the super-sized shows aren't going anywhere, but they can be an absolute chore.
1. Roman Reigns STILL Doesn't Look Strong
WWE finally crowned Roman Reign as Universal Champion last night, but did so in a way that didn't present him as a winner at all.
'The Big Dog' was fortunate to dethrone Brock Lesnar. 'The Beast Incarnate' was too preoccupied with neutralising Braun Strowman and his Money In The Bank briefcase to focus on his challenger, and while he bludgeoned the monster with an F5 on the outside and several chairshots, Reigns had time to recover. Thus, Roman blasted Brock with a Spear as he slid back in, then scored a quick victory that was all about Lesnar screwing up, not his grand accomplishment.
While the finish keeps 'The Beast' protected, it devalues everything that has defined Reigns' chase over the past few months. Granted, his general character direction has been patchy lately, but WWE have undermined their entire post-WrestleMania narrative by having him triumph on luck alone. It is but another misstep in a career full of them.
WWE's follow-up is critical, and if they try to portray Reigns as an all-conquering, Superman-esque babyface on Raw tonight, they might as well burn their creative department to the ground.